Stuck in a Love Pentagon

It was around 3:30pm when Ember and Spike walked back through the castle doors with groceries from the market. Setting them in the kitchen, they unpack and place away what they had. After 30 minutes, they finish and relax in the lounge room across from the kitchen, sitting on the couch and watching television together. After 2 hours pass, Ember looks at the time from the clock on the wall and sits up from laying on Spikes lap.

“Well, today was fun. I’ve gotta go. Dragon lord stuff, my father wants to talk and hopefully Garble is out of his state from hitting on me.” Spike opened his mouth to say something, But Ember continued, giving him the basis of the problem. “He was hit with a Spell out of nowhere that made him attracted to me and he wouldn’t stop following me around and using cheesy pick-up lines. Even if he was the last dragon on earth I wouldn’t want him.” The television was still on playing an episode of Maury.

“You are not the father.”

“That’s what I expect to hear in Garbles case. Thanks for letting borrow some clothes for the way back. It feels different wearing them, especially a short skirt and belly shirt, but it helps. Does Dragon Lord Spike request anything else before I leave?”

“Just one thing. We have to do this again sometime. You were amazing.”

“I could say the same about you.” Ember starts walking away, and stops at the opening of the lounge area, lifting her tail out of the way, revealing her ass to him and wearing no panties. “Don’t miss me too much.” She winked at him before she left, hearing the front doors open and close. Spike leaned back on the couch, smiling from having sex with Starlight, his secret Alicorn Mare crush, and Dragon Lord Ember. Spike never thought he would have sex with Ember as well as her serving him for the whole day. After 4 more hours of television and making himself a gem meatloaf for dinner, he took a shower and went to sleep if the first room he came across, being too tired to even make sure it was Twilight’s room. Falling asleep, he hoped this week wouldn’t just end with Starlight and Ember pleasuring him.

[Hours Pass]

Spike woke up with the sky slightly dark outside. He thought the sun was rising, but after looking at his phone, he realized it was way passed that. His eyes widened with shock when he saw it was 8pm. He swiped the screen to open it, and saw 2 missed calls from Twilight. One right after the other. Seeing a number 1 on his messaging app, he pressed it seeing a message from Twilight as well.

“There’s only 3 reasons that I know of why you wouldn’t answer your phone Spike. My best guess, who’s room are you sleeping in?” He looked confused about the message at first, but realized what she meant after he looked around the room and saw confetti, party balloons, and a picture of the Pie family. Texting Twilight back, he got out of bed.

“Pinkie’s room. Now remembering the perimeter sleep spell in her room to make her stay asleep from her energy. Too tired last night to even think about the room to go to. Sorry.” 2 minutes later, he got another text back.

“Just checking up on you to make sure you’re safe and the castle isn’t destroyed. Also, talked to Ember. Can you wash that maid outfit before I get back?” His face turned crimson red after reading that. “Yeah, she told me.”

Spike didn’t know how to text back that she might need a new one after Ember ripped that last one. That thought changed when the sound of his cell phone going off. He figured it was just Twilight, but when he looked at the number, it was one unknown to him. He thought it was just a spam caller, but he remembered Twilight answering this exact number one day without giving out any personal information. Still a little hesitant, he answers it.

“Hello?”

“Spike, daring, are you awake?”

“Rarity? Uh, yeah, I am now. Are you alright?”

“I’m well. Sweetie Belle on the other hoof is…well, more covert than usual. I have a favor to ask of you. I know she’s 18, but allow me to explain why afterwards. I need you to watch over Sweetie Belle while I’m in Manehattan. She was out very late last night saying she was looking for someone. I thought you would’ve seen her since she said she went to the castle earlier. Anyway, I don’t want her outside today and it needs to stay that way. Can you watch over her for me please?”

“Uh, I was gonna clean up the castle a little actually.”

“Spike, she was wearing a black hoodie very late at night so I wouldn’t know it was her. I’m scared that something might happen to her if she’s out again, then I would never see her again. Please Spike, do this for me?”

