Lust 'til Dawn

You peer down at the paper in your hands, looking it over again and again while glancing out the corners of your eyes to keep yourself from accidentally walking into passersby. Honestly, she knew you were going to be out late again, so was there really a point in arranging a party when it’s obviously just going to be the two of you tonight? Well, that’s still implying she was able to find a sitter who would be willing to work this late at night to watch her daughter, Luster Dawn. The only possibility you can even think of to fill that role would be her friend Rarity, but while she may be generous, she’s still not exactly a saint.

Just as the sun sets, you fast-walk over to one of the streetlights that suddenly turns on, giving you at least something to work with while you try and figure out the message hidden in her letter. “Happy birthday, sugar bear! I’m not really good at surprise parties, so how about a threeway instead? That counts as a surprise, right? I’ll be waiting at your place as soon as you’re done with work, so don’t come home until then, OK? Love you!”

You really hope she didn’t mean a threeway with another dude.

If you’re being honest, you expect to walk in to see party decorations and a cake just for Starlight to apologize about not finding anypony willing to do a threeway with her, again assuming she didn’t mean with another dude. Even if Starlight is one of the most important mares in all of Equestria, she still isn’t the best when it comes to social interactions, which is probably why the two of you work so well in the first place.

When you first arrived in Equestria, you were immediately put into Princess Twilight’s urban development program seeing as how the world you came from had technology that was way more advanced than what they had already. That streetlight from earlier? Yeah, you’re welcome, Equestria. Of course, this was how you ended up meeting your girlfriend Starlight Glimmer in the first place, seeing as how she’s basically Twilight’s best friend in this world, but that also means that you barely ever get the chance to see her. Twilight has you working these crazy hours from sunrise to sunset--both of which are her responsibilities--and by the time you get home, Starlight is so busy taking care of Luster Dawn that she barely has any time left to spend with you. You were lucky enough just to convince Twilight to let you live in Ponyville instead of the hustle and bustle of living in Canterlot.

Speaking of Luster Dawn, you’re still not sure how you feel about her yet--not that you hate her or anything like that! It’s just that when you met Starlight, you thought she was just like everypony else here, but as it so turned out, she had an illegitimate love child with some guy named Sunburst a couple years earlier. When you first started dating, you couldn’t imagine going a single day without her, but if you’re being honest, you probably never would have even asked her out if you knew she had a kid to begin with. The idea of getting serious with her knowing that Luster Dawn could eventually be your kid one day… “Heebie jeebies” doesn’t even begin to describe it.

Still, though, it’s times like these that keep Starlight Glimmer in your life. You look down at your letter and smile again, thinking of who Starlight could have possibly had in mind to do a threeway with in the first place. Of course, there’s no way it’s Twilight. You’d tell half of Equestria about it just for the memes, and they both know that. Trixie is another possibility, but you’re secretly hoping that she chose somepony else, just because Trixie would ruin it like she ruins everything. You still haven’t forgiven her after that little stunt she pulled with the ducks and the windmill.

Before you can think of any real candidates, though, you find yourself at the doorstep of your house, seeing the lights already on from inside. Just for fun, you audibly drop your keys onto the floor, and immediately, you hear a crash from inside as well as several “ow” sounds before the lights turn off. Then, with a smile on your face, you bring your keys to the doorknob, give a little twist, and push yourself into your home, flicking the lights back on to see streamers, cake, and your beautiful girlfriend in the middle of the room with a bow tied around her horn.

“Surpriiiise! Happy birthday, sugar bear!”

You chuckle quietly, grinning to yourself at how perfectly you predicted her every move. Then, hanging up your jacket, you walk up to Starlight and give her the best kiss in your arsenal, bringing her into a tight squeeze before your lips separate.

“Thanks, babe,” you reply, looking around at all the streamers that must have taken forever to set up. “You really went all out, didn’t you?”

“Well, I may or may not have gotten advice from somepony who knows a thing or two about parties.”

“Who? Applejack?”

Starlight scoffs with a teasing smile. “Don’t be a butt. Now, go have some cake. Not to brag, but I think I did a pretty good job on this one.”

