A little over an hour later, Fluttershy’s house stank of sex and sweat. I lay on the floor, my face and groin slick with fluids as I sucked long deep breaths into my lungs. Dash and Fluttershy were lying next to each other on the bed. We’d moved to the bedroom eventually after breaking the couch so that we’d have enough room.

I made a note to repair the couch for Fluttershy sometime next week, once I could move again, of course. The girls were worn out, and between the two of them, so was I, even with semi-magic sex crystals helping me out. Even after all of the crazy sex I’d had today, having a threesome with Fluttershy and Rainbowdash was… special.

It wasn’t just the threesome, though we’d switched positions and partners many times, and I’d managed to fill both girls with more cum than I’d thought possible for a human to make in a week, let alone a day. Technically, plowing Pinky as she sucked my cum out of her sister counted, and I’d take that memory with me to the grave.

Which, let’s be honest, might be closer than I think.

If I were honest with myself, it was probably that I was in love with Fluttershy. I loved all the girls, in various ways, not least of which was deep friendship.

I was broken out of my half asleep musing when Fluttershy called my name softly. I pulled myself up on my knees, and crawled around the bed to her, exhausted.

She rolled over to face me, and cupped my head. “I know Human Day will be over soon, but I was hoping…” she bit her lip and blushed, but pressed on. “I was hoping we could find out if… um… humans and ponies can…” She finally stopped, too shy to continue. She took a deep breath and said, “Or maybe Twilight could turn you into a stallion? Not permanently of course!”

She had finally come out and addressed the elephant in the room. Both of us wanted to be together, but a cross species relationship- it was peculiar even in Equestria, and the subject of jokes and courtroom hearings back on Earth.

My tongue felt like lead in my mouth, but I forced it to move. “We’ll talk to Twilight about it, OK? And… I’m not opposed to either, or both, but- I need to think about it before I say yes. I don’t want to lie to you.”

I gave her a friendly nuzzle, and despite what we’d been up to for the last hour, she blushed cutely.

Fluttershy smiled slightly and nodded. “Thank you, Shepard.”

She closed her eyes, and I watched her breathing change to a steady pace. I dragged myself to my feet, and pulled a sheet up over the girls before heading down stairs, and slugging back a large glass of water. Finally I pulled a sofa cushion free from the mess we’d made of it, and curled up on the floor, not wanting to wake the girls, even though I was sure they’d want me in bed.

I woke up as I was being lowered into warm water. Not expecting this, and being half asleep, I panicked slightly.

“Wha?!” I splashed at the water haphazardly until I realized I was in a metal bathtub.

“Calm down, Shepard. I’m just giving you a bath. You really needed one.”

I did calm down, as I recognized the voice. It was Applejack. I looked around and realized I was in a barn. A few more seconds and I recognized it as the Apple family barn, which made sense.

I didn’t see her, but her voice had been from behind me. “Hey, Applejack. How’d I get here?” I asked. “Not that it’s not nice to see you, but I’m pretty sure I was at Fluttershy’s home.”

“You were.” She walked into view with a bucket of water, and poured it into the bath, raising the water level. It was deliciously warm, and I let out a slow moan of appreciation. Then I took in the sight of Applejack.

She wasn’t naked, surprisingly. It looked like she’d taken some tarpaulin or something and made a rudimentary set of overalls. It was covered in several stains already, and I could imagine why she’d need clothes working as hard as she did on the farm. I hoped Rarity never saw this, as she’d take it as an affront to fashion, but it was clearly a minimalist, functional garment. It was also fairly tight all over, and was barely holding her chest in.

Applejack saw me looking and smiled. “I don’t have Rarity’s skill, but I don’t think it’s too bad for something I rigged up in half an hour. Or were you looking at what’s underneath?”

“Both,” I admitted.

“Good. You’re clearly exhausted. I carried you here from Fluttershy’s and you didn’t wake up even once. You stay there and enjoy the bath. I’m getting you some food, and once you’ve eaten, then maybe I’ll slip out of this and join you in getting wet?”

