Aim for the Sun, Shoot for the Stars

From your kitchen you idly gather drinking materials as the sound of both girls gossiping in the background fills your ears. Even with Starlight being a new person to meet, you kind of found yourself on the sidelines when it came to small talk and didn’t engage with her as much as you could. It didn’t bother you—nor did the girls seem annoyed at your reluctance—since you always preferred to listen in and give your two cents whenever the chance arrived.

You pull a bottle of whiskey from the shelves above and grab three freshly washed shot glasses, before lining them up in succession. As you remove the top and quickly pour, you smirk as your mind races with potential scenarios you’ll be able to pull off in the bedroom. Even with your mind on the incoming threesome all day, actually seeing Starlight in person sent your imagination into overdrive as endless thoughts poured into it.

What could you do? What did Starlight like? What were her limits? How would you balance pacing yourselves between both girls? Would Sunset focus on you or Starlight more? What would they do with each other? The questions never ended, and you could only gird your loins and speculate the answers. You didn’t want to worry about it; everything always seemed to guide itself in the end when it came to sex, and all you would have to worry about was having enough endurance to last for a long time.

As you finish pouring the shots, you put the bottle back and turn your attention to the sounds of idle gossip from the living area. Both are sitting in opposing couches across from one another with only a small glass table separating the two. You hear Starlight speaking, mostly talking about a few adventures she and her friends had taken in Equestria.

Her tone was cheerful yet blunt, and you can’t help but feel a natural charisma in her voice that makes you recall that she once was a leader in her own village. You pick up other things though, especially when the conversations shift to areas where Sunset brings up feelings and such. When Starlight answers, you notice how she sounds disconnected and almost tries to sidestep that area with other things, almost like she’s too emotionally insecure to talk about it. Part of you wanted to step in and pry, but the way she spoke made you realize that underneath her calm demeanour was someone who knew how to work a silver tongue and sidestep the questions any way she could.

You decide to not waste anymore time and put the shots on a small plate before walking to the living area with drinks in hand. As you walk in and sit down, both girls continue to talk back and forth, even as Sunset watches you with a soft smile as you put the shots on the table, one in front of each of them.

“Thanks, hun,” Sunset notes as the conversation pauses and she leans forward and picks up the drink, then quickly slams it back.

You chuckle mildly as she lets off an overly-exaggerated sigh and puts the empty glass back down. You notice Starlight pick up her own glass and do the same motion, albeit without the sigh at the end. Not wanting to be the odd one out, you follow with your shot.

“Not as strong as the stuff back home,” Starlight says with a sly grin, while she licks her lips. “Definitely has more flavor to it though.”

“Shame we finished off the schnapps the other night,” Sunset breaks in, shrugging casually. “But now that we are all sitting together again… how about we talk about tonight? I think a certain someone is ready to go,” she ends with a devious smile.

You blink absentmindedly at the comment, until you hear a giggle from Starlight and notice Sunset is looking down at your pants. You look down, and instantly blush and look away in embarrassment as you notice a stiffening bulge below. It's barely noticeable, but your loose-fitting sweat pants make it stand out more. Considering your mindset prior and the fact you’ve been quietly listening to both of them talk, you lost focus. So much for being too seasoned in the sex department.

“Guilty as charged,” you start up, trying to appear nonchalant about it. “Hard to think of anything else, especially when I’ve been saving myself all day.”

You get an unamused tut from Sunset as she shakes her head, while Starlight smiles at you with a curious glint in her eyes.

“I’m with you on that,” Starlight says as she brings her hands up to her chin and rests them against it. “I’ve been raring to go all day, since Sunset’s been constantly hinting at it.” She rolls her eyes in a sarcastic manner.

“What can I say? I’ve been looking forward to a threeway for a long time. It’s also gonna be our first time trying this,” Sunset adds, putting her hand on your lap as she turns her attention to you. “So I think it’s smart to lay out a few proposals before we get going.”

“You have something special in mind, babe?” you ask.

“Maybe," she quips sarcastically. "But I wanna do my best to make it enjoyable for all of us. That being said, since we know each other very well in the bedroom, my first proposal is that you,” Sunset says as she points at Starlight, “are the center of attention for this evening.”

Starlight’s eyes lit up, almost like stars themselves became noticeable in her pupils.

“Now, with you being the center of attention, do you have any special kinks that you can or won’t allow?” Sunset continues.

“Well…” Starlight tilts her chin upward and stares at the ceiling. “Most of my kinks are magic-based and since I kinda can’t use my magic freely here, I was hoping you two could show me the ropes, especially with your fingers,” she adds as she looks to her hand. “These fingers and thumbs are more useful than I could have ever imagined. Just the fact I can move them so freely and pick stuff up without worrying about dropping things is something I’m going to miss when I head back home… but back to the point, I really wanna see how an intimately strong couple performs first. You know… for studying reasons.”

"Sure thing, Twilight," Sunset jests with a big grin.

“Hey, if she wants to watch us beforehand, I say we give her a show,” you casually say as you bring your hand up and begin to wiggle your fingers back and forth. “So how about we do this right here and now?”

