Author's Note

A big shout-out to FrostGuardian for helping me out with this story and a big shout-out to Carlosesunbrony, the birthday boy who asked for this. And as always, thank you for your patience and support and remember to stay tuned for more and keep bronying on.

Yes, Yes It Is

The foreplay was unlike anything you've ever imagined. But it only fueled your desire to take your time with Starlight and Rarity to the next level. After some time cuddling with your lovely mares, you were fully recharged and ready to go. "Alright, ladies. It's time for the main event. Which one of you would like to go first?" you asked, staying in character.

"Wait one moment, Anon darling. Before we go any further, there's something I forgot to tell you that you might wanna hear," Rarity said.

It became clear to you that she needed to tell you something important. So, you got out of character just as she did "Hmm? What is it?" you asked, wondering what she needed to say.

"Oh right, I forgot," Starlight remembered, also breaking out of her character.

"You see, darling. Starlight and I may have invited a good friend of mine over. She's heard a lot of great things about you. Plus, she's undergoing a slight little dilemma at the moment," Rarity said sheepishly.

"What's her dilemma?" you asked.

"Well, you see… my dear friend, Octavia Melody, I'm pretty sure you've heard of her, has gone into heat and there's no pony in Ponyville she trusts more than you to help her sate her urges. Though, she's never met you before in person, she told me that she did watch you from afar. You're turning into quite the little stud, Anon," Rarity explained.

"O-O-Octavia Melody? The Octavia Melody? Ponyville's best classical musician who's an expert at playing the cello?" you asked while blushing.

"If you know her, then you'll be happy to hear that she's coming by Rarity's shop any minute. Octavia didn't show up earlier due to a concert she finished yesterday and because she overslept. She has some added stress and it didn't help her estrus all that well," Starlight pointed out.

"Damn, I feel sorry for her. But, if she needs me, I'll be happy to oblige. When is she--" before finishing your question, there was a knock on the door downstairs.

"Oop, that must be here. Wait right here, darlings, I'll be right back," Rarity said, getting off the bed and leaving her bedroom.

“You girls are serious about this? I mean, you’re not joking with me?” You asked Starlight to be sure.

"No joke. Octavia is really into you and she wants to experience you first-hand. Who knows, she might end up being your 3rd girlfriend. Plus, she's in heat, so that makes getting laid all the more fun for you, Anon." Starlight said.

“I know my dear Glimmy,” you scratched the back of your head rather uncertainly. “It’s just, I thought that Octavia loves mares instead of stallions as I sometimes see her hanging around with DJ Pon-3 or Vinyl Scratch.”

"That's what everyone thinks, but in reality, she and Vinyl have an open relationship. She gets laid with other stallions sometimes, but Octavia never found the right one to get laid with. That's where you come in. So, there's no need to worry about wrecking their relationship.

You sighed in relief when you heard those words from Starlight. As the gentleman you are you know your boundaries. As Octavia and Vinyl are in an open relationship who are you to deny a request from the famous Octavia Melody?

Speaking of which, the door opens up and in waltzes the famous cellist herself along with your lovely fashionista lover. "Sorry for the long wait, darlings. Here's the lady of the hour." Rarity gestures to Octavia, who's smiling nervously.

"Wow… she's even more beautiful up close," you say, getting up from the bed. The gray cellist blushes from your comment.

“Thank you, Anon.” Octavia kindly replied. “I’m glad I finally got the chance to meet you.”

“It’s an honor to meet you, too. I've been a huge fan of your work for a long time. I can see why Vinyl loves you so much," you said.

“My, my and gentlecolt and a flatterer.” Octavia swooned, biting her lower lip. You could see that she was getting more nervous.

"Pardon me for asking, but… would it be alright if I gave you a hug?" you asked. "You're just so pretty, I can't resist."

"Aww, that's sweet of you. Of course you can hug me," Octavia nodded opening her arms to you. Your smile grew wider the moment she said that. You walked up to her and hugged Octavia. She gladly hugged you back, but due to her estrus, her hands traveled all across your body, even touching your butt.

“Eager, aren’t we, Miss Melody?” You gave her a teasing look as she looked up at you, with blushing cheeks.

