Lust 'til Dawn

The filly’s head shrinks into her shoulders as her face turns away with another bright blush. “I dunno. There’s no way I’ll be as good as you, and I don’t want to ruin Anon’s birthday.” You have no idea why her bashfulness turns you on, but your dick visibly bounces upwards with more blood flowing to it than ever.

“Oh, you’ll be fine!” says Starlight. “Why don’t you just give it a shot? I’ll tell you what. If Anon really doesn’t like it, then I’ll take over.”

Luster Dawn traces a circle on the floor with her hoof. “I… guess that’s fine. You’ll promise to tell me if I’m not doing a good job, won’t you, Anon?” Honestly, if she keeps this up, the bigger issue will be finishing too quickly, but regardless, you nod your head frantically, allowing a small smile to creep up on her face. “OK. I’ll try.”

You gulp as the filly takes a step forward, trying not to stare too hard and make the situation even more embarrassing for her. Once she arrives in front of your cock, her hoof steadily rises up to your shaft before she instinctively pulls it back to her chest.

“It’s OK, honey! It won’t bite!”

“Mooom!!”

Just as you’re about to snap at your dear, sweet girlfriend, however, Luster Dawn faces your dick again and gently grabs your skin, completely forgetting what she’s doing as she shakes her head at her mom. Her hoof quivers as it slowly moves back and forth, massaging your nerve endings while continuing to lather the dampness that her mother left before. The filly gulps, and finally, with her mouth slowly opening up, she squeezes her eyes closed and jerks her head forward, latching her lips around the head of your dick.

You have to mentally hold yourself back from unintentionally thrusting your hips deeper, but with your mind so preoccupied on your waist, you don’t even notice your hand moving behind Luster Dawn’s head. The filly then looks up at you to make sure she’s down OK, making your eyes fall into the back of your head as your hand gently nudges her closer. You don’t push her by any means, but with your guidance, Luster Dawn slowly allows more of your manhood into her mouth, delicately caressing your skin with her lips.

You can hear her breathing in deeply from her nose, almost as much as you can feel her exhaling it back out onto your pelvis. Once she gets to the end of her comfort zone, she slowly pulls back out with the tips of her teeth softly kneading you down the whole way. The minute she gets back to the edges of your head, however, she instinctively pulls the rest of the way out, still holding onto your shaft while she takes this chance to catch her breath.

“Am I doing OK so far, Daddy?”

Honestly, you’re too horny to answer her clearly right now, and with the nod of your head, you push your hips closer to her face. Thankfully, she takes the hint and continues where she left off before, moving her head back and forth, each time going faster than before. Then, once she finds a good rhythm with her mouth, she gets her hoof going too, showing off her youthful enthusiasm as she energetically tugs your shaft in two different directions. You can’t finish already. She just barely started! Still, though, if there’s one thing your penis is good at, it’s finishing prematurely. Besides, there’s still one trick you’ve learned since coming to Equestria…

“Hey, Luster. Can I ask you something?” The filly simply acknowledges you by looking up from your cock, never losing her girlish vigor, a sight that makes your pelvis physically tingle. “Feel free to say no if you want, but uh… C-can I cum in your mouth?”

Immediately, Luster Dawn pulls your dick out of her mouth, making you quickly regret asking such a stupid question in the first place. To your surprise, however, the unicorn filly’s eyebrow rise in curiosity.

“You mean it?” she asks. “I’m really doing that good?”

You then bring your hand up to rub the back of your neck just so you can play aloof instead of turning her off with how much you want to praise her dick-sucking abilities. Sure, she may still be awkward and inexperienced, but it’s actually kinda hot when she’s doing it.

“Yeah,” you respond probably as bashfully as her. “I just wanted to warn you so that it wasn’t a surprise.”

“It tastes like coconut water, by the way!”

You quickly turn to Starlight to give her the most aggravated stare you have, and then you look back down at Luster with the same timid smile as before. “Is… that OK?”

Luster Dawn thinks it over for a few moments before shrugging her shoulders, giving you an adorable grin. “I like coconuts.”

Should you tell her it’s more like salty coconut water?

...Nah. Maybe this way she’ll think of the beach when you explode in her mouth.

You then lift the base of your member, handing it to Luster Dawn as she places her hoof around it. Then, to your surprise, she lifts it up higher in the air and gives you a long lick up your shaft, coming down with her lips closing over your dick. Almost immediately, the two of you pick up where you were before, guiding her head back and forth as her mouth coats your cock with more and more of her saliva. Every time her mouth comes towards you, she goes a little bit deeper than before. Whereas before she could barely cover the head of your dick, now she’s taking in practically your entire shaft, squeezing her eyes closed as she gets all of your length down her throat.