“It doesn’t sound like she’ll be in much danger since she’s 18 now and her magic is almost as strong as yours. She’s an adult. Let her explore the world around her-”

“She’s trying to find another stallion to have sex with to make Button Mash jealous and to not be laughed at for being a virgin.”

“…oh…so it’s that kind of situation. (Awkward) Fine, I guess I could come over. You owe me for this though.”

“Oh trust me Spikey wikey, I’ll pay you back in the way you’re expecting.” Spikes face went red and his eyes widened from Rarity's comment and voice tone. “I’ll see you in 30 minutes.” She made a noise that sounded like a kiss then hung up. He set down his phone, packed a couple of his personal items and got dressed, thinking about what he and the mare of his dreams could do as he left the castle.

[Rarity’s Boutique]

Spike approached Rarity’s house, having a relaxing walk along the way. He even met up with Tree Hugger who he knew liked him and was able to let her know that he just wanted to be friends. She accepted it with her words of “All good man. Don’t wanna slay the dragon too soon. Catch ya later dude.” Whatever that meant. Furthermore, Sunburst was hiding in a wooden box from Starlight, upset at the fact Spike broke a part of the bro code and Sunburst now hiding himself and in his words, “Saving my future children from Starlight’s wrath.”

Spike felt a little bad, but Sunburst should know better than to use his friend to get some pony else. Spike wondered what would happen if Twilight found out as well, or if Moondancer knew the truth. All questions in his mind were pushed aside after the door opened and the mare of his dreams was there, wearing a crimson glitter long dress, purple lipstick and had her mane in a bun. She hugged him instantly when she saw him. When let go, she placed her hoof on his mouth when he opened his mouth to ask a question.

“I know what you’re thinking. You’re wondering why I’m wearing this for Manehattan. Fancy Pants and Fleur de Lis invited multiple celebrities to the boutique tonight. I need to make sure I look perfect for them. Besides, Sassy Saddles was able to invite Countess Coloratura who’s bringing more. I need to make sure everything I’m wearing is perfected. How do I look? If my make-up alright? Do I need to redo my mane? Is the dress too much? Should I wear-” Spike placed a claw on her mouth to make her stop talking.

“Rarity, when you stress too much, you sweat a lot. Don’t ruin that dress. You look outstanding from what you’re wearing. If others don’t see the beauty in you then obviously they don’t know true fashion like Fancy Pants or Fleur. Or by you, a mare who owns a shop all about fashion.” He removed his claw and held her hooves. “When I see your face, there’s not a thing that I would change. Cause you’re amazing, just the way you are.” Rarity smiled, pulling him closer and kissing him. Slightly startled at first, he relaxed into the kiss when their tongues met. They let go 5 seconds later, as Spike grew a cheesy grin on his face.

“There’s more where that came from for helping me Bruno Mars. Also Scootaloo and Apple Bloom said they’ll be over soon so keep an eye out for them.” A chariot led by Pegasus Royal Guards landed in front of Rarity’s Boutique with a light brown coat stallion wearing a fedora and white suit sitting in the back of it. Spike snapped back to reality, looking back and realizing who the stallion was. “That must be my ride.” Spike whispered in her ear, making her eyes widen with excitement. When he moves away, the stallion opened the side of the Chariot as Rarity walked up to him. While she was entering, the stallion looked over at Spike, smiled and tapped his chest twice. Spike did the same and held up 2 claws (in a “Deuces” form) as the stallion closed the chariot side door, walked to the other side and joined Rarity. The chariot flew off with Rarity and the stallion already talking.

“I’ve gotta meet him personally when I get the chance. I just can’t believe she didn’t know Bruno Mars when she saw him.” Spike walked inside the boutique, remembering how it was before. It looked the same when he was smaller, besides the fact that it was slightly bigger than last time and had a lot more dresses for display than before. For 5 minutes, Spike looked at each dress design, seeing the next one slightly better than the last. After he looked at the ones on display, he heard Sweetie Belle call him from upstairs.

“Spike, is that you down there?”

“Yeah, it’s me. Just looking around.”

“Can you come up here for a minute please? I need your help with something.” Spike carried his bag over his shoulder while walking up the stairs.