"You could always do me first, darling," Rarity said, spreading her pussy lips open.

"No, do me. I've been dying to feel your cock inside my wet, wanting pussy for a long time," Starlight said, showing off her wet flower. You could feel your boner getting hard as a rock. These horny mares wanted the full treatment of you and that huge monster you keep stored away in your pants. And who were you to deny these ladies their just desserts?

“I have been waiting for so long for you! Don’t you want to give me a ‘ride’ first, Sweetie?” Octavia flirted with you. She even licked her lips when she had a good view of your erect manhood in your pants.

"Okay, I think I'll start off with Rarity. Octavia shall be next and then I'll do Starlight. Would that be ok with you girls?”

“Fine by me, master.” Rarity replied with a sultry grin.

“Someone else before moi? I guess I can wait for one round, it gives me the time to get ‘ready’.” She winked at you, making you blush and wondered what she has in store for you.

“Oh, alright then. I’ll be saving the best for the last. Especially when it’s for you, my master, ” Starlight threw you a sweet kiss.

Flustered at her cuteness, you turned your attention to Rarity who had begun taking off her purple, see-through lingerie. Seeing her beautiful hourglass figure in full glory. You nearly had a nosebleed from seeing her like this. "Yes, such a lovely body. I'm going to cherish this moment for the rest of my life. Get on your arms and knees, my little love slave," you commanded.

“As you wish, my master,” Rarity obeyed. She soon brought her lovely alabaster ass in full view. You took out your dick and aimed it at her dripping entrance. You rubbed the tip of your cock against the surface of her marehood to tease her.

"Master, please! Don't tease me! Put it inside me and ravage me!" Rarity whined adorably. You chuckled and gave her what she wanted, sliding your cock inside her wanting pussy. You felt the tight resistance the moment you popped her cherry. Rarity yelped in surprise but surprisingly took it well. "It's all in! So, this is what it feels like to be a real mare. Thank you, master Anon. I'm all yours now."

Oh, she's yours, alright. You grabbed her hips and thrust in and out of her pussy, causing her to moan and gasp. You watched her ass jiggle every time you thrust in. She looked so hot. You couldn't resist the urge to spank her as you fucked your uncouth lover. This dirty diamond mare turned you on so much.

Meanwhile, Starlight watch you fuck Rarity like a sex-crazed horn dog. She envied Rarity but was also happy to see her the way she was now. Her eyes shrunk to small sapphire dots, her teeth biting her lower lip, sometimes opening up to loll out her tongue. Her breasts jiggled up and down violently. Wet slaps filled the room. Starlight couldn't resist touching herself, waiting in anticipation for her turn to come.

It was truly a delicious sight to behold for you. You wanted to make this interesting, so you quickened the pace, hitting deeper inside Rarity's love tunnel. She shrieked, then turned to face you with a cute, blushing smile. "More master! Give me more! I've been so uncouth. Ravage me harder, make me your slutty love slave!"

"You're such a naughty mare. You obviously deserve some punishment!" You yelled, spanking her even rougher. She let out a throaty moan, panting heavily as you also thrusted harder.

“Buck me, until I can’t walk anymore, master! Ravage me more with that beastly cock of yours!!!” Rarity yelled out in ecstasy.

"No problem. But if I'm gonna do so, I want to see your face," you said, pulling out so you could turn her onto her back. You then reinserted your cock in her pussy, then mashed your body with hers and resumed pounding her pussy more savagely. You thrusted and thrusted all while gazing down at Rarity's cute face. You smirked and kissed the lovely lady. She kissed you back while holding you in her arms and legs. While kissing her, you grabbed both her gorgeous breasts, giving them a nice massage. Rarity moaned in pleasure from the breast massage you were giving her.

"Yes! Use my big girls however you wish. They're all yours! You've made me the happiest mare in all of Ponyville!" she moaned.

As you kept pounding your marefriend, you felt that your feelings for Rarity were really genuine. The compliments she gave you, the cuddles you had every night, it wasn’t just a crush you had on her, it was true love you felt for her and Starlight. You would do anything for them to make them happy. Right now, that means giving your loving fashionista the time of her life.

