Equestria Handyman

“And then what happened?” One of the kids a pre-teen filly dressed as a witch, looks at Mark in expectation as he smiles, looking at all the kids around the fire, them looking at him with hopeful eyes, making him chuckle, after finishing his last story. At the time the human was wearing a gladiator costume complete with a fake black leather gauntlets, a big leather belt with a lion face on the front, an armour skirt on top of a white one, long sandals, a helmet and a red cape

“I think that is enough for tonight, kids.”

“Aww.” They look down in disappointment. “I wanted to know what happened next with Zombie Starlight.”

“I wanted to know if the human became a king of the vampires?”

“Big deal, what about the memory jackal, that monster is still on the loose!” They all voice their complaints. Making him smile and laugh a bit more.

“Tell you what, if you invite me to your next campfire, I might continue one of those stories, but you will have to choose between yourselves which one.” Immediately their eyes light up, and they start to discuss why their suggestion should be continued among themselves, as Mark leaves them to their devices to enjoy the rest of Nightmare Night.

Exploring the town the human takes a moment to admire the decorations and games placed everywhere as colts and fillies run around the street asking for candy.

“There you are” Ms. Cheerliee, wearing a sunflower costume, calls for Mark as she approaches “How did the storytelling go?”

“Hi Ms. Cheerilee, it went well thankfully, I’m not exactly good when it comes to this kind of thing but well I did my best”

“Thanks again for filling in for Zecora these last couple of days as she recovers her sore throat. It was very thoughtful of you to keep the kids entertained before the festivities, and for what I am hearing, it looks like your stories were quite the hit.”

“It was nothing, I mainly was recalling some of the chores I have had to do these last couple of days and…well spin them to try to make them scarier.”

“Oh, so is Princess Celestia actually pregnant now?” She asks with a smirk.

“What? No! That was mostly to have a happy ending to that story, though it was getting very grim and…wait how much do you know?”

“Some of my students recalled the story in class dear, a teacher can hear snips and parts of it.” She chuckles a bit. “But don’t let it go giving you a big head now, ok? Ponies might start to think you actually have been chasing Princesses to add to your herd.”

Mark shares her laugh. “Yeah, and that would only be silly.”

“Indeed, speaking of which, how are they doing? I heard about their little burn after their trip.”

“Pretty good actually, I rubbed some ointment all over their bodies and washed them well to take away the pain and they are good as new, still reddish but it is almost gone now.”

She had to pause a bit. “Y-You rub ointment…?”

“All over they bodies, yep, that is what it means to be a good coltfriend, help them recover make sure to be as comfortable as possible, and even give them a deep relaxing deep body massage to help them sleep as my hands make their way on their soft fur getting rid of all the knots I find with delicacy and presion pressing just on the right places until…”

“OK!” Cheerlie stops him from continuing with a completely red face. “I-I get the picture, by Celestia do I get it now, glad to hear they are ok. So will you be coming to the party at Town hall?”

“Sure! We will be there” He nods and turns around. “I should go check on them, nice to see you again Cheerilee, happy Nightmare Night.”

“Happy Nightmare Night!” She waves back, before sighing.

‘Oh my goodness, not sure if that was intentional or not, but he sure knows how to paint a picture in your head. I almost water the plants here’

Heading to the castle Mark could hear some music coming from the place and when he open the door, he was greeted by Twilight costume party going on full swing as Vinyl was busy playing the music as ponies in costume were dancing or chatting around the dance floor as he traverse his way around the crown until finally he found his herd talking with Octavia, Lyra, Bon Bon, Colgate, Trixie and Moondancer.

“Seriously? A beaker? How did you get that stuck on your head?” Surprise asks with a laugh as Moondancer finishes narrating the story of their childhood with her friends at the school for the gifted.

Deciding to take advantage of their coloration most of his mares decided to choose a costume with a red theme on it. Umbral opting to be a pink ninja that complimented the red of her fur, Surprise a demon, Milky a firefighter and oddly enough Fluttershy deciding to choose to be a vampire a slightly messy one with how frizzled, she made her mane as she put on fake bat wings and fangs that oddly compliment her black outfit that mixes well with her light reddish yellow fur.

“Swear to Celestia it’s true, we were just messing with the glasses, preting they were musical instruments, then my nose was itching and next thing I knew I was running around the classroom screaming with a triangular face.” Colgate continues as they all share a laughter. “Boy did the teacher get pissed once they managed to take that thing off of my head. Too bad they had to break it to do so.”

My parents ended up having to pay for that beaker that day.” Colgate finishes the story as they share a laugh, Mark finding a somewhat bit of irony in how she was talking about a lab accident while wearing a mad scientist costume. Like it was to be expected, Lyra and Bon Bon decided to do a couples costume dressing as Kangaroos being extra adorable in how they add their bellies to the costume by adding a stuffed baby kangaroo in their pouches, Trixie seems to be dressed as a magician with a elegant suit and top hat, Moondancer actually decided to dress as Trixie and Octavia choose a more elegant choice coming to the party as victorian noble complete with powdered face, wig and fan.

