Stuck in a Love Pentagon

Spike woke up around 10 with a note from the CMC’s next to him, thanking him for getting there men back. He had a small thought that it was kind of wrong to do that since that does also break the bro-code, but that thought left after feeling the sheets and blanket of Sweetie’s bed wet and sticky. Finding his clothes in the closet, he placed them on, took the sheets and blanket and went downstairs to use the washer and dryer. When he came back up, he heard the front door open. He looked around the corner from the kitchen, seeing the light brown coat stallion wearing a fedora from last night carrying Rarity inside while she was asleep. He set her on the couch as Spike came over with a blanket from a near closet, placing it on her. Spike contained his laughter from seeing her mane looking like she was partying way too hard. The light brown coat stallion handed Spike 3 items. Rarity’s purse, a picture with him and Rarity at the party with his signature, and a small bag of bits. He also took off his fedora and placed it on Spikes head. They gave each other a fist bump and the light brown stallion left. Spike took off the fedora seeing a signature of Bruno Mars on the side of it. He smiled placing it back on and setting Rarity’s items on the table next to her. Not wanting to wake her after her wild night, he decided to go out for a walk to get some fresh air and stretch his legs after a long night with Sweetie Belle. As he continued, he saw the CMC’s with Button Mash, Tender Taps and Rumble. They all looked like they were getting along with no trouble in sight. The 3 crossed Spike, with Scootaloo and Apple Bloom giving him a fist bump and Sweetie Belle tapping his butt as she passed. He smiled, remembering all of the private session he had with 3 females. His Alicorn Princess Starlight, Dragon Lord Ember, and the no longer virgin and younger sister of Rarity, Sweetie Belle. Tonight, he gets to be with the mare of his dreams. Being still daylight, he had to wait, but it was something he was willing to wait for. He started heading towards the Friendship Castle, only to be stopped by Shining Armor along the way. Shining was just checking in on him, making sure he was safe, relaxed and didn’t pull a Glim Glam moment, which meant flood the castle and set it on fire at the same time. [Season 6, Episode 21. “Every Little Thing She Does.]” They both had a laugh while making sure Starlight wasn’t around to hear. He was invited for a feast at the Crystal Empire that night, but Spike respectfully denied his request. They agreed to at least have a drink when he wasn’t busy then parted ways. Arriving at the castle 15 minutes later, he walked inside only to see Crystal Ponies cleaning it. One of them noticed Spike and immediately called for others. Spike didn’t mind seeing Crystal Ponies who loved him, but that’s when he was a kid. Now it was just weird, so he ran out of the castle and flew up to Twilight’s room, locking any and every door possible. Once he was locked in, he finally was able to relax on the bed, but that was shortly interrupted when his cell phone started vibrating. Figuring it was Twilight, he answered.

“Hey Twi.”

“How’d you know it was me?”

“Besides Rarity yesterday, you’re the only one that’s called me since you’ve been gone to check up on me. Rarity called yesterday cause Sweetie Belle needed to be watched cause of a certain situation between her and Button Mash.”

“Which reminds me, Sweetie Belle accidentally sent me a couple of pictures that was meant for you. 4 of them to be exact. Button Mash having sex with his mother, Rumble and Thunderlane performing a 69, Tender Taps being fucked by Braeburn, and Silver Spoon with Diamond Tiara having a threesome with Filthy Rich.”

Spike immediately froze when he heard Twilight explained the pictures, thinking of a reasonable explanation he could tell Twilight besides revenge for the CMC’s. “Also she texted me, keep them safe Spike. Is there something that I missed?” Spike started to sweat, trying to think fast.

“(Shit, what do I say)?! Uh, well, those are…” [!] “A solid I owe Sweetie Belle!”

“...come again?”

“Well, you see, while watching over her, she was on her laptop uploading and printing off pictures that were saved. She told me she and her friends had a problem with Button Mash, Tender Taps, Rumble, Diamond Tiara and Silver Spoon. There was an incident and Sweetie Belle and her friends wanted to get them back with embarrassing pictures. They weren’t posted online or anything and I made sure of that. Everything is fine now.” Anxious of what her response is, he started to sweat more. “(Please let that work).”

“That’s very strange and not that convincing, but alright.” He let out a sigh of relief and stopped sweating. “I thought you were just into different kinds of pornography, not that I’m judging. Anyway, Crystal Ponies came by to clean up the castle. I assumed you were still at Rarity’s boutique knowing how Rarity likes to party and comes back in the morning. Just checking to see how you were doing. Don’t Pull a Glim Glam make sure my room is clean alright?”

“Alright Twilight. Talk to you later.” He hung up and took a picture of himself wearing the signed Bruno Mars fedora and sent it to Twilight. Afterwards, he took the fedora and his shirt off and closed his eyes, wanting to rest for now while thinking how lucky he was to get passed Twilight with that lie.