“Does that mean it took you several attempts?”

“What? No! I meant… Shut up. Go eat.”

You chuckle under your breath as you make your way to the table in the kitchen, picking up a nearby knife and cutting yourself a slice of what appears to be normal chocolate--Yup. There’s pudding in the middle. Definitely a Pinkie Pie cake if you’ve ever seen one. Still, though, it’s not like that’s a bad thing. Heck, in comparison to all the other birthdays you’ve had, this one takes the cake!

...Yeah, you’d better not tell Starlight that one. You don’t want her to break up with you before your threeway. Speaking of which…

“So I take it you weren’t able to find anypony to do that thing with us?” you ask, licking some excess frosting off of your finger.

“Oh! About that--”

“Hey, don’t worry about it, babe. I’m happy with just the two of us tonight. You wanna watch some TV? I think Equestria’s finally figured out how to do late night sitcoms like in my world.”

As you walk towards the sofa with your plate of chocolate pudding cake, however, Starlight raises a curious eyebrow. “Uhh… I was going to say that she’s getting ready in your bedroom, so if you need anything, I’ll have to go get it for you.”

THANK CELESTIA IT’S NOT A DUDE!

Before you manage to sit down, though, you freeze once the message sinks in and slowly turn your head towards Starlight, who’s still wearing that wide grin on her face. “Wait… You found someone?!”

“Weeeeeellll, ‘found’ is a strong word. More like I just happened to know somepony for the job.”

“Who?”

Then, as if you had just uttered the magic password, the door to your bedroom creaks open, and out walks a pink filly with a golden mane, decorated from horn to hoof in red ribbons. “Moooom? I can’t figure out how to get my bow on right. Can you help me?”

Your jaw drops, and as soon as the filly makes eye contact with you, so does hers. There’s no way you’re seeing what you think you’re seeing, but at the same time, it’s not like there’s any way you can deny it. This filly… is Starlight Glimmer’s daughter, Luster Dawn, and she’s no older than eleven years old. Again, it makes no sense, but you can’t exactly explain it any other way.

“Oh!” she blurts out. “Happy birthday, D-Daddy.”

“...Yeah, I’m just gonna turn 360 degrees and walk away.”

You immediately turn around, but that’s when you realize that you’re in your own house, not giving you many places to go. Still, anywhere has to be better than here. What was Starlight thinking, not just inviting a filly to join in on a borderline orgy, but her daughter of all ponies?! You’re not sure if there are any laws about this in Equestria, but in your world, basically everywhere besides Florida would have you locked away forever! And that’s assuming you got off easy!

“Wait!”

Suddenly, Starlight grabs you by the hand, digging her hind legs into the floor while you try breaking yourself out of her grasp. “Sugar bear, please! Let me explain!”

As much as you’d like to get out of there, you’re not proud to say that it’s actually harder to pull her off of you than you originally anticipated. Then, pinching the bridge of your nose with a sigh, you calmly say, “You have thirty seconds.”

“Wow. That’s not a lot of time. OK! Uhh, where to start? So, I tried asking Twilight first, but she told me that it would end up being the biggest scandal Equestria had ever seen if it ever went public somehow. I tried telling her that you’d never tell anypony about it, but she didn’t like those chances.”

For good reasons.

“So then I went to Trixie,” she continues, “but she said that she was still mad at you after that time with the trombone and the balloon animals.”

“Wait, she said what?!”

“THEN I kinda ran out of options, and since this is your first birthday in Equestria, I wanted to make it really special, so I… asked Luster Dawn to fill in.”

You raise your eyebrow at Starlight, then turn your attention towards Luster Dawn, who shrinks in embarrassment, her cheeks turning an even brighter shade of pink. You have no idea what Starlight told her to get her to come over in the first place, and you’re even less sure whether or not she actually knows what a threeway is. Still, the poor girl looks like she’s trying so hard, way harder than you’ve ever tried being part of her life.

You breathe out another heavy sigh. “Starlight, what were you thinking? Isn’t this illegal?”

Starlight tilts her head in curiosity. “‘Illegal’? What’s that?”

