Pinkamena lay propped up on the bed, with Fluttershy spread across her back legs. With her back braced against the headboard, Pinkamena held the leash to Fluttershy's collar in one hoof, while she brushed her pet with the other. The work was both stimulating and relaxing, allowing her to express dominance over Fluttershy, while also being a nice break from more sexual domination.

In her own world of bliss, Fluttershy lay fully extended across Pinkamena's legs. The wing nearest Pinkamena just hung limp, but the other was stretched out over the bed. Behind her, Fluttershy's back legs were stretched back, forcing her rump to squeeze tightly on the slick fluids within. Her forelegs were stretched out too, and her head rested on her yellow furred limbs. Eyes closed, she made a soft, happy sigh with each stroke of the brush.

"We don't often spend time just cuddling before sex." Pinkamena kept the brush moving, only aware Fluttershy even heard her voice when she flicked of one of ears towards Pinkamena. "I love cuddling with you. I love playing with you. And while I don't think I can really be around much more often, I love having sex with you."

Eyes closed still, Fluttershy barely managed to nod her head the slightest amount. Moving further would require her to stop feeling so relaxed, and her Mistress had told her to relax. "I love you." The words were out before Fluttershy realized it, and once they were out she couldn't take them back—not that she wanted to.

Pinkamena's hoof froze, causing the brush to as well. Between one heartbeat and the other, she ran through the weeks that led to this moment. That first time, as Pinkie Pie without her promise, had been a revelation for her alter ego. When they had come together again it was like her own conception, and then when Pinkie Pie had climbed into the box fully and left her behind to have control had been her birth.

Smiling, Pinkamena poked at the box in her head, rousing Pinkie Pie from a dormant state. Amusement boiled out from the pony in the box; amusement and love. "We love you, too."

Fluttershy turned her head and looked up at Pinkamena. Her heart swelled with excitement at hearing the words back. A happy giggled bubbled up from deep inside, and Fluttershy pulled her wings in to her sides, and rolled away from Pinkamena.

Winding up on her back, Fluttershy kept her body fully stretched out, and looked at her Mistress with bedroom eyes. "Mistress, I want you." Her leash was taut, and though Fluttershy felt the collar straining in Pinkamena's direction, there was no pull at it.

Staring for just a moment, Pinkamena shivered in pleasure. The cuddling was over the moment Fluttershy called her Mistress again. Pinkie had spent some bits on more toys than just a leash, however, and now Pinkamena wanted to make use of what her other half had purchased.

Climbing off the bed, Pinkamena fastened her end of Fluttershy's leash to a bedpost. "You wait just like that, pet, I have some things I think you will like." Leaning down, Pinkamena kissed Fluttershy, bringing her lips down and shoving her tongue forward the moment they made contact.

Squirming on her back, Fluttershy surrendered her mouth to her Mistress, parting lips and teeth to let Pinkamena delve into her. Her own tongue was immediately pressed down firmly, pinning it in place while her lips were ravaged by her Mistress.

Pinkamena held Fluttershy in the embrace until she felt the pegasus relax again. Pulling her lips back slowly, she licked her pet's lips before drawing away. "Hold that thought." Walking to the box of "party" supplies Pinkie Pie had purchased, Pinkamena reached inside and pulled out a hefty butt plug first, then a set of rubber socks.

Twisting from side to side on the bed, Fluttershy tried to do what Pinkamena had commanded, and kept naughty, submissive thoughts high in her mind. "Mistress?" She didn't lean up to see what Pinkamena was doing, but when she felt a hoof touch her plot, she stilled her movement.

The hoof stroked gently between Fluttershy's back legs, a tender rubbing of her tender belly, but it was the touch to her tail-hole that made her moan. She couldn't help it, the thought of her Mistress pushing into her was just too arousing, but before Fluttershy could realize the touch wasn't Pinkamena's shaft something started to push into her.

Hard, tapered, and very slick; Fluttershy moaned louder as Pinkamena started to work the plug into her anus. Her sphincter was already stretchy from her Mistress' shaft, which made the entry of the toy a smooth widening process that had Fluttershy flapping her wings in excitement.

"You really love me playing with your ass, don't you?" Pinkamena kept her pressure up on the toy, and watched Fluttershy's body accept more of it with each push. The toy was almost all the way in, and Pinkamena was rock hard in excitement. She judged the thickness of the plug was just a little bigger than her own "self."