Luster Dawn definitely doesn’t have the same kind of technical skills that her mom has, but she more than makes up for it with the amount of vigor she uses to go down on you, going at about twice the speed of a normal mare. There’s no way this is within her comfort zone, but the amount of tenacity she has in trying to make this the best night ever seems to help her get lost in the experience. If the look of determination in her eyes doesn’t get your cock pumping, the way her tongue delicately grazes the base of your shaft definitely does the trick.

Finally, you feel yourself getting close to that edge right where you’re about to creampie her mouth and warn her by gripping as much of her mane as possible. You’re not totally sure whether she gets the message, but the way she moves her head back and forth almost looks like she’s nodding. Then, once you feel your sympathetic nervous system begin to take over, you pull her as close to your pelvis as possible, pumping more seed into her throat than you initially expected. Her eyes go wide at first before she squeezes them together, gulping down your semen without so much as flinching, and once the initial two or three bursts are finished, you pull yourself out of her mouth, allowing the rest to lazily drip onto her face. Even though you’d like nothing more than to fill her mouth with your cum and see her show it off before swallowing the rest down, she probably needs to use this time to breathe. Besides, it’s not like you dislike seeing her face decorated in semen.

Once she knows you’re finished, she discreetly peeks one eye open, making sure she’s not going to accidentally go blind from sperm. Then, after making sure she’s good to get it off of her face, she brings her hoof up to her muzzle and wipes the excess orgasm away as best she can, licking the remains off of her hoof like frosting. You can’t help but pulse one last drop onto your carpet.

“So!” Starlight says, jumping in. “Did it taste like coconut water like I said?”

“It’s hard to say,” Luster says, gulping down whatever’s left in her throat. “It was more like moist, salty whipped cream.”

You scratch your head in confusion. “Wait. That’s good, right?”

The two girls then look at each other with the same expressions before breaking into laughter, and suddenly you wonder whether you should be self-conscious of the taste of your semen. “It… wasn’t as bad as I thought,” Luster says with a smile. “You did kinda surprise me, though! It almost went down the wrong pipe!!”

You blush bashfully. “Sorry. I guess I’d better give you more warning next time.”

“It’s fine. Did I do a good job?”

You give her a half-chuckle. “Oh, I’m sorry, was that not rhetorical? Did you not notice how big a load I just shot out?”

“Hey! It’s not like I would know! That was…” Luster Dawn looks away with a blush. “...my first time.”

There’s that look again, the one that gave you such a huge boner that you practically gave yourself a hernia just from a single orgasm. Speaking of which, maybe now would be the best time to teach her about that little trick you learned when you first landed on this horse planet.

“Then you wanna do it again?”

The filly’s jaw drops, trembling like she’s trying to make words come out but unable to do anything other than blink voraciously. Then, turning towards her mom, she asks, “Isn’t it supposed to take a while before they can do it again? I thought boys were supposed to have something called a ‘redactory period’ or something.”

Suddenly, Starlight raises a suspicious eyebrow. “Wait! Who taught you about that?”

Luster Dawn grits her teeth, looking out the corner of her eye as she obviously tries coming up with an excuse. “Uhhhh… A friend from school.”

“Which friend?”

“Ummm… Tart, Stack…”

“Who the fuck is Tart Stack?!”

“A friend from school.”

If you’re being honest, you’d be surprised if she didn’t learn it from a porn magazine, but only because Twilight hasn’t quite figured out how to make internet work in Equestria yet. Then you’re going to have an entirely new way to stash all the stuff you’re hiding from Starlight!

“Anyway!” Luster Dawn announces. “What about that refactory thing?”

You immediately give her a snide grin, lifting your shoulders back and puffing out your chest. “Normally, you’d be right, but I just so happen to have a super penis.”

“Mom, he just said ‘penis’.”

“He said ‘super penis’, honey.”

You quickly wave your hands to get their attention back on focus. “OK, let’s just forget about that thing I said. Anyway, my point is that ever since I came to Equestria, I can have multiple orgasms. I think it has something to do with magic or friendship or something.”

The two girls then look up at you in awe, not like you did something incredible, but more like they suddenly learned something very, very important. Then, running her tongue along her bottom teeth, Starlight quietly mutters, “Sooo you’re not finished, then?”

“I’ve only gotten warmed up.”

