Kissing Away Scars, Finding Home

As the weeks went by Autumn and Starlight settled into their new routine.

Which honestly was the same as their old one. In quiet bedroom discussions, Starlight and Autumn agreed that they weren’t quite marefriends. Starlight wasn’t quite ready to settle down with another pony, to truly open her heart, not after she had lost Sunburst. For her part, Autumn didn’t want to take things too quickly. She was content to only share Starlight’s bed on occasion, whenever they had a “wild mares night.”

Starlight did decide to go out more. She took up a position teaching at the new Crystal Academy set up for gifted crystal unicorns, whilst also becoming a school counsellor. From what Autumn learned over dinner conversations, the students were initially wary of her, but they respected her, and were growing to really love her. It unfortunately did mean Starlight had to spend long hours preparing material at the academy, and wouldn’t return to their home until late.

Their home… huh. Autumn smiled to herself as she stepped out from the backstage of her evening engagement, which tonight, was at the bar “The Graphite Ginhouse.” The night life of the Crystal Empire was booming, with ponies celebrating the engagement between their regent, Captain Shining Armor, and his wife Cadance. Since Starlight wasn’t going to be home until late, she had time to kill at the bar.

As she took a seat, the kirin drew some appreciative glances and a few compliments about her singing. She was wearing a shimmering red number that clung to her barrel and flanks after all.

“One Strawberry Sunrise,” said Autumn.

“One Strawberry Sunrise,” stammered the bartender, an orange unicorn with an elegantly groomed goatee. The kirin looked up watching the liquids pour from their bottles, and the unicorn shake the mixer with his teal magic. When the pink-orange drink was finished, she took a sip, and nodded appreciatively. Despite the stammer in his voice, the bartender was good.

“This is really good. Thank you. What’s your name, sir?” Autumn asked.

“I should hope so. I’m Sunburst, the owner of t-this fine establishment. Your performance tonight was superb by the way,” said the unicorn shyly, adjusting his monocle.

Autumn nearly spat out her drink. As it was, enough spilled that Sunburst was staring at her.

“Sorry, I could have sworn you said your name was Sunburst.”

“But i-it is. D-do I know you?” he stammered.

Autumn shook her head. “No. Sorry. I-um.” The kirin glanced around for something, anything.

That was when she spotted a picture in the back, displayed right in front of the less-used bottles. One of Sunburst, grinning in his mage robes, and looking a bit dazed. One hoof draped around his shoulders was an unscarred Starlight.

The photo also had a single red lipstick mark, and Autumn had a pretty good guess as to who those lips belonged to.

“I know Starlight Glimmer, though,” said Autumn slowly, eyeing Sunburst.

Sunburst sighed, and his shoulders sagged. “Ah… well, everything she told you about me is probably true.”

“Actually, she hasn’t said much about you. Mentioned your name once or twice, but otherwise hasn’t said much,” said Autumn, honestly.

“That’s because she hates me.” Sunburst pulled the photograph from the shelf. “She was-no, still is the love of my life, but… I failed her.” The unicorn shut his eyes. “I was too slow.”

“Slow?”

“The final battle for Sombra’s castle. I was in charge of defending her position, while she threw artillery spells. It… it happened so fast. One moment, she was casting a beam, next, Sombra was in front of us.” Sunburst clutched the photo to his chest, his eyes screwed shut. “I threw up my shield but I was too slow. Enough of the spell got through to hit her face because of me. Because I wasn’t fast enough to protect my fiance.”

Klonk.

Sunburst blinked as Autumn looked up from where she’d planted her head into the bar table.

“Oh, you pair of idiots. Starlight still loves you. She just thought that you wouldn’t want a mare scarred as her.”

“Wait, what, she still loves me?”

Autumn rather quickly cleared up the colossal misunderstanding between the two academically gifted, but thick-skulled unicorns. However, getting the two to actually see each other was harder.

Sunburst had switched from feeling guilty about not protecting Starlight, to feeling guilty about not going to see her and leaving her to wallow in self-pity.

As for Starlight, she was overjoyed that Sunburst still loved her… but was feeling worried that he wouldn’t actually love her if he saw how bad her scars were, and… she felt guilty about sleeping with Autumn.

Which had led to Autumn wrangling the two to a round cafe table, ordering a milkshake for herself, and sitting down to sip it as the two unicorns awkwardly averted their gaze.

It took a while, but finally, Sunburst opened his mouth.

“I’m sorry. I thought… I thought you were mad at me for not protecting you.”

“I’m sorry too. I… I should have… said something, asked for you,” said Starlight. She glanced at Autumn. “I… Sunburst, you have nothing to be sorry about. It was just a misunderstanding and my own shame. I… I… I slept with Autumn.”

