Anonymous in Dark Equestria

You awaken chained up in a basement.  You try to call for help but your mouth is gagged It also feels numb and dry. What did that pony do to you? You don't really remember much from before you passed out. You notice that all your clothes are missing, leaving you buck-ass nekkid. You start crying, all you wanted to do this whole time was go home.

You hear screaming and crying coming from above you.You try struggling against the binds in a crazed panic. You then  try screaming through the gag. Neither of those worked, so you're pretty much out of ideas. Suddenly you hear hoof steps.

clop. clop. clop.

You scream and struggle even harder against the binds.

CLOP. CLOP. CLOP.

You hear a door creak open. "Daaaaaarliiiiing....." You stop, totally stunned in fear. As she steps through the door, you notice she's holding a plate with what looks like the leg of an animal and a bucket of water.  She drops them  both in front of you. "Oh dear me, I seem to have forgotten my corn starch upstairs."

She undoes the binds and you dive into the meat. It's amazingly seasoned, probably the most delicious thing you have ever eaten.  It seems to carry a hint of peppermint.  You wonder what kind of meat it is.  You also drink a lot of water, you are horribly dehydrated. You look up and notice Rarity has been watching you eat. You drop the leg bone. "Please don't hurt me I'm sorry."

"Shh It's quite alright darling, you see ponies are herbivorous and I was just taking certain measures to make sure you didn't attack my sister and I."

What about the third one?  She must have gone home. "I promise, I wouldn't hurt you or Sweetie Belle or anyone else for that matter I just want to go home." you break down into tears, you are scared out of your mind.

"Shhh it's ok." She strokes your hair with her hoof as you continue eating. Soon the strokes go to your chest, then too your stomach, then to the crotch area.

"M-miss rarity what are you doing?"

"Nothing darling just continue."

You nibble at the leg some more trembling, it almost feels like pleasure but it feels so wrong. She levitates something in front of your face. Its a purple collar with a diamond resembling the trampstamp she has, fucking whorse. She fastens it onto you neck. "What is this?"

"Just a little present darling."

You don't like this one bit, now you understand what Sweetie was trying to tell you. "Uh, no you've already been so generous with me..."

"Watch your tone foal. It's collar time, you're MINE now!" she says as she grabs part of it with magic and pulls you down inches from her face.

"FUCK THAT."

"My my darling, where did you hear such vulgar language?"  She throws you against the cold cement wall in the basement.

You start crying. "Now now foal, it's okay.  You just need a few obedience lessons, that's all." She goes back to marshmallowing your crotch area. You sit back and accept it, there's no fighting back. You are already in so much pain.

"Do you enjoy this pup?"

*sniff* "Y-yes miss Rarity." Wrong answer dipshit. Rarity lifts you again and pushes you up into the ceiling, then lets go. Your teeth cut into your lip in the resulting impact, and you begin to bleed profusely from the lip "PLEASE I SAID I WAS SORRY."

"Flesh eating monsters are never sorry, I won't forgive you to what you did to little Twist."

"W-what I don't understand."

"You ate her you uncouth beast."

"Y-YOU KILLED HER  YOU'RE THE ONE WHO COOKED HER YOU FUCKING WHORSE"

"Darling I don't know what you are talking about, you ate her and you must be punished."

"SWEETIE BELLE! COME HERE, WOULD YOU DARLING?" She trots down and looks as if she's been crying and beaten.

"Take our new pet and give him a bath would you?"

"Yes Rarity..." She looks at the scene in horror, the bones of the other foal have been devoured and are right next to you. Rarity applies a leash onto your collar and levitates the end to Sweetie. You are aching and don't want to get up. Rarity then bucks you in the ribs and you start screaming. You hear a sickening crack

"Tsk tsk tsk why must you be so unobediant?" She stabs you with another syringe and the pain is lessened although you still find it hard to stand. You crawl after Sweetie Belle. The bathroom is actually pretty large with some help from Sweetie you get over and into the tub. She slowly fills the tub with water.

"Will your parents really come looking for you?" she says avoiding eye contact.

