It's no secret that Scootaloo doesn't have a sense of direction, but Apple Bloom and Sweetie Belle would never have imagined she'd lead them in circles for lost treasure that may or may not exist.

When it begins to rain, they find shelter in an isolated cabin in the woods. Unfortunately, the cabin already has an inhabitant… a really hungry ogre, and he has his eyes on the Cutie Mark Crusaders. As they're bound by rope and the Ogre prepares a large, black cauldron, the Cutie Mark Crusaders make a deal with him: if they can entertain him by telling the best stories they can come up with, he'll let them go. The Ogre is not easily entertained, but decides to take their bet. There's nothing like a good story before a meal.

Three fillies, three stories, and one very hungry (and very impatient) ogre.