The two girls turn their faces towards each other and giggle into their hooves before looking up at you with feminine grins, Luster Dawn fluttering her eyelashes excessively. “In that case,” the younger says, “what were you hoping to do next?”

That’s honestly a good question. You’ve never been involved in a threeway before--at least that you were conscious for--so now that you have two girls and only one dick, what exactly do you do first? Fortunately, you don’t have to think hard to know what you want, but now the question is whether or not either one of them would be up for what you have in mind. There’s no way asking them would completely ruin the mood and make them want to stop for the entire night, is there?

“So, uh…” you begin, rubbing the back of your neck. “Either of you wanna try anal?”

Both girls then look at each other with the same sly smirk, and almost immediately, the two of them begin cracking up, holding onto their gut as they lean on each other to stay standing. You, on the other hand, are now wondering if you’re going to be going solo for the rest of the night.

“Oh, Anon,” Starlight says, wiping a tear from her eye. “You’re such a boy.”

You scratch your head in confusion. “Soooo does that mean yes, or…?”

Luster Dawn rolls her eyes. “What do you think, mom? It is his birthday, after all.”

“True,” the mother replies. “I guess there’s no harm in trying it out just this once. You go high and I’ll go low?”

“Mmmm. Sounds yummy.”

The two girls then face you again, and even though you’re still not one hundred percent sure what their plan is, they both walk towards you with devious grins. Once Luster Dawn arrives in front of you, she gently presses your chest, pushing you backwards until you fall flat on your butt, your back pressed against the wall behind you. Starlight then falls down by your crotch, using one hoof to gently rub you up and down while Luster Dawn continues moving closer. Suddenly, the filly’s privates are directly in front of your face, making you gulp as a sweat drips down your forehead.

“You like it?” she asks with a sadistic smile. You’re honestly so overwhelmed by the sudden stimulation that you don’t know how to respond with anything other than a nod. Then, with a quiet snicker, the filly lifts one of her legs over your shoulder, places her hoof against the back of your head and softly places your mouth against her vulva, where you instinctively give her a long lick up her lady lips. “Ahh! Ohhhh just like that, Daddy.”

Meanwhile, as your mouth begins to take away Luster Dawn’s virginity, Starlight runs her own tongue up your cock, making your back shiver so hard that Luster probably feels it in her uterus. She starts out with long, slow licks, but after a few moments of your whole pelvis clenching in pleasure, Starlight finally pulls her bangs out of the way and allows your entire phallus into her mouth at once. With everything that’s going on, you can hardly breathe, both from the amount your heart is beating and the sheer excess heat emanating from everyone’s body right now.

With one hand, you grab hold of Luster Dawn’s tail, gripping her with more force than you probably realize just to get some of the tension out of your body. Then, with the other hand, you grab Starlight’s mane, pressing her deeper into your crotch as you reflexively move it up in the overwhelming pleasure she’s giving you. You would be afraid of pushing Starlight too far, but this is child’s play compared to what you’ve done with her already, and if there’s one thing you’ve learned about your girlfriend, it’s the rougher the better.

Right when you can feel her tongue begin to reach down to your balls, though, Starlight pulls away entirely, leaving you not only with disappointment, but also with the feeling of the suddenly frigid room temperature around your cock. You’d be giving her a look right now if it weren’t for the absolutely delicious taste of Luster Dawn’s innocence dripping down your throat.

“What do you think, Anon?” your girlfriend asks. “Think you’re lubed up enough, or should I use my mouth some more?”

That… actually is a tough question. Not that you particularly care how much saliva’s on your dick, but rather would you prefer she continued her blowjob or started anal right away, both of which sound pretty good right now. Plus, it’s not exactly easy to think with her daughter pressing her crotch down on your face, her hooves resting on your shoulders as her breaths turn into gasps.

“What do you think, Luster?” she continues. Luster Dawn, however, slowly pulls her crotch off of your face, but only long enough to turn herself around and press it down on your mouth once more, facing her mom as your tongue reaches up towards her clitoris.

“Mmmm, I think you should put him in right now,” the younger replies, her shoulders pinching backwards once you find the nub at the top of her vulva. “Ahn! I think Anon agrees with me.”

In all honesty, it’s kind of hard to see what else is going on just from Luster Dawn’s tail in your eyes, but you can feel your girlfriend beginning to stand up, her hoof never leaving your shaft. The wait is agonizing, making it difficult to continue licking the filly despite how sultry her moans are becoming. Luckily, however, you don’t have to wait much longer, because in the next moment, you feel something surrounding your manhood, encompassing your length on the way down. It’s such a tight opening that you can barely believe you’re fitting inside, and once she lowers herself all the way down to your pelvis, you can feel her inner walls clench against you even tighter.