“Huh? I mean it’s against the law, right?” Again, Starlight blinks in confusion. “As in, doing something like this could land us in a whole bunch of trouble?”

“Uhh, nooooo? Why would it?”

You scratch your head in bewilderment, trying to figure out if she’s just dumb or if there’s really that much of a cultural difference between your worlds, but before you can think about it too hard, Luster Dawn interrupts your train of thought. “Mom? Do I still have to wear this? It’s kind of embarrassing.”

“Well,” Starlight responds, “that really depends on what Anon wants to do. Don’t you wanna open your present, sugar bear?”

You quickly turn towards the filly, who shrinks with a sheepish grin, doing her best to make eye contact with you. She looks so adora--Wait, NO! This is bad, right? Like, even though Starlight doesn’t realize that this is wrong, that doesn’t give you permission to go through with it… does it?

Suddenly, you see a bead of sweat drip down her forehead, snapping you out of your thoughts for a second. She’s waiting on you to get her out of this situation, after all, and in this particular circumstance, it would be weird for her not to undress in front of you, right?

You’d better not go to Hell for this.

“It’s fine, Luster,” you say. “You can take that stuff off now.”

The filly’s face lights up, but almost immediately, the cringe from before returns. “Thanks, Anon, but the knot is too far back for me to reach by myself. I’m gonna need some help.”

“Luster Daaaawn,” Starlight says with an authoritative tone. “Remember what we talked about? It’s Anon’s birthday, after all.”

Luster Dawn winces before turning towards you again with a gentle smile. “I mean… Will you help me get my ribbons off, Daddy?”

Yup. You’re going to Hell.

“S-sure. Just give a second.”

You gulp and take a step forward, trying to keep your hands from shaking despite the chill that rushes under your skin. The way she looks up at you with those big eyes makes your heart race at twice its normal speed, causing you to overanalyze literally every movement you make. Are you walking too fast? Can she see how hard you’re breathing? Maybe if you just try to breathe normally for a second… and now you’re breathing even harder. You just hope Luster Dawn isn’t feeling as uneasy as you are right now.

Finally, you’re standing a foot in front of her, and now you have to find out where the stupid knot to this outfit is in the first place. Would it be weird to ask? Hopefully it’s not in a totally obvious place that you’re just completely overlooking somehow.

“It’s by my tail,” the filly says after like twelve seconds of looking without finding anything. “You might have to get a little low to find it, though.”

Well, at least you don’t have to frantically search around her abdomen like a doofus anymore. You then walk around the filly’s body and begin examining around her tail, but the minute you find where the knot is tied, your skin goes pale. If this were literally anypony else, you’d probably be the happiest guy in the world, but it’s kinda weird getting horny seeing a bow tied around your girlfriend’s daughter’s vagina.

“Hey, Starlight? Maybe you should come do this instead.”

“Oh, quit being a baby. I think you’ll really like it once you open it up!”

You really hope she’s talking about the bow.

As much as you’d like to just walk away, though, you can tell that Luster Dawn probably wants to be done most of all right now, and with your hand trembling and your head leaning away, you slowly pull on a loose ribbon, freeing the filly as her little lips become the focus of your vision. You try to look away, but once she shakes the ribbons off of her flank, she accidentally pushes her butt even higher, giving you an even more intimate view of her crotch. It looks so delicate, like it has some kind of youthful charm that somehow lures you in…

...but then you come back to reality, turning towards Starlight again with an awkward smile. “Thanks, babe. I really appreciate what you tried doing, but I think I just wanna watch TV for now. Doesn’t that sound like fun, Luster?”

“Y-yeah,” the filly replies, rubbing her forehoof bashfully. “That sounds… great.”

You raise an eyebrow curiously. You thought that she’d be ecstatic not to go through with a threesome involving her mom and mom’s boyfriend, but the smile she has is obviously forced, like she’s just trying to be polite and not hurt anyone’s feelings.

“Luster?”

“Anon?” Starlight says through a gritted smile. “Can I speak with you alone for a minute?”