My eyes danced over her lean, muscular physique, hidden to me, but all the more enticing. It was clear what she wanted. “That sounds excellent, but as much as the spirit is willing, and believe me, Applejack, I’m very willing, the flesh is…” I let out a sigh. “Weak. I can’t make any promises. You saw what those two did to me. I don’t know if I can get it up again.”

Applejack didn’t seem discouraged. “How about after you eat,” she rubbed the crotch of her overalls, “I find you some dessert to munch on? Then we’ll see how you feel after that?”

I grinned. “That sounds like a plan.”

Fifteen minutes later, I was being served mac and cheese alongside a bowl of some kind of spicy lentil stew and a small salad. Applejack made me stay in the bath, and occasionally scooped out a bucket of water to replace it with a fresh, hot bucket.

She did all this with a pronounced sway to her hips, and plenty of bending over farther than really necessary. I could see all the way down to her stomach between her breasts, and her toned ass was pressing against the fabric with each step. It was a kind of subtle sensuality that I honestly didn’t associate with the hard working farm pony.

It made her seem more… Sophisticated.

“Feeling better?” She asked, now behind me. She placed her hands on my shoulders, and began to rub them. I groaned softly, and leaned back into her touch. My head rested between her large, firm breasts. It was erotic but also very comforting.

“Much,” I admitted with a soft sigh. “You know, you’re not normally this… Pampering.”

“Sure ah am,” Applejack chuckled, making her boobs shake pleasantly against my head, “you jest don’t appreciate it as much when ah ain’t human.”

“I do appreciate it,” I responded, “just… Differently.” I looked up into her eyes, as she smiled down on me. “Things are going to be very different around here after today.”

“Sure are,” she confirmed, digging her thumbs in and loosening my shoulders. I sighed quietly.

Applejack tilted her head.

“Scared?” She asked.

“A little,” I admitted. I looked up at her and smiled broadly, “but I’m happy too. It’s hard to explain. Honestly though, I don’t get why you’re so chill about all this.”

Applejack chuckled softly, and cuddled me from behind.

“Well, cause ah reckon you’ll need a mare who can herd this herd o’ crazy,” she said softly, “and ah reckon ah’ll be a good fit fer the job.”

“Hmph, everyone underestimates the farm pony’s cunning,” I responded, pulling her down into the bath. She pulled off her overalls, and calmly set her hat down on a table nearby. She then tied up her blonde hair in a red handkerchief, with white polkadots.

Honestly, it made her look hotter. And she probably knew it.

Sun kissed tanned skin, with freckles on her shoulders. Firm, round breasts, that I took in hand and began to kiss and suckle as she settled in my lap. Firm abs, which I gave attention to with my hands as she pressed her tits around my face. She kept her hands going though, rubbing my shoulders and chest. This gentle warmth rallied my cock, who stood at attention. A little TLC and I was raring to go again, too.

My hands kept going, grasping her round, firm bottom. I returned the favor, massaging her ass. She moaned appreciatively, but the wonderful scent of her arousal and her sighs indicated her impatience.

Her puffy pussy lips were wet and glistening. I looked up at her coyly, and a pleasant blush fell on her cheeks.

“How long were you watching~?” I asked.

“Long enough,” Applejack chuckled, still rubbing my shoulders, “now relax… Lemme handle this~.”

She sucked in a deep breath and slid her pussy down onto my cock. She may have been human right now, but apparently she retained her equine vaginal control because her muscles squeezed me. I let out a soft gasp as she took me in, slowly, her muscles massaging around my dick.

Applejack bit her lower lip, and embraced me tightly. Her breasts were crushed against my chest, and I hugged her back. I looked up and pulled her into a kiss, as we sat together, connected.

Her pussy fluttered around me, and she stifled a soft cry against my lips as she came. I cupped her cheek as I deepened the kiss, and she moaned again as she smothered me in her embrace.

“Hnnn…”

We just sat like that for a while, basking in eachother’s warmth and the heat of the bath. We explored each other gently, fingers trailing over each other’s bodies. It was deeply relaxing. Not worse than the frantic sex I’d been experiencing up to this point, but different. And very nice.

