Rubinstein was back in his hotel room. The maid had cleaned it, but left some choice words on the note and had left the bits. According to the note, he was getting kicked out. Packing up his things, he figured he’d head to the next town. He’d burned a few bridges while he was here, like he always did after getting drunk.

He had been hoping for some drama-free time away from the old world to see the new, but here he was without a place to sleep and with the fate of two celebrity mares in his hands. He should just make them serve the writs together in one forty hour block of debauchery, and then head out of town. That’s what he should do—punish that bitch and leave.

But he still wasn’t sure how he felt about it. His mind drifted to his last try at a relationship. Her name had been Amberlocks, and it had gone terrible. She had constantly turned him down for any sort of physical attention, but had kept leading him on. He gave up on her the night she came drunkenly crying to his house about how her current lover just wouldn’t stop hitting her during sex.

Rubinstein hadn’t even known Amberlocks was seeing anybody else, let alone sleeping with them. Yet there she was crying about how her other coltfriend abused her during sex. He had comforted her, assuring her that things could get better if she wanted. He even recommended she go get help and get away from the jerk. Then he saw them together the next day and immediately cut contact with the mare, burning another bridge with his hostile reaction and angry public response.

Amberlocks was only the most recent of a string of failed relationships that either never started, or the mare left him for somepony who was a jerk. He’d been nice to them, helped them out, and they’d leave for somepony who just wanted to use them.

So what was wrong with him just using these mares now? The only difference would be that they had no wrong ideas. They knew they were there to fuck him from the beginning, not for some kind of emotional support. In a twisted way, making them honor the writ was the most honest thing he could do for himself and them. It was their own fault they were in such a stupid predicament.

On the other hand, they clearly didn’t want to get intimate with him. But no mare ever really did. And he had won the writ fairly. It would be scummy of them to back out of the bet, and he shouldn’t let them force him to just hand it over. That was actually robbery.

Sighing, he loaded the heavy bit bag into his pack. He needed to deposit that sucker. He figured doubling down the bet was the best way to deal with this. If they won, they’d get their writs back fair and square, hopefully a little wiser for wear. If he won, well, he’d worry about that if he won. He’d feel less guilty about whatever he decided to do with them, that was for sure.

Grumbling, he checked the room one more time for any stuff he might have forgot. He knew what the right thing to do was. The right thing to do would be to throw the game, get thrown out of town, and take a train to Canterlot. He hated doing the right thing.

*****

The three of them were sitting around a dining table at Fluttershy’s cottage. The table had been cleared, and was covered in cards and chips. The room was too hot for Rubinstein, but it didn’t seem to bother the two girls. Rubinstein wasn’t sure what to think anymore. At first he had thought it was a joke, but then they had started playing. He asked one more time, just to be sure, “So… explain to me again why you’re wearing sunglasses?”

“I told you! It’s our secret weapon!” Rainbow Dash reached over and hoof bumped Fluttershy. “You can’t see our eyes. This way we have no tells!” She waggled her eyebrows over the top of the ridiculously large mirrored glasses.

Fluttershy hummed happily in confirmation, “Mmhmm.”

Rubinstein was lost. He wasn’t sure if this was a trick or if they were messing with him. He could see their cards in the ridiculous sunglasses. Did they want to lose?

He had played the first few hands aggressively, trying to throw the game, but the mares were playing worse than his intentionally bad plays. He had watched Dash fold with a straight, and push with a pair of twos! Fluttershy was doing much better, playing fairly evenly with him, but he could still tell what she had in her hand. He wasn’t sure he could lose the game if he tried.

Soon he was up a sizable amount, and he decided that he’d had enough. He was tired of playing the mental game of chicken with them. It was tearing up his conscious each and every hand. Should he take the victory? Should he fold? Should he bet more, since he knew when he was going to win a hand? He’d been winning more hands lately, and the girls were looking actually nervous, which shouldn’t be the case if they were intentionally throwing the game. Rubinstein was confused and getting angry at the strange situation.

“Okay girls, stop messing with me. What’s going on?”

Rainbow was frustrated, “Hey! You’re the one messing with us! You’re cheating or something. Nopony has luck that good.”

Rubinstein sighed, “Are you girls trying to lose? Because we don’t have to play this out if that’s the case.”

Rainbow frowned and said, “What? Why the buck would I be trying to lose?” Fluttershy looked intently at her cards, seemingly ignoring the conversation.

“Because I can see your cards in the reflection of your sunglasses.”

Rainbow and Fluttershy looked over at each other’s sunglasses. Rainbow slowly took them off, and gently placed them on the table. Fluttershy took hers off as well, her face turning bright pink.

Rainbow blinked, looked at her cards, and then looked back at Rubinstein. “We were giving you a handicap.”

He squinted incredulously, still not convinced, “Oh? Is that why I saw you fold on a straight?”

Rainbow looked confused, “What? When did I have a straight? I never had enough tens for that.”

Fluttershy looked over at Rainbow and gaped at her, “Rainbow! We’ve been playing Poker for weeks now!”

“Yeah? And?” Rainbow rolled her eyes, “It’s just like go fish. You match cards. The more matches you get the more points you get. The person with the most points wins the hand.”

Fluttershy began to whimper and tear up, then she looked at Rubinstein with large panicked eyes. He flatly returned, “I’m not helping you with that.”

Fluttershy whispered, her voice wavering on the verge of tears, “We’re going to lose, aren’t we?”

Rubinstein shrugged. He’d planned on throwing the game, but with how things had turned out he had lost sight of his goal. He had a huge lead and he wasn’t sure he wanted to lose anymore. The night was getting later, and a train would have to wait until morning. He’d wanted to do them a favor and just let them win, but then things had gotten confusing. Now, well, he wasn’t so sure about anything.

Fluttershy looked sadly at Rainbow and sighed as she placed her cards face down, folding for the round. She looked as though she had made a decision, and calmly but assertively stated, “Mr. Rubinstein, I don’t want to play anymore.”

He looked at her, surprised.

Rainbow was shocked, “Fluttershy! You can’t just give up like that!”

“I don’t want to give up, but…” She gestured at the table, “we’re going to lose.”

Rainbow huffed, “You don’t know that Fluttershy! It’s a game of chance!”

Fluttershy looked flatly at Rubinstein, and ignored Rainbow. “Can I ask for a favor, Mr. Rubinstein?”

He was getting sick of doing favors for these mares, but Fluttershy had always been polite at least, “Sure.”

She took a breath and then closed her eyes, “I want to play just one more hand. The highest hand wins. No more chips, no more bluffing. Just one hand, no folding.” She opened her eyes, and looked pleadingly at him.

Rubinstein thought for a moment. If he won right now, he’d still feel guilty. But it was their fault, and he already let them have a second chance. He should just beat them and claim his victory.

Fluttershy begged him again, this time making her eyes large and pouting slightly, “Please?”

