Thirty One Nights Of Nightmare Night!

The train cart rattled from side to side as it traveled along the tracks at high speed. Near the back of the train was a single locked compartment in which a small filly was tied up with her hooves behind her back and a gag in her mouth, preventing her from making any cries for help. She watched as the Crystal Guard pony stood over her with his thick cock dripping precum as he poked it at her defenseless cunny. She wiggled at it’s touch, she was so wet from his preparation for this moment.

“A slut like you deserves this! All the horrible things you’ve done. I’m going to enjoy making you my whore, Cozy Glow.”

The pink filly with the arctic blue coiled mane made a noise that was indistinguishable through the gag, her eyes constantly on his stallionhood as it pressed against her underaged slit. Then without another word, he plunged deep inside her, making the filly tilt her head back in recoil. He started pounding away into her hard, again and again, holding nothing back, quickly reaching her cervix to pound at the entrance to her womb. She shrieked, squealed and moaned as he roughly used her, treating her as nothing but a fuck toy, grabbing her hips and spreading her wide, punishing her for her crimes. This is what she deserved, to be nothing more than a cock sock, a stress relief station for the rest of her days!

Cozy could feel her insides churning, her cunny aflame. She knew this feeling well, she was seconds away from that release. She looked up at the guard, his face alight with pleasure from ravishing a helpless filly when suddenly there was a click from the door and it was pulled open.

“Oh, for the love of… COZY!”

Princess Flurry Heart stood at the doorway looking at the guard who was almost balls deep into the filly as she’d walked in. The Crystal Guard immediately pulled out of Cozy Glow and then stood at attention. The young Princess didn’t even look at him, knowing full well that his erection would be dripping with both of his and the small pegasus’ fluids. She made a noise of disgust before addressing the gagged filly.

“What have I told you about doing this? It’s naughty!”

Cozy rolled her eyes and then removed a hoof from the ropes behind her back and then pulled out her gag.

“Geez, you can be such a buzzkill, you know that? Can’t you wait like another minute? I was so close… Unless you want to watch?” She said with a smirk.

“Eww, no!” Flurry said, disgusted. “Come on, mom is waiting for us up the front of the train.”

“Hmph, Fine.” The pegasus flew over to the guard and in her sweetest voice said, “Same time next week, Jarhead?” He gave a slight smile and then returned to standing at attention, with the Princess still in the room, praying she wouldn’t tell her mother about this. “And also next time…” Cozy’s sweet voice changed to a more annoyed tone. “Make sure the ropes are tight!”

She then slammed the rope to the floor and then walked out the carriage with Flurry, who still looked annoyed as she shut the door. The two of them walked side by side down the Crystal Express, with Cozy being just slightly taller than the Alicorn filly. While the princess was only six, she was almost the size of a filly twice her age. Cozy suspected purebred Alicorn’s grew faster than regular foals.

“I can’t believe you’re doing stuff like that.” Flurry said, upset.

“What? Having sex? I told you, It feels great!”

“But it’s so weird. You should be learning about love! That’s not love.”

“Golly, I dunno about that.” Cozy said with a smirk, switching back to her sweet voice. “I used to love controlling ponies and manipulating them into doing what I wanted with friendship and overpowering them, but after being imprisoned in a small cage in Tartarus and then in stone, I really learned that what I love is having ponies overpower me! Heehee!”

“But you’re still manipulating them to do that!” She yelled, causing the pegasus filly to look away annoyed. “Cozy, please. I begged mom and dad so hard to let you stay with us! I thought that maybe having a family who’d be there for you might help. I thought… I thought you having somepony you could call a sister might be good for you. Can’t you please just try and be a good filly?”

One Year Ago

Flurry Heart, Cadence and Shining Armor were walking through the Canterlot gardens, looking at all the statues. They had seen famous ponies, heroes, guards who’d given their lives in the field of duty, and now, they were all standing before a statue near the back, a statue with three of Equestria’s greatest villains. Tirek, Chrysalis and Cozy Glow. The tiny princess looked up at the pegasus filly who was encased in stone, the horrified look was scary.

“How was she a bad pony? She’s just a filly, like me.”