‘She is committed to the disguise I will give her that.’

Mark nods as the group finally sees him, and Surprise waves at him. “Oh, and here he is, Marky! Our Gladiator King returns from storytelling time.”

He laughs and shakes his head. “It's just a regular gladiator Surprise, hi everyone.” He waves at them.

“Hi.” Everyone waves back

“It would be a king of gladiators if you had just put on the crown I gave you.”

“It looked like overkill, besides I’m pretty sure you hid my gladiator shirt missy.” He counters back.

“I did not, and it's not like you needed it, if anything it looks better shirtless.”

“No complaints here.” Octavia voiced her approval, gaining an eye roll from Mark.

“So how did storytime go Star? Those kids will be having nightmares for weeks?”

“I’m not that good with stories Umbral, I just invent things from things that happen, mostly when I return the relics.

“Ha! How would you make going to a museum, apologizing to a queen, having a spare battle with some random bull and talking with some guards about putting a piece of jewelry back to its place any interest or scary?” Umbral questions in disbelief.

“Oh you would be surprised.” Mark smirks at the comment. “So…how is Crystal doing?” He asks in worry to his herd.

“Pretty great actually.” Fluttershy nods pointing at the center of the dance floor were what looks to be a crystal alicorn with Fluttershy’s hair, Rarity’s tail, Rainbow’s wings, and Applejack’s general body and ass, Pinkie’s tits, and Twilight’s horn seems happily dancing with Time Turner without a care in the world. With a Princess costume.

“She has been dancing for almost two hours now, the poor dear looks like a kid on Hearth's warming eve”

“Well in her defense she kind of is, isn’t it?” Moondancer points out. “I mean like she literally was born yesterday.”

“Can you call that born though?” Bon Bon comments. “I mean she is the tree of harmony borrowing Twilight and her friends features in…like a golem sort of deal? I’m sorry I’m still trying to process the fact that the tree of harmony actually asked you to let her use your appearance to have fun on Nightmare Night.”

“Oh it’s ok, honestly I’m trying to understand it myself too.” Fluttershy nods “But she looked so sad and only wanted to be a part of the group for a bit. So we just couldn’t refuse.”

“And are you sure, this is just temporary?” Lyra questions looking at how she was now dancing with Gladius.

“That is what she told us at the very least.” She simply shrugs “And Twilight confirmed it, it’s like when we took the elements, she is extending her reach, but eventually will have to return to the original tree.”
“Ah ok, then the more the merrier I say.” Lyra proclaims with a smile. “Boy will this Nightmare Night be full of surprises.”

“Agreed, and we can’t let her have all the fun.” Bon Bon takes her wife's hand. “May I have this dance?”

She only giggles and blushes as the pair goes to the dance floor too. The rest of their friends follow their example, or have to excuse themselves for a snack, or to go talk with some other friends leaving the herd alone, Mark pulling Fluttershy closer to him.

“Are you still trying to…help Crystal with the other thing?”

She smiles and nods, “Flash Sentry already decided to help with that, Twilight was kind of fascinated with the whole experience and well, they mention something about apologizing for something?” she says, trying to recall exactly what Twilight said to them.

“Ah ok.” Mark smiles and nods. “Was afraid that was still in the air, she seemed a bit vulnerable with how wide eyed, and new to a lot of experience was and what not.”

“Don’t worry, we have it all under control.”

“Hey lovebirds.” Umbral says. “You are gonna make us jealous here with all the whispers.”

They chuckle as Mark goes and hugs the Thestral from behind. “Don’t worry my sweet little bat, I’m here for you too.”

“O-Okay, that is enough, no need for the mushy stuff either.” She stutters with a blush as he starts to nibble her ear. “Are you sure?”

“S-Star, we are in public.” She mocks panic, as her blush increases making everyone giggle at Umbral’s reaction.

“Well that aside, we all are happy you are free now Mark, now we can celebrate the rest of the night properly.” Milky smiles as her eyes turn sultry and approach him. “And the girls and I have a special surprise for you.”

He gulps, caught by her change of attitude, seeing how the others follow her example.

“What do you have in mind?” He looks at them in anticipation.”

“Ah ha, that would ruin the treat.” Surprise pokes his nose. “Let just say we have thought of a special little trick for our cute little stallion.”

“Girls, you still are a bit burnt and sore…there.” Mark reminds them with some worry. “Perhaps we should wait just a tinsy bit more and…”

“Shh” Fluttershy puts her finger on his lips “We know sweetie, and we appreciate your thoughts, that is why until we are ready we came up with an idea before that.”

“O-Ok.” He blushes and looks at them in expectation, as they all giggle and nuzzle his frame as they share a small moment, before something catches Umbral’s attention.