“Oh.”

“I thought you didn’t love me anymore and you never wrote, so I… I let her in. But… I still want you. She and I, we’re friends. With certain benefits, but I—my proposal… It still stands if you want it.” Starlight sniffed, wiping her moistening eyes. “Though, I understand if you don’t want to.”

“But I do!” Sunburst exclaimed. “I mean, you must have been so lonely and sad, and well, I can hardly begrudge you for spending time with the Belle of Equestria.” He managed a weak smile. “I’m just glad… that you still want me.”

Starlight sobbing with joy, embraced Sunburst, “Oh you silly stallion. You’re my best friend. Of course, I want you.” And nothing else was said, for they had locked lips with one another.

Autumn grinned with glee, and yet, much to her own surprise, a sudden ache rang in her own heart.

Sunburst and Starlight spent more and more time with one another as the days turned into weeks, rekindling their romance. There were new barriers to overcome for both were changed ponies, but Autumn stood by both, helping them on the way, mediating between the couple, while also just acting as their sounding board.

After all, she had rapidly become a regular performer at the Graphite Ginhouse, whose respectable theatre space allowed her to really show off her singing talents. This meant she had frequent contact with Sunburst, who was quite the musical enthusiast and generally pleasant to talk to.

However, more and more, Autumn was finding it hard to listen to see Starlight with Sunburst, and she knew what that meant.

She was in love with Starlight. She’d been for the longest time, and it took her to see her with Sunburst to realize that.

Autumn couldn’t even be jealous of Sunburst. She was technically the interloper in their relationship and he was a lovely stallion. They’d been engaged before she moved in with Starlight! Moreover, there were nights after shows where she’d spend hours talking to the intelligent stallion about a variety of topics until closing time. He also paid her well, even though they were more than just acquaintances.

So on one night, while Starlight and Sunburst were having a date night, the kirin wrote a note, packed her belongings, and left Starlight’s home. She wasn’t moving out of the Crystal Empire, just to another house in a different district. She couldn’t bear to cut her ties with the pair, but she needed her own space.

The next day she woke after a sleepless night in an unfamiliar bed, to the pounding of a hoof on her door. Groggily, she staggered to her door, opened it, and found two unicorns who looked like they’d been up all night running around the Empire.

“Starlight?”

“Autumn, why did you leave? Did I do something wrong or? Did I leave you out or—”

“Oh Starlight, I couldn’t stay. I—it wouldn’t have been fair to you or Sunburst,” said Autumn.

“Fair to us in what way?” Sunburst asked, curious.

The kirin took a deep breath. “Sunburst, I’m in love with your fiance.”

Autumn expected the pair to recoil, she’d braced herself for it. What she didn’t expect was for the pair to turn to look at each other with wide eyes, and for Sunburst to chuckle.

“Told you,” he said.

“Sh-shut up!” stammered Starlight, her cheeks red.

“Um, sorry? I think I am missing something here,” said Autumn.

Sunburst, was smirking, and he nudged his fiance forward with his snout. “Starlight loves you too, Autumn. And I’m fine with it if you are.”

The kirin’s jaw dropped open.

“Really? But… she’s your fiance.”

“I also love her, and I like you, and I think we can share… if that isn’t too overwhelming for Starlight,” said Sunburst, glancing at the mare beside him.

“No! I… I’m perfectly fine with it,” she said, her cheeks red.

“Then… why are you blushing.”

“Just thinking things.” Starlight shook her head and wrapped Autumn in a hug. “Autumn… I’m sorry, it took me until you left for me to bring this up with Sunburst. I don’t know how it’s going to work… if it is going to work, but I want you to stay, with us… in our home.”

“I…” Autumn sniffled and nuzzling her love, began to cry. “I will. For as long as you will have me.”

There were some things to get used to when Sunburst moved in with Autumn and Starlight. For one, the house got quite a bit cozier and while there were no spacing clashes, there was an adjustment period.

Oddly enough, the bed was the easiest thing to figure out. Starlight liked sleeping in-between Sunburst and Autumn as her four-poster was too big.

Otherwise, things were comfortable between the three, though, Starlight only ever had sex with either Sunburst or Autumn. The stallion and kirin were alright with that. They liked each other, but sex? Nah.

That was until the aftermath of Cadance and Shining Armor’s wedding. Starlight and Sunburst had helped fight off the changeling invasion while Autumn had hid behind them.

The day had been stressful, to say the least, and the three limped home, unscathed, but stressed and shaking, and all in need of a shower.