The smile on her face slowly turns into a lusty grin of approval. Her hand traces up your legs and comes dangerously close to gripping your junk below. You play into it and move your body closer to her and bring your own hand down to her lap, before gently caressing her inner thigh. You get a soft rumble of approval and she parts her legs slightly, giving the guest ahead a full view of what’s under the skirt. You see Starlight look down and notice her try to conceal a smile while she bites the corner of her lower lip.

“Ready for the fun to begin, Sunshine?” you whisper into Sunset’s ear, giving it a playful nibble on the lobe and follow it up with a quick kiss.

“I’m always ready for a great time with you, hun,” she answers back as her hand moves from your lap and rests against your free hand.

You smile and chuckle, before you move your hand against hers and interlock your fingers. As you do that, your other hand down below trails more inward, until you are greeted by the feeling of panties blocking access to the prize waiting for you. You would remove them fully, but before you can attempt to do it Sunset shifts her body and leans against you. Her face comes close to your’s and before you can do anything, she turns her head and gives you a kiss on the lips. You opt to simply pull the delicate fabric to the side. Once the fabric is set and you have unhindered access, you press the tip of your middle finger against her labia, earning a soft ‘mhm’ and a slight buck of her hips. Your finger sinks deeper momentarily, but you don’t let it slip in fully. Instead, you let your finger sway and slowly trail it upward, letting it brush over her clit and letting it stop over a shaven patch of skin.

She bucks herself again and you can't help but let out a chuckle as your finger runs in a slow and circular motion. She bites her lip, and her eyes travel down briefly to notice the growing mass of flesh underneath your pants, letting her know that you're just as excited as she is. She lets go of your hand and you instantly brace for her to grip your erection below, but it doesn’t come. Instead, her hand goes under your shirt and you feel her coarse yet delicate fingers roam over your lean frame, slowly rubbing it up and down.

You get a purr of satisfaction from her as her fingers run against your abs and she shows it further by planting a quick kiss on your lips. You answer back and move your finger back down to her outer lips, purposely avoiding her clitoris, and you get a long, soft moan as you feel her now moistened lips. It’s warm and you can feel a bit more heat radiating from her core as you press your finger back against it, refusing to stick it in.

“You’re such a tease, you know that?” she murmurs into your lips as she plants another quick kiss.

She tries to pull away but you don’t allow it. You want to feel more of those whiskey-tainted lips against yours, if only for a second more. You quickly move your free hand upward and rest it against her shoulder, briefly massaging it before you move your hand behind her neck and pull her closer. Her lips press firmly against yours as you cup the back of her hair and she moans softly into your mouth, her tongue briefly jutting out to meet yours.

You don’t abide and quickly pull away.

“Gotta get the audience hyped up, you know,” you jest as you look to the side and notice Starlight is still eying your finger movement with a smile on her face. You see her cheeks are flushed with heat and, while she’s resting her head against one hand, you can’t help but notice the other is down by her inner thighs, gingerly tapping against the taut fabric, as if she’s almost debating dropping her pants and fingering herself on the spot.

Suddenly she catches your gaze and Sunset soon after looks in her direction. As their eyes meet, you press your finger harder against Sunset’s pussy and finally let it slip into the moist area.

“Aa-ahh!!” Sunset moans loudly, almost like she was caught off guard by the sudden movement, and her hips jerk forward. The palm of your hand makes contact against her clitoris, and you instantly start to rub against it.

Starlight reacts as well, and you notice her legs spread more.

“Seems you get more into it when you have an audience,” you tease in a low tone as you wiggle fast enough to warrant pleasure, yet slow enough that she gives you a needy moan. “Didn’t realize my girl was a closet exhibitionist.”

“Th-that’s because... mhmmm,” her words trail off as you slip more of your finger in until the second knuckle feels the warmth inside.

You wiggle your finger quickly, pressing it upward and rubbing against a G-spot she has there. She tries to kiss you again, but your finger is driving her mad as her legs slip open even more, causing you to feel less resistance than before. You can’t help but smirk as you watch the movement of your finger doing its job.

She’s looking down at your hand, her eyes half-lidded and slightly glossed over. Her mouth hangs open and meek little pants flow freely from it, while her hips gingerly try to rock in tune with your movements. They fail miserably as she can’t find a pace, but you know she’s absolutely enjoying it.

You look over to Starlight, who now has her own hand in her pants, her face more flushed than before. Her eyes stay latched on your finger, no doubt trying her best to mimic the movements for her own pleasure. You can see movement under the tight fabric, but you wish you could see more.

A throb from your hardened erection below reinforces your point. You feel the dampness from it clinging to your neglected cock, begging for it to be stuffed inside of either female at this point. The situation arouses you greatly, and over the next several minutes, you continue this show, perfectly working Sunset’s body and mind into a lustful stupor. You tease her effortlessly with your very dexterous finger as it dances and slithers inside her increasingly tight sanctum. All the while you purposely avoid touching her clit, never once stopping your movements inside her, even as she tries to grind herself against the palm of your hand in the vain hope she can feel the brief touch of skin against her more delicate area.