We began to move slowly. Applejack’s strong, gorgeous legs pushed her up, and she lowered herself down, driving me in deeply. I pushed up with my hips, slipping harder up into her tight, welcoming sex. She would stop every now and again, and I’d eagerly suckle on her breasts or kiss and lick between them, as she reached down to fondle my balls or massage my thighs.

I got close to orgasm a few times, but Applejack seemed to sense it… And would slow down, or stop entirely. After the third time, I groaned in annoyance. She grinned softly, though her smugness was diminished by the red on her cheeks and the contractions around my cock.

“Haa… Haa… Say please~,” she crooned in my ear. I groaned again, and gripped her hips tightly.

“Seriously?” I growled. I rammed up into her, turning her grin into an open mouthed gasp.

“Uhn!” She managed another chuckle, though it was strained.

“Well… Yer gonna have a herd after this,” she murmured, “you up to it?”

“I think the gaping, cum filled pussies left in my wake speak for themselves,” I growled back, annoyed. I slapped her ass, and she gasped happily. She squeezed around me again.

“Ahn… But mine’s powerful empty right now,” she crooned softly, grinding her nipples against my bare chest, “ain’tcha gonna fix that~? Or do ya need a few more tries t’ take the hint~?”

Applejack was a tease. Goddamnit, she was a tease. I’d learned so much about everypony today.

I found strength in my legs, and lifted her up in my arms, most of her weight settling on my cock. She gasped happily, wrapping her arms around my shoulders. I pushed her right up, and slammed her back down with a meaty, wet slap. My balance wasn’t perfect, but it was enough to keep us upright as I proceeded to slam fuck her up and down. I bent my knees to keep us stable, and to thrust up harder into her slick tightness.

“UWAH! AHH! AHHN! AHNN! AHNN!” Applejack cried, her breasts bouncing into my face as I rammed her up and down. Her hair stayed up in her handkerchief, but was all over her sweaty face. I grit my teeth, and had a sudden, feral and stupid idea as I spied her hat on the side table.

I paused, letting her tremble against me. I reached out, seized her hat, and put it on my head. She gasped in shock, eyes narrowing in challenge.

“You… Cain’t… Have that… Without… Earnin’ it…!” She gasped out.

I found a grin on my face as I pushed her onto her back in the tub, braced against the other rim. I held up her hips and she thrust them forward as I pounded her against the metal. The tub groaned with each thrust, as Applejack held on for dear life.

Applejack was a pony strong enough to knock a house down with a kick, but in my arms, she felt as weak and delicate as a flower. And by her cries, she knew it too… And enjoyed it.

“Yes yes yessss~! AHHHN!” She cried, another orgasm blasting through her. I gave it my all in a last ditch effort to bust my nut. Again. Like I had with so many other mares today.

Yet… Our closeness gave me reason to slow down a bit. I held her more tenderly, and nuzzled her neck. She looked at me in some confusion, as I slowed my thrusts.

“You… You ain’t gonna tease me back, are ya?” She asked.

“Nah,” I murmured, “just something to say...”

“Wha…?” Applejack asked.

I put my lips on her ear and whispered:

“I want you to have my foal.”

Applejack’s face turned an even darker red. She let out a soft gasp as I shifted up deeper inside her, and fluid squirted around my cock buried in her pussy. I rolled my hips and pounded away, still hard, but not as frantic.

She wrapped her strong legs around me and kissed my neck with a soft, feminine coo… Which was it for me, as I groaned her name and let loose my seed. The magic must have been working overtime, as it felt bigger than the other loads I’d shot into and onto several mares-turned-girls that day.

Applejack held me tightly, panting quietly as she planted happy kisses all over my throat. I kissed her back just as warmly,

“Haaa…” She sighed happily, “that.. That was… Wow…”

“Mmm,” I murmured, kissing her ear, “yeah… You’re not the only one.. With soft power…”

As comfortable as we were, I guess she couldn’t avoid some of her natural competitiveness. Which was fine: It was something I really liked about her.