Fluttershy froze as the full extent of the toy was pressed to her anus. She stared ahead, not even breathing for fear that Pinkamena would shove the whole thing inside her. It teetered, the thickest part holding her pucker stretched around its girth.

"Buhhhhkkkkk…" Fluttershy's eyes closed slowly as the shape pushed past its widest point, and her tight sphincter pulled at the trailing edge, dragging the toy deeper into her. Wiggling her butt, she made happy, whimpering noises as the plug seated itself, and her body started to get used to it.

"Full?" Pinkamena rubbed her hoof in a repeating circle around the base of the plug, where it snugged up against Fluttershy's pronounced anus. "You look so full. Do you still want your Mistress to take you?"

Fluttershy was panting for breath, the sensation of being played with, moments after the hefty plug was inserted, made the bloated feeling of her rear into a constant throb of pleasure. When the circling turned into a stroke of her vulva, she moaned loudly again.

"That wasn't an answer." Repeating the stroke, Pinkamena was just about to climb up when she heard the softest, but most important word of her life.

"Wait." Fighting with the arousal she was experiencing, Fluttershy felt she needed just a little bit. "P-P-Please I just need a bit."

Pinkamena entered a little panic. She looked at the hefty plug, and to the mare she loved, and didn't know what to do. "Sh-Should I take it out? Do you want to stop? I didn't hurt you, did I?" The worry and panic grew, and she reached for the base of the plug to pull it out.

The moment Pinkamena's hooves touch the plug, Fluttershy shouted (despite her earlier moans, a Fluttershy shout is actually a lot quieter), "Stop!" Panting a few breaths, she reached a hoof up to her collar and unfastened the leash. "I'm okay, Pinkamena. I just need a few moments." With her head free to move, she tilted her neck forward and looked down her body at Pinkamena.

When Fluttershy saw the look of worry on Pinkamena's face, she reached out with all four legs for a hug. Letting out a sharp breath when her Mistress pounced into her embrace, Fluttershy pulled Pinkamena close. "It's okay. I'm okay. I just wasn't expecting something that—this big."

Clinging to Fluttershy as tight as she could, Pinkamena shook her head. "I thought I hurt you. I just wanted you to have something, and I think Pinkie Pie might have gotten something too big, and—" A kiss to her snout cut off Pinkamena's little outburst, and she looked at the mare kissing her. "Just tell me you are okay."

"I'm okay. You didn't hurt me." Fluttershy nuzzled against Pinkamena's snout, her voice making soft little whimpers. "I-I really like it, now I am used to it. I feel full, and stretched, and now we can keep going, if you want?"

Fluttershy didn't need to see Pinkamena's smile and little nod to see her Mistress wanted to continue, the proof was pressed firmly against her belly. "Mistress." The way Fluttershy said the word spoke volumes for her intent. "Let your pet take care of you."

Pinkamena thought about it, pondered what it would be like to be tended to. She nodded slowly, and her little smile grew more. "Be good to your Mistress, and I may just take that plug out."

The fantasy of spending a whole week with the plug in never once touched on the reality of what such would mean, but nonetheless Fluttershy was aroused that Pinkamena would have enough control of her as to be able to do just that. "Of course, Mistress." She bobbed her head, kissed Pinkamena's snout, and rolled off the bed. "Mistress, if you would lay on your back, please?"

"Asking me to do things? I should rut you for an hour to teach you your place." Pinkamena, despite her threat, rolled to her back and stretched her back legs out. A gentle touch started at her rear, left hoof, and when she looked, Pinkamena saw Fluttershy holding the leg carefully, while nuzzling the foot.

"Oh…" Flopping her head back, Pinkamena felt Fluttershy's tongue lap around her frog, her soft lips kissing every part of her hoof again and again. The soft touch of something new surprised her, but when she felt Fluttershy rolling the latex sock up her leg, Pinkamena nearly squealed with delight.

Fluttershy was having a ball. Completely wrapped in a submissive fantasy, she had caressed and worshiped Pinkamena's hoof before sealing it away under the rubber. "Am I pleasing you, Mistress?"

"Very much so, pet. I thought Pinkie got those for you, but maybe she got them for me." When the last of the rubber sock petered out at her stifle, Pinkamena lifted the leg straight up and looked at it. Shiny and black, she felt her shaft jerk and bob as her arousal built further. "More."

