Aria's Dilemma

by StormLuna

An Emotional Evening

Load Full StoryNext Chapter

Earlier in the day Aria and Sonata engaged in a very intimate and erotic moment, a moment that Aria had dreamed of for years but after Adagio offered Sonata tacos, her new girlfriend left her in a very compromised position just so she could go and eat. This left Aria feeling betrayed because she had given Sonata so much trust but in the end tacos would win out and she remained cuffed to Sonata's bed for two hours. Most of all though, it left Aria feeling hurt.


Supper time had arrived and while she was normally the first one into the kitchen to fix herself some food, Aria was strangely late. Adagio and Sonata had already fixed themselves their food and couldn't help but wonder where their sister was. Fifteen minutes after she normally would have went downstairs, Aria showed up to fix her supper. Both Sonata and Adagio gave her strange looks as she was not dressed like she normally was, she was wearing a black hoodie which hid most of her face.

Sonata was the first to say anything, "Ari, are you ok?"

Adagio added, "Yeah, we were worried about you. You're never this late for supper."

Aria was angry with both of them. Not only was she angry with Sonata over abandoning her for tacos, she was angry with Adagio for causing Sonata to abandon her in the first place. She mumbled, "Whatever."

Aria was not very hungry that night so she fixed herself a simple bowl of cereal. It wasn't just a matter of her not being hungry, she didn't want to be around her sisters any longer than she needed to be. While she was eating Sonata asked, "Ari, why are you wearing your hoodie?"

Adagio added, "And why are you hiding your face?"

Again Aria mumbled, "Whatever."

Sonata and Adagio gave one another strange looks wondering what was wrong, especially since Aria was in such a good mood earlier and given that her and Sonata had became girlfriends earlier in the day, Adagio couldn't help but wonder what happened. Aria finished her supper rather quickly, headed up to her room and shut the door.

Adagio asked, "Sonata, what is up with her? I thought she would be happy given everything that happened today."

Sonata replied, "I'm not sure. Maybe she is mad because I left her cuffed to the bed while we ate those tacos."

Adagio began to realize that perhaps this was her fault. She commented, "It could be. Maybe I should go up and talk to her."

Sonata replied, "Maybe so. I'm worried about her but I think it might be best if you go check on her."

Adagio headed upstairs towards Aria's room and knocked on her door. She heard nothing but silence so she headed in to find the curtain closed and nothing but darkness. After feeling around for a bit she found the light switch on the wall and turned it on. When she did this, there was still no sign of Aria but Adagio did notice something strange. She saw that Aria's closet was closed, which is normally not the case. When she opened it she found something she never thought she would see, Aria curled up into a ball sobbing quietly.

She leaned down and asked, "Aria, are you ok? Why are you crying?"

Aria, despite being emotionally broken growled, "Oh and why would you care?"

Adagio replied, "I care because this isn't like you. It isn't like you to eat a light supper, it isn't like you to not even talk to us and I never once thought I would see you in this state. I never once thought I would see you closing yourself up and be crying."

Aria gave her a death look and simply grunted. Adagio continued, "Aria, something is wrong and both me and Sona......."

Aria snapped, "Don't say that name! I don't want to hear it right now!"

Adagio gasped, "What? Why would you not want to hear her name, she is your girlfriend!"

Aria had enough of this. She got up and shoved Adagio, "Would you just leave me the hell alone? You can act like you care but I know you don't. If you gave a shit you wouldn't have done what you did this afternoon."

Adagio asked, "What, you mean with Sonata....."

Aria yelled, "Just GO AWAY and leave me alone!"

Adagio turned Aria's light off and shut her door. She headed downstairs realizing that maybe she was partly responsible for what happened. She began to realize that maybe she shouldn't have brought up those tacos when she caught her sisters in their moment.


When she returned to the dining room she had a look of concern on her face, which brought out more concern from Sonata. Sonata asked, "Dagi, what's wrong?"

Adagio replied, "Sonata, we messed up. I messed up mentioning those tacos and you messed up by leaving her cuffed to the bed."