You find it hard to speak but you manage a simple "Mmmhmmm."

She pushes you into the water, you feel so heavy and can't push her off. She lifts you by the collar out of the water. You try to catch your breath but the pain in your ribs makes it close to impossible. "WILL THEY EAT US TOO?" You can't speak. She pushes you back under the water. She lifts you up and then breaks down into tears.

You hold her close and whisper "I didn't know.", It took the last of your energy and everything goes dark again.

You are Rarity. 5 hours ago you went to check on Anon and Sweetie, and to much of your surprise she was trying to kill him, she really believed you when you said humans had a mind control power, stupid foal.  He is now in her bed and she's sobbing over what she almost did. Poor little thing still denies she will be like you when she grows older.

You hear clopping on your front door. Ughhh more hideous monsters… ohh wait it’s just your friends Twibitch Sparkbitch and Apple Whore. Wouldn’t kill them to visit the spa every now and then would it?

"Rarity there's been a report of a foal missing, I'm sorry but I'm going to have to search the premises.” Twilight says, clearly not in any mood for bullshit.

How dare this bitch come and accuse you. "Do you have a warrant to search my house officer marehood?"

Ohh she’s getting mad. "Rarity I swear to Celestia if you don't let us in-"

"I'm just joking darling my 'friends' are always welcome. It just so happens your little Twist IS here, or part of her anyways I think you should see this."

You lead up the stairs into Sweetie's room. Twilight and applejack hesitate to follow but do so. You obviously tense up, there is a hole in your plan, sweetie belle still might defend him.

"Rarity just show us this thing you found."  Applejack says

"I TRIED TO STOP HIM BUT HE OVERPOWERED ME WITH HIS BRUTISH, INCREDIBLE APE-LIKE STRENGTH!"

"Relax sugarcube I got rope just in case it tries tuh retaliate."

"Darling, remember that case with the Diamond dogs? I was perfectly capable of taming it, even gave it a collar I don't think he'll be fighting anytime soon." You lead them inside the room, little Anon is awake and coughing up blood. Sweetie is still crying.

"RARITY WHAT IN TARTARUS HAPPENED." Twilight explodes in your face. "I don't think it was necessary to go this far to make it stop it looks like a colt."

____

You are Anon. You have tunnel vision and the pain is coming back, you would do anything for more of Raritys something to help the pain.

A purple pony is up in your face, you try to ask for help with all your might but you cough up more blood. "Rarity you call the vet right now."

"Very well darling, by the way that thing eats pony flesh I wouldn't get too close if I were you." You can’t fall back asleep, you are with 2 newer ponies and you are terrified as to what they would do if they find out what you did. You hate to say it but you don't want rarity to leave you with them.

"Sweetie I need the truth what happened." the Purple one says. She seems reluctant to talk.

"Sugarcube look at me we both need to know what happened, what is this thing and where did it come from?" The orange one speaks.

"H-he ate her, the bones are in the basement."

"What happened to him?"

"I... I did this...I almost killed him, but Rarity stopped me before things got bad.." Why is she defending Rarity? You need to tell her the truth.  You need to speak even if it kills you. Too bad your ribs are all fucked up n' shit.

You manage an "Uhhhh" before you cough up a little more.

"Twi, ahh don't think this thing is gunna make it."

She starts using magic, you try to move and get up. She is going to kill you…. waitamin. The magenta aura covers you and is somehow alleviating the pain. All you can do is smile at her before you pass out again. You wake up to another pony bandaging you up, she must be the Vet. Wait a minute, wouldn't a doctor be better? Well what the fuck ever, she's doing the job just fine it seems.

"I think we should let Fluttershy watch over it until it gets better."Say’s the purple pastel pony.

"No darling, I couldn't put her in danger like that.  He seems tame now, but in reality he's a raging carnivore.  He might very well prey on Fluttershy's little animal friends, and we would certainly hate for that to happen now wouldn't we?" Argues Rarity.

You’re starting to doubt if you’ll survive by the time your parents come to get you.