“How does it feel, mom?”

“Mmmm he’s so hard right now. I bet you’re feeling pretty good yourself right about now.”

“Ohhhh yeah. I can’t believe you’ve been doing this without me!”

“I wasn’t sure if you were ready, honey.”

“Ready? What girl isn’t ready to feel this good? Hahhhhh.”

The entire time the two of them talk, Starlight bounces on top of your dick, starting out with her butthole dragging along the skin of your shaft before finding a steady rhythm where she uses your cock as a pole vault. You can’t even lift your hips to help because as soon as you get feeling in your waist again, Starlight’s ass presses you back down to the floor. With your basically non-existent refractory period, you can legitimately cum whenever you want, but the feeling of edging for as long as you can with her anal walls gripping against you just sounds too enticing right now.

Starlight’s moans now begin to mimic Luster Dawn’s, only based on her experience, she knows how to let her voice trail off in a way that makes your legs tingle. Her daughter, however, gets louder with every flick of your tongue. What she lacks in experience, she makes up for in how high her voice can go, not only overpowering her mom in volume, but also in how easily her voice cracks with her rising pleasure.

“Ohhhh!” your girlfriend exclaims in ecstasy. “Baby, I can feel you getting bigger inside me.”

“Can I feel too?” asks her daughter, making Starlight chuckle between moans.

“Are you sure you want to stop what you’re doing? It looks like you’re having fun over there.”

“I am, but--Mm! Ahn. Ahn. I’ve just never… felt… a dick… befoooorrre. There. Right there. Ohhh, Daddy, you’re making me so wet.”

Starlight opens her mouth to speak, but right when she’s about to make sound come out, you slide your dick further into her asshole, causing her to exhale passionately instead. Her eyes squeeze closed as she bounces even harder, which you only partly see through Luster Dawn’s trembling legs.

“In a minute, honey,” Starlight says with a weak voice. “Once mama’s finished, you can do whatever you’d like with him.”

That basically means that it’s up to you whenever you want to switch holes, and if Luster Dawn’s pussy feels as good as it tastes, you might want to get started sooner than later. Still, though, it’s not exactly easy to think about your cock anywhere else right now, especially with Starlight rubbing her hips in circles on your pelvis after every few strokes. That, however, creates a paradox where you want to keep her bouncing on your dick forever while simultaneously craving the feeling of climaxing as hard as you can into her tight, little ponut hole.

“Ah. Ahhhh! Mom, I feel something hahhh!” Luster Dawn puts her hoof over her mouth, her lower body shaking more than ever like they could give out at any second. “I feel something happeniiiiing~! AH! AHHHH!!”

“Oh, honey! You’re about to cum for the first time!”

“Mom, I can’t hold it in anymore! I’m gonna… I’m gonna… AAAHHH!!!!”

Suddenly, Luster Dawn places both of her hooves onto your shoulders, arching her back as fluids begin streaming into your mouth. Her whole body convulses uncontrollably, but somehow, she manages to keep the most sensitive part of her body still while you continue sucking on her vulva, your tongue flicking across her clitoris as her vagina squirts down your throat. In your home world, something like this would probably be more enjoyable in idea than in actual practice, but in this world, her pussy tastes like liquid sugar, making your taste buds go crazy as your dick fights its own battle.

Hearing Luster Dawn scream in ecstasy seems to be turning on her mom just as much, who’s now forcing your cock as deep into her rectum as it’ll go, her hooves gripping into your legs as she begins screaming along. With all this stimulation going on, there’s no way you can handle it any longer. You quickly grab Starlight by the hips, pull her into your waist, and cum so hard that her back actually jolts in surprise. For the next few moments, literally everything around you disappears aside from the feeling of your cock flooding her insides. You can’t even tell anymore whether you’re throbbing inside her or she’s the one throbbing around you. Gradually, though, as you begin to see out your eyes again, you can see both happening at the same time as she leans forward, enjoying every last moment and happily taking in every last drop.

You really don’t want to cut her indulgence short, but unfortunately, you can only ejaculate for so long, and even though you can go all night, you’re legitimately starting to feel fatigue from your overworked urethra. Starlight made a promise, after all, so who are you to deny her daughter from what she’s been looking forward to all day?

“Alright, babe,” you say, weakly pulling yourself out of her butthole. “I think it’s time Luster Dawn had a turn.”