At the top, he saw Rarity’s room on the right side of the house. Directly across from it and what he was standing next to was Sweetie Belle’s room with the door cracked open. He lightly tapped on it a 3 times. “You can come inside. Just close the door behind you.”

Spike walked inside, but doesn’t see her in sight when he closed the door. Looking around, he heard a shuffle from her closet. Thinking she might be in the closet trying to scare him, he silently walked over thinking that he’ll scare her before she scares him. He grabbed a door handle of the closet, but let go when hearing her bathroom door open. When he turned to face her, his face turned red, his jaw dropped as well as his luggage when seeing Sweetie Belle wearing a Cupless Black Net Mini Dress, revealing her nude body to Spike. To add extra, she had whipped cream on her nipples, cherry juice covering her pussy, and chocolate drizzled down and between the cheeks of her plump ass. With a sexy voice tone, Sweetie Belle spoke again. “Looks like my knight came just in time for desert.” She looks down at his pants, seeing a bulge in them. He looks down, covering his erection with his claws from her sight. “And brought his own utensils.” She slowly started walking towards him, swaying her hips the closer she walked, seeing him back away nervous and confused. “What’s wrong Spike? I’m not too sexy for you am I?”

“Sweetie Belle, what’s going on? What’s gotten into you?”

“Oh nothing Spike. I’m just missing a little ingredient for this dessert, and I need your help to get it. I’m sure you can handle that right?” Sweetie Belle uses her magic from her horn to make Spike’s clothes disappear. “I’ll take your silence as a yes.” Spike backed away from her, but pinned himself against the wall with no more space to go. Sweetie walked over towards him, swaying her hips as she proceeded. When she reached him, she pinned herself against him, pushing herself against him. And holding up her breast to his face. Out of words to say, Spike started to calm down and took one of her breast into his mouth, licking her nipples covered in whipped cream. She lightly moaned as spike started sucking and tugging at her nipple. Hearing her starting to pant, he moved to her other breast, showing the same display of actions as her first. Once he released her breast from his mouth, she ripped open the mini dress, tossing it to the side. “I knew you couldn’t resist.”

“You know what could happen if Rarity found out about this right?”

“That’s why she won’t. I talked to Fleur De Lis and paid her to spike her drink so she’ll get so wasted to where she won’t be awake until morning. But enough of that.” Sweetie slid her body down on her knees, facing Spikes dick. Grabbing her breast, she slid Spikes dick between them and started moving them up and down. “We should get down to business.” Spike groaned as Sweetie Belle continued stoking his dick with her breast. Seeing him pleased, she wrapped her mouth around his heading and began sucking as she was stoking him. He gasped out of surprise, but relaxed seconds later to enjoy the pleasure she was giving him. She started moving at a quicker pace, making spikes groans of pleasure change to pants. Sweetie could tell Spike was enjoying this, so she quickened her pace. Spike grunted again, feeling his orgasm approaching.

“Sweetie Belle, I’m gonna cum.” Sweetie released her lips from Spike dick still using her breast to pleasure him.

“Do it. I wanna feel you’re cum all over me.” She wrapped her lips around Spikes head again, sucking harder to help his orgasm come faster. His claws dug into the wall behind him and he closed his eyes as he reached his climax. A loud moan came from Spike as he came into Sweetie Belles mouth.

She tightened her lips around Spikes head to keep all of his cum inside her mouth, but couldn’t as her mouth got full and she wasn’t able to swallow fast enough. She opened her mouth to gasp for air as he shot his continuing loads over Sweetie Belles face and over her breast. After 10 seconds, his orgasm subsided and he relaxed. He opened his eyes and they widened with surprise when seeing Sweetie Belles face and breast was covered in his semen. Her mouth was full as well and heard a gulp after realizing the mess he made. “So warm and tasty, but I think I need more.” Sweetie belle stood up and grabbed his claws, bring him towards the bed. She turned around and bent over, moving her tail out of the way revealing her ass and pussy to him. “Wreck me dragon.” Without hesitation, Spike grabbed the sides of her ass and shoved his snake like tongue into her pussy while lapping up the cherry juice covering her. After the cherry juice was gone, his tongue moved over her ass, licking up the chocolate that was covering it. She knew he was slightly teasing her while licking everywhere but the main place. She opened her mouth to say something, but was stopped once spike shoved his tongue into her ass. She dropped her head on the bed and spread her cheeks wider. After about a minute, Spike removed his tongue from her anus. Sweetie Belle slightly lifted up her head and looked back, seeing spikes eyes change to a predatory look.

