Shivered Timbers' Sexty Minute Ponies

Doubly Mared 1
by Shivered Timbers

(Prompt: Nopony can know about us. Will likely be revised and posted as part of a series later.)

"Cara, what are we doing?"

The dark-coated stallion grunted and stumbled as his paramour led him deeper into the Everfree Forest.

"C'mon, Zig, it'll be fun!" Caramel's eyebrows wiggled up and down and he swished his hips. "Nopony will ever know!"

"That's what I'm afraid of." Ziggy Stardust glanced over his shoulder the way they'd come. He could no longer make out Sweet Apple Acres behind them. "Don'tcha think somepony in your family is gonna notice we're not applebuckin'?"

Caramel rolled his eyes. "Please. I'm such a screwup at apples, even if they did notice, they'll be happy I'm gone. And you're just a volunteer after all, not even hired seasonal help." He ground his teeth together. "Granny Smith and Applejack were getting on me to settle down again. I just had to drag you away, don't you see?"

Ziggy nodded. "All right. But I still don't get why we had to come here, of all places. This ain't exactly romantic."

"Oh, it's plenty romantic," Caramel purred. "And more importantly, it'll keep prying eyes out of our manes for a little bit so we can have some fun." He leaned down, lifting his rump invitingly. "You like fun, don't you Zig?"

Ziggy licked his lips, feeling arousal slide forth from between his legs. "You betcha!"

The pert brown rump snapped up and took off down the path. "Then you gotta catch me, mister!"

With a whoop and a laugh, Ziggy was off after his quarry. They barreled down a surprisingly well-marked path, albeit one bordered by twisting branches, thorns, brambles, and all manner of scary, dark trees. But with lust hot on his heels, Ziggy was able to put all of that out of his mind and focus on the pursuit.

Hollering, Caramel suddenly disappeared from sight, and Ziggy's heart raced.

"Cara, you okay? What happened?"

"I'm all right!" Caramel coughed. His voice sounded funny. "I'm down here! Be careful you don't--"

"Ahhh!"

As he leaned over to see what had happened to his lover, the ground gave way under Ziggy's hooves and he slid down to land in a patch of flowers.

"Oh, my achin'... What's wrong with my voice?"

He stood, checking himself for injury and finding none, then looked to Caramel. What he saw blew his mind.

Instead of the bubbly, round stallion he had met at his club those many months ago, before him stood a mare, of similar proportions and exact coloration. She even had the same triple-horseshoe cutie mark.

"Zig, are you okay... All right, my voice sounds weird, too."

The mare peered at him, and then recoiled slightly in horror.

"You're a mare!" they cried in unison.

"Oh no, oh no!" Ziggy raised her hooves, staring at them in disbelief. "What're we gonna do? I can't go back to work like this!"

"Zig, calm down, it's okay." Caramel the mare trotted over to her and nuzzled her gently. "Deep breaths, it's okay, I promise."

"What the hay happened, Cara?" Ziggy felt tears at the corners of her eyes.

"It's these flowers," she replied, looking down. "I heard something about this from my cousin Applejack." She stamped a hoof. "Ponyfeathers, what a dumb idea this was!"

Ziggy had by this time fallen back onto her rump, still staring at her hooves. "Caramel, I feel funny."

Caramel rolled her eyes. "No duh."

"No, I mean I feel..." She swallowed. "Horny? But it's kinda... different."

"You do know that colts and fillies have different parts, right?" Caramel's vapid expression quickly turned devious. "Hmm, that gives me an idea. You know, you are an awfully hot mare..."

"Oh no!" Ziggy shook her head, scooting backward on her haunches. "I ain't into fillies the way you are, bucko!"

"You mean you're not into fillies like... me?" Caramel lidded her eyes, pouting her lips and shaking her rump. Ziggy swallowed, unable to help feeling a strange attraction.

"I'm not your 'buck' anymore, sweetheart. Why don't you spread those gams and I'll show you how the other half loves, hmm?"

Ziggy made a face. Then she looked down between her legs. The plumbing was all wrong! Not that she should have expected anything else, it was just hard to wrap her head around was all. Not to mention said plumbing was currently leaking.

"I, uh..."

"C'mon, Zig, what harm could it do? We came out here for a little nookie in the first place anyway." Caramel poked her nose against Ziggy's raised hooves. "If we change back now or later, it doesn't matter. When are you ever going to get a chance to try this again?"

"I, uh..." Ziggy swallowed. "Okay. But just this once, I'm warnin' you."

She spread her legs as bidden, and leaned back on her elbows for support. Caramel got straight to work, lapping at Ziggy's folds. The sensation was electric.

"Oh my Celestia, it's like you're giving me a whole blowjob all at once!"

"Take notes," Caramel murmured, looking up. "I'll show you the ropes and then we're both going at it, got it?"

Ziggy nodded numbly, watching as Caramel used a hoof to stimulate her nub. If the previous licking had been electric, this was more of a thunderstorm. Ziggy threw her head back, moaning passionately. Heat rose in her chest as her new fillyfriend probed here and there with tongue, lips and nose.

"Now lie back..."

Ziggy did so, and soon had a full view of brown mare rump. She swallowed.

"C'mon, don't be shy." The rump swayed overhead. "I'm not starting until you do; hope you paid attention!"

The rump lowered onto Ziggy's muzzle and she tasted musk and salt. She gave a tiny, tentative lick and the mare above her shivered.

Then she steeled herself. Yeah; when was she gonna get to try this ever again? There was always a first time for everything! Closing her eyes, she inserted her tongue into the soft folds presented to her and began licking.

"Ooh, yes, just like that! Ohh, you're a good learner!"

Soon, the lightning sensation between her own thighs intensified and they were both eating each other out with gusto. The blue flower bed made a soft cushion beneath Ziggy as she bucked and writhed under her marefriend's ministrations. Her own attentions were directed solely at the joining of the nub and folds, and Caramel for her part seemed thoroughly satisfied by it.

It didn't take long for Ziggy to come, and instead of the usual piercing of fire and squirt or two, it was a rolling sensation, a wave of ecstasy that coursed through her entire body. It was like riding a cloud high over Equestria, moving and staying still all at once, and moving some more, until she thought she might burst at the seams.

Caramel came in the midst of this, and coated Ziggy's muzzle with thick, creamy juices, which she had definitely not been expecting. The taste wasn't dissimilar to Caramel's sex, however, so she made the best of lapping them up. Caramel groaned and mmm'ed, then shifted around until they were face to face.

"So what'd you think?" she asked, kissing lazily under Ziggy's chin.

"I think that was pretty darn incredible," Zig responded, holding her mare close. "I almost wanna do this again sometime."

Caramel smiled sadly. "I don't think this stuff works that way, honestly. We just got lucky this time." She kissed Ziggy full on the lips, and the two reveled in exchanging their own flavors with each other.

When the kiss broke, Ziggy let out a sigh of relief. Her satisfied expression quickly turned into a frown.

"Okay, well... Now we had our fun. What about going back?"

Caramel grimaced. "Yeah, I, uh... I really have no idea."

Ziggy glanced at the flowers, then back to Caramel.

"Well, if we're gonna be stuck this way for a while... Round two?"

Caramel grinned. "Round two!"