Starlight could see that you were giving it all to Rarity. Pleasuring herself, she imagined that you were currently making love with her. Thrusting your fashionista for a few minutes more, you felt the urge to cum again. You gritted your teeth as you didn’t want to stop yet.

“R-Rarity! I’m about to cum!” You shouted.

“M-me too, master!” Rarity moaned. “Don’t hold back! Make me your one and only!!!”

You needed no one to tell you twice. Holding your fashionista in your grasp and vice versa, you thrusted as deep as you could in her tight quarters. Before you knew it, your cock flared and shot your hot seed straight into Rarity's womb in large spurts. Rarity couldn't hold it in herself and released her mare juices all over your cock and her bedsheets.

Rarity released you from her grip as she relaxed on her bed, trying to catch her breath after the amazing moment you both had. You decided to lay down next to your fashionista lover and gently turned her head to face yours.

“I love you, Rarity,” you said with small tears in your eyes.

“I love you too, my master.” Rarity replied before giving you a small kiss on your lips.

After you and Rarity broke the kiss, you looked around the room and wondered where Octavia had gone to. You got your answer when you heard somepony clearing her throat. Octavia stood next to you wearing a lavender bathrobe. You could tell she was very shy as she looked away from you with her face turning completely red. You stood up and gave her a hug, assuring her that everything’s ok.

“Thank you… handsome,” she said in comfort. “I’ve been wanting to do this but… now I’m a bit uncertain since I haven’t done this before with a stallion.”

"It's okay. We'll just take this whole thing one step at a time. And… is it alright if I called you "Tavi," since you're so cute?" you asked, making her blush even more.

"I… well, I … o-of course. But, umm… could you possibly remove your clothes so I can see you more clearly?" Tavi asked.

"Sure, anything for you," you said. You let go of Tavi and removed your clothes, revealing to her what you really looked like. Her flushed cheeks definitely told you that she liked how you look. But also admired how fit you were.

"Oh my… you're a handsome fellow. I like what I’m seeing, ” Octavia complimented you. She then grabbed her bathrobe, ready to show herself to you. “You ready handsome?”

Nodding eagerly, Octavia took off her lavender bathrobe, revealing her sexy, black see-through lingerie to you. "Wow… you look so lovely. I think I'm falling in love all over again."

Octavia nervously fiddled with her fingers. “Do you really mean it?”

"Does this answer your question?" you asked, going up to her and kissing her right on the lips. Octavia was caught by surprise at first. But the more you pressed your lips onto hers, the more she got into it and kissed you even deeper. After a minute of making out, you both broke the kiss to catch your breaths.

“I’m convinced, handsome,” she placed her hand on your cheek, making you close your eyes at her soft touch.
You yelped when you were pushed onto Rarity’s bed again. Looking up, you saw Octavia crawling up to your face with a smug look.

“I can’t wait anymore, handsome,” she whispered in your ear. “Take me, with all the love you've got in your heart.”

"As you wish, my dear," you replied. You helped out Tavi by getting her out of her lingerie to display her naked beauty in all its glory. "You're a beautiful star!”

She blushed again at your words and grabbed one of her breasts and licked her nipple. “What’s the matter, handsome? Don’t you wanna play with them?”

With your mind being on auto-pilot, you grabbed her D-cup breasts and softly began with giving Tavi a massage with her amazing breasts. She moaned when you touched her heavenly breasts.

“B-be careful with them, handsome. They’re sensitive.” Already she felt her marehood was starting to get wet from the affection you gave her.

"As you wish," you said, being as gentle as you could with her cleavage. Tavi moaned happily, squirming a little. She sounded so beautiful, it was like heaven. You used your only vacant hand to caress her body while you used your occupied hand to massage her left breast and keep your mouth latched on her right nipple.

Meanwhile with the other mares, Rarity fell asleep not long after you broke the kiss. She was currently having a wonderful dream about you and her as a family. Starlight was rubbing her chin with a mischievous look, watching you and Octavia going at it.

When you felt like you've had enough, you removed your lips from Tavi's boobs and looked up to her with a calm, sultry smile. “Are you ready for our ‘duet’ together, Tavi?”

