During the car ride Twilight turned to Fluttershy and Rainbow Dash and thought about something.

"What if I was wrong...." she asked out loud, Rainbow and Flutters looked over.

"What?" asked RD.

"What if I was wrong...." Twilight repeated.

"Wrong about what?"

"What if I was wrong about Big Macintosh?" Twilight said. "and the real killer is still out there maybe Cadence...." Rainbow then quickly interrupted Twilight.

"No Twi, don't listen to that Cadenza bitch, you said it yourself you saw what his body structure looked like when he walked out"

Twilight looked down. "Rainbow, what I mean is that.....Cadenza would technically be right.....anyone could have worn Mac's jacket....it would be pretty tough to see someone when it's almost pitch black at night...."

Rainbow looked at Fluttershy for her opinion. "Well......um.....I...I side with Twilight.....sorry Rainbow it makes a little sense...."

Rainbow nodded, being fine which side Fluttershy chose. As the 3 mares stayed silent, Shining spoke up.

"Hey guys, lighten up, this is one fucked up adventure we're having with this killer on the loose on our quiet town which is not so quiet anymore.....yeah?"

"Yeah......" The mares answered in unison.

"But...we all should remember to stay positive, like your Get Together, that's fun right?"

"Yeah..." This time they sounded a little confident.

"So lets put all of this killer vibe away for tomorrow and have some fun!"

"YEAH!"

"ok...ok...not too much." Shining and the girls all shared a good laugh as they stopped in front of the store.

"Alright girls c'mon!" said Rainbow as she, Twilight, Fluttershy, and Shining ran out of the car.

Dual Blade rode a cart of DVD cases to where he needed to place them, until he almost hit a blue stallion.

"Hey, watch it jackass" the stallion said, as Dual Blade climbed off of the cart.

"Sorry" he replied as the stallion walked off.

Dual Blade took some cases from the cart and before he was about to put them away....a mare came up behind him.

"Boo!" she said, which caused Blade to jump and drop the DVDs he was carrying.

Turning around he saw Sage, his old friend from when they were in Nursery, laughing.

"Ha Ha very funny" Blade said sarcastically, bending over picking up the cases as Sage walked around the shelves.

"How's it going Knives?" she asked, leaning on the shelves.

Dual Blade picked up the DVD cases and snickered a little, hearing the nickname Sage used ever since they saw each other again after the 4th grade. "Nothing much...." he replied, putting some DVD's in their proper place as Sage looks around.

"Damn this place is packed today."

"Yeah...we got a run in at the Horror movie section."

"So your going to the Get together at Fluttershy's?"

"Yep, I'm out early thanks to the curfew."

Before Dual Blade could say something else a green stallion walked over to them. "Excuse me, Do you have those movies when 4 ponies get corrupted to kill thanks to Pinkamena?"

Dual Blade nodded. "Pinkamena, Twilight, Rarity, and Applejack X. All 4 movies are right over there." he told the stallion while pointing to where the movies were located.

The stallion thanked him and walked to the aisle while Dual Blade looked at Sage again. "Anyway, what brings you here Sage?"

"Nothing...." Sage replies, slowly sliding her finger on the top of the shelves and holding her head up with her left arm. "I was just checking to see if you're alright with the whole 'Twilight thing'."

Dual Blade looked up and smiled at his long lasting best friend. "I'm ok...Thanks for being there for me."

"Hey no problem man, always happy to help you."

Sage then picked up her hand and booped Dual Blade on the tip of his muzzle causing him to scrunch his face, and causing Sage to laugh again.

Dual Blade chuckled. "I've just been really stressed with this whole thing...."

Sage smiled seductively. "Well......maybe I can help you relieve some of that stress..." she said, giving Dual Blade the 'bedroom' eyes and flicking her pull tab on the zipper to her jacket up and down playfully.

Dual Blade looked at her. "Sage, I'm working right now."

Dual Blade and Sage knew each other for a long time that they're comfortable with having sex together, but they don't see each other as a couple just staying as 'friends with benefits' is fine with them.

Sage playfully whined. "Come on.....you should know that a woman needs a release too.....this day just never ends!"

Dual Blade cupped her cheek in his hand. "I promise ok? After the party we'll go straight to my house. My parents will be out for the rest of the week anyway."

Sage smiled. "Yay, I can't wait!"

Dual Blade pulled his hand away from her cheek and started to get serious. "Anyway....I'm still concerned who the killer might be...." Sage then thought of something.

"Hang on Knives......What about Twilight's father?"

"Twilight's father? Why him?"

"Well.....think about it....why can't the cops find him?"

"How do you know that?"

"Well....Twilight keeps trying to call her dad in the bathroom while class is going on and she always puts the call on speaker for some reason.....I just happened to be at the right bathroom at the right time considering we don't share any classes except Math and Science...and I kept hearing the phone go straight to voicemail...ha ha..while hearing Twilight cuss in the process."