“Hey Flutters, isn’t that your brother flirting with Crystal?”

“What?!” She looks ahead in horror and indeed she sees Zephyr dressed in a black burglar outfit with rope included, pulling Crystal away to the snack table as she giggles lightly as he talks.

“Has anyone ever told you that you have the most beautiful pair of wings I have ever seen?”

“No, I don’t believe they have.”

“Oh heck no, not even if it's just my wings!” Dash says approaching the two, dressed as a shadowbolt.

“Oh my! I better go solve this before Dash makes a scene.” Fluttershy says, before rushing to Crystal and Zephyr.

“You have give it to him, he really knows Dash on an unconscious level.”

The mares nod in approval of that. “But anyway, enough about that drama, come on honey, let's have some fun? This is our first nightmare night as a herd isn’t it?” Milky asks.

“Hey you’re right, it is the first time I have ever celebrated Nightmare Night like this. And now I’m wondering how do you celebrate in Trottingham, or Prance, or Baltimare.” He tells in interest, making Surprise giggle.

“Oh there is plenty to talk about, don't worry, but first let's check the games! I want to see what Ponyville has to offer.” Surprise says guiding the group to the game section of the castle where they find Pinkie who oddly enough decided to dress as an angel which she and Surprise mentioned, and at some point wander off to play some kind of prank, and even thought about ideas for the future.

“Should…we be worried, we might have created a double sized problem with them pranking around.”

“We will cross that bridge if it happens honey, we will cross it if it happens.” Milky nods in worry to herself, as her and Umbral decide to enjoy the rest of the night together for a while and mingle a little.

At that moment in Canterlot

An impatient Luna was tapping her hoof on the floor while waiting for her sister to come out of the bathroom. “Come on Tia! We are gonna be late, and I swear I will leave if you don’t get your flank out of that bathroom right now.”

“Just a moment Lulu, I’m almost…done!” Celestia replies in victory as she exits the stall showing the night princess her costume of Nightmare Moon to her. For the most part it was a dead ringer but no matter how much she tried the sun princess simply couldn’t make her mane shine like stars like her sister could, it looked fake upon closer inspection.

“How do I look?” She spins around so Luna could admire the costume properly. “Hmm not bad, you got the helmet right, the breastplate fit, I say the fur coloration worked flawlessly, if not for the mane, I say you could make a convincing Nightmare Moon dear sister.”

“Thank you and I must say.” Smirking, Celestia admired how Luna almost made her feel like she was looking in a mirror on how close she looks to her, as she decided to go disguised as Celestia, coloring her fur, and adding some fake hairlines to complete her rainbow color, it didn’t radiate as much and the glimmer of her stars could give it away but over all, Luna looked like a slightly smaller version of Celestia. “You can truly pull the Princess Celestia appearance sister, say, would you be interested in passing as me in a meeting or two?”

“Very funny sister.” Luna rolls her eyes and passes her some fake fangs. “Now take this to complete the image.

“Do I have too? It's hard to talk with the fake fangs in Lulu.”

“It is part of the mystique Tia, the colts and fillies are expecting to be scared by Nightmare Moon so she collects the candy they offer to them, I hardly think a growl would be difficult with them, and it is not like anyone is expecting you to make an elegy.”

“Fine.” Celestia picks up the fake teeth. “But once the scare is over, they come out so we can enjoy the rest of the festivities.”

“Fair enough.” They all walk to the balcony and prepare to board the chariot to Ponyville. “I still find it curious how you decided to want to be Nightmare Moon this year dear sister.” Luna eyes her suspiciously. “May I ask what got your interest in the tradition?”

“It felt right to help you from time to time after well…everything that happened.” Celestia looks down in sorrow, until Luna grabs her hand. “It is all in the past sister, I forgive you.”
That made her cheer up. “Regardless, I wanted to be more involved in your life and join in the fun.”

Luna smiles and nods. “Sister, I’m actually touched, didn’t know you would like to be involved like this, really I’m flattered.”

“Don’t mention it, and speaking of flattery.” Her smile turns into a smirk. “I might have arranged a little treat for you.”

“Tia, what did you do?” She asks in worry.

“Oh, nothing too big really, mostly though on wanting to repay dear Mark for his help dealing with the relics and their safe return, and a form of congratulations for finishing his lessons in courtship. By inviting him on a date night, with approval from his herd.”

“So you are gonna juggle being Nightmare Moon AND having a date on the same night?”

“Not exactly.” She smiles and pats her shoulder. “It's obvious that I would be busy, so it's a good thing I’m not Celestia tonight right?” She questions with a wink, making Luna blush and look away in realization.

“Tia, you can’t be serious!”

“Why not? Come on Luna, it's Nightmare Night, why don’t we have some fun, have a bit of a trick between us sisters. One free date with no strings attached.” She gets closer. “It will be like the ultimate tease.”