[4:30pm]

Spike woke up to the sound of whispering and quiet laughing. Opening his eyes, there were Crystal Ponies around the bed watching his as he slept. He jumped and quickly sat up in shock.

“What the hell?!” He covered his chest with the pillow on the bed behind him. “How long have you all been watching me?” One of the unicorn mares spoke.

“About 2 and a half hours. I unlocked the door with my magic. You’re so cute when you sleep. The noises you make are adorable, and you talk.”

“What? No I-” He stopped himself, getting back to the real topic. “Look guys, I really appreciate this attention and I like you all, but I need some privacy sometimes. Also, this is a little weird since I’m 18 now.” Some of them hung there heads. “It’s alright though. Twilight informed me you guys would be here cleaning the castle after I arrived.”

“And we’re finished with it. Everything was scrubbed down from top to bottom. We wanted to let you know cause we have to go back to the Crystal Empire due to Shining Armor throwing feast. Also you have visitors.”

“Really?”

“Yep. Well, we’ll see you soon Spike.” They all left the room, seeing Aloe and Lotus walk inside carrying bags on their sides. Walking to each side of the bed, they drop the bags beside them.

Spike opened his mouth to say something, but was stopped by Lotus placing her hoof on his mouth and Aloe removing the pillow and lying him down. Lotus removed her hoof, went down to his feet and started massaging them as Aloe was above Spike, massaging his shoulders. “Aloe, Lotus, what’s going on?” Lotus spoke.”

“Mistress Rarity called us over and said you needed to relax. We can help you with that. Also, she doesn’t want to be tense or stressed out before your special night with her.” Spike was surprised by this, but then settled in to relax and let what the spa sisters do best. “And don’t worry, all of your tension will be gone, including your friend here.” Spike looked down at Lotus to see what she was talking about, but quickly figured it out as there was a bulge in his pants. His face turned a deep crimson with and embarrassed look. “Don’t worry about it Spike. It’s natural for us two to see this when we give our treatments to males. Mistress Rarity wants you fully prepared and we plan to make you prepared.” Spike smiled and closed his eyes, enjoying the treatment he was given but was confused on one thing. Why Aloe and Lotus called Rarity, mistress.

[30 Minutes Later]

At the castle door, Spike was wearing a police uniform that came with a key, handcuffs and a metal detector wand given to him by Aloe and Lotus. Confused on why he was wearing this, Aloe and Lotus were excited about it.

“Thank you for everything Aloe and Lotus. Those massages really helped. How much do I owe you?”

“Considered it paid off if Mistress Rarity is pleased with you by the end of the night.”

“Thanks. I just have one question though. Why do you girls call her Mis-” Spikes sentence was interrupted by Fleur De Lis appearing in front of him, wearing a private investigator uniform. “Fleur, what are you doing here?”

“Officer Spike, we caught her.” He thought about it for a quick second, but then caught on to the role playing. “Detective Fancy Pants awaits to speak with you.” Spike cleared his throat to go along with the role playing.

“Very well Mrs. Fleur. Let us go.” Fleur nodded, holding Spikes arm and using her magic to teleport them both to Rarity’s boutique. When they arrived, they were in a small room across the hall from Rarity’s bedroom. In the room was a small table. Fancy Pants was on the left side wearing a private investigator uniform. On the other side in a chair was Rarity, wearing a French Maid Lace Apron Set. Her hands were cuffed behind her back and her mane looked completely out of control. She was giggling as Fancy Pants was staring her down. “Detective Fancy Pants.” He looked over and saw Spike and Fleur there.

“Officer Spike. I’m glad you’re here. As you see, we finally caught her, and in her act after her class ended. She was having sexual intercourse with a college student and his older brother. The college student was Rumble already enrolled in her class. The brother was Thunderlane. He came by to pick up Rumble for an appointment and says was forced in by Rarity. His story changed when we placed him in custody, saying that he and his brother were going to keep quiet about this and pay her for it. They both are already in custody and waiting in the holding cell. Rarity is continuing to play these mind games thinking what she did wasn’t wrong. Also she’s been trying to get close with me. Rarity flung her mane out of her face and smiled, talking in a way of being drunk, horny and tired.

“Oh c’mon detective. You know you want to search for more clues with Mistress Rarity. I can give you more clues than you’d expect.”

“Anyway, Rumble is refusing to speak of the situation. What Rarity is wearing currently was under her work clothes and during her sexual acts. She has some hidden weapons on her that she’s not telling us of, so you might have to search her for that. Fleur and I have to discuss this matter with Rumble and we think we may know of a way to get him to talk. As for Rarity, she all yours as you requested.”