“She’s not like you at all.” Shining Armor said. “She brought Equestria to the brink of devastation when she tried to erase all magic. If the Princesses lost the power to move the sun and moon, Equestria would have frozen through an eternal night. Many of our cities and businesses would have shut down, earth ponies would lose their connection to the farms and would have devastated crops. Pegasi would no longer control the weather. It would have ruined civilization as we know it.”

“It’s true dear,” Cadence said in agreement. ”She also went and teamed up with Tirek and The Changeling Queen to overthrow Equestria. The same changeling who imprisoned me and brainwashed your father. With their combined power they were almost unstoppable. This was the only way we could safely protect our world.”

Flurry looked up at the stone filly again.

“But… she’s still just a filly. And she’s so scared. What about her mommy and daddy?”

“All… all records showed she had no family. She just appeared out of nowhere one day. She’d been faking signatures for years.” Cadence said, sounding a little sad.

“Well, I think she’d say sorry if she just had a family who loved her. You’re the princess of love mommy! You can teach her, can’t you?”

“Ohh Flurry. You’ve got such a sweet heart, but it’s not that simple.”

“But why not?”

“Because she’s evil.” Shining armor interrupted. “She was a traitor to our kind and she even tried to hurt your aunt. She doesn’t have a heart worth saving. Come, let’s go-”

“But that’s mean!” Flurry interrupted. “You don’t know! She could just need love, you taught me that love c… con-cures all.”

“Flurry…” He tried to reason with her but she wasn’t having it.

“I think I could help her! Foals shouldn’t be statues! They shouldn’t! Tell Auntie Twilight to let her be a foal again!”

“Flurry, that’s enough!” Her father said, raising his voice. “She’ll never be set free, it’ll free the other two aswell and they’d destroy Equestria. Is that what you want?!” He shouted.

“Shining!” Cadence cautioned her husband. But it was too late, Flurry Heart began to cry and in a spark of magic, the young filly disappeared with a pop, teleporting away.

“FLURRY!” They both cried out. But she didn’t hear them. The tiny Alicorn wanted to be away from them both and was just so upset. Tears were running down her cheeks at this point.

“It’s not fair, how could they do that to a filly? It’s not right!” She spoke aloud to herself.

The young princess had seemingly teleported herself into the middle of the Canterlot maze. The green hedges stood tall all around her, a few potted trees and flowers around the area and two benches were right in the middle, back to back. Flurry sat down and wiped her tears.

“It’s not fair.”

“Life never is.” A voice spoke from behind her. Flurry jumped and spun around.

On the bench behind her was a pony wearing a dark cowl, hiding their entire body. Flurry was positive they weren’t there a moment ago.

“W-w-who are you?!”

The stranger didn’t respond right away, instead they looked to the sky and she could see a grey mussel poking out from the hood.

“I am… a seeker of balance. I heard your cries and I do agree, it’s cruel what happened to the young filly called Cozy Glow.”

“Y-you think so too? Well… maybe we can talk to my Auntie together! Make her see right!”

“No…” The stranger said, who sounded like a mare. She lowered her head again. “Cozy Glow would never be accepted back after all she’s done, nor would she want to in her current state. But… I believe that you, little one, could be just the one to save her.”

“Really?” Flurry asked. “But what about-”

“Your parents will never love her as you do. They are hurt and struggle with forgiveness. You… are the only one who’ll be able to have her see the right way.”

Flurry was confused. Who was this pony? How’d they know so much?”

“All will be answered in time, Princess Flurry Heart.” The mare responded, startling the filly. “But right now, I have a preposition for you.”

“A what?” She asked, confused at the word proposition.

“A deal.” The mare said with a laugh. I can free Cozy Glow, and only Cozy Glow. If you are willing to make a sacrifice. Magic comes at a cost. At least, Dark magic does.”

The figure stood up and turned to face the filly, their face was still shrouded in darkness. Only the grey mussel being visible.

“I… What deal? I don’t have any of my toys with me!”

“Toys?” The stranger chuckled. “No, I require something else. Something only you can give me. And with it, I shall free the pony in stone.”

“What… do you want?” She asked nervously.

“Just one thing... Your innocence.”

Now Flurry was really confused.

“My innocence?”