She mulls it over and looks away. “I don’t think that would be fair to dear Mark, don’t you think?”

“Like I said, his herd is fully aware, and on board with the situation, and let’s face it Luna. You have been curious about a turn ever since Fluttershy.”

“Do not!” She gets defensive with an intense blush.

Celestia only raises an eyebrow at her. “Ok maybe a little, but that is besides the point!”

“Luna I’m telling you it will be fine, and it's just one date, I’m not asking you to sleep with him either am I?”

“I…suppose that is true”

“So what do you say? Do we prank our friend?”

“Hmmm! Ah, ok! One prank but only because I want to see his face when he sees you teasing him like I do!”

“That is the spirit, but I should warn you, Mark isn’t as innocent as he used to be, dear sister. He has improved and…well even I have to confess that I might have had some sway over some of his charms.”

“Oh really now?” Now it was Luna’s turn to smirk. “Do tell dear sister.”

“Another time perhaps, for now, it’s time to find our friends.”

“You said it Tia, Hehe Mark Star will not know what hit him.”

At that moment the human in question felt an odd chill in his spine before looking back. “Is something matter sweetie?” Fluttershy call looking at him as the group headed to the forest to the Nightmare Moon statue where kids were marching to make their offers, Pinkie and Surprise acting as literal angel and demons of morals to the adults, to try convincing them to offer candy too until Umbral and Milky stop their shenanigans.

“Nothing, really I just had an odd chill all of the sudden he confesses looking at her, after feeling that there was nothing behind him.

Smiling, Fluttershy approaches, and uses her wing to bring him into a hug. “It’s ok to admit you are cold Marky, you are shirtless after all, but don’t worry, I will keep you warm.”

“Thanks.” He gets closer and closer, enjoying the sensation of her feathers and the warmth they give him as they advance.

“You know it’s a bit early, but I thought I could maybe tell you a little bit of the surprise we have for you.”

“Huh?” He looks at her in interest as she nods.

“Well the girls and I were talking and we don’t mind taking a rest of being intimate for a while after our soul bonding, at least for a bit, but still want to give you a little something so we thought that maybe you could take Princess Celestia out on a date.”

“The pr…!” He almost shouts but stops himself. “Fluttershy, I can’t exactly take Celly out with…”

“Don’t worry we thought of that too.” She stops him before he finishes. “It’s nightmare night silly, we all have been wearing disguises, if anyone sees you, they would only think she is just in disguise, see?” She points at the flower mares to make her point, as they too were dressed as Princess Celestia.

“Oh I get it now.”

“We understand your relationship is purely casual, and she is just a very good friend of the herd, but we thought you might enjoy this one tinsy night out, for yourself.”

“I don’t know Flutters, it feels like I would be ditching you in your time of need.”

She smiles, touched by his words, and gives him a kiss on the cheek. “You wouldn’t be doing that, we have all night together to have fun, and spend Nightmare Night as a herd, plus you have been taking such good care of us. So just think of this as a small present from us.” She nuzzles his cheek again. “We can have as many dates as we want anytime, we can give this night to her.”

“Well, if you girls are really ok with it.” He nods at the idea, as she smiles. “We do, we all are, see?” She shows him a text of Fluttershy asking and all the mares saying yes.

“Ah nice, that clears things up.”

“Also, I think it’s kind of obvious, but maybe for this date you two could have a little…play of sorts.”

“Oh?”

“Well, she is supposed to pretend to be a mare in disguise isn’t she? Then why don’t you play along, pretend this is the first time you met the princess this way, like you want to invite her out.”

“You mean like a test, where I ask her out?”

“Exactly! She wants to help you now that you finished your lessons, plus it could be kind of a bit of role play.”

“Well, well, well, Fluttershy you have become more kinky since you came back, haven’t you?”

She blushes and looks away with a nervous giggle. “Maybe a little?”

He smiles lovingly at her hearing that laugh, and nods “I’d loved to, thank you so much, all of you. I will make sure to repay your kindness for this.”

“You don’t have to, we only want to help you make this night memorable.”

“Trust me Fluttershy, something tells me it will be, especially if Molly decides to say hi too, always wondered, how would she fare on a date.”

Speeding up a little, the two reach the group as Cheerilee, covering for Zecora, starts telling the story of Nightmare Night to the kids while in front of the Nightmare Moon statue, as a blue fog starts to appear and surround the group.

Soon a shadowy figure starts to loom into the sky as Mark smiles with the announcement of the Princesses appearing, and the kids screaming with Pinkie, and Surprise put their candy in front of the statue, before being scared off when the statue's eyes seem to come to life. After being engulfed by the fog it was replaced by the actual monster, that roars at them making their manes stand on end as they ran off, while the adults watch them leave and chuckle lightly for a moment waiting for the final kid to be out of earshot to turn around and clap at the mare of the night in question for yet another good performance.

