Prologue: Meeting the Sisters
It had only been several days since Sugar Belle, her darling Night Glider, and the rest of the village’s residents had been freed and allowed their cutie marks once more. The first act that Sugar Belle had done was pin down the starry blue pegasus and scissor their marehoods together whilst locking their lips in a moment that the two would never forget. Moments after crashing into their bed and catching their breath, Sugar Belle leaped off the bed and started babbling about her four sisters back at Sire’s Hollow. Night Glider nodded as she listened, remembering how Starlight came to Sugar Belle one day, promising of a village where everypony was treated equally. Night Glider scoffed, the two-timing unicorn pulled that schtick at Cloudsdale too, and had fooled her and several others. Then, as she took in her marefriend’s bright eyes and poofy mane as she spoke, Night Glider’s body relaxed. Manipulated or not, the events still lead Sugar Belle and Night Glider to each other. That was the only truth that Night Glider could thank Starlight for, if she was still around.
“We have to go see my sisters! You’re going to love them!” Sugar Belle insisted, jumping back onto the bed and placing her hooves over Night Glider’s shoulders. Night Glider placed a hoof over her marefriend’s poofy mane, slowly moving it down her mane as she smiled at her and nodded. A break from the village, and meeting Sugar Belle’s family? How could the pegasus say no?
So only days later, Night Glider found herself staring at the window on the train seat with Sugar Belle dozing away against her shoulder. The sleeping unicorn held their one suitcase against her chest, and Night Glider stared at each mountain they passed by. There was little for the dark blue pegasus to go off on, besides Sugar Belle’s promises of a smoothie shack that’d blow her mind. What was there to know about her marefriend’s sisters? She’d have to wait until Sugar Belle woke up, so her heart started beating fast. What if they didn’t like her? Did they even know that Sugar Belle liked mares?
Night Glider shook her head, and took several deep breaths. She would be the best mare she could be in front of these sisters, and that had to be enough. Sneaking a wing behind Sugar Belle’s back, Night Glider wrapped it around her marefriend as she leaned against Sugar Belle’s head and closed her eyes...
Only a few hours later, Night Glider flew after her marefriend as she galloped into Sire’s Hollow, the magic around her horn taking their luggage with her. Glider barely had time to take in the sights and ponies around them as she never took her eyes off the dashing unicorn. Towards the end of Sire’s Hollow resided a tall house that could be three stories tall, and had flowers of many colors growing on either side of the stairs leading to the porch and front door. Sugar Belle bolted up the stairs, resting the luggage next to her as her hoof flew to the doorbell. Night Glider felt a cold jolt run throughout her body at the sound of the doorbell. She took a deep breath, only to be cut off by the sound of stampeding hooves. The door swung open just as Night Glider attempted a mental rundown of her words, and all of those words were thrown out the window as Night Glider took in the four ponies at the other side of the door.
Four mares that shared the same physique and poofy mane as her marefriend, only of varying fur colors. A light orange mare with a dark orange mane and eyes was the first one to lunge for Sugar Belle in what Night Glider could only imagine as a soul-squeezing hug, with a light grey mare with a dark grey mane and eyes hugging Sugar Belle and their orange sister shortly after. A baby blue mare with a navy blue mane and a lime green mare with a forest green mane joined in the group hug, grinning as Sugar Belle looked at her four sisters.
“So, I take it you received my letter?” Sugar joked, causing the four sisters to chuckle. Night Glider kept her hooves firmly planted against the floor, waiting for the right moment. Sure enough, ten pairs of eyes landed on her as the orange mare waved her forward. Night Glider jumped off the ground, flying over and wrapping her forelegs around the five mares.
“This is my marefriend, Night Glider,” Sugar explained. “Night Glider, this is Cheddar Belle, Pigeon Belle, Blueberry Belle, and Limey Belle. Don’t worry, their fur should be clue enough to which one is which.”
“Is Belle a last name?” Glider asked.
“Sure is!” Cheddar glanced up at the pegasus with a wide grin. “It comes from our mother, Southern Belle. Instead of taking the second half of our Dad’s name, Mom thought it was a good idea to give all her daughters the second half of her own. And she gave birth to five Belles!”
“Is Southern Belle here?” Night Glider asked, her heart quickening at the thought of meeting the mother.
