Aim for the Sun, Shoot for the Stars

You sit quietly at your couch, the sound of music playing from the television filling your ears. Your eyes are preoccupied with the phone screen below, your fingers almost on autopilot as you continuously tap and swipe away at the screen before you, trying to find anything of relevant interest.

You decide to scroll past a few old texts to look for a picture Sunset took of her and Starlight. An image of both girls holding up a peace sign with their fingers catches your attention. Even though it was just a quick photo Sunset took when Starlight crossed over, it would be the first time you would actually meet her. It wasn’t her first time visiting, but thanks to work, you could never set up a proper date to get acquainted with each other.

You get a notification on your phone, and you quickly recognize it as a text from Sunset. You open it and she tells you both her and Starlight will be at your place shortly. You reply back, telling her their timing is perfect since dinner will be delivered soon as well. You would have cooked a nice meal, but unsure of how Starlight would react if anything had meat in it, you abstained and asked Sunset what kind of pizza she and Starlight would like a short while ago.

You get another text; she asks if you're ready for a fun night and accompanies the text with a heart emoji. Ready was an understatement. You were both looking forward to this day for quite some time. Thanks to previous sexual sessions, Sunset would always rile you up and excite you further by saying how much fun it would be to have two hot girls sucking you off, and even included other little kinks.

You reply, promptly telling her you'll leave both her and Starlight so sexually satisfied, they'll be walking funny for the next few days. You don't see it, but you know she's rolling her eyes as she reads the text.

You adjust your lower body as your mind starts to thoroughly remember the more intimate and kinkier memories you have. There's a stiffening feeling below, but you shut down the feeling as you focus more on the phone. You are too seasoned in the sex department for careless erections to sway and distract your mind, but you can't help but wonder if Sunset would be interested in using the leash at some point. It was wishful thinking, but you hoped that Starlight would have a very open mindset towards it.

You hear a knock at the door, and you briefly wonder who it is. The question gets answered as the door knob starts to jiggle and you hear the door creak open.

"We're home!" a voice proclaims as you turn off your phone.

"Coming, Babe!" you answer back, dropping the phone and instantly recognizing Sunset's voice as you throw your body upwards and walk for the door.

As you round the corner and come to the entrance, you notice Sunset has already entered and removed her boots. You note she's wearing her usual attire of a black sports jacket and a skirt, while she's wearing a purple shirt with a sun logo underneath, before your eyes notice the absence of the secondary house guest.

You wonder where Starlight is, until the sight of a star decorated, pinkish-purple beanie peeks from behind the door. A face appears and you instantly recognize Starlight. You watch her eyes scan the room curiously as she starts to appear more from behind the door, but the sight of Sunset smiling draws your attention to her.

"Hey, Baby, how was your day?" Sunset asks, her voice a subtle mix of affection and someone who genuinely missed their companion throughout the day.

"Better now that you're here, Sunshine," you say with a smirk as she throws her arms around your neck and draws you close to her.

You embrace her by wrapping one arm around her back, while your other hand rests dangerously close to her butt. She doesn't protest, and you are rewarded with a soft purr of affection and a low giggle before she leans forward and plants a kiss on your lips. You hug her close and take in the feeling of whiskey-tainted lips, along with the cherry flavored lipstick she's wearing. You press your lips harder into hers, causing her to moan softly into your mouth while your hand creeps down her butt and begins to grope it.

"Save it for the bedroom, Tiger," she warns halfheartedly as both hers and your grip loosens.

"Sorry, Babe," you reply as your eyes turn to the other woman in the room, who is quietly standing in place and watching the both of you with studious intent. "Kinda hard to do that. Especially when I haven't seen you all day."

You get an unamused smirk and you can tell she's holding herself back from rolling her eyes. She begins to pull away but stays close enough to you as she turns around and leans her back into your chest. Once settled, she lets out a sigh as you instinctively wrap your arms around her midsection. You hug her close and hum affectionately into her neck as you kiss it. Her hair obscures your vision briefly as your nose picks up that all-too-familiar scent of tangerines, before you rest your chin on her shoulder.

Without missing a beat, Sunset quickly introduces you. You focus on Starlight and take her appearance in. Light pinkish-purple skin greets your eyes and a deep purple head of hair with a mint green stripe going down the middle accompanies it. You notice her faded purple jeans have strips of her skin showing through evenly cut holes.

Though you feel like a lecherous pervert, you can't help but notice how her high-cut, light green tank top hugs nice and close to her chest. She’s well developed, very much like Sunset is. A bit more perky, but only because you notice the tips of her nipples poking ever so subtly through the tank top. You’re quick to notice a lack of a bra on her, but it didn't really surprise you, since Sunset told you ponies from the other side don't have undergarments on when they cross over. Not wanting to stare too long, you look up to her lilac colored eyes.

"Nice to finally meet you," Starlight speaks up cheerfully as she brings her hand up and wiggles her fingers, albeit awkwardly.

"Nice to finally see the pretty face from behind the screen," you say with a cheeky grin, earning you a soft chuckle from Starlight, while at the same time Sunset halfheartedly bumps your gut with her elbow. "Sunset tells me you two have a lot in common."

"I hope she only shared the good stuff with you," Starlight replies, a subtle but slightly tense grin appearing on her face.

"No need to worry about that. All I know is that both of you are connected through pony-Twilight, thanks to past actions. I won't pry for information, but whatever you did, there is a high chance it doesn't bother me at all," you tell her in a reassuring tone.

"Really? Why wouldn't it bother you?" Starlight asks, almost like she was confused by your answer.

"We all make mistakes that we regret… and sometimes we let those mistakes hold us back from progressing through life," you start as you feel Sunset bring her hands up and place them against yours. "If you let that happen, you end up missing out on all the good things to come."

"He kinda knows my whole backstory and how I left Equestria for my…" Sunset cut in, but found her voice trailing off. She goes quiet and looks away with a somber frown on her face. You know what pains her and quickly hug her close for reassurance.

"Quest for power?" Starlight finishes her sentence, rather nonchalantly.

"Well… yeah," Sunset answers, her smile quickly returning as you snuggle her closer to you. "I've actually told him about my incident with Twilight and how I brought Equestrian magic into this world as well."

"Forgiveness and acceptance. It's the only way to look at life," you say as you give Sunset a kiss on the cheek. "Besides, having magic in this world has livened things up around here. Plus I still find it awesome that Sunset went full demon and managed to partially destroy the high school."

Sunset gives you an unamused groan, but you see a small smile of someone who enjoys the compliment.

"It is nice to see some humans are just as forgiving as ponies are," Starlight replies, looking less tense than before. "I can see why Sunset speaks so highly of you."

"I do my best." You give Sunset's cheek another kiss as you move your hands to her hips. "Even though I love to drive her up the wall with my antics."

You get a giggle from Sunset and her hands follow yours. She doesn't protest to your touch and she even turns her head slightly to give you a small, lusty grin. You grin back before you kiss her on the lips.

"Though now that I think about it…" you break the kiss and look to Sunset. "I am curious to hear all the good things you've said about me."

"I bet you are." Sunset gives you a cheeky grin. "I told her ab-"

The sound of knocking at the door pauses the conversation and everyone focuses on it.

"Nice. Dinner is here!" you proclaim as you let go of Sunset and turn your attention to your wallet in your back pocket. "How about we continue this after I pay for the food?"

"Sure thing, Babe," Sunset replies as she reaches out and grabs Starlight's hand. "Come on, I'll give you a quick tour of the place."

"Lead the way," Starlight says back as she takes off her boots and walks with Sunset.

You just smile at them as they walk off into the living room.