He sighed and put his hand down, folding too. It was at least an interesting idea—leaving it up to just the cards. Maybe he wouldn’t feel guilty if he won. And it would give the girls a significant chance to recover. The numbers were definitely in their favor.

“Okay. But the odds really aren’t in my favor, it’s two to one. I only have a one in three chance of winning, and you have a two in three chance. What if we double down again?”

Fluttershy glanced at Rainbow, and then back to Rubinstein, “Umm… how?”

If he won, he was going to stay in Ponyville. Since he had gotten kicked out of his hotel, he needed a place to sleep. And if he was going to stay in Ponyville, he might as well stay with his two new pieces of property. “If I win, I can stay here.” He gestured to Fluttershy’s house, and then to her friend, “And Rainbow moves in with us while I’m here.”

Fluttershy gulped, tapping the table, “I… oh… okay.”

Rubinstein liked her nervous fidget so he added a little bit just to throw her off. Waggling his eyebrows, he taunted her in a low voice, “And no limits… You’ll both be my property. I’m talking about doing the really raunchy stuff. Whatever and whenever.”

Fluttershy froze and her tapping stopped. Rubinstein figured that she was imagining the things, what with her blush. She slowly turned to Rainbow, scared. Rainbow huffed and glared at Rubinstein in disgust, “I told you he was a sleazeball.”

Fluttershy kept quietly staring at Rainbow, her wide eyes just waiting for something. Eventually Rainbow glanced at her and sighed, putting her cards down as she turned angrily back to Rubinstein, “You are a real rotten pony, you know that?”

“Yeah. I do.” He was finally nervous about the outcome. Maybe saying it out loud had been too much? Up until now he could have laughed and pretended it was a distasteful joke. Rainbow had kept her ire in check during the game, pretending they had been playing for fun, but now she was clearly repulsed by him. The worst part was that he knew how much he deserved her scorn.

Rainbow squinted at Rubinstein, threateningly, “Fine. I’m with whatever Fluttershy wants. If I see you cheat, I’m gonna beat the living crap out of you.”

Notably, Fluttershy didn’t ask her to be nice this time.

If he won he didn’t want them arguing about it or making up some stupid excuse. And honestly he would be relieved to lose at this point. The stress was getting to him, and he just wanted this over. “Then how about you deal, Rainbow?”

Rainbow nodded at him, continuing her threatening gaze, “Good. Fluttershy, It’s up to you. What do you want to do?”

Fluttershy looked nervously back and forth between the two of them, still blushing, before answering. “Oh… Okay. I accept.”

He spoke up one more time, “Just to be sure, we all know what we’re betting right now and we all agree to the terms? If I win then no more second chances for you two. The writs will be changed to ‘the duration of my stay’ and you’ll both effectively be slaves until I leave. If either of you win I’ll give you the writs, and I’ll leave Ponyville tonight.”

Both mares nodded, Fluttershy nervously and slowly, Rainbow firmly and sure.

Rubinstein steeled his nerves, and then dramatically took the writs out, slamming them in the center of the table. “Double down, ladies. Let’s do this.”

Rainbow carefully started passing out cards, never taking her eyes off of Rubinstein. He, in turn, watched his cards. At this point he didn’t think her capable of cheating.

As the cards slipped across the table, Rubinstein began to shake. What would he do if he won? He knew he wanted to bang the girls, but he regretted increasing the bet again and again. He had never considered treating mares like property before, and he could potentially have these two for quite some time. Even forever if he never left Ponyville; he wondered if they’d realized that technicality.

The nerves were starting to make him nauseous. The more he thought about it, the more he actually wanted to win. He felt like that thought should disturb him more than it did. As he reached for his cards, he realized how utterly despicable he was, and it startled him just how much he didn’t care anymore. He wondered when he had become the kind of jerk that he used to despise, but he didn’t regret it.

Slowly, he picked up his cards and looked at them. They weren’t what he wanted. He had a pair of princesses, an ace, and a couple of trash cards. He hadn’t seen the two princesses show up before, most ponies took them out of their decks.

Rainbow smirked over her cards, and then shouted, “Yes! Three tens!”

Fluttershy smiled, and wing tapped Rainbow happily, “Yay! I only had two fives.”

Rainbow puffed up, her confidence restored. “Okay, Sleazy. What’d you get?”

He held the cards, smiling calmly. At least he didn’t have to worry about this anymore, “Not enough. It was a good show though. I guess the writs are yours.” He slid them across the table.

Rainbow at least seemed in good spirits again, her distaste for him temporarily forgotten, “Not enough? Come on, Ruby! How much did I beat you by?” She leaned forward, eager to see his cards, and probably gloat.

Rubinstein shrugged. Good-bye fantasy. It was fun while it lasted. He put his hand down so the others could see it, laying the cards face up on the table.

The mirth dropped from Rainbows face instantly. “Why… Why would you fuck with me like that? What kind of sicko are you?” She looked disgusted.

Fluttershy paled as well, her wings softly flapping as she stared at the cards with wide, surprised eyes.

“What are you talking about?” Rubinstein looked at his hand closer. “It’s a pair of princesses. It’s rare, but not a valuable hand.”

Fluttershy blinked, and then looked at Rainbow questioningly. She looked back at the hand, and then back at Rainbow again. “Umm….”

Rainbow groaned, and sat back down as she put her head in her hands. “I know what you’re thinking, Shy.” Rainbow shouted into her hands, “Fuck!” She took a breath, still covering her face. “You’re right. We’re not gonna win like that. Just tell him.”

“Umm… Mr. Rubinstein, sir.” Rubinstein looked at Fluttershy curiously as she spoke, “In Ponyville, The Princesses are wild. You have three aces. You… um…. win.” She timidly slid the writs back across the table, in front of Rubinstein’s cards.

Rainbow Dash shouted, “Fuck!” She slammed her hands on the table, and shouted again, louder, “Fuck!” Rainbow was so angry she looked close to tears.

Fluttershy moved quickly to calm her, “Rainbow! Please! Watch your language.”

Dash was looking accusingly at Fluttershy, “Why couldn’t we have just lied to him, Shy?”

“No Rainbow, it’s was fair. You made the right choice. I’m here with you. We’re not the kind of ponies that cheat.” Fluttershy was at her friends side, gently stroking her.

Rubinstein swallowed his guilt as he stared at the writs. Fate had put them here. These were good ponies, but good ponies got used by jerks. That’s what he’d learned. It was his time to be a jerk. Bending over, he amended the writs and added the agreed terms to them. He initialed receipt again, and left a blank spot for the mares to sign. He was curious if they would.

They didn’t have a ‘legal’ obligation to sign the paper, it was on their honor to fulfill the bet. But once they signed the paper, it was beyond the idea of honesty, and into the territory of courts. If they signed the writs as written, they would be legally bound to effectively be slaves. Should they fail to fulfill them, he could approach the Princess for punitive actions. The writs had no official end, and had no limits whatsoever listed. Admittedly, the wording was open for interpretation, but they all knew the intent.