“Oh no, her and Dad have been travelling Equestria,” Blueberry replied. “They’ve been sending us postcards and souvenirs on and off for the past three years, I’m pretty sure they’re in Las Pegasus right now!”
“Haven’t they been there for the past three months now?” Limey snickered. “Y’know, what happens in Las Pegasus…”
Limey glanced at Night Glider with a smirk and half-lidded eyes, and Night Glider felt a hot jolt throughout her body from the bottoms of her hooves to the tips of her wings. Glancing away from the green mare, Night Glider felt her heart thumping against her chest as she tried to force anything to come out of her mouth to pierce through the silence.
“Shall we go in?” Cheddar broke away from the hug, walking inside before her sisters could respond. Only, the walk was slow, and the sisters turned their heads to look as Cheddar’s tail flicked to the side to reveal a glistening snatch the shade of her name. Night Glider’s mouth gaped open, before closing not a second later as she glanced down at Sugar Belle. The pegasus did a double take as she thought she saw a glint of saliva around Sugar Belle’s lips.
I think I’m just a little pent up after the train ride, a little romp with Sugar later should relieve the tension. Right?
Cheddar picked up the pace in her walk, opening the fridge and leaving Night Glider to wonder if she really was reading into their introduction earlier. The other four Belles pulled out their chairs at the wide dark brown table, sitting down in their seats as Cheddar set out a bowl of guacamole and chips at the center of the table. Noticing the three empty chairs, Night Glider pulled the one closest to her marefriend and sat down. Blueberry reached over for a white baseball cap, placing it atop her head as Limey grinned and snuggled against her sister as close as she could in her own chair.
Night glanced and tilted her head at the foreign green goop in the bowl, waiting until she saw her marefriend take one of the chips and dip it in the green texture, eating the chip in one bite.
“That’s guac,” Blueberry spoke up, causing Night Glider to make eye contact with the other blue mare. “Dad makes dishes like those and tacos from his hometown, the two dishes together is fuckin’ bomb.”
“And Mommakes dishes like fried tomatoes and red beans,” Limey pointed out, closing her eyes and licking her lips.
“Course, Sugar wanted to divert with her own style,” Cheddar added as she closed the fridge, walking towards her pink sister. “Now that you’re back, will we be seeing those sugary sweets again?”
“Of course, I know how much y’all love my cherry pie~” Sugar grinned, her tail moving from her chair to brush up against Night Glider’s back. Glider’s wings sprung up from her sides as she barely covered her mouth with her hoof. Cheddar, Blueberry, and Limey sported grins of a clowder of cats that ate canaries. Then, she glanced at Pigeon Belle at the end of the table, a small smile creeping upon her face.
“Oh, you should know that Pigeon has plenty thoughts of her own,” Cheddar explained. “But the doctor diagnosed her as a mute when she was a foal. She can laugh and shriek sometimes, but not a single word comes out of her mouth.”
Pigeon nodded, giving a wider smile and waving at Night Glider. Somehow that gesture made Night Glider blush more heavily than the other sisters’ could. What was that mare hiding behind that smile?
“So…” Night Glider glanced away from Pigeon. “Did all of you know about Sugar being into mares?”
The silence took over the table as Night Glider gulped as quietly as she could, tucking her wings back against her sides as the mares were wide-eyed for two seconds before breaking out into thunderous laughter.
“Oh darling,” Cheddar cackled. “She didn’t tell you?”
“We’d have to be dumb as doorknobs not to notice that,” Blueberry snickered.
“And it’d be very hypocritical of us to disapprove of such a thing,” Limey winked.
Night Glider stared down at the table as she heard Pigeon pounding her hoof against the table as she wheezed and shook with every laugh, their words processing in Glider’s head.
Were they all…? What, all five of them??
“Uh oh, I think we broke her,” Limey giggled. “I mean, I might be the only one of us that’s dated stallions.”
“Dated stallions,” Blueberry teased. “Y’mean banged every creature that walks?”
“You take that back!” Limey howled with a twinkle in her eyes, grinning as she stared down her sister.
“Or what?” Blueberry’s grin revealed itself, resembling more of a wolfish smile.
Limey blushed, glancing at Night Glider and returning her gaze to Blueberry. Cheddar smirked as she glanced at the two of them, before looking at Night Glider and Sugar Belle.