"As my Mistress commands." Fluttershy curved her wings around this time, cupping Pinkamena's hoof with one, she brushed it with the other, and nuzzled for all she was worth. The soft frog got most of her attention, but when she was done the hoof had been given a thorough tongue bath all the way to Pinkamena's fetlock.

When the second rubber sock rolled up her leg, Pinkamena let out a little sigh of delight. It passed her hoof and her cannon, rolled over her gaskin and, like the first, finished up all the way to her stifle. "Good filly."

Fluttershy almost danced at hearing the praise. She plucked up the remaining two socks and pressed her chest to Pinkamena's belly. "I hope you don't mind your pet laying on you?" Fluttershy nuzzled Pinkamena's shaft before she slid forward.

Squealing in surprise, Pinkamena looked down her body to see Fluttershy squirming along. Belly to belly, Fluttershy stopped just shy of Pinkamena's forelegs, letting her admire the mischievous gleam in her pet's eyes. "Pet, you seem a lot more active than normal. Are you feeling okay?"

"Of course I am, Mistress." The truth was, Fluttershy was split between being terrified she was pushing too far and desperately wanting to hear Pinkamena tell her she is good. The strangest thing for Fluttershy, however, was that her tail just wouldn't hold still. The hefty plug inside her seemed to trigger her body's need to flag her tail, while also making it restless. The end result was her pink, flowing tail was swishing side to side like a happy dog's.

Much closer to her pet, Pinkamena held up one hoof to Fluttershy's snout. "Be a good filly now." She wiggled the tip until, to her shock, Fluttershy opened her mouth and sucked her hoof inside. Pinkamena's eyes were wide, and her shaft was suddenly aching in arousal. She could feel Fluttershy's tongue licking the underside of her hoof, and the submissiveness of the gesture almost sent her into an orgasm.

With her snout dipped to Pinkamena's hoof, Fluttershy rolled her eyes up so she could look at her Mistress' face. The look Pinkamena shot back to Fluttershy told her that she was doing the right thing. Closing her eyes, Fluttershy sucked on the foot. Breathing through her nose carefully, Fluttershy repeated the process, sucking again and again.

"Please…" Pinkamena hated to beg Fluttershy, but if her pet continued she was going to lose herself. "Fluttershy, other hoof, now." The message got through, and Fluttershy sucked back and let Pinkamena's hoof pull free. But it wasn't time to move on yet, apparently; Pinkamena watched as Fluttershy brought the next sock up to the "cleaned" hoof, and began rolling it on. "Good filly."

A pleased little sound leaked from Fluttershy's snout in response to the praise, and she kept rolling the sock on until Pinkamena's foreleg was clad all the way to her elbow. "How would Mistress like her last hoof cared for?"

"Suck it, pet." Traitorous words though they were, Pinkamena couldn't resist feeling that expression of Fluttershy's submission again. Lifting her hoof a little, she booped Fluttershy on the nose before the whole foot was engulfed. Pinkamena moaned loudly and threw her head back. She lost some of her control and Mr. Humpy lived up to his name.

Bucking her hips, Pinkamena scrunched her eyes shut when her whole body shuddered. She couldn't control herself, and bucked again and again as she shot a hot mess between their bellies.

Fluttershy felt what happened, but it just made her murmur happily around Pinkamena's hoof. She suckled again, building the same repeating pattern as the previous time. The sticky heat soaking into her fur was easy enough to ignore, particularly when Fluttershy felt Pinkamena harden up again.

Pinkamena was panting, and her eyes were locked on Fluttershy's. When her pet finally slurped off her hoof, Pinkamena gave a little sigh of relief. "You are entirely too good at that." She booped Fluttershy again before the sock was prepared.

"Thank you, Mistress." Fluttershy put as much of her desire into the last word as she could, and started to roll the last sock onto the last of Pinkamena's legs. Each time she extended it a little further, she heard her Mistress gasp a little more, and each gasp seemed to make Pinkamena harder and harder between them.

Once the last sock was rolled all the way on, Pinkamena sighed. "Pet, if you don't get on me right now I am going to—to—" She cut off when Fluttershy slid a little higher, and gasped when her shaft pulled free of its prison and lifted up a little. She knew, somehow, that she was aimed right at Fluttershy's vulva, but until her pet slid back down she didn't realize how close.

With her rear plugged so full, Fluttershy gasped in surprise when she pushed down and got Pinkamena's penis to breach her vulva. It felt like the lump in her rear was huge, big enough that it put pressure on Pinkamena's shaft. Nonetheless, she had promised her Mistress, and by bracing her forelegs, she worked her way down the length.