He let them talk to each other and calm down for a while as he watched and thought. Fluttershy was soothing Rainbow, talking to her and rubbing her reassuringly with a wing. Rainbow was wavering between blind fury and tears, but succumbing to neither.

He observed them as he waited. Rainbow was the smallest pony out of the three of them, and she was wearing her same comfortable track suit from earlier. Fluttershy was larger, a little big for a mare, but not quite as big as a stallion. She was wearing her green hoodie and some black sweatpants.

He figured that they were over reacting. Rainbow was probably thinking that they’d be his sex slaves all the time, and Fluttershy just seemed worried about her friend. He didn’t have that kind of stamina, so he thought he’d ease Rainbow’s mind a bit, and help Fluttershy in the process, “Hey. It’s not so bad. You still get to do your usual stuff most of the time. It’s just like having a sleepover every night.”

Rainbow grit her teeth, “Yeah.” She dropped her head to the table, making a thud before she spoke again, “A sleepover where I suck your cock.”

Fluttershy frowned disapprovingly, “Rainbow! Language.”

Well, she wasn’t wrong, “Actually, Fluttershy….” Rubinstein felt a wicked smile forming. “I wouldn’t count that as profanity. She’s right.” He couldn’t believe that he’d just said that. It didn’t sound like him at all, and the words had left butterflies flapping up and down in his stomach. He leaned back in his chair to ease his nausea and watched the mares response.

Fluttershy blushed and murmured, “Oh my.”

Rainbow just kept her head down on the table, loudly whispering, “Fuck.”

Fluttershy didn’t correct her this time, and that observation darkly amused Rubinstein. He was going to enjoy making them both uncomfortable, and then hopefully quite comfortable. But first he had to actually act instead of just talk. He kicked the butterflies out of his stomach, and tried to imagine a better place for them. “Time to pony up, girls.”

He slid the now adjusted writs across the table, and rolled a pen with them. Fluttershy eyed them suspiciously, but picked hers up and read it. When she was done, she set it down and gulped, looking at him. “This is…. Real?”

He guessed it was probably surreal for them. Fluttershy seemed more aware of the situation than Rainbow, but Rainbow had a bad attitude about the whole thing.“Yeah. It is.”

Fluttershy continued questioning him, fidgeting nervously, “And they’re… um… binding?”

He thought about it. Yeah, the only out he saw was how they defined “stay in Ponyville.” He’d have to sit down and discuss it with them later, but he figured the town limits were safe for now. He did want to visit Canterlot at some point, but he also didn’t want to end his stay. Would a day trip end the writs? If he wanted to really take advantage of the situation he probably shouldn’t leave the house. “Pretty much.”

She blushed and looked down at the paper as she picked up the pen in her shaking hand. Slowly she signed the document, then she dropped the pen and looked up at Rubinstein. “Oh. My.” She blushed furiously, and repeated herself louder as her eyes got wider. “Oh… My…” Fluttershy looked at Rainbow, panicked. “I don’t belong to me.” Rainbow looked up at her, curious as Fluttershy continued to panic. “I actually signed it. Oh my….” She covered her face in her hands, blushing furiously.

Rainbow watched her for a moment, and then grabbed the pen from the table. She didn’t even read the writ, just signing randomly and letting her fore head thump back into the table as she dropped the pen.

Rainbow muttered into the table. “So that’s it then.”

Rubinstein felt a moment of shock. It really was it. No more gambling or weird discussions. He could make them both fuck him right now, and they couldn’t tell him no. He felt tingly in his hooves and hands, so he squeezed them as he responded, “I guess so.”

Rainbow Just muttered a long drawn out, “Fuuuuuck.” while Fluttershy continued to panic and hide her face.

He didn’t know how to start now. He didn’t just want to open up with them jumping his bones. He’d also never been with two mares at once before. Slow was probably better, he should take the time to get to know them. They’d have lots of time. “I guess should inspect my goods.”

Rainbow spoke slowly and strained, picking up her head to level a hateful gaze at Rubinstein, “What do you want me to do first, Boss?”

Rubinstein was actually unsure. Slow could be any number of things. He figured that he was too hot, so there was something that quickly came to mind, “Well… you should take your top off.”

Fluttershy seemed unsure as she pulled gingerly on the drawstring of her hoodie. “Just the tops?”

Rainbow looked curiously at Fluttershy, and then had a moment of revelation dance across her face, “Shy? Are you… into this?”

Fluttershy looked briefly alarmed, then blushed and pulled the hoodie string tight, causing the hood to close around her head. She mumbled something that only she could hear.

Rainbow froze, and then spoke slowly, “The sunglasses…” She stood up and walked over to Fluttershy with her eyes locked onto the retreating mare. “The research.” She frowned, accusing Fluttershy, as realization dawned on her. “The first poker game!” Rainbow took a step back with a wide eyed look of betrayal. “Shy! How could you?”

Fluttershy let out a whine, attempting to shrink.

Rainbow turned to look at Rubinstein, disbelief on her face. “That’s why Angel isn’t here right now! That’s why she brought up love slaves earlier!”

Rubinstein was at a complete loss, but it explained the odd behavior. He had originally figured that she was just blindly innocent, and slightly stupid. But now he was beginning to see another picture painted in front of him. “You mean she wants this?”

Rainbow fell back into her chair, looking blankly at the ceiling. “I can’t believe this.”

Rubinstein mused out loud, suddenly feeling much better about everything. “I feel way less guilty about this now.” A weight was lifted off his shoulders; Fluttershy had been trying to throw the game, and probably had thrown the first game.

Rainbow looked incredulously at Rubinstein. “Less guilty? What about me? I’m innocent!”

“Innocent? You’re a bitch! You tried to rob me!” She deserved what she was getting. He didn’t feel guilt about owning her at all. “Back in my time, you would have been sentenced to indentured servitude for that.” The princesses had always had a sense of humor with their justice, so he even knew where she would have worked. He indignantly stated, “Probably to me!”

Dash had found her anger again, and shouted back at him, “I had a good reason!”

Rubinstein started to get really angry. Every time she shouted at him it pissed him off. “Since when is not paying a debt a good reason?” He shouted back.

Suddenly Fluttershy screamed from under her hood, “Everybody stop fighting!” She took a breath, and then closed her drawstrings again. “Please.”

Rainbow furiously turned her attention to the hiding Fluttershy. “Why should I stop fighting? For you? This is your fault Shy!”

Fluttershy mumbled, “It’s not like that!”

“Oh? What’s it like then? Why don’t you tell me. I’d love to hear it!” Rainbow crossed her arms and scowled, waiting for an answer.