Sonata said, "Maybe. I didn't even think about it. I just heard tacos and got excited." She looked towards the stairs and asked, "Do you think maybe I should go check on her?"

Adagio replied, "I'm not sure but you can try. She didn't even want to hear your name so I doubt she'll want to see your face."

Sonata gave her a nervous look before going up to Aria's room. When she headed in she immediately heard a yell, "Look Dagi, I said leave me the hell alone."

Sonata turned on her light and said, "Ari, it's me, Sonata."

Sonata was the absolute last person Aria wanted to even hear, much less see. She yelled, "Get the hell out of my room Sonata."

Sonata saw her closet door was shut so she opened it. Rather than finding Aria crying, she found an angry Aria. Sonata bent down to check on her to be met with, "Don't even think about it Sonata."

Sonata got down to where she was eye level with Aria and was met with the deepest glare she had ever seen. She asked, "Ari, what's wrong? Why are you hiding and why don't you want to talk to us?"

Aria was not one bit pleased with this question. She snapped, "You know what Sonata, you are the worst!" She threw her hands up and continued, "If you honestly don't know why I want to be left alone then you must be dumber than I thought."

The comment hurt Sonata greatly. She began to tear up, "Aria, I thought you loved me. Why would you say that?"

Aria yelled, "You want to know what has me so upset? You want to know why I'm like this? Fine, here you go! I allowed you to put me in a very vulnerable situation today, I gave you my heart, I gave you my trust but then you simply run off so you can eat tacos! You leave me cuffed to that bed for two hours while you eat tacos!"

Sonata said, "I'm sorry."

Aria snapped, "Oh, so you're sorry?" Her yell became angrier, "The only reason you say you're sorry is because you don't want to lose my love, right?"

Sonata was shocked by the accusation. She protested, "No Ari, I don't say it because I don't want to lose you. I say it because I love you and it hurts me to see you like this."

Aria snapped, "Bullshit." She shoved Sonata back and yelled, "Just get the hell out of my room and leave me alone, ok?"

Sonata went rushing out of Aria's room with tears in her eyes. She never imagined that the day would end like this. Her and Aria were so happy earlier in the day and now Aria was very angry and she felt hurt that Aria would treat her so poorly.


When she returned to the dining room Adagio could see the anguish in her eyes. She asked, "I take it things didn't go well?"

Sonata began to cry, "No! She told me I am the worst and she told me I was dumb!"

Adagio asked, "Why would she call you dumb? I thought she loved you."

Sonata replied, "She called me dumb because I didn't get right away why she is acting like this." She then began to scream, "And this is all your fault! You just had to bring up those tacos didn't you?"

Adagio stood up and yelled, "Don't you go blaming all this on me. No one ever said you had to come down for those tacos or you could have at least uncuffed her."

Sonata screamed, "Well you know how I am when it comes to tacos." Something crossed her mind, perhaps Adagio was jealous. Her scream became angrier, "You were just jealous! You were just jealous that I have Aria and you wanted......"

Adagio interrupted, "Look Sonata, you can claim to love Aria all you want but I know tacos are your real love."

Sonata screamed, "What?"

Adagio repeated herself, "Tacos are your real love. If you truly loved Aria you would have put her first but that obviously isn't the case."

Sonata went quiet when she heard this. She sat down and began to cry realizing that she shouldn't have put the tacos first. She began to cry, "What am I going to do? I'm afraid I lost her Dagi, what do I do?"

Adagio sighed, "Give her time Sonata, maybe she will calm down and if that doesn't work maybe the two of you need to sit down and talk. You can let her know that she truly is your first love and apologize over this. Once she has calmed down, I'm sure things will work out."

Sonata replied, "I certainly hope so."

The rest of the evening was full of negative emotions for both Aria and Sonata. Aria continued to sit in her closet full of both anger and sadness. She was very angry that Sonata would do what she did yet at the same time she felt like Sonata had abandoned her for something more important. Sonata was full of sadness. She realized that what she did was wrong and very selfish. She hoped that once Aria calmed down, that they could talk and that everything would be ok.

Next Chapter