Lost in her lust, Pinkamena wrapped all four legs around Fluttershy, stopping her pet from moving further. Using the legendary strength of an earth pony, Pinkamena rolled sideways, dumping Fluttershy onto her back, and putting Pinkamena on top.

Fully in control, Pinkamena let go of Fluttershy and braced herself on the bed. She looked down at her squirming pet, and started to push forward again.

"M-Mistress!" Fluttershy was so worked up with the plug in, that the encroaching penis pushed her into her first trembling orgasm. She mewled and whimpered, and squirmed around too, but nothing she did would stop Pinkamena from pushing. Soon, Fluttershy felt their bellies touch again, and she knew she was as full of her Mistress as she could get.

Pinkamena held still. Hilted in her pet, she was just about as happy as she could get. "You are such a good filly, Fluttershy. I love you."

"I love you too, Mistre—" Fluttershy's soft words were stolen by her sharp cry of pleasure. Pinkamena had timed her stroke perfectly, pulling back and shoving back into Fluttershy again. The pace her Mistress set was slow, agonizingly so.

Stroke after stroke soon set Pinkamena in her slow and steady pace. She didn't so much buck as rock against Fluttershy, but she had a plan. Each time she pushed forward, she sped up just a little. It took time, and she had Fluttershy whimpering and squirming under her before she was going at a normal speed, but the rush of control and dominance it inspired within her was worth it.

Each long thrust broke Fluttershy to Pinkamena's will anew. When her Mistress' medial ring pushed into her, it always caught for just a moment on the swollen lump in her rear. The pressure and friction was too much for Fluttershy to bear, and she tipped easily into an orgasm. Mewling like a kitten, she looked up at Pinkamena in awe.

At the loving hooves of her Mistress, Fluttershy was pushed from the end of one orgasm into the beginning of the next. Never before in her life had she been so turned on, and it showed as her normally mild climaxes seemed more focused and intense.

Fluttershy's depths felt the hot rush of fluid, and she snapped her eyes wide to see that Pinkamena was rushing into her own orgasm. "Fill me, Mistress!"

Pinkamena shoved as hard as she could, pushing Fluttershy along the bed a little before she finally collapsed on top of her lover. Wings and legs wrapped around her, as she wrapped her own around Fluttershy. Nursing each other against themselves, both mares rode out their orgasms together.

Stuffed as full as she could imagine, Fluttershy reached up and rubbed Pinkamena's ear slowly, and nuzzled against her chin. "Thank you, Mistress."

"You are a good filly, my pet." Pinkamena could hear the box in her head rattle around, and knew Pinkie Pie wanted out. As neat as she could, she pointed out the position she was in, and that Mr. Humpy was in, and the box subsided. "Pinkie Pie wanted to thank you too, but she doesn't want to come out like—like this."

"Mistress?" Fluttershy was comfortable being under Pinkamena, more comfortably than she could have imagined before.

Pinkamena nibbled a little, playfully, on Fluttershy's nose. "Yes, pet?"

"I want to go on some dates with you, too."

"Of course." Pinkamena tried, and failed, to imagine how such a date would go. "I will be wearing the socks, though."

Fluttershy giggled and kissed Pinkamena's smiling mouth. "Perfect."

Author's Note

Fluttershy/Pinkamena: now that you two have a strong relationship will you ever think of spicing it up a bit such as public accessible locations or in the nearby woods?

Pinkamena raised an eyebrow, and turned to Fluttershy without a word.

"N-N-No." Fluttershy looked at her Mistress to seek her guidance, and when she didn't see a frown, it made her face light up. "That would be wrong. What would happen if a filly or colt saw us?"

"What my pet is saying is, we like to keep things consensual. Doing that kind of thing in public is still consensual between us, but not for the pony who might catch us." Pinkamena reached a hoof up and rubbed Fluttershy's ears, then kissed her on the nose.

Support me on Patreon or fuel my writing on Ko-Fi!

Join me on Discord. Warning, said chat may contain NSFW material and should be considered adult in nature.

Awesome ponies who are already helping to keep me in keyboards and rum:
A.P.O.N.I.
Airy Words
Boulder
Canary in the Coal Mine
Daremo
Dio-Drogynous
Ian
Javarod
Nils
Shaushka
Sirion123
Tanis

And special thanks to the following, for careful eyes and friendly words:
Airy Words
Cross Lament
Vutava