Rubinstein took deep breaths and squeezed his fists, letting himself calm down as Fluttershy explained herself, “I really did lose at first because I was trying to make you happy and we were drunk. I’m sorry!”

Rainbow sighed, calming a little, “Fine. Then what?”

“Well, I didn’t sleep very well because I kept thinking about how Mr. Rubinstein had our writs and of all the things he could make us do. I was scared. But then I thought about certain kinds of things, and, well… it wasn’t scary.” Fluttershy’s face turned bright red when she confessed.

Rainbow was both incredulous and accusatory, “So you rubbed one out? To the idea of being this guys property?”

Fluttershy mumbled something incomprehensible from inside her hoodie as she held the drawstrings tight.

“That’s pretty depraved, Shy.” Rainbow had one eye raised in mild disgust.

Rubinstein was curious, and he began to go over every interaction with the quiet mare. “I remember! It was your idea, wasn’t it? You mentioned that you didn’t want to be my love slave. I hadn’t even thought about anything like this until then.”

Fluttershy mumbled and turned around, “It wasn’t… Ooh. That’s not right.”

Rainbow sighed. “Just spit it out, Shy.”

Fluttershy made a high pitched whining noise, and then slowly spoke. “I was scared! I just said the first thing that came to mind. I was thinking about the book I’d read with the Lord that collected writs. I didn’t mean to make it real.”

Rainbow rubbed her forehead, “So is that why you wanted us to wear the sunglasses?”

“That was supposed to be a joke! But then, you said it was a good idea. I didn’t want to tell you that you were being stupid. So I thought that maybe you wanted to lose. And if you wanted to lose, I’d… um…” Fluttershy paused, and then her voice cautiously raised, “just go along?”

“I never want to lose, Fluttershy.” Rainbow growled. Rubinstein could believe it. She seemed like the never surrender type.

Fluttershy let her hood slide open enough to see, and then turned around slowly and apologetically, “I realized that I was wrong when you didn’t know what a straight was.”

Rainbow just grumbled in response, muttering about poker hands.

“And then I knew that I messed up. So I tried to fix it with one last bet. I didn’t want you to get trapped if you didn’t want to.” Fluttershy grew quiet, sounding sad. “I was even ready to lie about the princess cards for you.”

Rainbow glowered at her.

Fluttershy sniffled, and lowered her face in shame, “I’m sorry. Everything really was an accident.”

Rainbow sighed in defeat. “Dammit, Shy.”

Rubinstein was amazed by the transaction he’d just heard. This changed things. He walked over to Fluttershy, and slowly pulled her hood off as she looked up at him with scared, blue eyes. Her hair tumbled out, and she trembled slightly. He spoke calmly now, putting on a little bit of a show to steel his nerves. He needed to ask directly, even after the confession, “Do you really like this sort of thing?”

She kept her eyes locked with his, like a fawn caught in a bright light. Slowly she nodded up and down, still terrified.

Rubinstein relaxed. She was more nervous than he was by far, and that helped him calm down. Staring at her, he noticed how cute she was in the hoodie; it made her look farm more innocent than her nervous confession implied. He wanted to tease her a little, give her something she’d enjoy while still scaring her a just a bit. Smiling, he reached over and patted her head like a dog. “You’ll make a good pet.”

Fluttershy blushed, turning bright red and uttering a quiet “meep” as he pet her.

“Well, that’s just fucking great.” Rainbow was watching with an eyebrow raised, trying to keep her distance. “I’m super glad you two sickos found each other. Now you can have your weird, deviant fantasies and I can get some sleep while pretending this bizarre nightmare never happened. Good luck. See you later.” Rainbow turned and walked towards the exit.

Rubinstein saw a brief flash of pain in Fluttershy’s eyes at Rainbow’s dismissive attitude toward her. Rainbow was being a bitch again, and that pissed him off. Did that she think she could leave, just like that? She was trying to be both sneaky and rude, a terrible combination. “You’re staying.”

Rainbow stopped, and turned around with an exaggerated shrug, putting her hand up defensively to mime innocence. “Hey! I don’t want any part of this.” She gestured at Fluttershy and then to herself, “Shy’s clearly into it, I’m clearly not.”

Into it didn’t matter—not when the terms had been clear. “We all agreed on the rules, and you acquiesced just fine.” He had won her in a fair game. She was up to no good again, trying to steal away his things. It just so happened that this particular thing was her.

Rainbow shouted back and threw her hands to the side, “Well I didn’t know that Shy was on your team!”

He wasn’t going to let her argue her way out. “That didn’t affect the outcome. She even admitted to being willing to lie for you.” Now that he thought about it, Fluttershy’s silent offer to Rainbow had been a little underhanded, which was not a trait he wanted to cultivate. They were his responsibility now, so their moral fiber was a reflection of him. Thinking on it, he added, “I’m going to punish her for that later.” Fluttershy quivered slightly under his hand, but didn’t shirk away from it.

Rainbow stared slack jawed, and then shook her head in confusion. “What?”

Her constant weaseling was frustrating him. He was done arguing with her. He had given them both chances, and if Rainbow had been too stupid to take advantage of them, that was her problem. Not his. He’d won her, and he wasn’t going to let her leave. He was also sick of her arguing, so he tried commanding her clearly. “You signed the writ. You don’t get to leave. Now come here.” He pointed to the ground just in front of him.

Rainbow groaned, “Ugh. Fine!” then walked to the spot that he’d marked, and glared hatefully at him.

Her defiant attitude was not a good feature for her. He scolded her with a reminder, “I own you now. Like it or not, you need to be obedient.”

Rainbow looked like she was going to murder him when she spoke. “Just cuz I have to do it doesn’t mean I have to like it.” She glanced briefly at Fluttershy, and then back to Rubinstein as she muttered, “Fucking creep.”

He wasn’t sure if the curse was for him or for Fluttershy. He didn’t like the idea of them fighting. While the thought of Rainbow arguing with him wasn’t ideal, it still seemed natural. Thinking about both them fighting with each other didn’t seem right. If there were any bad feelings between the two, they needed to be crushed, and quickly.

“Okay. New idea. You stand right here…” He grabbed Fluttershy roughly, and moved her right in front of Rainbow. “And you stay right there…” He took a step back and put his hand under his chin. “Now, hold hands. Both hands.” He smiled. This was a trick that had worked on him when he was a kid and didn’t get along with others. He was gonna take it up a notch, but it should still work.

Fluttershy reached out first, and Rainbow reluctantly grabbed her hands, looking angrily over her shoulder. Fluttershy was looking down at their hands, thinking silently.

Hopefully this would defuse the situation. “Now, look each other in the eye.” It’s hard to look at someone you’re hurting in their eyes and still be angry.

They both slowly looked. Rainbow suddenly didn’t seem nearly as aggressive, and Fluttershy was slightly blushing, probably from embarrassment. Ruby smirked, They seemed like they would be fine, any anger or deeper hurt had been passing. But he still had an idea that might cut down on any future bickering. He was going to mix an old chant his parents used to make him say with a more mature one that he’d never had the chance to recite before.