“Aww, thank you, thank you, it was nothing.” Nightmare Moon takes out her fake fangs, and bows to the audience as they cheer for her, as Mark takes advantage to admire the features of said ‘monster.’ He had heard stories, and saw the mural before, but this was actually the first time he had a good view of the mare in the moon in question.

All other Nightmare night’s Luna seems too busy or just being a plain troll to let him see her properly as her alter ego, so each time he tries to talk, he only manages to see blurs and glimpse at her figure.

Now that he had the chance, he had to be honest to himself and admit, she had a sort of attractive air to her. The armour looks to hug her chest just a bit too tight, to leave space for imagination, the dark blue fur, the starry long hair blowing in the wind. It really adds layers of mystique and intrigue to the overall appearance, and he sure was captivated by it.
As well as being confused as something about her appearance that seems to improve her height seems oddly…familiar but he couldn’t put his finger on exactly what.

“Another great performance, your highness.” Cheerilee compliments Luna. “I must say, it is interesting how you decided to mix things up a little this year.”

“Really?” Nightmare looks at her confused as she nods.

“Yeah, normally you like to create some build up before the big reveal, some maniac low cackling, echo warnings on the wind, speedy shadows from tree to tree, honestly I don’t remember the last time you decided to be so direct. Are you perhaps experimenting with a different technique?”

“………Yeah, that is exactly what I was doing.” Nightmare finally replies after a small awkward silence making Cheerilee giggle.

“Well it sure seems effective, will you be joining us for the after trick or treat party tonight, your majesty?”

“It would be my pleasure.” She nods once, “But of course I should first scare off any lagging kids that might want to escape curfew first right?”

“Of course, we wouldn’t want anyone to end up gobbled up right?” The teacher winks as all the adults share a laugh, and waves goodbye to Nightmare as she turns to mist and goes chasing the running kids.

“After the trick or treat party?” Mark questions his herd as they look at him confused.

“You are joking right? You've never been to one?”

“I always thought the party ended when the kids made the offer and Luna picked up the candy.” The human defends himself. “I mean isn’t that the whole point of tonight?”

“Well he technically has a point there, plus after Luna arrived you mostly spent the night trying to catch her, didn't you honey?”

“Yeah, pretty much.” He admits to the group.

“Well then consider this a new experience, Star.” Umbral smirks at him and grabs his arm. “Prepare to meet ‘Nightmare Night After dark!” She exclaims with all the adults yelling their approval and heading back to town.

“Ok, I think I see what is going on, in this party everyone will be dressing suggestively?” He looked at his herd in worry.

“Nah, you are thinking of a Las Pegasus style party, relax Marky this party is fairly tame honest.” Milky reassures him as they walk back from the path they came. “And the princess is most likely waiting for you there.” She whispers the last part with a smirk.

Following the group they all headed to the center of town where as they get closer and closer to Town Hall, the human starts to notice that less children were in sight, and previously tame costumes were getting a bit more daring, particularly on the mares, as he starts to see the classic sexy teacher, police, nurse and so on in normally reserved ponies, including the cakes that when he took a glance, he sees Carrot still as a chef, but shirtless while CupCake seems to be a cake mixer judging by the bowl on her hips acting as pants and mayan pieces of clothes with different shapes of yellow on it, hugging her body pretty tight.

“Girls you said the ponies would not dress suggestively.”

“Well, ok some do, but not all.” Umbral clarifies.,

“Look, this party is not that different than what you are familiar with, it’s just Nightmare Night for the adults of town, the moment at night where all the herds, single ponies and couples in general get out, and enjoy some harmless games, sharing a beer or two, starting your usual contests, and entering into scary houses.” Milky explains.

“Why do they reserve the last one for just the adults?”

“Those are stronger scares Marky.” Fluttershy explains “One thing is just a small scare and a good time, another is traumatizing or scarring their childhoods.”

“Oh? Oh! Ok I get it, so it is mostly just a more adult themed party then.”

“And mixer.” Milky adds as the spa twins were passing by from the other side with sultry eyes at them, with a sexy cat assembly of black for Aloe and white for Lotus.

“Hi.” They say to them at the same time before walking away.

“…yeah we better stay close, until we see the Princess just in case.”

And just like she said, after reaching the center of town, the group saw the mare of the hour happily munching on a caramel apple by the town fountain all by herself, ironically without any costume but as Fluttershy told him, it would be kind of redundant as every pony most likely would have thought she was just another mare in disguise, a less appealing copy of her from the looks of things, as stallions, herds, and mares were swarming other Celestia clones with more scandalous versions of her regular attire.

‘Ha, if only they knew how close they are to the actual Princess Celestia.’

Mark smirks and laughs internally, shaking his head at how innocent the ponies in town could be at times like these.

“Ah, speaking of the Princess, there she is.” Milky claps her hands together.

“Have fun tiger.” Umbral winks at him and slaps his ass, moving him forward as Fluttershy giggles. “You…are not coming to say hi?”

