Equestria Girls alternate story

Sunset and I waited in the cafeteria as the girls sat in there various positions, shortly afterwards they started singing and rallying the other towards Twilight. "If they do vote for Twilight what do you think Darkheart will do?" I asked, Sunset thought for a bit "if it was me then I'd destroy the setup for the Fall Formal" she said. "Then I'd find a way to frame Twilight for it" she continued, "the question is how?" this stumped us for a bit.

Once the girls have finished their song and dance we regrouped with them, from the looks of things it was a success but with what Sunset said I was worried. I grabbed Sunset and headed to the gym to check if it's ok, as we got close I noticed Darkheart coming out of the gym. I followed her as Sunset checked the gym, I kept my distance from Darkheart until I saw her go to a trashcan. She chucked something into the bin before running off somewhere, once it was clear I checked out the bin. I found some photos including a few that had a figure cut out of them on some, I placed them in my pocket before heading to the gym.

I heard Sunset scream as I got closer to the gym, as I entered the gym I saw Snips and Snail was in there with Sunset. They had her hands cuffed behind her and her top was pulled up over her breasts, Snail even had her panties in her hands as they spread her legs open. Snips caught sight of me as he warned Snail, I ran towards them as they jumped out of an open window. I helped Sunset up as I pulled her top and skirt down to cover her up, unfortunately, I couldn't find any keys for the cuffs. We headed out of the gym to the janitors closet, I was able to find a pair of bolt cutters in there which I used to cut the cuffs off her wrists.

As we went to leave the closet we heard Darkheart and Vice-Principle Luna near the gym, Darkheart said that Twilight had done the damages just like Sunset predicted. We waited until they left the gym before we exited the closet, we followed Luna who had gone looking for Twilight. Thankfully Darkheart had left her at some point allowing us to show her the photos I found in the bin, she thanked us for the information but the Fall Formal would have to be cancelled.

We headed to the girls to tell them what has happened, we found them at Rarity's Carousel Boutique. As we told them what had happened Twilight went into one of the changing rooms upset, "Spike could you check on her?" I asked as Pinkie was getting a bit too loud from the news. Thankfully Spike got Twilight to come back out and it looked like she was going to say something, "There's something I need to tell you" she said, "you see". Before she could finish Pinkie said "You’re from an alternate world and you’re a pony princess there and the crown actually has a magical element embedded in it that helps power up other magical elements and without it they don’t work anymore and you need them to help protect your magical world, and if you don’t get the crown tonight, you’ll be stuck in this world and you won’t be able to get back for like, a really, really long time!". I couldn't believe she said all that in one breath let alone guessed all that, as Rainbow doubted that Spike just simply said "Nope, she’s pretty much spot on". This caught the girls for a loop except for Fluttershy who was excited about this, I looked at Pinkie "another of your guesses?" I asked as she nodded.

One they have recomposed themselves we took them to the gym to see the extent of the damages, even though it looked bad Twilight was still confident that we could clean up the mess and redecorate the place. As we started to clean the place several students saw us as they came in to help out, with everyone's help it didn't take long to clean the place and redecorate. Both Celestia and Luna arrived and announced that the Fall Formal was back on for tonight, as the student left it was clear on who'd they'd be voting for.

We all left and headed back to Rarity's place as we celebrated on a job well done, I was about ready to leave the girls alone so they could change and get ready for the event but Rarity insisted I stay there and watch. I watched as they changed costumes while the girls minus Twilight took every opportunity to pose for me in their underwear, Sunset did ask Rarity if she had some spare panties to replace the ones she had pinched. As I watched I could feel my pants getting tighter while a visible bulge could be seen, Rarity had grabbed Fluttershy and me and pulled us into a spare changing room. Both of the girls knelt down as Sunset poked her head through the curtains, Rarity quickly pulled my pants down as my boner popped out.

Rarity gently guided Fluttershy's head to my cock as they both kissed the head, keeping their lips on it they slid down the sides of my member. Rarity took the head into her mouth as Fluttershy licked the underside, She bobbed her head a few times before encouraging Fluttershy to try. Fluttershy opened her mouth as my cock slipped inside, Rarity kept her hand on Fluttershy's head and made her bob her head a few times. They took turns sucking as I lent towards Sunset and kissed her, I heard the rustling of something being opened before I felt Rarity putting a condom on me.