“Now, both of you repeat after me.” Rainbow’s face strained, but she didn’t look away from Fluttershy. Rubinstein hoped this worked. If either of them started laughing half way through or gave up, it might end poorly. “And speak clearly so I can hear you.”

He tested first, making sure they were repeating him. “Hello.” Both were, although Rainbow was slightly louder. He decided they performed good enough to start.

“I am your friend, and sister.” Both mares seemed surprised, but still repeated after him. “I will live with you, and I will sleep with you.” Rainbow stuttered on sleep with you but managed to work through it. They were both beginning to blush. “I will take care of you when you’re hurt.” They both said it easily. “I succeed and fail with you.” Rainbow was showing a faint smile. She seemed to be getting into it. “Together we will face highs and lows. And together we will pass through them.” Fluttershy was also showing enthusiasm, getting louder and more confident.

Rubinstein was pleased with how it was going, excited that maybe this would work. “We will be different, and we may disagree.” Fluttershy glanced down quickly, but then back up as she finished. “But that won’t tear us apart. Our bond is strong.” He noticed Rainbow reassuringly squeeze Fluttershy’s hands. He smiled at the affection. “With it we will love, and with love we will forgive.” Fluttershy seemed glassy eyed, smiling at Rainbow. Rainbow was blushing, and glancing to the side constantly.

“I will be yours, and you will be mine in all things.” He wondered if maybe he was laying it on a little thick when Rainbow glanced suspiciously at him as she recognized the line. Maybe he should have hid the marriage chant better instead of stealing that last one exactly line for line. Meh, he figured they were still repeating it and not interrupting him. Luckily, it was almost over.

“Hello, Sister. Welcome home.” Both mares blushed profusely, but said the lines and looked deep at each other.

He smiled, and let them know they were done. “Good job girls. You don’t have to repeat anymore.”

Both of the mares held quiet, lost in thought for a moment. Eventually Rainbow Dash broke the silence, leaning in closer and winking as she held Fluttershy’s hands. “Hey. He might be a jerk, but I didn’t lie. Okay, Shy?”

Fluttershy nodded. “M… Me too.”

Rubinstein wondered how much of the marriage chant Rainbow had recognized. It might have changed a little over time, but he doubted it was completely different. He also had hidden it in another chant and exercise that his parents made him do when he fought with his siblings. It didn’t really matter if she recognized it or not. As he thought, he noticed how they were now calmly standing and waiting. Seeing them that close with their flushed faces gave him an idea—there was an appropriate end to a marriage chant.

“Now, kiss.” Both mares looked at him, their eyes wide in surprise. After a moment of thought, he added, “And take your time.”

Dash rolled her eyes after a moment, but turned back to face Fluttershy. Fluttershy slowly turned back to face Dash, and swallowed. They looked each other in the eyes and leaned in, going for a soft peck on each others lips. Rainbow looked calm at first, but slowly got more stiff and nervous looking as the kiss drew on. Fluttershy was the opposite, awkward and stiff as she leaned forward, but closing her eyes and melting into Rainbow as she got into the affection. She even pulled on Rainbow’s hands, coaxing Dash more firmly into the kiss.

They slowly parted, Dash keeping her nervous face puckered for a moment while Fluttershy smiled softly back. Dash muttered, “Oh… whoa…” and Fluttershy blushed.

“See, it isn’t so terrible? Is it?” He sidled up next to Fluttershy, putting his arm casually around her shoulder as he looked at Dash. Fluttershy was warm under his arm, radiating heat through the neck hole in the hoodie.

Dash looked from Fluttershy’s face to his, and then grimaced. “I… Do I have to answer that, Ruby?”

He sighed dramatically. “Fine. Be that way. But now that we’re warming up, why don’t we get some clothes off. I think it’s getting hot in here, what do you think Fluttershy?”

Fluttershy fidgeted with her hair as she responded. “Oh… Um. I’m pretty warm. I guess.”

He raised an eyebrow meaningfully at Rainbow. “I’m also pretty sure I asked you to strip once already, didn’t I?”

Rainbow scowled. “Okay, Back to terrible.”

Fluttershy let go of Rainbow’s hands, and lightly gripped the base of her hoodie, getting ready to pull it over her head. Rubinstein stopped her, “Not yet. Your new sister goes first. We can both watch her.”

Rainbow glanced nervously at Fluttershy, and then back to Rubinstein. “I’m going to hate this, aren’t I?”

He didn’t answer, instead reaffirming his previous command. “Strip.”

Huffing, Rainbow took off the top half of her track suit. Underneath she was toned, her muscles gently rippling her blue skin. She wasn’t quite built like a body builder, but it was clear she was no stranger to the gym. Even though she was significantly shorter than him, Rubinstein was pretty sure that Rainbow could take him in a fight. Her wings were small, but strong looking, and they hung limply to her side.

Rainbow met his eyes as she bent over and slowly lowered her work out pants, daring him to break eye contact and glance at her uncovered, tightly fitting exercise panties. Rubinstein didn’t, instead evenly meeting her gaze.

He leaned on Fluttershy, putting his weight across her shoulders with his arm as he watched. He could tell that she was watching, too. He figured she was waiting for her turn, and watching to see what she could expect. Her eagerness to perform was cheering him, and he found himself enjoying Rainbow’s reluctant stripping more than he would have alone.

Rainbow’s pants dropped, sliding from her ankles to the floor. She stepped out of them, and kicked them to the side in a pile with her top. Standing up straight, she crossed her arms defiantly. “Happy?”

Rubinstein looked her body over. She was well shaped and had strong looking legs and arms. He figured the mare was probably all muscle, toned down for speed and efficiency. However, he wasn’t satisfied yet. “Not quite. Take em off.” He pointed to the floor.

Dash scowled and made a “Tsch” noise through her teeth. Rubinstein was jittery, he hoped his trembling didn’t make it to Fluttershy. This was the first actually lewd thing that he’s made either of them do, and it was giving him chills. Rainbow was reluctant, but still obeying him, and the sight of her increasingly naked flesh was certainly raising his interest; erecting it even. While he did feel just a touch guilty, the feeling was quickly being buried under more pressing wants.

Rainbow took a deep breath, and turned around to face away from him. She lowered her hands to the waistband of her panties and grabbed the elastic. Blushing, she looked over her shoulder at Rubinstein and Fluttershy. Then she angrily squinted and said a single word before turning her head away. “Pervert.”

Slowly, she pulled her skin tight panties down. He butt cheeks were firm and round, her cleft in between hidden by her multicolored tail. As she bent further down to get the underwear off, her tail lifted slightly; unwittingly teasing Rubinstein but still not revealing anything. Her fur was blue and unblemished, perfectly smooth as the panties slid across it. The stretchy cloth found the floor, and this time Rainbow didn’t step out of it. Instead she stood back up, put her arms across her chest and stared at the wall with her back to Rubinstein. “Now are you happy, asshole?”