Wait, are you in trouble somehow? Starlight then motions her head towards the kitchen, and you can’t help but throw up your hands in aggravation. Yeah, you kinda ruined the birthday present that Starlight planned, but it’s not like you didn’t have a good reason! You almost got turned on by a filly! Twilight would kill you if you actually put your dick in her! Er--put your dick in Luster Dawn, that is. Not Twilight.

You barely make it into the kitchen when Starlight uses her magic to pull you by the ear, dragging your whole upper body down to her mouth as she whispers angrily. “What the heck are you thinking?!”

“Oh. Huh. I wonder. Maybe it has something to do with the fact that Twilight will throw me into Tartarus if I actually went through with something like this!”

“...What?! What are you even talking about?”

“Come on. Are you telling me that in Equestria, it’s really OK for me to have sex with someone as young as Luster Dawn?”

“Duh! I wouldn’t have asked you if it could get you in trouble! Why? Did Twilight tell you not to or something?”

“No, she didn’t, but…”

Now this is starting to get weird. Is there seriously nothing wrong with porking Starlight’s daughter? You’d just assumed the whole time that you’d go to whatever Equestria’s equivalent of jail would be, but either Starlight is a total idiot, or you legitimately have the option to do whatever you want with her.

You look up to see Luster Dawn’s reaction, just to catch her looking over at the two of you before flinching and turning away bashfully. You’ve never really thought about it before just because of the consequences, but now that you’re not trying to force the idea out of your head anymore, she actually looks kinda… cute. Then she looks up at you again, and you immediately see how much her golden eyes naturally glimmer. She looks as beautiful as her mom, but she also has a beauty that’s completely unique to her.

Before you let your thoughts go crazy, though, Starlight pulls you back down with an aggravated stare. “Listen. It’s your birthday, so you can do whatever you want, but Luster Dawn was really looking forward to this!”

You shake your head in bewilderment. “Wait. She was?!”

“Yes! Don’t you get it? She wants you to like her! If you’re going to be part of my life, she wants to be part of your life too. She wants you to love her as much as you love me.”

“So… it isn’t because she wants me to put my dick in her?”

“Oh, well yeah. She wants that too. I mean, what girl is gonna turn down free dick?”

You look over at Luster Dawn again just to see the same sight as before, making you gulp nervously as your chest trembles. You aren’t really going to go through with this… are you?

“Is everything OK, Daddy?”

“Yeah! I just uhh…”

Before you can stammer any further, however, Starlight Glimmer nudges you forward, making you stumble as you self-consciously walk towards her. You can see her start to smile, but before she can get too carried away, she bites down on her lip, making eye contact and looking away over and over again. Suddenly, you’re standing right in front of her, and right when her eyes manage to look up from the floor, they quickly dart back down once she looks you in the eyes.

“So Anon!” Starlight says before this situation can get any more awkward. “Luster Dawn asked me the other day how to kiss better.”

“Mooom!” the filly exclaims, her face practically sizzling all over.

“Oh, it’s fine, honey. Anon and I would be happy to give you a demonstration, wouldn’t we?”

Not gonna lie, even though the two of you have kissed in front of Luster on more than one occasion, it’s still kinda weird in the moment, but the way that Starlight nods her head reminds you that saying no would probably be worse than the alternative. Then, with a quick nod of your own, you slowly lean down as Starlight gets on her hind legs, reaching her hooves around your neck as her mouth comes closer. Everything after that seems so familiar, like you can let your muscle memory take over so that you can enjoy what comes next, and by the time her lips meet yours, you’ve already forgotten that Luster Dawn is even there.

Suddenly, you feel her tongue entering into your mouth, licking up the sides of your teeth. You then open your mouth wider, unintentionally showing off to Luster Dawn the two of you fighting for dominance in each other’s mouth, tasting each other’s tongues like candy. Starlight grips onto your hair, standing up taller to press your mouths even harder together as your fingers run through her mane. You can feel a bulge in your pants trying to break free, but just as soon as it gets to the good part, Starlight pulls away and wipes the spit off of her mouth.

“How was that, honey?” she asks, looking at a very flustered Luster Dawn. “Think you’re ready to give it a try next?”

