Imagine my surprise upon meeting my mother-in-law, only to discover I'd dated had sex with her years prior. Awkward.

OC tag is for 1st person pony perspective. 3rd place in the Incest Is Wincest Accidental Incest '19 contest. Contains (accidental) incest. Duh.

<=== Spoiled Rich disapproves of this story. She's silently judging you for reading this. Her lawyers are not-so-silently judging me for writing this.

7,000+ views and featured: September 2-5, 2019. Spoiled has been doing a lot of silent disapproving. But it's okay, her face is already frozen that way.