Equestria Girls alternate story

I woke up next day to Find Sunset was missing before I sat up, I heard some sounds in the kitchen so I got off the couch and headed there. I found the girls talking to each other as they were eating breakfast, Sunset had some ready for me as I sat down next to her. I ate my breakfast as I listened to them talking with each other, sounds like Twilight had the same idea as I had last night as she was finding out how Sunset broke up the girls. We finished up as we cleaned the table before heading towards the door, we carried on talking as we headed towards school.

We walked through the hallways a bit until I felt someone drag me into a room, a white-skinned girl with purple hair was in the room with me. "So you're the guy who stood up to Darkheart?" she said examining me, her hands grabbed the waistband of my trousers "you must allow me to thank you for helping Fluttershy". Before she could do anything Applejack entered followed by Pinkie, Fluttershy, Sunset, Twilight and Spike, "sorry Rarity he's taken and you'll need to ask her first to do that" Applejack said pointing towards Sunset.

Rarity looked a little disappointed before shooting a scowl towards Sunset, "easy gal she's ok" Applejack said patting Rarity on the shoulder. "For now let's just focus on helping Twilight winning the Fall Formal and beating Darkheart", Fluttershy spoke to Twilight “ I know it’s not much but I’ll vote for you, you were so nice in defending me from Darkheart”. Pinkie spoke up “Hah! Don’t let the shy part fool you”, Fluttershy retaliated “you think you’re better? you can’t take anything seriously”.

Twilight knew they’d start arguing so she quickly stopped them “Sunset can you please tell them what you’ve told me”, Sunset stayed close to me “long story short, I sent the message to Pinkie saying that Fluttershy wanted a loud party. One to Rarity saying that Pinkie had enough help to decorate her party and finally one to Rainbow saying Applejack’s bake sale was moved to the next day”, the girls looked at her before Applejack put her arms around her.

“If I didn’t see how far you were willing to go to make it up to me, well I’d be having you over my knee by now,” Applejack said. She looked to Twilight “guess that means I’ve gotta talk to Dash now huh?”, Twilight nodded as the girls huddled around.

“Have you really changed?” Rarity asked as she looked at Sunset, Sunset nodded “since meeting Daydreamer” she replied. “Simply put she had some unwanted attention and I could’ve put her right in the middle of it but I didn’t,” I said, “I was willing to risk it all for her and I believe that’s what started to change her”. “Well I don’t sense any malice from you anymore,” Rarity said, she hugged Sunset before we headed towards the football field.

Once we got there we saw an athletic girl with rainbow hair on the field, Applejack took a deep breath “well here goes nothing”. We sat on the side as they started talking which was a good sign, “oh hugging” Pinkie said, “hugs are good”.
They walked over to us before Rainbow put her hand under Sunset’s skirt and pulled her panties up hard, Sunset winced but bit her lips before Rainbow let go. “No offence but you had that coming for a good while now,” Rainbow said, Sunset resorted her panties while Rainbow spoke to Twilight.

"So you're looking to dethrone Darkheart eh?" Rainbow said as she kicked her ball about, Twilight nodded as Rainbow continued "gotta say I'd love to see that happen, I'm in but". "But?" Twilight replied nervously wondering what she is going to say, "but you'll have to beat me at football, first to five wins". I looked at the two girls as I weighed them up against each other, it was obvious that Rainbow would easily trump over Twilight but that didn't stop Twilight from accepting.

As I predicted Rainbow ran rings around Twilight with little problems, she even took the time to bend over and pull her shorts down to flash me her rainbow-striped panties. I couldn't help but blush from that but Sunset took it in her stride, she whispered into my ear "if she is willing, would you tap that ass?". I turned to Sunset "would you be ok with that?" I asked nervously, she kissed me on the cheek "after watching you with Applejack yesterday, I don't mind sharing. I kinda enjoyed watching it to be honest" she said as Rainbow scored her fourth goal, "plus I think the girls like you," Sunset said as she noticed Rarity still eyeing me.

We walked over to Twilight who was on the ground as Rainbow scored the last goal, Rainbow helped her up as she offered her help. It made sense that Rainbow would still help even if Twilight lost, after all, Twilight took the challenge and didn't quit until the end. When Rainbow saw that it was enough to win her over as they hugged, Rainbow then walked over to Sunset and hugged her as they whispered to each other.