The aforementioned filly, meanwhile, stumbles forwards, trying to walk on all fours again while wobbling back and forth weakly. “Ugggghhhh,” she moans. “I don’t know, Anon. That felt really good, but I think I might need a little while before we do it again.”

“But honey,” her mom intervenes, pulling the rest of the way off of your shaft while dripping fluids from her anus. “Anon’s birthday is only for another hour!”

“So? We’re just gonna have sex every time he comes over anyway, right?”

You can already feel yourself growing again, even though Starlight doesn’t seem to be sharing the same expression. “Well… You see… The thing is…”

“Wait…” Luster Dawn backs away slowly. “Are you saying I only get to do it with him this once?”

“Luster Dawn, sweetie, Anon is my boyfriend. I’m only sharing him because I wanted to indulge him a little. After tonight, we’re going to go back to being a couple. You know… Just the two of us.”

You quickly switch glances between the two of them, seeing Starlight’s face grimace as Luster Dawn glares into her eyes. Then she turns to face you, making you gulp when you notice that her glare hasn’t disappeared. “Fine. Come on, Anon. If I only have you for a little while longer, then I wanna make the most of it.”

Before you completely understand what’s going on, Luster Dawn grabs you by the wrist and starts pulling you away, making you jump to your feet before she accidentally dislocates something important. You turn towards Starlight to give her an “I’m sorry” face, but she seems just as confused as you are. Then, after the filly manages to drag you into your bedroom, she uses her magic to slam the door behind you, looking up at you with desperation in her eyes.

“Luster Dawn, what’s going--”

“Fuck me, Daddy.”

Your jaw stammers before you can finally ask, “What?”

“Fuck me. Make my pussy hurt. I want to feel you inside me. Right now.”

Her answer makes you scratch your head in confusion. Your dick grows nonetheless, but you’re still confused. “OK? I thought your pussy already hurt.”

“Not enough. Please! I need you so bad right now!”

“But--”

Before you can cockblock yourself any further, however, the filly lifts herself up, wraps her hooves around your neck and places a hard, awkward kiss on your lips. You freeze up at first until your body relaxes enough to wrap your arms around her lower back, helping guide her lips around yours as she clumsily does her best to make the kiss good. Finally, once the kiss breaks, you can see her panting, placing her hoof to your lips as she shakes her head.

“Stop talking. Just put it in.”

This whole thing seems to be escalating pretty quickly, but she’s made up her mind much more definitively than you have. Pulling herself off of you, she turns around and lifts up her tail, showing off her nether lips, which are far smaller than her mom’s. You can only imagine how it’ll feel to be inside them, and thankfully, your dick agrees, allowing you to forget how sore it was a minute ago while you close the distance between the two of you.

You slowly bring your hand down to your shaft, slicing up and down her lower lips and making her coo softly. They’re so soft you could practically spend the whole night hotdogging her, but your mind, meanwhile, is on autopilot, which means that you barely waste another second before you feel yourself gradually slipping inside her, making her gasp femininely. That’s when you realize that even though she was practically begging you a second ago to boink her, this is still the first dick she’s ever had inside her, and she’s probably at least a little nervous.

“Hey, you doin’ OK?”

Luster Dawn doesn’t face you. Instead, she breathes heavily as your manhood goes a little bit further into her inner walls. Then, with the nod of her head, she looks back at you and says, “Yeah, I’m fine. Keep going.”

You’re less than convinced by her tone, but waiting any longer would just serve to make the situation that much more awkward for her. With more gentleness than you’re used to, you leisurely allow yourself deeper inside, feeling her cervix much more quickly than you expected. Luster Dawn, meanwhile, continues to breathe heavily, letting out small, quiet moans whenever you rub against her sensitive spots. Even though the feeling is familiar to what you’d normally get with her mom, Luster Dawn grips you in a unique way, giving you entirely different sensations despite her vagina basically doing the exact same thing.

“Does…” she begins, blushing profusely. “Does it feel OK?”

Seriously, someone needs to give her an award for being the cutest filly ever.

“Yeah, it feels amazing,” you say with a smile, which she happily mimics.

“Really? How about this?”

Suddenly, she backs up her hips even further, pressing you against the door behind you while giving you a sultry smirk that only serves to make you grow to practically twice the length you were before. If she wants to play like that, you’ll wipe the smirk right off of her face. Then, grabbing her by the hips, you start going at twice the speed as before, your balls practically slamming against her clit while her mouth turns into an O shape.