He was in fact much happier. But he figured he could always be more happy and there was no sense in stopping now. “Come over here and we’ll see.” Now he could feel Fluttershy trembling under his arm as well. She’d grabbed his dangling arm with her hand for support. She was probably terrified of being face to face with her naked friend. Rubinstein grabbed her arm back, gently reassuring her. She’d get used to seeing Dash naked.

Rainbow looked angrily over her shoulder, and then swiftly turned towards him. Coming to a decision, she spread her arms as she walked, raising her palms up as well. She wasn’t hiding anything, her small slit was nestled between her thighs, with a tiny patch of rainbow colored fur topping it. She sounded more frustrated than anything. “There. That’s everything. I’m naked, and you can see it. Good job. Add it to your spank bank, you’re on a short list.”

She stopped in front of him, putting one arm on her hip and sinking slightly to that side in a confident pose. “We done yet?”

“Not quite. I still haven’t seen everything. How do you feel about doing a little warm up?”

Rainbow dash just scowled, naked.

“Lets say, oh.. Twenty slow hoof touches? The wide ones where you touch one side, then the other, then settle in the middle.”

Rainbow actually flipped him off, and cursed at him. “Fuck you.” But after her gesture she still did as she was told—bending all the way over, and stretching just like he asked. She kept her eyes closed as she did it, slowly moving from one hoof to the other, and sinking down into the middle. Then she’d slowly stand back up again and start over. It looked like she was pretending she was somewhere else, probably the gym.

Rubinstein walked around her, bringing Fluttershy with him. He settled behind and crouched down to the ground, looking under her tail as it lifted up and drifted to the side with each exercise. Her pussy lips were slightly spread due to her wide stance, giving him a view of her pink inner flesh. It stretched slowly with the rest of her, pulling slightly as she moved. Rubinstein noted her folds and where they met, marking it to his memory for later. Her body looked like lots of fun, even if her attitude was sour.

He also saw the tight little pucker nestled between her cheeks as her tail tried pointlessly to keep it covered. It was pink as well, and looked to be a ring of firm muscle. He wanted to touch it, and feel her warmth directly. From here, she smelled slightly sweaty. Not the unpleasant stench of B.O., but the smell of fresh sweat, more like wet skin. The muscles in her thighs were visible, gently rippling under her skin as she pulled them taught and then released them. He wanted to feel her, she looked strong. He could grasp her inner thigh, and squeeze if he wanted. The thought burnt into his mind, causing his body to warm.

Rubinstein stood back up, his body shaking. He was about out of courage. While his erection was uncomfortable in his pants, this was too much for him. Rainbow was doing naked hoof touches, and he’d almost reached out and grabbed her. He wasn’t ready for that yet. He didn’t need to rush either, he had plenty of time. Taking a step back, he held Fluttershy tightly for support. She let him, leaning into him as well. She’d seemed to understand what he needed, and provided quiet stability while he recovered,

They walked the rest of the way around, standing in front until Rainbow finished. Eventually, she stopped, stood up straight, and opened her eyes. She spoke evenly, with her face expressionless. “Did you get a good show?”

Rubinstein was surprised at how calm she acted. “I thought it was an excellent show, Rainbow Dash.” He still needed a moment, so he deflected the conversation, “You’ve been quiet, what did you think, Fluttershy?”

Dash blushed, catching Rubinstein’s notice. So she was embarrassed, just not by him. Fluttershy gripped his hand tightly, and then she relaxed, “I thought… you are very pretty, Rainbow.”

Dash raised an eyebrow, “Pretty, huh?”

“Oh yes.” Fluttershy nodded. “And strong. It was…. Um… Nice.”

“Thanks. I guess.” Dash was blushing slightly as well, a hint of pink on her cheeks as she cautiously appraised Fluttershy.

“Well, Fluttershy, I think it’s your turn.” He wasn’t sure how to feel or what to do with them, so he decided to swap. “Dash, switch places with her.”

Rainbow glanced hopefully back at her tumbled clothes, but Rubinstein shook his head. He wanted to escalate this, not de-escalate. She glared dangerously as she stepped closer.

Fluttershy cautiously stepped out from under his arm, and switched with Dash. Rubinstein put his arm over Rainbow’s smaller frame, her head only coming up to his shoulder.

Rainbow hissed dangerously when he touched her, “Watch it, buddy,”

“I think I will watch her, thank you. And while you’re watching her, how about you be a good little slave and just relax.” He could feel her body, whip tight under his arm. She was hard like a rock, tense to the core; whether from her nerves or anger, he wasn’t sure. He placed his warm hand against the soft side of her torso, and began to rub her fur. It was luxurious, she had short hair like velvet and an incredibly strong frame underneath. He was beginning to like owning this mare, her body more than made up for her poor attitude.

Rainbow shuddered in disgust at his touch, trying to pull away. She quickly changed her mind when he lightly grabbed around her abdomen, placing his hand high on her stomach. She eased next to him as he pulled her tightly against his body. He could feel her heartbeat with the palm of his hand, it was fast and heavy. Rubinstein chuckled, she wasn’t happy, but she was obedient. He’d press her limits later. First, he got to watch Fluttershy strip for him.

For her part, Fluttershy stood nervously, twiddling he drawstrings. Rubinstein admired her openly, and then spoke, urging her on, “While you are adorable in the hoodie, lets start with that.”

Fluttershy didn’t hesitate. “Yes, sir.” She peeled the hoodie above her head, revealing a buttoned white shirt underneath. Her arms were long, and she looked incredibly soft compared to Dash. He could see that she had much more cushion around her body, providing more ample curves. Especially her plush waist. Once the drooping hoodie was taken off, he saw exactly how much it hid, and he liked what he saw.

He wolf whistled, causing her to miss a button as she began to unbutton her shirt. Grinning, he turned to Rainbow and gave her a light squeeze. “What do you think, Dash? Isn’t she stunning?”

Dash mumbled, embarrassed at being asked to comment on her friend’s body, “Shy’s… yeah.”

“How about you loosen up a little, you’re still awfully tense.” He noticed that Rainbow hadn’t calmed down at all.

Dash answered wryly, “How about you let me put my clothes back on?”

Touche. “No dice, but nice try.”

Fluttershy continued to undress, and had managed to remove her shirt. She stood, half exposed and nervously waiting for further instructions.

Rubinstein was liking this whole experience. He began to relax, easing into his role as their boss. Smiling, he gave Fluttershy some encouragement. “Good job, Fluttershy. Now, finish up.”