Later on, we went over the cafe to grab some drinks while we figure out how to help Twilight win the Fall Formal, Fluttershy had mentioned to Twilight yesterday lunchtime about the school students being divided into their own groups. Rarity shouted out loud as everyone looked at her, she rummaged about in her bag and pulled out some headbands with ears on them and a belt with a tail on them. Seeing them reminded me of home and it appears to be a hit with the girls, they quickly worked out how to use them to help the students vote for Twilight.

As they worked on the idea Sunset and Rainbow dragged me off towards the toilets, Rainbow pulled out an "out of order" sign and hung it on the door as we entered it before locking the door. Like a pair of ravenous wolves, they pounced on me as they pulled my shirt up and started licking my chest as they went to work on undoing my pants, as they worked together my pants stood no chance as their hands quickly made work of it before they slipped under my boxers. Slowly they left trails of licks and kisses down my chest and stomach as they pulled my cock out, as they got down to my shaft they started licking and kissing my balls as they slowly stroked me off.

Sunset carried on as she played with my balls in her mouth as she ran her tongue over them, Rainbow slowly licked the base of my cock as she slowly trailed her tongue towards the tip of my cock. As Rainbow reached the tip she opened her mouth and slowly took me into her mouth, once she reached the base she held me in her mouth for a bit as she stared into my eyes before greedily bobbing her head back and forth. Once my cock was good and wet she stood up as my cock left her mouth with a satisfying plop, she turned around and lifted up her skirt and pulled her shorts and panties down. She held her ass apart as she bent over which gave me a good view of her pussy and ass, Sunset stopped sucking on my balls and grabbed my cock as she pointed it towards Rainbow's ass.

I gulped as the head of my cock touched her ass-hole, I've never even done anal with Sunset and here I was about to have my first experience with Rainbow. Rainbow started moving backwards as my cock slowly disappeared into her ass, the tightness was more than I expected as her bottom finally reached my hips. "What do ya think?" Rainbow said as she looked back, "most awesome ass and the tightest hole right?". I couldn't answer as she started to rock her hips against mine, the tightness felt good as her ass gripped tightly around my cock as it slid up and down on my shaft.

Sunset stood up and kissed me "you like?" she said, Sunset turned around and bent over as she flipped her skirt over her hips. She pulled her yellow panties down and spread her anus, "be gentle" she said inviting me to try her ass-hole. Rainbow pulled me out of her ass and redirected my cock towards Sunset's, the resistance was greater but Sunset bore the pain as the head of my cock started to squeeze through into her anus. Sunset slowly moved her hips until her butt reached my hips while her anus squeezed my cock like a hot tight vice, Sunset winced as she took the full length inside of her.

As Sunset tried to get accustomed to having my cock inside her ass her anus muscles keeps twitching, each twitch brought me closer and closer until I finally came filling her butt with my cum. Sunset waited until my orgasm had passed before she started to move her hips, my cum helped her to move a bit easier. Rainbow dipped underneath to lick away any cum that had started to leak out, once she got what leaked out she got back up and bent back over. Sunset let my cock slip out as Rainbow took it back into her ass, she moved her hips as she rubbed her pussy as Sunset started to rub her own pussy. Once again Rainbow allowed my cock to slip out so Sunset can take it back into her ass, this kept up for a while until I couldn't take it anymore as I pulled out and came all over their butts.

The girls also came as they dug their fingers deep into their pussies, they also yelped as my hot cum splashed over their butts. Once the girls have recovered from their orgasms they walked over to the bidet to clean themselves, Sunset motioned to me to come closer before taking my cock into her mouth. The girls were still sensitive as the bidet cleaned them up, sensitive enough that they came again from the water jets hitting their ass-holes. We took our time going out of the toilets after we've cleaned up so no-one would notice all three of us in there, once out we removed the sign from the door and regrouped with the other girls.

It seems like the girls have figured out how to get the students to vote for Twilight as they filled us in, all we have to do is wait for lunchtime when everyone will be in the cantina. The girls and I will wear the Canter Wondercolt jumpers and tails before putting on the headbands, the girls minus Sunset and I are gonna sing to rally up the students. Sunset and I will keep an eye out for Darkheart and her lackeys in case they try something, if they do we'll do what we can to either stop them or lessen the damage they might do. All we have to do now is wait for lunchtime if the girls don't eat me alive that is, we put the jumpers on and tied the tails around our waists but I can still feel the girls eyes on me like they are mentally stripping me. Hurry up Lunchtime and not because I'm getting hungry.