“Thank you detective. You both are dismissed.” Fleur and Fancy Pants teleported away, leaving only Spike and Rarity in the room. A folder was in front of her on the other side of the table. He walked towards it, but pushed it off to the side. Rarity continued to smile. “You can wipe that smile off your face. You realize how much trouble you’re currently in right now.” She giggled.

“This isn’t the first time officer. A college teacher has to have some fun some time. Grading and paperwork gets boring after a while. You know that.” Spike looked away from her. “I miss the old days. Where you and I worked together in that college together. We got work done when needed. And how I miss the feeling of your touch after a long and stressful day.” Spikes face flushed crimson when he heard her say that. “You miss it too, don’t you Spikey?” Spike looked back at her, seeing her smile and giggling. “You can’t deny that you don’t miss it. Besides, I’m not wearing any panties just for you.” Spike closed his eyes and sighed. When he opened them, he walked behind Rarity, removing her cuffs with the key, leading her towards the door.

“Detective Fancy Pants informed me of weapons that were hidden on you. I’m gonna have to search you for those. Keep your hand behind your back, and don’t try anything stupid or I’ll get violent.”

“You would like that, wouldn’t you officer?” Spike opened the door, leading Rarity to her bedroom. Closing and locking the door behind him, Rarity sat back on her dresser. “So, what hidden assets are you looking for? Do I need to strip search for you?” Spike pulled out the metal detector wand.

“Face the wall and place your hands on it criminal.”

“As you wish officer.” Rarity did what she was told never letting her smile fade. To add to her act, she tuck out her flank to tease Spike. “I’m ready when you are.” Spike went behind her and waved the wand over her, stopping when a noise went off when it was over her flank.

“Oh? What do we have here?”

“Oops. Guess I forgot about that.” He noticed in was vibrating when he moved the wand away. A grin grew on his face when realizing it.

“So, this is what you were hiding huh? Something to pass the time?” He placed the wand on the dresser next to her and started patting her down. Feeling something vibrating in between her thighs, he placed his a claw on it, moving it around. Rarity moaned when she felt it move. “What’s this? Another one huh?” he started patting her moving up, feeling something between her breast. “And what do we have here?” He reached in between her breast, pulling out a small remote. “A controller? You must be a busy lady, am I right…Mistress Rarity?” She opened her mouth to speak, but was shut off as Spike turned the rotary switch to a higher number, making Rarity quiver and moan. “Just that makes you quiver? I wonder how long it will take you to explode.” He turned it higher, seeing Rarity’s legs shake with anticipation. “This is what you wanted right?” Rarity smiled.

“If this is your way of interrogating me, you’re gonna have to do a lot more to break me.”

“Talking back huh? Very well criminal. I’ll get you to crack.” He turned the rotary switch to an even higher number, seeing her almost about to fall. “Oh no you don’t. You asked for this.” For 10 more seconds, he saw her trying to hold herself up until she couldn’t take anymore.

“Officer please. I can’t stand it anymore.” Spike grinned at her reaction.

“Doesn’t sound very convincing Mistress. I can wait though. It’s only a matter of time until you crack-”

“Spike please end this torture! By the gods I beg you!” At that moment, Spike turned rotary switch off, seeing Rarity trembling.

“Told you I would make you crack.” Removing her from the wall, he carried her to her bed. Laying her down, he pulled up her arms and cuffed her to the metal bars of the frame at the top of her bed. “Now that interrogation is taken care of, is there anything Mistress wants to admit?” Rarity smiled.

“Besides the fact that Rumble and Thunderlane did a better job than you?”

“Very well.” Spike took off his shirt, pants and boxers, standing naked in front of his Mistress criminal. “He can do this the hard way as well.” Spike walked down to the bottom of the bed, sticking his claw in her vagina and pulling out an egg vibrator from her soaked and dripping vagina. “You must be really pent up right now.” He tosses the egg and handcuff key to the side as he climbed over her with his dick erect and close to her dripping pussy lips. He reached under her flank, pulling out anal plug vibrator. “But, you’re not gonna cum until I say you can.” He reached one of his claws one of his claws to the top of her French Maid Lace Apron, slowly moving down and seeing rip open along with her bra under it, revealing her full naked body. He lifted up her legs placing on his shoulders as he gripped her hips. “You’ve handled other victims before Rarity. Let’s see if you can handle me.” He lined up his dick with her vagina and pushed forward. Before he entered, Rarity called his name making him stop.