Autumn, resting on the couch, felt her eyelids drooping. Mostly out of relief. She wasn’t too tired, but the day’s events were weighing on her. Sunburst was in the sofa-chair trying to read, but the kirin could tell he was failing.

Starlight trotted into the room, a towel massaging the tender skin around her face’s scar. “So… that was a day.”

“Oh yes it was,” said Sunburst.

“At least it had a happy ending,” said Autumn, cheerfully.

“True,” said Starlight. Her eyes flicked between Autumn and Sunburst. Back and forth they went, until she took a deep breath and set her towel down.

“Sunburst, Autumn, we’re all stressed and in desperate need of some relaxation. And since neither Autumn nor I am fertile at the moment… are you both interested in a threesome?”

Autumn’s eyes widened. Her mind immediately took her to a wild, crazy place, and the images that flicked through her head turned her cheeks pink.

Sunburst’s jaw dropped open for a moment until he shut it, stammering. “Uhh-S-Starlight. D-did you day, th-threesome?”

“Yeah. I um… well you said you were interested in… butt stuff. And Autumn, you said you wanted to shake things up a bit. I found out this spell that um.” Starlight braced her forehooves against the couch, pursed her lips and her horn flashed.

The pink tip of a currently sheathed member peaked up under Starlight’s barrel, accompanied by a fairly normal set of balls. It was exactly where a stallion's equipment would normally be. Apart from that, Starlight was the same, and as Sunburst trotted around to get a better look, he could see his marefriend’s marehood still there.

“That’s hot,” said Sunburst hoarsely.

Autumn was already off the couch, her hoof grabbing Starlight’s. Her magic was grabbing the hem of Sunburst's cloak.

“Bedroom both of you. Now!”

“But I haven’t cleaned out my butt—”

“Are you a unicorn or not?” hissed Autumn.

Starlight turned red. “But I don’t know any spell that—”

Sunburst’s horn glowed and his marefriend was engulfed in a golden glow. She blinked and felt… distinctly empty in her lower bowels.

“Sorry! I was doing some research. I hope you don’t mind!” Sunburst stammered, throwing his cloak off.

“No that’s perfect! Wait, Autumn, what are you doing?” Starlight squeaked as she was floated into the air. Sunburst was too, and both unicorns flailed slightly before they were dumped onto the bed.

The kirin, slowly stepped onto the bed, rising over the unicorn pair’s limp cocks. She licked her lips, and her mouth parted. A hungry look was in her eyes, which seemed to glow amber in the dim light of their room. Somehow, when Starlight wasn’t looking, Autumn had dimmed the gas lights.

“Let me prepare you for the main event,” said the kirin in a husky voice.

Both unicorns instinctively clasped one another’s hooves, which to Autumn was absolutely adorable. She lowered herself, her mane and barrel resting on the pair’s legs, and gently began to stroke their limp members with both of her forelegs.

To Sunburst, the kirin’s hoof was a much different sensation he was used to. Kirin’s had this hard tip to their hooves that felt a bit odd, and were furrier than his marefriend’s hooves. But he found that Autumn was far too skilled at using the softer parts of her hoof to tickle his leathery member, while also using the hard part of her hoof to give the occasional firm stroke.

For Starlight, having never had a cock before, this sensation was alien, and electric. She shivered, clutching Sunburst’s hoof tightly as a tight pressure started to build at her nethers.

Autumn smiled as her charges swords began to unsheathe, and curiosity, as well as a fair bit of lust, drew her to examine the proferred equipment more closely. Sunburst’s cock was… actually rather girthy if how leathery he felt was anything to go by, and his musk had an orangey-citrus undertone. Starlight’s ozone-like scent was more familiar, but her new equipment, which was smaller, but tighter had this… masculine tang now.

Both were now much stiffer, and so she moved to the second act of her play.

She leaned toward Starlight’s cock and felt her stiffen underneath her hoof. Grinning, she nuzzled the hardening pink spear, using her fluffy orange mane to caress the soft shaft. Starlight turned red, anticipation building as Autumn drew up, and leaned forward to her tower, and gave it a single, long lick, which drew a sharp breath from the unicorn.

But instead of sucking on the pink cock in front of her, Autumn flashed Starlight a mischievous wink, before moving to Sunburst’s member, caressing the stallion’s balls, and taking it in her mouth. Having long conquered her gag-reflex, she forced the thick stallionhood over her tongue and down her throat, until it was so far down, the salty precum threatened to make her gag.

“No fair!” pouted Starlight.