“So,” Cheddar said. “What do y’all want for dinner tonight?”
Night Glider flew into Sugar’s old bedroom, with pastel colors and posters of famous bakers, rubbing her belly full of fried tomatoes. How she lived in Cloudsdale without ever tasting the delicacies, she’ll never know.
She landed on Sugar’s poofy lavender bed as her marefriend climbed in, using her magic to tuck both of them into the covers. Sugar leaned over, her hoof running down Night Glider’s face as she stared into her eyes.
“So what do you think of them?” Sugar asked.
“They seem lovely, and themselves,” Glider replied. “What more could you want in a family?”
“Hmm, couldn’t agree more~” Sugar nodded, closing her eyes. “We’re very close, I hope that doesn’t intimidate you?”
“Oh, of course not,” Glider mentally scolded the heat that ran through her body for the millionth time that day. “Just more to love about my marefriend, right?”
Sugar’s bright eyes opened as she lunged forward and pressed her lips against Night Glider’s, the kiss lasting for a few seconds before she pulled away and cozied up on her side of the bed. Closing her eyes once more, her hindleg brushed up against her marefriend’s hindleg in a gentle motion as she turned off the lights.
Night Glider felt her body give into Luna’s night, only to wake up an unknown amount of time later to the need to take a leak. Glancing at Sugar’s sleeping form, Night Glider leaned in and kissed the unicorn’s forehead before slipping out of the bed and slowly opening the door with her mouth.
“Nngh~”
Night Glider let go out the doorknob, freezing up at the sound.
“So you don’t fuck anycreature that breathes? Tell that to the stallions-”
“Fuck~”
“-the griffons-”
“Dammit, Blueberry!”
“-and that one Kirin I caught ya with~”
Night Glider stepped closer to the slightly opened door without thinking about it, leaning forward as she witnessed Limey writhing on the floor with cheeks as bright as tomatoes and mouth gaping wide open, Blueberry towering over her as at least a third of her foreleg was deep into the green unicorn’s pussy.
“Hell, I bet you were planning at having a go at the new mare before the rest of us,” Blueberry growled as she leaned her face closer to her sister’s face. “Tell me I’m wrong~”
“Ohhh fuck you!” Limey hissed, and Night Glider gasped as Blueberry smacked her sister with a casual swing of her hoof. Limey squeaked, shaking around Blueberry’s pounding hoof as she bit down on her own hoof. Night Glider saw juices squirting around the blue unicorn’s hoof.
“Say it,” Blueberry ordered.
“I want to fuck her first!” Limey squealed, her shaking and squirting coming to a stop as her head collapsed on the carpet. Loud, careless gasps escaped Limey’s mouth as Blueberry lifted her soggy hoof to her own mouth. Her tongue swirling around the juices, Night Glider took several prolonged seconds to notice just which direction Blueberry’s dark purple eyes rested.
Right in her direction.
Night Glider jumped away from the door, leaping back into the bed and getting into the covers, burying her face deep into the bed itself. Several heart-thumping minutes passed before Night Glider got up, walked back to the cracked open door…
...and saw only a puddle of juices remaining in the hallway. Flying over the puddle, Night Glider flew into the bathroom, shutting the door and turning on the light.
Staring back into her wide-eyed, red-faced reflection, Night Glider then closed her eyes and let out a long groan as she covered her face with her hooves. Her wings remained out and erect while she cursed the burning heat between her legs.
What did I just get myself into?
Night Glider’s eyes flickered open, expecting to be staring back at the pink ray of sunshine next to her. But the bed was empty, with the door slightly opened. And within less than five seconds, Glider’s hooves gripped the sheets as she remembered staring at Blueberry and Limey through that exact cracked door. Glancing at the window to her left, the pegasus contemplated opening it and flying as far as her wings could take her.
But did she even want to?
Her only worry was if one of the sisters had come onto her, and Sugar Belle walked in, running away shortly after in tears. But then she remembered Sugar Belle staring after Cheddar, speaking of her cherry pie, and even going on about how close the five of them were. And Night Glider’s self-control was seeping out of her like the sand in an upright hourglass, given that she didn’t even tend to herself last night. If she just took one of the sisters and bent them over, sinking her teeth into their poofy mane, would the rest of them even think twice before cheering her on?
Stop it, it's not even breakfast time yet. Get a grip.