“How about now, Luster?” you ask sarcastically. “You still doing OK?”

“Deeper, Daddy! Your cock feels so good!”

After all the foreplay you’ve done tonight, you’re glad you can cut right to the chase this time. Pulling her by the tail, you slide yourself in until you hit her cervix again, making her tongue hang out of her mouth as her eyes practically fall into the back of her head. You’re putting so much energy into your thrusts that even you’re grunting at this point, but that only causes her insides to grip you tighter, making you fight harder to push yourself between her filly lips.

Before you know it, the room is echoing the sounds of Luster Dawn’s moans and the splashing between her thighs. Her natural lubricant completely coats your skin, which is probably the only thing allowing you to enter her at this point based on how tight she is on the inside. Even though your dick hurts from how much it’s stretching, the feeling of her pussy pulling your shaft makes you want to give her every inch you can possibly grow.

“Ahn! Yes! Yes! Mm~!”

You bite your lip as you feel your shaft twitch below. “Luster, if you keep moaning like that, you’re gonna make me finish already.”

“You mean it? Then what if I do this? AAAAAHHHHH!!!”

The filly’s voice breaks, hitting a pitch that you didn’t even hear during her orgasm earlier. It catches you so off guard that you actually jump, stopping your hips before the stimulation accidentally overwhelms you. “Seriously, Luster! You’re gonna make me cum!”

“Ah! Ah! I love your dick so much, Daddy! Give it to me! Put it all inside me!”

You try to hold back as much as you can, but even when you try to stop humping her, you can still feel your balls clenching up, getting ready to finish her off. There’s nothing you can do now. Finally, you dig your fingers into Luster Dawn’s waist and thrust your hips as fast as you can go, completely giving into your instincts and experiencing as much pleasure as you can before it’s over. Just a little bit more. Just a little… bit… more…

“Mmf!”

You bite down on your lip as your dick explodes with way more semen than you expected for your third time in one night. The filly’s back arches as she feels your manhood throbbing between her legs, panting femininely and wincing with every pulse. There’s no way her vagina was built to handle the amount of semen from someone like you, which becomes very apparent once you slip your dick in a little further just to see your seed dripping out the sides. Still, though, for her first time, she handled you like an absolute pro. It’s just a shame that this’ll probably be the last time you get to do this with her… Well, at least until next year.

Finally, once you’ve finished coating her insides, you pull yourself back out, wincing at the pain that comes from ejaculating three times within one hour. Luster Dawn, meanwhile, keeps her hips up while her legs shake weakly. You can only imagine how sensitive she is right now and how much it would hurt to move any part of her body.

“Ugghhhhhhh,” she moans, allowing her entire body to collapse. You hate to laugh based on how exhausted she probably is, but the way she’s acting is just too cute to resist.

“You feeling alright there?”

“Too good. I wish I’d known sooner so I could have prepared myself.”

You lift an eyebrow. “You mean with another guy?”

“No, I mean like with a hairbrush or something.” Again, you laugh, but Luster Dawn simply smirks, her eyes trailing off to the side as her smile gradually fades. “Hey, Anon? You weren’t just being nice to me, were you? You really thought I did OK?”

Now you’re the one with the smirk. “Luster, you were better than OK. I’m just sad that we won’t be able to do it together anymore.”

Once the statement leaves your mouth, though, the filly tilts her head to the side. “What are you talking about? We’re gonna do it all the time. We’re just not gonna tell my mom about it.”

Hang on… Isn’t that cheating? Before you can think too deeply, however, she gets up, places a hoof to your chest and lifts her face high enough to plant a small kiss on your lips, a kiss that’s far improved from the first one she tried tonight.

“It’s her own fault for introducing us in the first place.” Luster Dawn then adds a wink for good measure, which makes you suddenly remember something very important.

“Hey, could you not tell your mom about the whole… me cumming inside you thing? I think she’d get a little mad at me if she found out.”

The filly takes a minute for the message to register before giggling deviously into her hoof. “Looks like we’re both gonna have some secrets. Now let’s go back out there before my mom eats all the cake! I’m starving!”

You roll your eyes with a smile. This night has been hectic, unexpected, and probably the best night of your entire life. You have no idea how you’re going to thank Starlight for all the--

“Seriously, mom?! You actually ate all of it?!”

The moment the door opens, you see your darling girlfriend with her mouth full, chocolate smeared all over her lips, and standing next to an empty tray where the cake used to be. As you stare at her in shock, however, she simply smiles back and says with a mouth full of cake, “Happy birthday, sugar bear!”