Sunburst had nothing to say as the kirin expertly sucked on him. Tongue coiling and pressing around his stallionhood. Balls gently being caressed. Autumn bobbed up and down and he couldn’t help but buck up into her. Yet, she timed herself perfectly, letting him help her continue to hilt herself onto him.

But Autumn had no intention of leaving Starlight alone. Even as she sucked on Sunburst, her horn glowing blue. With one hoof still on Starlight’s member, she wrapped Starlight’s member with a azure glow and began to massage her cock and her inner thighs.

Starlight gasped, panting as perfectly timed strokes of magic caressed her, stiffening her member and drastically growing the wetness between her legs. Her member was growing harder by the second and was nearly fully erect.

“Autumn, touch me now, please!” she begged.

Autumn obliged, taking one long suck of Sunburst’s tower, savoring the citrusy musk, before bearing down on Starlight. It was less girthy, but fairly sizeable and she felt wet as she knew that she was going to be penetrated by it. Taking a deep breath, she thrust it into her mouth, whilst expertly wrapping her magic around Sunburst’s cock and continued to caress his balls. With her free hoof, she started to stroke the very edges of Starlightouter folds.

Attacked from two sides, Starlight moaned, her sword stiffening, even as the back of the kirin’s throat tightened around it. The fire in her was stocked to a burning life, at the same time that hot, slick walls drove up the pressure she felt in her member. She grabbed the back of Autumn’s mane and froze, just restraining herself from driving the kirin onto her member.

Only for the kirin to give her a permissive wink, and so the unicorn gave into her lust and drove the kirin into her crotch.

Tip of Starlight’s cock hammered into Autumn’s throat, taking the kirin by surprise, but she took it in stride, sucking and licking harder.

“Autumn! I think we should move to the main event!” gasped Sunburst, even as he groaned as the kirin’s magic gave a rather well-timed squeeze. Precum was already flowing from his cock.

“You mean the rising action? Of course!” Autumn pulled herself off of Starlight, savoring the taste of the salty precum and taking a lick of her hoof. The fruity taste of her marefriend’s nectar bringing a smile to her lips. “Time for some blocking changes. I believe I shall take the supporting position. Sunburst, please move aside.”

The stallion complied and Autumn lay down where he had laid. Starlight blinked, puzzled, until the kirin, with her magic, and hooves, helped Starlight up, and gently pulled the unicorn until the mare was straddling the kirin. Her erect member aimed at Autumn’s folds. The path was free, thanks to the kirin spreading her legs wide.

“And you, Sunburst, will take our star from the rear,” said Autumn, grinning.

Sunburst grinned, nervousness all gone, he confidently clambered back onto the bed, and braced his forehooves on his marefriend’s shoulders.

Autumn smiled, and Starlight took in the loving, serene look on her marefriend’s face. She looked over her shoulder and saw the love on Sunburst’s features. His expression seemed almost proud, and clearly eager to start, and bore a confidence that he rarely had.

“I love you both, so much,” Starlight whispered. She felt like she wanted to cry, and her cheeks flushed. “I don’t deserve you two.”

Sunburst leaned forward to nuzzle Starlight’s scarred cheek, just as Autumn raised herself to plant a chaste kiss on the unicorn’s chin.

“It’s not about deserving, Starlight,” said Autumn meaningfully.

“We love you, all of you,” whispered Sunburst.

Starlight’s eyes were moist, and she nodded, looking down at Autumn. It was then she noticed the kirin’s folds were only slightly wet.

“Oh, one last thing.” She opened a drawer with her magic and gently spread a tube of lube on Autumn’s folds.

“Good idea,” said Sunburst, grabbing the tube, he quickly spread it on his member. Readjusting his position, he grinned. “The stage is set, ladies.”

“Time for the final act then!” said Autumn.

Starlight chuckled. “Oh you theatre nerds.” She knelt down and thrust her hips forward, plunging into Autumn’s folds.

Oh my gosh it’s so hot. Was her first thought as Autumn’s folds clenched around her member. It was such a different, yet arousing sensation that she was still for a moment, allowing the tight wet walls to adjust to her cock.

Then she felt Sunburst’s tip penetrating her ass.

She bit her lip, even as Sunburst groaned. Asshole squeezing his thick sword as he hilted himself into her love. It was warm, but unlike the comfortable snug fit of her pussy, Sunburst found her ass’s walls seized his cock so tightly it was borderline uncomfortable.

As for Starlight, warring sensations traveled up her spine. That of being so filled from behind, and being grasped from the front.

From experience, Autumn knew she had to be careful with her next steps. Both unicorns were adjusting, enjoying themselves, but could be turned off if they went too fast. She wanted so badly for Starlight to rut her senseless, to scratch the growing itch she felt, but for now, the sight of the two horny unicorns hazy expressions would have to do.