“Hang on, Starlight,” you say reflexively. “I don’t know if--”

“Yeah… I think I’m ready.” Finally, she looks you directly in your eyes, obviously still bashful, but never wavering in her conviction. “Is that OK with you?”

If she doesn’t mind your Jimmy Cooper trying to poke out of your pants.

“Y-yeah,” you say hesitantly. “I think I’m ready too.”

Luster Dawn smiles, making your heart pump so much blood to your lungs that you might not even have enough left for your dick at this point. No, wait. Your dick is getting plenty too. Then, trying to mimic what she saw from her mom, Luster Dawn gets up on her hind legs, wraps her hooves around your shoulders and reaches forward with her lips. Her eyes are squeezed shut in the most adorable way possible, making you want to leave yours open for just a little while longer, but before you can think that far, your muscle memory once again kicks in, interlocking your lips with Luster Dawn’s as your hand gently caresses her body.

You can already feel a difference, not just because her lips are smaller than her mom’s, but also because the way she kisses you makes you remember that she probably has literally no experience. At first her mouth barely opens up, causing you to lead her with your lips, putting her where you want her before her hooves grip you harder and her tongue catapults forward. You take a step back in surprise, but that just causes her to hold on tighter, pressing her mouth harder against yours like she’s doing damage control, trying to make up for her lack of training.

The more she pushes her mouth against you, however, the more you feel yourself falling backwards, and after taking an extra step, she begins to lose balance herself. Suddenly, her hooves slip off of your shoulder as she falls onto your chest, looking up into your eyes while panting heavily.

“Good job, honey!” Starlight says, breaking the two of you from your immersion. “Now do the thing we talked about!”

Luster Dawn grimaces. “Do I have to? It’s so embarrassing...”

She’s not talking about something weird, is she? “Wait, do what?” you ask, switching your gaze between the two of them, but mostly looking at the red-faced Luster Dawn.

“I… Uh…” Then, shaking her head until she can look you in the eye with a newfound confidence, her hoof slowly travels down your chest as she says, “I really like how firm your chest is. D-do you work out? It makes me wonder how firm your penis--Oh, sweet Celestia, I just said ‘penis’! Mom, I can’t do this.”

Before you can even react, Luster Dawn pulls herself off of you and covers her face with her hooves, but even with her cheeks covered, you can still hear how much they’re sizzling right now. You can’t help but give her mom an angry glare for making her go through with something like this.

“Seriously, Starlight?”

“I never told her to say ‘penis’!”

“Quit it, mom! You’re embarrassing me!”

What did those two talk about? In all honesty, you’re probably just as embarrassed as Luster Dawn right now, but that just means that you need to be the one to set things right… somehow.

“Hey, Luster?”

Luster Dawn turns around, but her eyes only go as far as your knees. “Yeah?”

“If you wanna know how stiff my, uh… well, you know…” Just when you try to make the situation less humiliating, you can see her mouth quivering, quickly informing you to get to the point. “Anyway, I was just wondering if you wanted to uh… see it.”

Finally, her eyes rise enough to make contact with yours, allowing a small smile to reach across your cheeks, an expression that Luster Dawn mirrors back. “Really? Would that be OK?” You nod silently, allowing her to exhale a breath of relief. “Then… Yeah. I think I’d like that.”

The moment you reach for your belt, though, Starlight blurts out, “I think you’ll really like it! It’s got a nice curve to it!”

“MOM!”

“STARLIGHT!”

Your wonderful girlfriend then rolls her eyes like she did nothing wrong. “Fine, fine,” she says. “I’ll stop talking now.”

Ironically, her mom’s outburst seems to have taken the tension away, like Luster Dawn has completely forgotten about her own insecurities while trying to ignore Starlight. That, however, means that you probably need to try not to blow it on your end.

Slowly, your belt slips out of the prongs and escapes the frame, making Luster Dawn gulp nervously as her eyes fixate on your lower torso. You try not to rush how quickly you pull the accessory out of your belt loops, but once it’s fully off of your pants, you waste no time reaching for the button at the base of your waist. You can see Luster Dawn’s chest expanding farther with each breath, and the moment your fingers start sliding your zipper down, her breathing seems to stop completely. Finally, you grab hold of both your pants and undergarments, sliding them down just far enough for your manhood to poke out the top, causing Luster Dawn’s eyes to go wide.