“Oh... Okay, sir”. Fluttershy glanced between Rainbow and Rubinstein as she slowly dropped her sweatpants. She blushed furiously as Rubinstein and Rainbow realized that underneath she was already wearing nothing at all. Her sweatpants fell on the floor, and she carefully bent over and folded them up. While her pink hair and tail were much longer than Dash’s, she took extra care to not cover anything with them. Rubinstein and Rainbow both got an eyeful of everything the mare had to offer as she slowly folded her clothes up on the floor.

The demure pegasus finished folding her hoodie, blouse, and pants. Then she looked at Dash’s crumpled clothes and frowned, “May… May I fold Dash’s as well?”

Dash clenched tightly, like she had been punched in the gut. Rubinstein chuckled. He was really going to enjoy Fluttershy. “Of course. Fold away.”

Rainbow shivered as he firmly dipped his hand lower down her abdomen. She turned angrily up to look at him, grabbing his hand to stop its descent. “Hey. That’s off limits.”

“No. It is not.” He met her dangerous gaze with his own. “While your friend is folding your panties over there, I’m going to feel what they were covering.” She was challenging him, squinting her eyes as if to dare him to continue. Rubinstein didn’t like being told what to do. He owned her, and if he wanted to cop a feel, he would. She’d learn to deal with it. This would be her first lesson in that.

He dipped lower, his arm firmly sliding through her grip as it reluctantly loosened. He touched her rainbow pubic patch, and she pursed her lips as she bit back a response. He slid his hand between her legs, and a fire ignited in her eyes, but she stayed silent—livid, but silent. He pressed gently forward, and stroked her soft flesh, running his finger the length of her smooth slit. She trembled in rage, but allowed him to continue his molestation.

Rubinstein smirked at her having met her challenge. She stiffly turned to stare at Fluttershy, pretending to ignore his light touches and caresses. He explored her, gently spreading her lips and running his fingers across ever bit of flesh he could find. She was firm, her muscles tight under her skin. Her outer lips were smooth, pressed tightly together as he ran his fingers across the cleft. Carefully, he parted her flesh with a finger and stroked the length inside; his finger dragging against her tender inner flesh. Her arms slowly dropped to her side, where her hands balled into white knuckled fists.

While he loved having her like this, she was dry under his touch and shaking in rage. Rubinstein’s guilt was coming back as he realized that he was raping the mare. No, that wasn’t right. She had signed the writ, so it wasn’t legally rape. After all, you couldn’t rape a slave. She was his property, he could do what he wanted with her. He just wasn’t sure he wanted to keep doing that to her, that was all it was.

Awkwardly, he took his hand out from between her legs. She was trembling, every muscle in her body looked rigid. He was beginning to be worried. “You okay there?”

She didn’t look at him, and sounded like she was going to cry, “Don’t fucking touch me right now, Ruby.”

He didn’t want to just let her have her way, but maybe she needed a break. He might have moved too fast with her, and he didn’t want to hurt her. “Maybe you should swap with Fluttershy. Go clean up the cards, and get the table ready. We still haven’t had dinner and it’s late.” A menial house chore should help her calm down, mares liked that kind of thing.

She stepped away from him on shaky legs, and swiftly walked to the table where she put her hands on it and leaned over for support. “Fuck. This is real.” She muttered to herself, regaining her breath and her composure at the table. She glanced back at Rubinstein, then down at the table again closing her eyes and whining softly. “Fuck.”

He was uncomfortable with what just happened. Everything had felt just a little wrong. Rubinstein looked over to Fluttershy, dutifully folding Rainbow’s panties and putting them in a neat pile with the rest of the clothes. When she noticed him looking she held her tail up, giving him a clear view of her smooth underside.

Fluttershy looked more voluptuous than Dash, and her bottom looked a little different as well. Instead of a small smooth slit, she had a larger crevice with some of her inner flesh poking out just slightly. As far as he could tell, there was no pubic hair to speak of. Her asshole was larger too, looking softer and more delicate. Rubinstein could see his dick fitting comfortably in there, a thought that made him blush.

He decided to play with her for a while and see how she responded, “So, Fluttershy. How often do you not wear any underwear?”

She finished folding, and looked meekly up from the floor. “Oh… Umm… Just today. Sir.”

Dash let out an exasperated cry from over by the table where she was picking up cards. “Damn it, Shy! What the fuck?”

He ignored Dash’s distress, instead walking up to Fluttershy and reaching down to help her get to her hooves. She took his hands comfortably, and let him lift her up. Her hands were warm, and she was blushing. Without him forcing anything, she pressed tightly against his stomach. While Dash was significantly smaller than him, Fluttershy was just barely shorter, and probably weighed nearly as much. She just happened to be softer, and as she pressed comfortably against him, he realized exactly how soft she was.

Curious, he let her stay close, and wrapped his arms around her waist.“Well, Why was that?”

“I… umm. Didn’t want them to get dirty.” Fluttershy nervously turned her head to the side.

“Oh? And why would they get dirty?”

Fluttershy just blushed, flushing bright red and avoiding his eyes. Carefully, he let go of her waist with one arm, and lowered his hand down her stomach.

Fluttershy didn’t say anything, but she did slightly spread her legs for him. Rubinstein liked this much better. While Dash was annoying, arrogant, and cold, Fluttershy was warm and welcoming; in every way he could imagine. He raised his other hand to her neck, and slowly turned her to face him. He wanted to enjoy her, to feel her heartbeat under his touch.

Rubinstein leaned in and kissed her, spreading her lips with his tongue while he touched and stroked her pussy. She was hot and wet, and her soft body melted nicely into him. He knew she wanted him, she wanted his touch and heat. He gave it to her slowly, drinking in her kiss as she softly moaned and wrapped her arms around his back.

His fingers quickly grew slick, and he hummed happily at her willingness. She’d be fun, and he wasn’t about to waste her. Gently, he separated from the kiss and pinched her clit, causing her to lean into him harder. After a moment, she winked and then smiled. “Sir, you look warm. Wouldn’t you like to undress? I could help you cool off.”

Rubinstein gulped. Fluttershy was moving fast, and he wasn’t going to tell her no. He slipped his hand out from her depths, and took a step back. “Yeah…” He glanced down at his pants and then back up at her, “That sounds great.”

Fluttershy started to unbutton his shirt as he unbuttoned his pants. Quickly he found himself standing in just his underwear, and then he was wearing nothing. Fluttershy giggled, and grabbed his hand as she lead him to the now cleaned table.

Looking over her shoulder, she leaned forward and put her hands on the table like Rainbow had earlier, only she spread her legs and lifted her tail. Rubinstein had never had quite such an aggressive offer before, and carefully put his hand on her soft butt cheek.

He stroked her back end, slowly fingering her pussy as and nudging her asshole with his greedy hands, “Well. I guess if you insist….”

Fluttershy strained to raise her tail higher, “Oh, I do, Sir.”

Rubinstein found his erect cock quite hard. Rainbow hadn’t even wanted him to touch her at all, and Fluttershy was this ready to go? He eased his hips forward, causing her to coo appreciatively as his cock rubbed the folds of her pussy without penetrating her.