Firmly, she grabbed your chin and pulled you closer to her stern looking face. “Be quiet and let us make some music together! I can’t hold it any longer. I want you now!!!”

Startled by her sudden domianced attitude she released your chin as your head fell back onto the pillow. Tavi then adjusted herself on top of you once more. Spreading her legs, she revealed her leaking pussy above your erect member.

“Are you ready for this, Tavi?”

“Y-Y-Yes. Here I go,” she tried to remain confident but failed at the moment you heard her stutter. Biting her lower lip she lowered herself down onto your manhood and soon, she took in all of your meaty shaft. Her hymen instantly broke the moment she got you balls deep inside of her.

O-Ouch!" Tavi gasped.

“Are you alright, Tavi?” you asked in concern.

Octavia hissed through her gritted teeth, bearing the pain as it slowly went away. She sighed in relief once she felt good. “I am now.”

"Then go ahead and move when you're ready," you said. Tavi nodded and slowly moved her hips up and down. Her pussy squeezed on your cock tightly and was heating up. Now you know exactly what a mare feels like when she's gone into heat. She felt amazing and looked so good riding on top of you.

She was going faster riding you cock, you could feel it the way her hips went up and down and her moans of pleasure were getting louder. Her mind was going crazy! Lust and love took over her gorgeous body and she laid down on you hugging you tightly while your manhood was still going in her love cave.

You hugged her back and smothered her with kisses on her cheeks and her lips. Octavia was becoming more aroused the more you showed her genuine affections. She sank her hips down lower, getting you deeper inside her love canal. You could feel your cock kissing the entrance to her womb repeatedly. Tavi moaned into the kiss and didn't stop for anything.

Octavia was having the ride of her life. Sadly her ride was about to end. She could feel it inside that she was ready and you were not far behind either.

“T-Tavi, I’m…. going…. to cum! I… h-have to pull out,” you tried to tell her.

“N-no!” She hastily placed her finger on your mouth. “I want you to cum inside me.”

“But… I’ll make you pregnant!” you reasoned.

“I don’t care, I’m ready to take the responsibility of a mother. For years I’ve tried to find the right stallion and no one is as sincere and handsome as you. I admired you from afar. I trust you with my life and… I also love you deeply, Anon!!!”

"I… I love you too! Here I come, Tavi!" you groaned. You grabbed her hips and thrusted upwards while holding her down on top of you. Panting heavily, you felt your climax draw closer by the second. Eventually, you couldn't hold it in and just as she wanted, a gush of cum flooded her insides, reaching inside her womb. Your cock flared and spurted tons of your seed. She moaned out loud and came all over your shaft before collapsing on top of you.

A few moments later, you both calmed down from the intense moment as Tavi stroked your cheek lovingly. "Thank you so much, Anon. You've made me the happiest mare alive." she said, smiling down at you.

"You're welcome, Tavi," you replied. You kissed her one last time before the cellist expert passed out. You gently set her down next to you and covered her with a warm blanket. After that you sat up. "Okay, Starlight. You're next. Are you ready to do this?"

"As if you even have to ask," Starlight said, posing all sexy at the end of the bed. “I have waited long enough for you, hot stuff!”

"You flatter me too much. Here I come, Glimmy-Glim," you say, crawling towards her.

"I'm all yours," she giggles. You get on top of Starlight and aim your cock at her pussy. "I'm gonna make sure to fill you up with lotsa cum and knock you up like I did with Tavi."

"Good. Put lots of foals in me," she urged. You nod and slide your cock inside her wanting love tunnel and pound her with finesse. Starlight moaned, watching you fuck her, now making her your official mare. You gazed down at her jiggling breasts. They looked so good, you leaned down and sucked on her boobs hungrily.

“Ooooh, Master Anon, that feels so good!” Starlight moaned. “Don’t stop!!!”

Obeying your mare, you kept pounding her tight pussy some more and kept on sucking her soft, squishy melons. Starlight let out throaty moans. You went deeper down her tight love canal, kissing her womb with your large, thick cock. The ecstasy was becoming so good, you smashed your body onto hers. Her boobs felt so good on your chest. You then leaned down further and sucked on her neck.