Applejack chuckled as we lounged in the cooling bath. She cuddled with me, and reached down to give my cock some gentle strokes.

“Yeah… Though ah’d promised that to Fluttershy,” she murmured back. “First foal.”

“Ugh… You guys… Planned this?” I muttered. Applejack chuckled and kissed my cheek.

“We planned around you, sugarcube.”

She went down on me, and I moaned and tangled my hands in her hair and along her sleek back as she blew me expertly. I came again in her mouth in almost no time, and she swallowed it all. She cleaned me up with her tongue, and grinned up at me with some of my cum on her tongue.

Which she then swallowed, with a wink.

My dick shot back up to full strength, and I had her again. This time, pounding her tight little pussy from behind as she neighed like a mare in heat. After I came in her, I fucked her face for a while before letting her ride me like a cowgirl. Then another position, and then another.

It wasn’t the same savage primal heat as fucking the Pie sisters or plowing Fluttershy and Dash, but it was just as intimate and deep.

And rather than draining me, it seemed to rejuvenate my body, mind and spirit. I cuddled with her on some hay, as the bath had long since gone cold, as she murmured sweet nothings into my ears and cuddled back.

“Hey,” said a familiar voice. I looked up, eyes widening.

It was Twilight Sparkle all right. She looked drop dead gorgeous in human form-High, proud breasts with barely any sag, wide hips, perfectly trimmed pubic hair, and a gentle, warm face. Her wings were spread behind her as she walked up to me, a sway in those hips. Her skin was light purpose and smooth, a beautiful contrast with her dark purple and pink hair.

“... And where the hell have you been all day?” I demanded, without any rancor. I was even smiling back. Twilight leaned over and rested a hand on my chest.

“There were a lot of participants for ‘Be a Human Day’, and I had to tend to them all,” she said. She then blushed, “that and I wanted to see how you did.”

“Naughty, nerdy voyeur,” I accused, “I knew it. You perverted mad scientist.”

Twilight giggled, and laid down next to me. I wrapped an arm around her waist, and pulled her close.

“Guilty as charged,” she admitted. “Princess Celestia wasn’t very pleased with me. Even though I thought I was being very generous.”

“Well, tell her I will happily punish you,” I growled, grabbing a handful of her thick ass to make her squeal, “and I’ll do it over and over, as many times as it takes.”

“Mmm,” Twilight sighed, and nuzzled me back. She then sighed, and stood up. I looked up at her in confusion. She looked contrite, though she blushed hard.

“Well, about that,” she said, tapping her fingers together, “since I’ve been, um… Watching you all day, uh, for science-”

“Of course,” I deadpanned.

“Princess Celestia and Luna demand that I observe one last… Session involving you, before I get any relief,” she said. She bowed her head. “Sorry for that, by the way.”

“You’re forgiven,” I said. I nuzzled Applejack once more, as she fell asleep. I stood up, and Twilight magicked up a blanket to cover her with. “So… Who do I do as part of your punishment?”

Her eyes and horn flashed with light, and we reappeared back in her castle. This time, in her bedroom. Two regal, tall, and beautiful women with horns and wings sat on the large bed. One had long, aurora-like hair, tanned skin, and kind eyes with white feathers. The other was pale, with midnight sky-like hair, and hungry eyes with dark blue feathers.

Princess Celestia and Princess Luna.

“It is good to see you again, Ser Shepherd,” Luna said, blushing hard, “we have been waiting.”

“It’s good for Twilight to expand the boundaries of knowledge, but she should do it in a more responsible way,” Celestia added, “after all,” and here her eyes flashed with sensual mischief, “this day has been quite a trial for you, has it not? Perhaps you would appreciate some aid.”

I nodded very slowly. True, at the start of this day I was annoyed and worried. And disgusted. But now, I was much more mellow and forgiving.

And hey: When you get laid this much, you learn to go with the flow if it leads to more sexy times.

“I agree, Your Majesties,” I said. “Shall we begin?”

Author's Note

Took us a while, and I got a lot of help from friends, but... We're back in business!