“I think it would be a bit suspicious if a herd starts talking with the less slutty looking Princess, casually, especially when, well, one of us is an element and might actually know the real Princess.” Milky summarizes.

“Good point.”

“Besides, we already have plans with Surprise and Princess Luna, so don’t worry about us, you just have fun.” Umbral says with a smile.

“And remember, just like a game, she isn’t the real Princess Celestia and this is the first time you two meet casually, got it?” Fluttershy winks at him, making him chuckle.

“Don’t worry Fluttershy I think I can pretend. Do you want me to call when I get back home?”

“Ha! Good one Star, don’t worry, we will be at Applejack’s.” Umbral winks at him.' The farmer wanted to tell us something and invite us over for a sleepover, so the house is all yours. Enjoy.”

“Ah.” He wanted to ask a couple of questions, but ultimately decided to hold his tongue and instead just waved at them and went to meet Princess Celestia, not noticing the contained giggles from his herd.

“By the stars, this is gonna be so funny when he finds out.” Umbral chuckles under her breath.

“Do you think they will be mad?”

“Maybe at first, but well, they both like to tease each other, and we aren’t forcing anything here, whatever happens, it was their own decision.” Milky says to the rest as they nod and leave to meet with the real Celestia and Surprise.

“Good evening, your highness.” Mark approaches Celestia with a calm smile earning her attention as she turns to look at him, and the disguise he was wearing.

“Good evening young Mark.” She returns the smile, internally giggling to herself.

“I must say, I knew of Princess Luna’s role tonight and how she likes to spend it scaring kids, but I didn’t imagine I would be seeing you here too Princess.”

“I should be the same in how easy you were able to find me among so many copies of me, kind sir.” She plays along, looking at the other copies of Celestia, before looking back at him with a smirk. “Have you been paying more attention to my appearance with each visit to Canterlot than I originally thought?”

Mark was caught completely off guard and blushed for a second, never expecting the Princess of the sun to decide to tease him. Not like this, for that matter, for a moment he even couldn’t help but actually scan her, once she said that and found something kind of odd about her like with Luna there was something different yet familiar with the Princess but he didn’t exactly know what.

Recovering from his stupor, and remembering how this night, she mostly only wanted to pass as another mare disguised as herself. He nodded and played along with their little game.

“Is that so obvious? My apologies if I made you feel uncomfortable, but under the beautiful moonlight, there is an incredible beauty that is near impossible to miss and confused me greatly on how no other pony has noticed yet.”

Now it was Luna time to blush and giggle uncontrollably at the compliment. “But sir, such flattery might make your herd get jealous.”

“I hardly think that, since they encouraged me to talk with the Princess in the first place.” He grabs her hand and gives her a gentle kiss. “May I have the honour of accompanying you this night?”

“You may.” She nods with a bit more eagerness than intended, as she grabs his arm, and the two depart to enjoy the rest of the games on Nightmare Night.

“I must say, I’m thankful that you came to see me, Mark. I was beginning to feel a bit lonely and self aware of how little attention I was receiving. It is so reassuring for the king of the gladiators to have noticed me. Even if you are missing the crown.” She decides to point out, earning a groan from him.

“I’m just a normal gladiator, your highness.” He corrected her.

“Oh my mistake then.” She giggles again at his expression.

‘Oh Mark, just you wait. Before this night ends, you will not be able to look my sister in the eyes for at least a week!’

She plots maliciously in her head, as they advance through town. Luckily the rest of the night was spent without any major events, as just like his herd told him. The games and activities were fairly tame, like in any other carnaval, and the adult themed section was mostly reserved by the selling of beers, some competition that Mark couldn’t tell if it was a bikini, or sexy contest, the scary mazes and only and in a way fascinating enough a masked section for mingling. Kind of like blind dates but everyone was wearing a big mask so the other couldn’t really know what their date looks like, giving a social experiment vibe, in how the participants would be needed to connect by personality before appearance.

After enjoying a series of games, the two decided to take a break and rest on a bench for a while to talk for a bit.

“I must say, tonight has been nothing but fun, Mark. Thanks again for giving me a tour, you really know how to show a gal a good time.” Celestia smiled before chewing on some cotton candy.

“It was my pleasure, and I have to say, for someone not in costume you really know how to scare Celly…ah I mean Princess…”

“Please, you don’t need a title here, remember, I’m not actually the real Princess.” Celestia tells him with a wink.

“Right, sorry, I’m just used to it I suppose.”

“It's ok, so what were you saying about me being scary?”

“Well, mostly how you seem to be really good at it, when that group of ponies dressed as werewolves tried to scare us, and you managed to scare them back with one simple glance and a stern warning? Goosebumps actual goosebumps, how do you do that?”
“Oh there is no major secret about it, you only need to embrace your character and ask the question, what could I possibly have that could make it scary? You can make anything scary with the right strategy.”