Gently, Autumn put her forelegs on Starlight’s hips and pulled the mare’s cock into her. She moaned with pleasure, as her marefriend’s cock filled her, scratching the burning itch, sliding comfortably in, and then out of her. Starlight’s member stroked her folds, adding fuel to the moist flame that burnt in Autumn’s nethers.

Sunburst hung on, cock still in Starlight’s taught asshole. The suction of his marefriend’s slimy walls was heavenly, and pulled him forward as she fucked the kirin under her. He took a deep breath, smelling Autumn’s cinnamon scent intermingle with Starlight’s fruity perfume, and slowly began to pull out, and thrust in. He had to go slow at first. But then her clenching walls started to relax, welcoming Sunburst’s girth as he thrust deeper into his marefriend. All the while, her wet asshole squeezed his cock with a blissful pressure.

Starlight’s breaths sharpened, as she was rutted, and rutted. Her stallion’s balls slapping against her sopping wet folds, and her flanks jiggling as his hips slammed into them. Her cock slid out, and back into Autumn’s blazing cavern. Her ass’s walls stretched to their limits by Sunburst’s deep thrusts, which filled her up so much, she felt like she was going to pop. All the while, her cock was welcomed in by Autumn’s wet folds wrapping around her. Both of her lover’s musks filled her every heady breath.

“Harder, Sunburst. Fuck me harder, so I can fuck Autumn harder,” gasped Starlight.

Sunburst obliged and doubled his pace, thrusting so hard, so fast into his mare’s ass that he bucked her into Autumn’s pussy. The kirin gasped and hissed as mare-cock hammered deeply into her, stimulating her already burning arousal. Meanwhile, Starlight, giggled, squealing as she was pounded by her stallion, and rutted her mare. She savored their sweat against her fur, their musk filling her senses. Her tongue lolling out, she met Sunburst’s bucks with a backward thrusts before sheathing herself back into Autumn’s taint.

The three bucked one another, rocking back and forth, every movement drawing hisses and moans of pleasure. Every thrust, and buck drawing the threesome closer to their limits.

Autumn let out a loud moan. “Oh Starlight, make me cum, make me cum over your cock.”

“What’s the magic word—Ohhh Sunburst. I’m so close!”

“So am I… What’s the magic word, Starlight?” Sunburst asked.

“Your mistress… commands you both to—” Starlight gasped as Sunburst suddenly yanked her hair, experimentally, but it tore a wild scream of ecstacy from her throat. “OH-Fuck-me. Buck me hard!” she screamed.

Autumn had been guiding Starlight’s thrusts, grinding her hips into her marefriend, but now, she authoritatively yanked the unicorn, and captured her lips in a savage kiss. She arched her hips, gasping, out of breath, as Starlight’s cock brushed by her sweet spot, and sent her over the edge.

Almost immediately afterward, Sunburst, obeying the command of his mistress, plunged himself into Starlight’s ass, the blessed tightness sending him over the edge. Groaning, his cock throbbed, the pressure releasing as he orgasmed.

Starlight was so close. She was nearly mad with ecstasy as hot stallion-milk filled her asshole, and spicy kirin nectar drenched her member. Autumn’s walls were pulsing, giving her cock the hottest massage in the world. Her ass was soothingly sore, and she was out of breath, both from the kirin’s kiss and from her exertions, but… she wasn’t over the edge yet.

“Oh bite me. Bit me please!” she begged, thrusting into and out of Autumn, trying not to be too rough on the sensitive kirin, but craving her near release.

Autumn let go of her kiss and bit Starlight’s left ear. Sunburst, pulling Starlight’s hair a bit, seized her left.

That extra bit of pain, sent her over and Starlight melted, the pressure built in her cock spilling out into Autumn’s pussy. She collapsed into Autumn, resting herself under the kirin’s chin on her mane, trembling as waves of ecstasy pulsed through her, and sighed contentedly as Sunburst, exhausted, collapsed on her.

“That was amazing, but… if you don’t mind, two unicorns laying on top of me might be a bit too much for me to handle,” gasped Autumn.

Sunburst, slid out of Starlight, as Starlight extricated herself from Autumn. Laying on the bed, they were gasping, limbs tangled, and yet, comfortable.

“We should do that again,” said Starlight.

“I’d love to be in the middle next time,” said Sunburst, turning over to Autumn and winked. “Starlight looked like she was having a lot of fun.”

“We can do both. And more,” said Autumn, lazily, contentedly. “We have all the time in the world.”

After all, the three were home. It would take time for all their scars to heal… but they were home.