“Spike want!” Spike yelled as he grabbed her sides and slammed him dick into her ass, making her head drop onto the bed and her tongue hang out of her mouth. He forced her head down on the bed with his left claw as he started pounding her, hearing her moan loudly while hearing the bed rock and thumping against the wall. He raised his right claw and smacked her right ass cheek, leaving a red mark on it.

“Yes Spike!” Sweetie Belle screamed. “Fuck me like a real mare! Punish me till I can’t feel my body! Abuse me!” Removing his claw from her head, he yanked her mane, pulling her head back and he continued smacking her ass and pounding her senselessly. Her eyes rolled in the back of her head as she let spike abuse her and fuck her like no other has before. Spike let go of her mane, clenched her sides and bit her neck as his pace quickened. “You’re getting close, aren’t you?” Spike grunted louder with each thrust. “Fill this slutty mare Spike!” Those words were enough to make Spike reach his climax and shoot his load in Sweetie Belles ass. She covered her mouth and screamed, feeling her insides warm up from Spikes cum filling her up. He released his mouth from her neck, reveling a bite mark on it as his last load shot off into Sweetie Belles ass. They both started panting as Spike released his dick from Sweetie’s ass. Sweetie Belles body dropped on the bed as well as Spike, resting his head on her right red ass cheek. After 30 seconds passed, Sweetie Belle caught her breath and broke the silence. “So, how about round 3?” Spike smiled, removing himself from on Sweetie Belle. She turned over onto her back, spreading her legs, giving Spike a clear view of her glistening pussy. “Make sure you finish your desert.” Spike grabbed her legs, pulling her towards him. Lining up his dick with her entrance with his dick, he pushed forward. She closed her eyes and bit her hoof out of slight pain that was felt as he kept pushing forward. When their hips connected, she opened her eyes, removed her hoof from her mouth with a look of anxiety. Spike felt concern for her since she was a virgin. He didn’t want to hurt her.

“We don’t have to continue if you don’t want to.” Sweetie Belle looked away for 3 seconds, comprehending her decision.

“…I know, but I don’t want to be a virgin anymore. I don’t care if I get pregnant from this. All I want is someone to take me…and that’s you.” Spike smiled, feeling her legs wrap around his back. “Don’t go easy on me either. I want you to fill me up and make my body numb. I want to walk funny for 5 days. I want to be fucked like a bad mare.”

“As you wish.” Spike slowly moved his hips back, then slammed forward, starling Sweetie Belle by hearing a squeak from her. “Going easy isn’t in my dictionary anyway.” Spike moved his hips faster and slamming hard into Sweetie Belle, hearing the echoes of wet slaps cover the room. As Sweetie vaginal walls squeezed Spikes dick, he slammed harder and harder inside of her and not letting up his pace. Sweetie Belles tongue hung out of her mouth as she played with her breast, panting and embracing the feeling of Spike being her first and taking her virginity. He walls clamped down harder as Spike felt his climax approaching. He gave a thought on what could happen if he came inside of her, but that thought was interrupted by Sweetie Belle.”