“Is…” you begin, your voice descending to a whisper. “Is it OK?”

Luster Dawn waits in silence, staring at the tip of your member before finally getting the courage to nod her head with confidence. “Yeah. Show me the rest.”

You give her a half-smile, shimmying the fabric down your legs in a manner similar to a striptease, and based on the way the filly’s grin grows wider the longer she stares, you can tell that her insecurities are starting to disappear. She seems almost entranced by your anatomy, examining it up and down, inspecting every detail, a sight which only causes you to grow longer, making her stare even harder. Finally, you step out of your pants completely and walk towards her, but when you thought she would step back nervously, she actually takes a step forward, closing the gap between you.

“You like it?” you ask quietly, making her giggle before finally looking into your eyes.

“Maybe,” she responds, giving you a youthful grin. “Would it be OK if I played with it a little?”

Where did her reservation from before go? Actually, now that you think about it, where did your reservation from before go? Maybe it’s just because she’s Starlight’s daughter, but you and Luster Dawn both seem to be thinking on the exact same wavelength right now. Well, might as well take advantage of it before you come back to your senses.

“Yeah. I think I’d like that.”

“Me too.”

Then, after the two of you share another smile, Luster Dawn lifts up her shaky hoof, reaches forward, and slowly grasps your manhood, practically bringing you over the edge from the very beginning. She’s obviously nervous, causing her to stop her momentum after every tug. Before she can get insecure again, however, you slowly move your hips back and forth in tandem with the way she strokes you, allowing her to look up with a smile as her hoof gradually finds a slow rhythm. This, however, leaves you with a new problem. How are you going to ask her to stop before you accidentally splooge all over her face?

“Am… Am I doing OK?” she asks, fluttering her eyelashes innocently.

“Y-yup!” you say, biting your lip and closing your eyes. “You’re definitely a natural at this.”

“Are you sure? It doesn’t look like you’re enjoying it.”

You’re trying not to enjoy it too much!

“You know what?” you say, pulling your cock out of her grip. “Why don’t we do you now? You’d enjoy that, right?”

Just as you’re about to turn Luster Dawn around to repay the favor, however, Starlight quickly intervenes, grabbing you by the arm and shaking her head. “Oh, uh-uh! It’s your birthday, Anon, which means that tonight is all about you.”

Dang it, Starlight! Can’t you read the room?!

“I don’t know, mom,” Luster says, rubbing her leg bashfully. “I don’t think I’m doing it right.”

“Here,” her mom replies, tugging her daughter closer. “Just watch me for a second. He loves it when I do this.”

You raise your eyebrow in curiosity, but immediately, Starlight falls to her knees, looking up at you while your dick rests along the curvature of her face. Right when you realize where she’s going with this, she turns her cheeks to the side, opening her mouth and letting her tongue slide along the edge of your shaft, again making you clench your fists to endure the pleasure. With one final flick of her tongue, the mare scoots back and lifts her hoof up, rubbing your skin back and forth while lathering the saliva that coats your cock. Starlight wasn’t kidding. You really do love it when she does this.

Then, after tugging your skin back and forth a few strokes, she once again lifts up her tongue and circles it around the head of your dick, slowly letting her tongue slide down the base of your shaft. Once she gets far enough, her lips slowly close around you, creating a suction as she pulls you with her mouth, gripping your skin and tugging you the other way. It feels so good, but not overbearing to the point where you need to brace yourself. There’s familiarity to it, allowing you to enjoy the moment without worrying about accidentally pumping your load into her mouth too soon. That’ll still happen pretty soon at this rate, but at least you’ll be able to enjoy it longer than when she did it to you the first time.

Right when you feel yourself getting lost in the flow of her mouth, however, she suddenly pulls away and wipes the spit from her mouth, leaving you with your mouth on the floor in disappointment, but she doesn’t even seem to notice you as she turns her attention towards her daughter.

“Alright, Luster Dawn! Now it’s your turn!”