“In another term, I require that which is defined as the moment of losing your innocence, or if you’d prefer, the blood of your lost virginity.”

“Blood?!” Flurry was now scared. This pony was going to hurt her!

“The blood of a filly when they lose their virginity is also that of losing your innocence. You’ll understand one day, I’m sure. It’s a mark of going from a filly to a mare. With the loss of your innocence, you might save another’s. So… Would you give up your innocence to save another pony who lost theirs?”

Flurry didn’t understand. What was this mare talking about? Her Virginity? Innocence? This was confusing. But she did understand that this would set Cozy free.

“Flurry!” A voice called from above. Flurry Heart looked up and saw her mother above, floating in the sky as she looked over the maze.

“If you call out to your mother now, the deal is off, young Princess.” The stranger said darkly.

The small Alicorn looked from her mother to the cloaked figure and then back again, she was in plain sight, why hadn’t her mother seen her? Wait, this stranger mentioned they can do magic.

“She can’t see us, can she?”

“Very astute.”

Flurry rounded on the mare with her, she was frustrated now.

“Hey! Stop using big words I don’t understand.”

“Forgive me.” She said sincerely. “So, do we have a deal?”

Flurry watched as her mother began to fly away and then turned to agree. She wanted to save Cozy and this mare said that Flurry was the only one who could, and she believed her. The stranger smiled and then flung her cowl in a circle around her. Suddenly the maze that was in daylight was now in darkness. The two benches were replaced with a cauldron. And the mare’s face was finally revealed. She was a Zebra. Her teeth were yellow and crooked, her left eye was all white with a grey pupil while the other was a normal yellow iris and black pupil. She was very scary looking, like the evil witches Flurry had read about in her story books. The cauldron only accented the fact, especially when it filled with a green ooze that bubbled.

Flurry turned to run at the sight of this mare, only to discover there was no longer an exit.

“Don’t be scared filly. I know my appearance might be frightening to you foals, but we had a deal, remember? Now, why don’t you come here, you might learn a thing or two about magic. I promise I won’t bite.” She said with a terrifying grin. “Come now, Magic’s not all unicorn horns and rainbow lasers, you know. Look deep into my pot. Tell me, what do you see?”

Flurry dared not move, and yet somehow found herself walking, almost against her will, and then flying up to look down into the cauldron. The green ooze bubbled and popped as wisps of green smoke traveled around her.

“I… don’t see anything.” She answered, a little confused.

“That’s fine, Princess, it’ll change soon. After you’ve provided your side of the bargain.”

Flurry gulped in worry and the witch threw her hooves in a circular motion. The smoke became solid and gooey and then grabbed Flurry around each of her limbs. She screamed and panicked as she started flailing and fighting, trying to get free as she was lifted and held over the cauldron. Was it going to pull her in there?

“Fear not, child. This is but part of the process. And don’t bother to use your magic, you’ll find it doesn’t work here.”

At that moment, Flurry realised she was right. She was powerless and being held against her will. She started to cry, scared for her life.

“Why are you crying? You wanted this, didn’t you?” She said with a hint of humor.

“Please let me g-go. I’m scared! I want my mommy!”

“Dear thing. Very well, I’ll get this over with fast. Just remember who you’re doing this for. A filly who was deemed a monster. A monster that you wish to save. Has that changed?”

Flurry sniffled again as she looked down. There was another smoke tentacle heading up between her legs that was turning solid. All her legs felt like they were wrapped in a slimy goo. It felt horrible. Was this really worth it? To save a bad filly she didn’t know?

“C-c-can she… really be good?” Flurry asked.

“If you’re willing to make a great sacrifice for her, you will save her soul.”

Flurry looked to the Zebra, who she just met, terrifying, old. A witch in every sense of the word that she’d describe one as. Yet she hesitated and then without another word, she nodded. The fifth tentacle then rose out of the pot and then aimed directly for her tiny cunny. Untouched and just a gentle shade of pink. The mare waved her hooves like a conductor, directing it towards it’s target. And then, it pushed into her. It was mostly an all thick goo like thing, but it still caused Flurry to let out a short scream as it stretched her, filling her tight little honey pot, causing the small alicorn worse pain than she ever felt before.

“Breathe, little one, and it’ll make the pain fade soon. We’re almost done.”