Night Glider growled under her breath, stretching her legs briefly before stepping off the bed and walking into the hallway. She could hear Cheddar babbling on about her foal-sitting business being in good hooves for the next few days as the rest of the sisters used their horns to levitate their toothbrushes to reach every angle of their teeth. Then, Night Glider noticed a certain grey pelt missing among the tooth-brushing unicorns.
Perhaps Pigeon isn’t an early bird. Heh, I crack myself up sometimes.
Night Glider smirked only for a few moments as she waved at the sisters and walked into the living room area, the smirk wiped off her face as she took in the maid dusting the coffee table. And her wings jumped from her sides once she noticed the grey poofy mane underneath the mobcap.
Pigeon.
Perhaps the rest of the sisters would walk in any moment, sparing Night Glider the moment where Pigeon Belle would make eye contact with her in an otherwise empty room. But Cheddar kept talking in the lengthy restroom as Pigeon Belle glanced upward, her long eyelashes and stormy grey eyes landed on Night Glider. The small smile on her face widened, before she stood up straight and mouthed “hi” with the brightness of a young filly. As Night Glider’s jaw dropped, the grey unicorn giggled as she turned around and dusted the emptied shelves, revealing her dark grey clit winking at her. Fucking winking.
Night Glider let out a sharp exhale, her thoughts sizzling out as she stomped over to the mare. Pigeon dropped the duster, smiling for a brief moment before she gasped. Night Glider’s hoof ran from the mute pony’s hindleg all the way to her clit, rubbing it in rapid circles. As the barest hint of a squeak escaped Pigeon’s mouth, Night Glider lunged and silenced her with a kiss, her tongue wriggling into the mare’s mouth.
Naughty bitch.
“I hope we’re not interrupting anything?”
Night Glider’s eyes shot wide open as her hoof landed back on the carpet, pulling away and staring at the four Belles staring back at her. Cheddar and Blueberry were smirking, Limey was scowling, and Sugar Belle? Well, she looked like a filly in a candy shop.
“Pigeon got to her first?” Limey huffed, looking away from the scene.
“Can you blame Night Glider?” Blueberry pointed her hoof towards Glider and Pigeon. “Everytime we walk around town, we have to keep Pigeon in the middle so her suitors don’t overwhelm her all at once.”
“I tell you, it’s that front she puts up,” Cheddar snickered. “Acts like an innocent filly, and every creature is putty in her hooves.”
Pigeon glanced at Night Glider and winked, and Night Glider blushed as she looked at Sugar Belle’s bright grin.
“Every mare before you ran away once I introduced them to my sisters,” Sugar admitted. “One even called me a freak, and...I’m sorry, this means a lot to me.”
“Don’t get all sappy cause your mare is making out with your sister!” Blueberry laughed. “Besides, sappy is the last feeling going through my body right now~”
Blueberry knocked Limey to the ground, the green mare letting out a squeak as she rolled onto her back. Blueberry lunged for her sister, yanking her face against her own in a tight lip-lock as muffled moans and squeaks escaped their mouths. Sugar glanced at Cheddar, stepping closer to her and resting her hoof against her sister’s cheek as she kissed her gently. The gentleness gave way as they pushed their bodies against each other’s, loud moans escaping as their tongues wrestled one another.
Night Glider felt her pussy getting wetter by the second, and glanced at Pigeon, who was blushing as her mouth slightly hung open. Night Glider turned around, resting her ass on the empty coffee table as she spread her legs. As Pigeon Belle stared right at the pegasus’ dark blue pussy, Night Glider waved her hoof in a “come hither” motion.
“Come take care of me, maid,” Night Glider ordered. As soon as Pigeon Belle came close enough, Night Glider sunk her hooves into the unicorn’s mane and shoved her face into her pussy. Pigeon squeaked against Glider’s snatch, her teeth gently nibbling Glider’s clit before her tongue slid into the pegasus’ hole. Night Glider moaned at the varying sensations, bucking her hips further against Pigeon as she ate her out.
As Blueberry and Limey broke away from their makeout session, Limey glanced longingly at the coffee table.