“You’re kidding.”

“No, I’m serious, test me, point me at any costume and I will tell you exactly how I could make them scarier”

“Ha, ok, let's see what about that classic due?” He points at two ponies sharing a costume of a donkey.

“Easy, add streamers and fake blood on the front part, put skeleton leggins, and a skeleton mask on the interior, complete with guts and you get half digested zombies.”

“Wow…that is creepy, ok then let's see what about that one?”

He challenges her, pointing at a fairly simple brick costume.

“Add cracks, spider webs, starving fake marks on the face and white paint to make it paler and you get a ghost halfway out from a wall, come on Mark give me a challenge.” she taunts him with a smirk.

He starts to look around trying to find something that might be harder to give a spookie twist on, be just too adorable, or plain and simple, yet Celestia seems to be on fire tonight.

“A full body bunny?”

“Red contact and some foam”

“A paper bag?”

“What's inside the bag?”

“Haha, ok now this, I’m sure you can’t add a spooky twist, the sexy/ slutty costume line of costumes?”

“Two words, void eyes.” She wiggles her eyebrows at him. “Do you give up?”

Sighing in defeat, Mark chuckles and shakes his head. “Damn Celly, you really are on fire, I didn’t think you liked Nightmare Night so much?”

“Well of course, I might have had my reserves at first, but it really grew on me, this night.”

“You really put a lot of effort into making sure to honor your sister's memory don’t you?”

“Hmm?”

“I mean, don’t get me wrong, Luna simply lives for this night and I don’t think there is any other mare that looks forward to this more than her.”

“Oh right, right.” She nods, almost blowing her cover.

“But at the same time, I still wonder why you choose a night that focuses on, well, the scary part of the story instead of how Luna really is?”

That caught her attention, as she looked at him with more interest.

“How Luna really is? And how exactly would you describe her?” She asks with a raised eyebrow and a smirk.

“Well for starters, I would say sexy.” He counters with a smirk of his own, making her eyes widen in surprise. “Excuse me?”

“Haha, relax Celly, don’t go getting jealous now either.” He lightly shoves her side, ignoring the pout she was making. “But in all honesty, it goes without saying how incredible Luna really is, she is very kind, outgoing, a bit of a prankster, but all in good nature, a devoted worker, especially when it comes to guarding and protecting the dreams, and well the list goes on. So why did you choose to make a night all about how she could scare you?”

“Well…” She keeps her head low, trying to avoid the heat forming on her cheeks and the grin from the shower of compliments, “…it was mostly a consequence of time dear Mark, originally this night was to honour the memory of my sister as she was, but as time went on and generations passed the story, especially with the idea of Nightmare Moon still fresh on then parents and grandparents, traditions start to change and bend over and over again, until a completely different story was formed. I tried to stop it, but by then, well the night in a way was bringing joy to the younglings, so I didn’t have the heart to stop. I did prevent it from being altered further though.”

“I see.” He nods before noticing his date still hanging her head down.

“Damn it. Sorry, I didn’t mean to open an old wound.” He admits in shame, placing his hand on her back, eliciting a small eep from the Princess from the contact. “Here I am praising a completely different mare, ignoring completely the date in front of me, Celly you are an incredibly attractive lady too, in fact I didn’t want to say anything, but did you add something to yourself, there is something…different about you.”

“How exactly?” She asks in worry that her cover was blown.

“Heck if I know, I just can’t put my finger on exactly what it is, but you seem different in a way, and I swear your hip has become a touch bigger, and rounder in all the right places.” He confesses, before realizing what he just did.

“N-Not that I was staring or anything! I-I mean there is nothing wrong with your flanks, they are magnificent! N-Not that I’m saying you are fat, or anything of the sorts, I’m just saying they kind of remind me of L-Luna! Ah that is worse, I swear I haven’t been staring at your sister's ass either, and…”

He keeps digging deeper, and deeper, until he hears Celestia laughing at his antics, and silences him by placing a finger on his lips.

“Just stop Marky, before you dig yourself to the other side of the planet.” She suggests with a smirk.

“You…aren’t angry?” He asks in disbelief?

Luna had to pause and think on a response for a moment, before continuing. “It’s not that I’m offended, because I’m not, because I’m happy that you acknowledge me and my sister as mares.”

‘Huh? Wait, is she still pretending that we didn’t have history?’

“But…” Her gaze turned sultry, as she grabbed his hands. “…if you wish to make it up to me, then I wouldn’t object to an invitation to your residence.”

Getting the idea, he smiles for a moment before returning to his surprise act. “Wait, Princess, do you want to go back to my place?”

“Oh my Mark, you are so forward! But since you insist.” They both stand up, and she hugs his arm leaning her head against his shoulder. “Let’s go.”

Deciding to just play along, he nods and guides her back to his home. At an appropriate time, all things considered, as there were very few ponies still up on the street, for how late it was getting.