The thing pushed into her more and then she felt something tear inside her, bringing another scream from her. The tentacle inside her pussy began to pulse, making Flurry feel like it was sucking up everything from her insides and soon enough, the green tendril turned pink, going from the tip, all the way down to the cauldron, turning all the ooze inside the same colour. The now pink tentacle was wiggling inside her, sucking against her torn hymen, absorbing all the blood it could, rotating and rotation, squeezing out all that it could, making the filly feel really weird.

“Lost innocence is the purest ingredient in dark magic, and these days it’s almost impossible to find one willing to give it. Your pain will end momentarily Flurry Heart. When you next wake up, you’ll be in front of the statue you seek, and when you gaze upon it, you’ll free the pony you seek to save.”

Flurry closed her tear filled eyes as her hips started bucking against the thing inside her, trying to get it out, but it just pulsed harder inside her, making her yelp as if it hit a nerve inside her. She’d never felt so weird. It was so horrible for her and she never wanted anything to ever touch her there again! The zebra walked over to the black pot and scooped up the potion into a glass jar. The potion then turned white as she sealed it with a cork, then the mare waved her hoof again, walking away from the crying filly..

With that, the tentacles faded and Flurry was let go. She wasn’t ready to be dropped so abruptly and as she fell she saw she was about to land in the caudron, but it too faded and instead of hitting the floor, she fell into a deeper darkness. She screamed, calling for help, only to hear the zebra witch’s voice from all around her.

“If you’re willing to make a sacrifice for her, you will save her soul.”

And then as she faded to darkness, she immediately felt the ground beneath her. Flurry opened her eyes and grasped at the ground with her hooves, holding the grass for dear life. But there was no need. She was back in the canterlot gardens, safe on the ground in the sunny afternoon. She looked around, but the witch was nowhere to be seen. She remembered it all so clearly. She touched a hoof between her legs. Nothing. No pain, no blood, no ooze. Was it just a dream?

She then looked up and saw the statue of the Villains of Equestria, and Cozy Glow’s was cracking apart.

Present day

“You really think I can be a good filly?” Cozy said, sounding unconvinced. “Your father doesn’t trust me, Equestria hates me, what could I possibly do to change their opinions of me when they are all right?” She sounded hurt and angry.

Cozy had done so much wrong in her past that Flurry had a difficult time convincing her parents (after they saw a barely conscious Cozy had been broken free from her prison) to not immediately call for the guards to arrest her! Eventually Twilight arrived, sensing the magic shift from the garden and even her Aunt wasn’t convinced that Cozy could be redeemed. But Flurry reminded them all that they said the same for Discord. All he needed was a friend. Flurry was convinced that all Cozy needed was a loving family.

They eventually gave in and decided to try Flurry’s hopeful plan, and while Cadence had given her all to accept and love Cozy like her own, her husband wasn’t quite as forgiving. Not for a lack of trying, but the pegasus was always acting out and getting into trouble, seemingly on purpose. Thankfully for Flurry, he didn’t know that the pink filly had been having sex with random stallions in the Crystal Empire. For some reason she loved rough sex. Getting smacked on the flank, being tied down, getting choked. Flurry was horrified the first time she’d seen it, but now it was becoming a regular occurrence. It was like Cozy wanted to be caught.

“Please.” Flurry said, trying to reason with her. “I just want you to get better and be a better pony. I know you can do it, you’ve just got to stop provoking ponies.”

“You mean, stop being myself?”

Flurry hated to hear that, it sounded so cruel.

“No, just… stop doing naughty things. Can’t you try? For me? Please!”

Cozy Glow sighed and then put on her chipper innocent voice.

“Don’t worry Flurry! I’ll be a good big sister that you can look up to and then we’ll go get matching dresses made together so ponies know just how good we are!”

“Please don’t do the voice.” Flurry said, rolling her eyes. “It makes you sound ditin- disin…”

“Disingenuous?” She said for her, still in the fake sweet voice.

They had reached and walked into the front compartment where Cadance was waiting for the pair.

“Oh girls, there you are. I was about to send a search party.” Cadence laughed casually and then turned to the window. “Well, you’re just in time. Grab your bags. Ponyville is right ahead.”