“Oh fine,” Blueberry chuckled as she shook her head at her sister. “Should’ve known you couldn’t keep away from hot commodity for too long, go for it~”
Limey squealed, clapping her hooves briefly before she got up and made a beeline for the coffee table. Climbing over Night Glider, the pegasus had only a few moments to register the other sister’s presence before Limey lowered her dark green snatch onto her face. Pigeon glanced up at her sister, and grinned as she slipped away from Night Glider’s loosening grip, sitting on top of Night Glider’s legs as she pressed her hoof against Glider’s opening. As Pigeon leaned forward and kissed Limey, the hoof slowly entered Night Glider’s pussy.
“Mmph!” Night Glider bucked her hips as she gasped into Limey’s snatch. Limey smirked against Pigeon’s lips, her bubble butt cheeks wigging in the direction of her other three sisters as she rolled her pussy against Night Glider’s snout and quick tongue. Pigeon pushed even more of her foreleg into the pegasus’ snatch, bathing in the sympathy of muffled sounds of pleasure from beneath Limey. As she pulled away from the kiss and glanced behind Limey, she smiled and rolled her eyes as Blueberry walked towards Cheddar and Sugar with her signature nine-inch rainbow strap-on hanging between her legs. Cheddar and Sugar broke apart from their making out, staring at the surprise strap-on like moths to a flame.
“So how are you two going to decide this?” Blueberry winked. “I’m sure both of you are dying to be fucked like bitches in heat, so…”
“Sugar Belle’s the one with the marefriend,” Cheddar pointed out.
“She’s a little busy right now,” Sugar glanced as Pigeon and Limey used her marefriend like a toy, causing the pink unicorn’s snatch to become even more demanding for attention. “Besides, I can eat you out until it’s your turn.”
“We did cuck her quite a bit before she left with that unicorn,” Blueberry shrugged. “I say we put you in that place for a change.”
“So you’ve decided?” Cheddar stepped back, her wide eyes staring at them as her hoof travelled down to her clit. Sugar Belle turned her back to Blueberry, flicking her tail out of the way. “Oh you better fuck her good then, I want to get off to her screams~”
“Oh don’t worry, I won’t even have to warm her up by the looks of it,” Blueberry chuckled, noticing how her sister’s lips parted as the rainbow tip pressed against her sloppy wet hole. “C’mon you little slut, I wanna hear you beg for this cock.”
“Blueberry~” Sugar groaned, pressing her pussy against the tip. “It’s been way too long, that cock belongs in my pussy. Please, fuck me hard!”
Blueberry grinned as she lunged and sank her teeth in Sugar’s mane, pushing the strap-on’s tip inside Sugar Belle. Sugar let out a loud feminine gasp as Blueberry pushed inch after inch of the rainbow cock inside her sister, letting out her own moan as she felt the other end of the strap-on stimulating inside her own pussy. Sugar let out a sharp gasp as she felt her insides being filled and the tip hitting the spot that sent stars into her vision, the spot that caused her to moan and scream words out of her control. Cheddar bit her lip as her hoof teased the outside of her hole, moaning as the tip of her hoof entered her pussy.
Blueberry grunted as she pulled half of the rainbow strap-on out, before thrusting the rest back in, and repeating the same motion with a growl into Sugar’s ear. Hearing Sugar’s feminine moans and gasps, Night Glider sank her hooves into Limey’s flanks, her tongue flailing around as she felt her pussy tightening around Pigeon’s hoof.
“Yes, fuck me like you mean it!” Limey screamed, bucking her pussy further into Glider’s tongue.
Night Glider gave a loud moan into the green unicorn’s pussy as she felt the peak of her pleasure, juices squirting all over Pigeon’s hoof. Pigeon giggled, pulling her hoof out and licking it slowly. Night Glider couldn’t tell what the mute unicorn was saying with her gestures, but she snickered into Limey’s snatch as she heard the pony above her.
“Okay, okay! I’m almost done!” Limey protested, thrusting even harder against Night Glider’s face. “Hope you can handle her next~”
Night Glider responded with a nibble against Limey’s clit and a smack against her green jiggly ass. Limey shouted out a loud “fuck!” as her hindlegs started shaking around Night Glider’s face, and even though Limey didn’t squirt like the others, Night Glider understood what happened all the same. Limey groaned as she stumbled off the coffee table and crashed onto the couch. Pigeon got back on the coffee table, leaning forward and licking the juices off the pegasus’ cheeks for a few moments. Then, she turned around and began lowering her face closer and closer…
“Wait,” Glider spoke up. “Blueberry, do you have another one of those strap-ons?”