He wasn’t quite sure if things were moving too fast or not, but she seemed happy about the situation. And he certainly didn’t mind. Carefully, he eased his way inside, feeling the heat of her depths for the first time. He grinned in euphoria as he grabbed her hair, letting the strands fall through his fingers. He figured it would be the first time of many, then he wondered how many times he’d fuck her before he let her go free.

Fluttershy moaned, tilting her head back and smiling. He felt her quivering and hot around him, so he didn’t make her wait. Pressing hard, he pushed deep into her little slice of heaven. She spread wider and pushed back into him, meeting his thrust.

They began to fuck then, him riding her on the edge of the table while she moaned and slammed into it again and again. Rubinstein couldn’t believe this was happening. She was amazing. She moved like a liquid, bending and thrusting softly as she enjoyed herself.

He leaned forward, resting on her back as her wings flapped lazily with each thrust underneath him. The table shook, rocking and scraping across the floor with their rough movements. Fluttershy began to loudly moan, squeezing her pussy around his cock.

He couldn’t take it, it was all too much and too sudden for him. Rubinstein grunted, “I’m close...”

Fluttershy groaned when he said that, and pressed back against him. The added momentum dug him deeper than before, and he felt the tip of his cock kiss something deep inside of her. He couldn’t stop, and pulled out while yelling, “Shit!” as he uncontrollably came over her back side. He quickly glazed her asshole and pussy, covering her in his cum. A little got into her tail, and dripped down her ass crack.

Fluttershy murmured happily to herself, and slowly smeared her now messy ass against his deflating cock. “Did I do good, Mr. Rubinstein?”

“Uh… Damn…” He was still recovering, but the sweet tone in her voice made his cock twitch even as it was slowly shriveling. Holy fuck, he had not been ready for that. It had been sudden and intense, smashing his expectations. “Yeah. You did good, Fluttershy.”

He stood back and admired her, unable to take his eyes off her cum stained asshole and pussy. He had done that. That was his cum, and he was still wrapping his head around that. The whole thing had probably only lasted a few minutes at most, but Rubinstein figured he’d remember it forever.

Fluttershy stretched her tail up high, smiling. “Good. I like making ponies happy, sir.” She gracefully stood up, using him for momentary support as she turned around and planted a kiss on his cheek. “I’ll make you very happy.”

Rubinstein blushed, completely taken aback by her sudden aggressive shift. Was this really the same mare who’d tried to hide in her hoodie earlier? He looked over her shoulder, and saw Rainbow Dash standing in the doorway to the kitchen. Oh. He’d forgotten about her.

Her face was bright red, and her wings were spread wide. She was holding plates and knives, clearly for the table, but she had frozen in place, with her eyes wide open in disbelief.

Rubinstein was slightly worried about the mare, “Hey, Shy. I think we broke Dash.”

Fluttershy looked over at Dash and then calmly stated, “Oh. I’ll fix her!” Fluttershy happily walked to the frozen Rainbow, cum still trailing down her legs. Dash looked up at her in disbelief, her mouth hanging open and not saying anything. Fluttershy just leaned down and kissed her nose. “I’m going to go make dinner. You set the table and spend some time with Mr. Rubinstein.”

Fluttershy walked by Dash, and into the kitchen. Dash closed her mouth and then frowned as though she was going to say something, but turned around and saw Fluttershy’s cum covered backside. Dash apparently changed her mind, and walked awkwardly forward like some kind of stiff robot.

Ruby felt good. He’d had some quick and dirty sex, and it had been fun. He was always relaxed after cumming, so he decided to take advantage of the next few minutes. Sitting down in a chair and leaning back, he enjoyed the show as Rainbow awkwardly set the plates. Her clear confusion made the spectacle amusing, and her body was pleasant to watch. Eventually, she sat down in a chair across from him, careful to stay far away from the spot where Fluttershy had been earlier.

She stared at him, and her expression slowly morphed from disbelief to straight up sour. “So… got your rocks off, huh?”

Rubinstein glanced down at his still wet dick. Should he be sitting at the table naked and still wet from sex? He didn’t know what was normal anymore, and he didn’t really care. “Yeah.”

Rainbow looked down, inspecting her hands as she looked to be thinking things through. “Shy looked like she enjoyed it.”

He grinned slightly. The memory was still fresh, and he could hear her humming happily in the kitchen. She definitely seemed to enjoy it. “I think she did, yeah.”

Rainbow looked up and wrinkled her nose, staring at the spot where they had been. Eventually she looked at him and asked, “The table?”

Rubinstein didn’t know what to say. “It was her idea.” Everything about this exchange was just strange. He was naked, getting interrogated by the also naked friend of the mare who he just banged. His dick was still wet and they were both sitting and waiting for dinner.

Rainbow shrugged after a moment, slowly shaking her head, “I really can’t believe this.”

He honestly asked, “Which part? That you’re my slaves or that your friend is excited about it?”

Rainbow sounded confused, “Both?”

“Makes sense. It’s a big change, I guess.” He could understand. Fluttershy had gone through a very strange personality shift once he’d gotten her clothes off. Rainbow had probably never seen her friend get quite so intimate with a stranger. Not to mention that she probably now realized how different her life was about to get.

Rainbow frowned, and evenly stared at him. “I’m not like that. You know that, right?”

She was different. She was more normal, and also maybe a little more cold. He couldn’t expect the same from her. “Yeah.”

She kept her even stare, not showing any emotion, “So… you gonna fuck me, too?”

He thought about it. He had lots of time, he didn’t need to force her right away. It’d probably be better to slowly work her way up, getting a little more frisky with each encounter. “Not tonight, but yeah.”

Rainbow continued to stare at him, unnerving him slightly. “Any way I can get out of that?”

Here she was, always trying to weasel her way out of things. He’d hoped once they signed the writs she’d stop, but she hadn’t. It had been a constant stream of her trying to escape. There was no escape, why did she keep thinking there was? Did she think she could walk out and the writ would disappear?

He could be nicer to her, or meaner to her, but she was his. What was wrong with her? Didn’t she understand the concept of slavery? She didn’t look like some sheltered noble from a prissy family. Fluttershy understood. He guessed from her behavior that she’d spent some time as a slave before, like he had. She even seemed to enjoy it.

Rubinstein had never owned slaves himself, but they were common growing up. And he had spent some time as one as well. It wasn’t a bad life, especially when the owner was as nice as he was. The more he thought about it, he just started to get frustrated as he worked through her continued weaseling. Deciding not to ruin the only decent conversation he’d had with her yet, he just stated, “No.”

“Shit.”

Author's Note

So, what does everybody think about this? He's definitely in the wrong, but what about Fluttershy and Dash?

Bits of advice and editing done by http://www.fimfiction.net/user/ambion