You give her something better and you slip in your ring finger and pick up the speed.

You get another moan; loud and carnal, that quickly turns into a cry of pleasure as her head jerks up and she stares at the roof above. Her facial expression shifts as her tongue lolls out of her mouth and her eyes seem to stare past the ceiling, almost like she’s staring into nothingness itself. A much-deserved ahegao, and it only deepens as she sinks more into the cushion beneath her body and her lower region arches upwards as she slides down. You move with her body, planting your foot firmly against the carpet before you lean into her ear and give off a deep rumble from your throat as wet plaps fill the air. She’s close. You feel her starting to tighten up the more you finger her. Yet you can’t help but wonder if Starlight is closer.

You look to your houseguest across the table and notice her eyes are closed and her hand is still moving underneath her pants. Even though she;s rubbing herself, you notice her other hand is oddly still. The fact she isn’t touching her chest at all, makes you wonder if she doesn’t realize what she is missing.

“You know it feels better if you play with your tits as well right, Starlight?” you ask out loud.

“My… my what?” Starlight remarks.

“Your chest,” you note. “Sunset always talks about how great it feels to play with her breasts when she gets super horny.” You turn your face towards Sunset. “Isn’t that, babe?”

Sunset just lets out a whine as your fingers work her. She’s too lost in her own lust to even answer your question.

“Give it a try,” you chuckle as you look back to Starlight. “Squeeze your breast and pi… oh you figured that out quickly.”

Her once free hand is now underneath her tank-top, and you watch her fingers twisting and pinching at her nipples. Her shirt is lifted high enough that you can see the bottom half of her breasts, yet the sight of her perky nipples and areolas elude your vision.

“Quick learner,” you snark.

Another whine from Sunset draws back your attention.

“B-baby, I’m… I’m about to…” Sunset pants quietly, her voice trailing off as she grinds yourself against your fingers.

You take a deep breath and move your drenched fingers as fast they can go. She twists and writhes with sexual agony as you push her closer and closer to her breaking point. Her hand never lets go of yours as she grips it tightly, squeezing it as a sign of reassurance to keep going. Your endless assault on her G-spot has her moaning nonstop and you patiently keep going until it hits her.

You get another moan and it transitions into a scream of pleasure that makes you worry the neighbours next door will hear it and call the cops. You quickly discard the thought as the sudden feeling of her pussy clenching tightly around your fingers draws your focus. Despite the increased resistance, you don’t falter as her nethers convulse, but as her body’s motions begin to die down, you slow down as well as she starts to relax and loosen back up.

“Damn, babe, I think that’s the hardest I’ve made you cum,” you joke as her body comes to a halt and you slowly pull your drenched fingers out and stare at the mess she made. “Seems someone likes being watched…”

She doesn’t answer, only the labored pants of a woman sinking into her afterglow fills the air as she stares down at the pool of girlcum she’s left on the couch. You just smile at her and turn your attention to Starlight.

She’s still going hard, but she wasn’t going fast enough with her movements to warrant an incoming orgasm. Either taking her time, or still trying to get the movements right, you can only watch quietly. As you stare, you notice Sunset has regained her composure and is now smiling at you while she watches an oblivious Starlight finger herself.

“You wanna go give her some attention, baby?” Sunset asks quietly. “Wouldn’t be fair to let her first human orgasm be boring.”

Your smile widens at the prospect as you pull your body up. The couch springs groan as you remove yourself from the cushion and you focus on the preoccupied woman in front of you. Starlight continues to focus on her own pleasure as you walk towards her, almost like she forgot there were two other people in the room with her. You can hear soft groans of pleasure as you come close, and once you're a foot in front of her, you squat down.

"You need a hand there, Starlight?" you ask with a smirk.

Instantly her eyes widen and her gaze locks onto you as her fingers stop. She says nothing as she continues to pant softly, her expression one of shock as she looks at you then over to Sunset.

"Sorry I... I was trying to get the movements down right," she answers finally as she pulls her hand out of her pants and moves her other one away from her breasts.

"It's easier without clothes on you know," you note.

"Oh? Wait, I thought we were supposed to do this in clothes," Starlight replies.

The response catches you off guard, and when you look back at Sunset, you get a shrug from her.

"What made you think that?" you ask.

"Well... you kinda did her with your clothes on and she didn't take anything off either," Starlight replies, almost like she was confused as well.

You pause for a second, until you remember that Sunset told you that ponies don’t wear clothes on the other side of the mirror. Guess she was still getting used to how things worked, and it looks like Sunset didn’t fill her in either.

“My bad,” you reply as you rub the back of your neck at the silly misunderstanding. “Humans don’t wear clothes when they have sex normally, and I forgot about social differences between humans and ponies.”

“It’s not your fault, I should have asked in the first place,” Starlight meekly replies as she grabs the underside of her shirt, like she is ready to pull it up. “Been looking for a reason to take these clothes off anyway.”

“Fair enough,” you shrug, before you give her a devilish smirk. “Would you like me to help you get out of those clothes then?

“Well since you’re offering.” She matches your smirk and lifts her arms straight into the air. “Go ahead and undress me.”