When I looked back at them they'd removed their underwear and have stood up, Fluttershy lent against the side with her legs open. I walked up to her as the tip of my dick touched her pussy, holding onto her hips I gently pushed into her feeling the resistance. She wrapped her arms around me as her hymen broke, I gave her time to recover before I started moving my hips. Rarity was next to her masturbating as I thrusted into Fluttershy, after a few thrusts I pulled out of Fluttershy and went to Rarity and slipped myself into her. As my hips thrusted into her I grabbed Fluttershy's ass and slipped my fingers into her pussy, keeping Fluttershy close I grabbed Rarity's ass as I slipped out of her and inserted myself back into Fluttershy. They moaned in pleasure as I went back and forth between them, once I was close I pulled out of them and removed the condom as they knelt down. A few strokes of my cock was more than enough for me to cum, I fired several ropes of cum as it landed on their faces and breasts. They took turns cleaning my cock before Sunset handed them some tissues to clean themselves up, once they have redressed they left as Sunset entered with some clothes.

She helped me undress before I helped her undress, she handed me a suit as she started to put on a pretty dress. I couldn't help but stare as she put it on as she looked magnificent, Rarity certainly knows her fashion as Sunset looked stunning. By the time I came back to my senses Sunset had put my suit on, I looked in the mirror "my we look quite the couple don't we?" I asked. As we walked out the other girls had finished changing and just in time too, Rarity had a limo take us to the Fall Formal.

We walked into the school and I noticed Flash asking Twilight if she wanted to go to the dance with him, not being one to turn him down Twilight accepted. We partied for a bit before Celestia announced the Fall Formal Princess, it was no surprise that Twilight won as she accepted her crown. but before we could celebrate Twilight ran outside as she chased Snips and Snail, the girls and I followed her as we saw they had taken Spike.

Once we got outside they let Spike go as Darkheart held a sledgehammer, she demanded the crown or she'll destroy the portal. Naturally Twilight wouldn't give up the crown even if it means losing her way home, Darkheart even tried to make her think about me not being able to go home. Naturally, I just flipped my middle finger at her and told her where she can put it, she grinned before rushing Twilight like a spoilt girl as she tried to take the crown by force. As they fell to the floor the flew off Twilights head as we tried to keep it out of Darkhearts hands, unfortunately, it eventually fell into her hands as she put the crown on.

She transformed into some sort of demon before turning Snips and Snail into demons, "Now this is more like it an actual body with real powers" she said laughing. "That Soul Stone I found five hundred years ago caused my body to destroy itself, but my soul lived on as I fed on the shadows of the castle. As I learned from the remains of the Soul Stone it had been corrupted by a dark Unicorn and as a result, had damaged the stone, I also learned that I can take parts of another ponies souls and rewrite various parts of the history it's associated to. But now I can finally take my revenge on my mother who didn't help me".

Hearing this finally helped me to understand why the girls thought Sunset was her lackey, when she passed through Sunset she took the part of her soul that became bad and had rewritten the parts of Sunset being the main honcho and replaced Sunset with her while making it look like Sunset was her lackey. I rolled my eyes at hearing that "she tried to help you but by the time you two had met your body was already", she shouted at me "enough I want no excuses". She tried to blast me before Twilight and the girls surrounded me, a glow surrounded them as they shielded Sunset and me. Twilight told Darkheart about the crown and how it really worked before they transformed, the girls all got their ears replaced with pony ears and their hair grew longer and became a ponytail like their pony counterparts. Twilight, Rainbow and Fluttershy all grew wings as well, I'd never seen the elements of harmony in action before but this time I saw them as they blasted Darkheart with a double rainbow.

As the smoke cleared there was a crater in the ground, we approached it and saw a girl there who had white dark blue skin with small white dots all over it, she brushed her silver hair away from her light blue eyes as she tried to climb out of the crater. "Stardust?" I asked helping her out of the crater, she weakly nodded as the other girls helped us out. She hugged me tightly as she cried "please forgive me" she said as she sobbed, I looked over to Sunset "I think this requires a mother's touch" I said. I looked back at Stardust "Don't worry I think mother misses you a lot, she hasn't been able to forgive herself for what had happened".

We decided to head back to Equestria as Sunset helped me to take her to the portal, I looked back at Twilight "go have some fun first we'll take care of this" I said. As we entered the portal the weird feeling returned before we ended up in my room, it was like we never left as everypony was still here. Mother saw Stardust and gently approached her before Stardust grabbed her in a hug as they both cried happily, everypony left my room as Sunset and I waited for Twilight to return.

It was a few hours later before she returned worn out, she spoke with Sunset as I made a few adjustments to the portal so nopony else could come through. I couldn't help but remember the day when I had the parts to reinforce the portal, Sunset and my mother on my bed naked and having some fun. I adjusted a few things so only Twilight, Sunset and I could go through the portal, the other girls came by and saw Twilight had returned. We walked out of my room when we passed the guard that Cadence had brought with her, Twilight couldn't help but stare at him as the girls teased her about him. As Twilight tried to explain she was cut off by Pinkie, "he totally reminds you of a guy you met in the other world who played the guitar and was in a band and then asked you to dance at the dance, Right?!". I turned to Sunset "she scares me" I said, we all just broke out laughing as the guard looked at us confused.