“Spike?” He looked at her with concern, seeing her expression slightly anxious. “I’m sorry to break character so early but, I really want you Spike. For so long, I’ve waited for this and I can’t hold this feeling back anymore.” Seeing magic glow from her horn, it hit Spike, making him a little dizzy and step back. “I want this more than you think, so please…take care of me like I know you would.” Spike felt tingling down on his crotch. He looked down, only to see that he now had to erect dicks. One right under the other. When he looked up, he saw Rarity bent over with her face in the pillow and free from than handcuffs. “Please Spike, I’m begging you for this. Fuck me until I can’t walk straight. I want you right now.” Spiked didn’t hesitate to do what she asked. He grasped her ass, shoving his snake like tongue in the pussy. She moaned louder than before as his tongue rapidly continued in and out of her, feeling her juices run down her leg. Spike could feeling her slightly shaking after 2 minutes, knowing that she was getting close. “Oh Spikey! Keep going! I’m so close!” When hearing that, Spike doubled his speed with his tongue, feeling her quiver even more. After 10 more seconds, he removed his tongue from inside her and tasting her juices shooting in his mouth like a faucet. After 8 seconds, she collapsed on the bed, heavily breathing from exhaustion. Through short breaths, she was able to speak. “Spike you were amazing.” After catching her breath, she tried to sit back up only to feel Spike claws grasp her flank again. “Oh, we’re not done yet I see.” Spike stuck his tongue out, licking over the hole of her ass. “Uh, Spike?” she slightly looked back at him. “I don’t think your tongue should go-” interrupting herself with a squeal, the front of her body plopped back down on the bed as he moved his tongue in the ass.

“Oh fuck yes Spike. Keeping doing that.” Spike smiled, continuing his efforts and remembering Sweetie Belle told him this is one of Rarity’s sweet spots and fetishes. He thought it was slightly weird that having his tongue in a mares flank was a fetish, but since it was Rarity, he didn’t really care much. He used one of his claws to tease her vagina, getting more moans and groans of pleasure. Wanting to be a tease, he realized rarity wanted him for so long as he did with her. He moved his claws away and removed his tongue from inside of her. Rarity could feel his claws moving higher on her flank, smiling to herself. Rarity looked back to see him standing up behind her.”

“Spike?” He looked up before pushing himself into her. “Don’t be gentle with me. I want you to be as rough with me as you can.” Spike smiled, pushing himself inside both of her holes. She gasped, then dropped her head on her pillow.

“As you wish, Mistress Rarity.” Instantly, he started pounding into her, hearing echoes of wet slaps cover the room. He gripped her ass harder while slamming her senselessly, hearing grunts and moans escape her mouth. An idea came to his head, gripping her mane and pulling her head back. Pulling her mane towards his mouth, he clamped his teeth down on it keeping her in place. Raising his right claw, he smacked her right cheek or her flank hearing her gasp, but moan afterwards. “Again!” She shouted. “Hit me harder!” He did the same with his left claw, smacking the left side of her flank. He repeated doing so, switching sides and turning her flanks a darker red the more her did it. When he saw how red they were and the claws marks he made he stopped and released the grip of her mane in his teeth, seeing her drop her head down on the pillow. He leaned forward over her and started licking the side of her neck, hearing her moans grow louder with pleasure. He noticed her tongue was hanging out of her mouth, which he continued his efforts to pleasure her. “Oh Spike! You know my sweet spots!” Spike smiled, slowing down and removing his tongue from her neck, then halted to a complete stop. “Spike?” He wrapped his arms around her waist, pulling her so she was now on top of him, facing the ceiling. She was about to ask him something, but he interrupted her by slamming his dick into her vagina. With a silent scream of pleasure, she rubbed her clitoris to further both of there pleasure. Rarity’s body tensed up in Spikes grip, realizing she was getting close. He smiled, letting his snake like tongue out and over her chest, wrapping around her breast and teasing her nipples with the tip of his tongue. “Oh Spikey!” She screamed, very sensitive of her nipples but knowing he pleasured her with that particular sweet spot. Not just that, but Rarity loved being on top and having her breast teased while being taken by a stallion, or in Spikes case, a dragon. He felt her tense up one last time as he felt her juices cover his dick as he continuously pounded her. With just that, it made him go over the edge as well as he thrusted one last time, lifting her hips up his, he shot a massive load of his seed into Rarity. She groaned with pleasure, feeling how warm he was and seeing her belly grow a slight bulge. His legs gave out, making his hips drop and his dragon hood slide out of her as it started to soften. As they both were panting, Rarity first broke it after 30 seconds, turning over and laying her head on Spikes chest. “Spike, you were amazing. I couldn’t have asked for anything better. Thank you so much for this.”

“It was my pleasure Rarity. I always wanted to do this with you.”

“That reminds me.” She used that magic from her horn to bring over her phone, pressing the videos app. “Sweetie Belle sent this video to her close friends, and sent this to me instead of friend Flurry Heart.” It was the sex video of him and Sweetie Belle while Scootaloo and Apple Bloom recorded in the closet. Rarity grinned, showing him as his face turned crimson. “I take it I’m not the only one you were wanting this with Spikey Wikey.”