Dual Blade started to think. "You could be on to something.....but what if he's already dead?"

"What makes you say that?"

"Well....if this was a slasher movie his body could pop up anywhere eyes gouged out, fingers cut off, guts hanging on the outside!"

his voice started to rise to full screaming volume. "see the cops are stupid in this town...if they watched Hours Loom they'd save time. You see there's a formula to it a VERY SIMPLE FORMULA! EVERYPONY'S A SUSPECT!!!!!

Every single pony in the store went silent and looked at the 2 teens.

Dual Blade saw everypony looking mostly at him and he chuckled nervously. "heh heh.....sorry." The ponies then went back to what they were doing. "You know what I mean right?"

"I guess....anyway would it be ok if I stay here with you?, so that way when you're done we can go from here."

Dual Blade nodded. "Sure, it'll only take an hour before I can go, plus if you get bored their playing a full movie on the TV over there, it's your favorite Pinkamena 2.

"Really?, Awesome!" Sage then rushed over to the TV and sat down in a nearby chair, watching the movie then she noticed what she's on. "Damn it, I missed the 1st kill."

Dual Blade laughed and shook his head playfully. "She hasn't changed a bit." he mumbled to himself as he continue putting the DVDs away.

As Twilight, Fluttershy, Rainbow, and Shining walked out of the store, they were carrying bags filled with snacks for the party.

Rainbow Dash looked around at the somewhat deserted town, It kinda reminded her of a movie she loved so she decided to ask Twilight something. "Hey Twilight, if they ever made this murder spree into a movie who would you want to play as you?"

Twilight started to think until Shining Armor spoke. "I think Rebecca Shoichet would suit you..." Fluttershy nodded in agreement.

Twilight continued to think and came with an answer. "Well....If the movie does happen...I would like Tara Strong to play as me."

"Yeah...funny thing is that I hear a little bit of her in your voice" said Rainbow agreeing with her.

Twilight chuckled a little as Rainbow continued. "well...I think we should have Ashleigh Ball play as me in the movie."

Fluttershy joined in. "I...I would like....um A..Andrea Libman to play as me....I...If that's ok with you guys..."

Shining joined in as well. "Andrew Francis for me."

While putting the snacks in the car Detective Sidney walked over to the group. "Excuse me girls I need to speak with Shining for a few minutes."

The girls nodded as Shining walked off with Sidney, telling the girls to wait in the car.

Around the corner of the grocery store, Sidney pulled out a file from her police jacket and gave it to Shining.

"What's this?" he asked, opening up the file.

"It's the phone history from Rarity's and Twilight's phones." replied Sidney. "We finally found out who called."

Shining looked through the 1st file and it read the following:

PVPF Phone History: The Belle Household/Business (Carousel Boutique 1st Floor)

6:00 Fancy Pants' Cellular: 555-7933

6:32 Sapphire Shores' Cellular: 555-1093

7:49 Pommel's Business: 555-0234

9:00 Hoity Toity's Cellular: 555-2173

9:55 Night Light Sparkle's Cellular: 555-2934

9:56 Night Light Sparkle's Cellular: 555-2934
9:58 Night Light Sparkle's Cellular: 555-2934

"Why did you highlight my dad's last call?" asked Shining.

"Remember when we discovered that Rarity received a phone call before she met her demise at 10:00?" asked Sidney, Shining nodded. "Well as you can see his last call is at exactly 9:58, and Rarity was confirmed to have died at 10:00, so you know where I'm getting..."

Shining refused to believe this. "M..My dad would never kill anyone!......Would he?!"

"You might want to look at the second file."

Shining quickly switched the files to Twilight's House, it read:

PVPF Phone History: The Sparkle Household (Living Room)

3:27 Night Light Sparkle's Cellular 555-2934

6:32 Rainbow Dash's Cellular 555-0020

6:33 Night Light Sparkle's Cellular 555-2934

As Shining looked on in the file, Sidney spoke. "Twilight confirmed she was attacked around 6:36 and since Night Light's call was 6:33 it would mean that he was talking to Twilight for about 3 minutes before the killer came out and attacked her, which would mean....."

Shining started to shake his head "No" while tears appeared in his eyes he couldn't believe it's true.

"Shining.......I'm afraid to say this but.......Your father is the killer!

Author's Note

Sorry for the delay

Also Instead of using Real life movies I've decided to use Fimfiction stories I've read in the past, those stories belong to their respective owners, You should read them their pretty good horror stories that would make great movies.

The Stories I used were Pinkamena 2, Pinamena X, AppleJack X, Rarity X, Twilight X (Those stories belong to Pinkamena666) and Hours Loom (Which belong to TheTimeSword)

Make sure you check them out, The Links to the stories are in this chapter if you wanna go straight there