This made her climax early all over your crotch and Rarity's bed sheets. Starlight was lost in a world of her own lust. She locked her legs around your waist and her arms around your neck.

She had nothing but pure love for you and vice versa. You wrapped your arms around her and went at a faster pace than before. Eventually her tight pussy got even tighter and your cock was growing bigger inside her. "S-Starlight, I… I'm gonna cum!"

"Yes! Yes! More! Cum inside me! Knock me up with lots of your foals!" she hollered. You kissed her in response to her plea. Your tongues danced together as your hips slammed together. Wet slaps echoed even louder throughout the room.

Starlight eventually couldn't handle it anymore and neither could you. Finally, you and Starlight moaned into each other's lips and came hard together. Her mare nectar sprayed all over your cock and the bed sheets once more. Your chunky, sticky seed flooded her womb, painting her insides white and filling her up to the max. The ecstasy was too much for her as she used the last ounce of strength to kiss you one last time. "Thank you… Master Anon," she said before she kissed you.

“I love you, so much!” She managed to say before passing out.

"You're welcome… Starlight and I love you too with all my heart." you replied before getting off her and passing out with your lovely mares with a big smile on your face.

A year and a half later, your life has changed dramatically. For starters, you now owned a house that was big enough to fit you, your 3 wives and your 3 children, one from each mare. 4 months after you had sex with Rarity, Starlight and Octavia, you wound up getting married. What became as a surprise is how you actually got all 3 mares pregnant. Apparently, since they've got humanoid bodies, they're able to reproduce with humans. Your three children's names were Starshine Glimmer, your daughter with Starlight. Silver Shine, your son with Rarity and finally Amber Melody, your daughter with Octavia Melody

Starshine's fur color was the same as your skin and has her mother's eyes and mane color. For your son, Silver Shine, he looks mostly like his mother, but has his mane a mixture of yours and Rarity's mane color, but has your eye color. As for Amber, her fur was also the same color as your skin, but her eye color along with her mane and tail style, were the same colors as her mother.

Moving into a new house this big was a bit of a hassle financially, but your wives helped out, even went so far as to move in with you. They still kept their businesses up and running. And as of right now, it was night time and it was your turn to put the kids to sleep. You are walking upstairs with two of your three children in each hand.

The two children in each of your hands were your two daughters. You gave them both a goodnight’s kiss on their foreheads. Your baby girls cooed softly, while making themself cozy as you tucked them in their little beds with some warm blankets. "Goodnight my sweet little angelic princesses."

Your baby girls cooed softly again before you softly sang a lullaby to them. As you were singing, Rarity entered the bedroom, carrying Silver Shine, and carefully tucked him into his crib as well. Afterwards, your wives all hugged and kissed you.

"We'll be waiting for you in our bed, darling," Rarity whispered.

"Don't keep us waiting too long," Starlight said.

"Do we make ourselves clear, deary?" Tavi asked.

"Yeah. I won't be long," you whispered back. You hugged and kissed your wives back, then went to kiss your son on his forehead. "Rest easy, kiddo." And with all your kids sound asleep, you turned the baby monitor on before you quietly left their room and closed the door.

You made your way back to the master bedroom where your wives were waiting patiently on the bed for you to return. "Are the little ones asleep now?" Rarity asked.

"Indeed, they are. It's been a long day for us all," you said.

"Most definitely," Tavi agreed as you climbed in bed with them. Your wives all snuggled up close to you, pressing their bodies snuggly onto yours. "You've always been such a gentleman since you first came here."

"Thanks, Tavi. You know, I was sad that I had to leave my friends and family and I still am. But you know, I'm sure they know I'm not suffering anymore. I've got three beautiful wives and three wonderful kids to take care of. You have me set for life now. So thank you all. I love you so very much, girls," you said softly.

"We love you too, Anon," Starlight, Rarity and Tavi replied in unison. As Luna's moon shined brightly in the night sky, you smiled upon it and fell asleep with your mares, embracing this new, wonderful life you'll cherish even if one day time comes to an end.

The End