“Ch-cheddar, get her the other one,” Blueberry responded without skipping a beat, causing the orange mare to grunt and get up, walking towards one of the doors down the hallway. Staring into Pigeon’s wide eyes, Night Glider smirked.
“Seems only fitting to bend the maid over the coffee table, right?” Night Glider snickered as Pigeon’s eyes lit up. “Get into position~”
Both mares jumped off the coffee table as Pigeon rested her forehooves on the coffee table, spreading her hindlegs out and moving her tail out of the way. Cheddar trotted to Night Glider’s side, hooking up the black strap-on onto the pegasus. Cheddar stepped back, glancing at Limey catching her breath on the couch, before looking over as Night Glider trotted over to Pigeon Belle. Night Glider stood up, mounting the grey unicorn as she wasted no time pushing the black strap-on inside the frilly maid. Pigeon squealed, thrusting back against the strap-on as Night Glider pushed it even further in.
“YES!” Sugar howled, her eyes meeting her marefriend’s as Blueberry continued to mercilessly pound her. “Fuck the shit out of her!”
Night Glider grinned, pushing all of the seven-inch strap-on inside her marefriend’s sister. Pigeon gasped, followed by a long moan as the pegasus pulled the strap-on out, and slammed it back in. Cheddar climbed on top of the couch, staring at her panting sister.
“Please hoof me,” Cheddar moaned.
“What, hate to the one left out?” Limey snickered, slowly getting off the couch. “Spread your legs, you little slut~”
Cheddar squeaked, jumping onto the couch and spreading her legs wide open. Limey got back on the couch, pressing her lips against her sister as her hoof teased Cheddar’s clit. Limey closed her eyes as she felt her sister’s hindlegs flailing about, like a wild animal being restrained. She pushed her hoof inside of Cheddar, purring into her mouth as she heard the loud moans and gasps of her sisters around her.
“Fuck!” Sugar yowled, feeling herself cumming around Blueberry’s strap-on. Pigeon gave a loud feminine scream only moments later, followed by Night Glider’s grunts as the pegasus collapsed on top of her marefriend’s sister. As Night Glider and Pigeon Belle were both catching their breath on the coffee table, they glanced over at Limey furiously hoofing Cheddar on the couch while they were in a tight lip-lock. Blueberry got up, walking past Sugar Belle’s gasping body as she smirked down at Cheddar and Limey.
“Don’t suppose you’d want my cock now?” Blueberry chuckled, smiling and shaking her head as Cheddar and Limey gave no indication that the blue mare had said anything. “Celestia, Limey always keeps it going long after we’re all done. Don’t be surprised if she dresses up for a ‘night out’ later.”
Night Glider managed a small laugh, her hoof gently moving around Pigeon’s cheek. As Sugar Belle shakily got to her hooves, Night Glider met her eyes.
“Well, that happened,” Glider gave a lazy grin. “You were just going to drop me into it all, huh?”
“Sorry,” Sugar blushed. “I wanted you to know my sisters before you decided they were a bunch of freaks.”
“I suppose that’s understandable,” Glider admitted. “Maybe give me a warning next time though, I thought I was going crazy.”
“Don’t worry, I’ll let you know when we meet Mom next,” Sugar nodded, causing Glider’s heart to skip a beat.
“Oh?” Night Glider steadily pulled out of Pigeon, removing the strap-on from her lower half. “What is she like?”
“Well, a taller mare than the rest of us,” Blueberry explained as she removed her strap-on as well. “And a very colorful one as well.”
“Probably best we leave these two to it,” Sugar waved her hoof in Cheddar and Limey’s direction. “Smoothies?”
“Smoothies,” Blueberry nodded, following her sister out the door. Night Glider and Pigeon followed the two, the sounds of Cheddar and Limey’s moans and squeals stopping as they closed the door behind them.
Night Glider flew to Sugar Belle’s side, resting her foreleg around her marefriend’s shoulders and pressing her lips against the unicorn’s forehead. A variety of warm and colorful emotions bloomed from the pegasus’ chest as she glanced at the two other mares, a brief yet life-changing glimpse into the world of Sugar Belle and all of her life experiences.
No amount of flying could bring Night Glider to such emotional heights.