“Spike, cum inside me! Fill my over with your batter!” Spike pushed all other thoughts aside and pumped faster and harder, hearing her scream as she covered her mouth. Spike grunted few times before his pace slowed down. He didn’t stop however. Still moving at a particularly fast pace, he grunted one last time and felt his load shoot straight into her womb. Sweetie Belle panted harder when feeling the warmth of his cum inside of both her ass and pussy now. She didn’t care about the fact the she could get pregnant from this or even why he was still moving. She was just glad some pony, or in spikes case, some dragon took her. She smiled as he started to slow down, feeling leftover cum that he shot inside of her leak out the more he pushed. He finally stopped after exhaustion of moving. Sweetie Belle on folded her legs behind him, seeing him drop to his knees, hearing them both pant and try to catch their breath. Sweetie placed her hoof on her stomach, rubbing it and feeling how warm she was and the slight bulge that appeared. That feeling was subsided as she felt her legs being spread and Spikes tongue slip into her pussy. It was different this time though. He was working harder than last time, and she could feeling her climax approaching. She pushed his head down, making his tongue go deeper inside of her. “Oh fuck yes Spike! Keeping going! I’m so close!” When Spike heard that, he shot his tongue farther than he ever did, making Sweeties body spasm and shake as she shot the juices of her orgasm into spike mouth. About 10 seconds later, Spike removed his face from her vagina and crawled on the bed next to her, pulling her close and embracing her in a hug with her head on his chest. Sweetie was panting, but after calming down, she managed to speak. “Thank you Spike. Thank you for this.”

“It was my pleasure Sweetie Belle.” After Sweetie caught her breath, Spike spoke again. “Just one thing next time.” She looked up at him, wrapping her arms around him as well. “Let me know if Scootlaoo and Apple Bloom are gonna be recording in the closet. I could smell them before we finished.” Inside Sweetie’s closet was shuffling, hearing Scootaloo break the silence.

“Dammit Apple Bloom, I told you he’d smell us.” Apple Bloom replied back with an attitude.

“Well if you didn’t decide to hide in the closet he wouldn’t have.”

“Just shut up and keep kissing me.” Hearing small moans from the closet, Sweetie Belle hugged Spike again, laying on the bed with him.

“They might be a while in there. Let’s just rest for now. I need to let your batter cook for a while.” Spike chuckled as they both lay down together, closing their eyes and resting.

“That’s something Pinkie would say. Was the desert thing her idea?”

“I had a little advice.”

“By the way, I have a question Sweetie?” She opened her eyes looking up at him. “Was this really what you wanted, or was it just to get back at Button Mash?” She sat up on her side with an expression of sadness. Spike sat up with her.” You don’t have to answer, but Rarity-”

“I didn’t want you to find out what it was in the first place. The girls and I were just tired of being teased by Diamond Tiara and Silver Spoon for still being virgins. Furthermore, they both took Button Mash, Rumble and Tender Taps away for a sleepover. The worst part about it is the 3 didn’t hesitate to go at all. That’s why I wanted to record this. I wanted to prove that I won’t be a virgin, and I thought this would get back at Button Mash for leaving me. I thought it would make him jealous for this and make him come back, but I guess I was the one being selfish. I wanted to prove that I won’t be a virgin anymore, but afterwards…I thought about you. I’m sorry Spike. You probably hate now for-” Spike placed a claw under her chin, bringing her closer and kissing her. She moaned into his mouth, enjoying the feeling of him being with her. They disconnected 5 seconds, gazing into each other’s eyes.

“A simple “I love you” would work Sweetie Belle.” She smiled and blushed, laying back down with him. Using the magic from her horn, she shut the light off. “By the way, I know something about Button Mash, Rumble and Tender Taps that would embarrass them enough to make them beg you 3 for their forgiveness.” The closet doors, hearing hoof steps come closer and stop by the bed. Sweetie Belle broke the silence, excited of what to hear.

“Really? What is it?”

“Look, I like you girls, but you all have to do something for me if you’re gonna get secrets like this.” Apple Bloom was the first to speak.

“Free Cider and Apple Pie for 3 weeks.” Scootaloo spoke next.

“Rainbow Dashes diary and free Wonderbolts show tickets for 2 weeks.” Spike smiled at both of their offers.

“Yes and yes. Sweetie Belle?” She was silent, thinking of what she could do for him. When an idea popped in her head, she moved closer to his ear and whispered.

“I’ll tell you all of Rarity’s sweet spots for intercourse.” When hearing that, Spike grinned and felt his erect dick poking Sweetie Belle’s stomach.

“It’s a deal.”

To Be Continued in part 4/5: Ravaging the Rare Ruby