“So this is where the magic happens?” Celestia smirks, as once inside she didn’t waste time in voicing her intention, by grabbing his cheeks and planting a strong kiss that caught him off guard as they shared a small intimate moment.

Deciding not to deepen the kiss, and ending it surprised, as it startled Mark. He was left confused by the action, as she slowly made her way to the second floor motioning him to follow, where she quickly admires the place, and the huge bed surrounded by medium sized ones.

“Yeah I know it’s kind of weird, but I’m still kind of getting used to how a herd would actually sleep, and I thought one huge bed would eventually have to have the length of the entire room to keep us all, which would be impractical and would be more of a hassle to have.

So instead I thought of having one big one and a couple of medium sized ones, spread around the room for easy cleaning and…other things.”

“I can see the functionality.” She says with her focus on a fairly big wardrobe on one of the walls.

‘Hmm that would not do, pretty soon this room will have to be expanded and remodeled for a herd to live in, still I can see the logic behind a bed this big, there is only so much a bed can hold before it starts to smoother the ones sleeping in, more beds could give a bit more mobility and space for everyone to breath more easily. Hmm maybe with some enchantments here and there too…’

She wonders for a second, before shaking her head and smirking at him, as she slowly makes her way to the bed with a sway to her hips. “So, what exactly are those ‘other things’ you were talking about? '' She sat on the edge of the bed, giving him a come hither look, and biting her lower lip.

‘Huh so you want to continue playing Celly? Well ok fine by me.’

Smiling, he approaches the bed and sits next to her. “Oh, I’m pretty sure you know what I’m talking about.”

“Maybe I don’t?” She says with a giggle. “Maybe I will need an example?” She pretends to be innocent as their faces get closer.

“Maybe I should give you a demonstration.”

“Maybe you should.”

They were inches away from each other, before closing their eyes and sharing a slow long tongue filled kiss, as they hugged one another. Mark brings her into a hug, being mindful of her wings as he starts to explore her body. His eyes widened, and then looked on in confusion as she felt somewhat different now. Like her usual sweet spots were not where they usually were, in fact she seemed a lot more tame and less hungry in her kisses that he was accustomed to.

Taking his time by exploring this new body, he starts to wrack his head trying to understand what was happening until an idea pops into light.

‘A special surprise, being in costume, a good imitation of Celly. Chrysalis! Of course, it seems like Discord’s lessons have been paying off. Ok Chrissy, let me give you a reward you will never forget.’

Smirking, Mark deepens the kiss, and they both soon start to work on undressing the other, breaking apart to remove Celestia's dress that was in the way exposing her cute little blue bra.

“Like what you see, dear gladiator?” Celestia smirks at him, jiggling her chest a bit.

“Oh greatly.” He returns with a smirk of his own, as he leaves his extended palm over her belly, and slips it under her bra. Getting closer to her face. “But I am way more interested in the treasure that lies beneath it.”

Gently squeezing her right boob, Mark could feel her erect nipple in between his fingers discovering a small arrow shape piercing in them as his other hand got to work on unhooking her bra.

Huh Chrissy, have you been trying something new? You naughty changeling, of course you might be liking a bit of pain after what we had

“Such a diligent, and incredible Princess in front of me. The sensation alone is incredible, I just need to see it.”

While he continues to praise her, Celestia’s face turns red and she blushes hard at being showered in compliments, as Mark continues to expertly manipulate her body.

‘By the moon! Those dreams didn't do him justice, his hands are something else. I just want to see what else he can do....But do I deserve it?’

The princess has to pause at the whispered voice at the back of her head.

‘I’m deceiving my friend here, as he thinks he is with my sister. This prank ran its course and it turned into something else. Before this night ends, he will not be able to look Celestia in the face.….Celestia herself suggested this! No, I deserve it. I'm a good princess too, and he knows it! He has been telling me how incredible I am, directly and indirectly, all night long! And I need to hear it a bit longer.’

Surprising him, the moment he manage to unhook her bra, she grabs his face and plants a stronger kiss, holding nothing back, as her tongue explores his mouth for a solid minute before she let go with a string of saliva still attached, while she continued to look at him with sultry eyes.

“Please, don’t stop, keep talking, tell me how incredible I am. Tell me how much you love my body.”

She requests with some tears forming in her eyes, almost begging to be praised.

‘Oh Chrysalis, you poor thing, you have grown so used to being praised by your subjects? Ok just for tonight I will acquiesce to your request.’

Smiling, Mark nods and gets to work removing her bra from her gorgeous alabaster orbs, smirking a bit at how her disguise was starting to crack.

‘Not bad Chryssy, they sure are huge and mouth watering, but you missed by one single size, still…’

Grabbing her other breast, Mark starts to fondle them, as he sits on top of her with an amorous expression. “You don’t have to request anything my beautiful goddess, your boobs are the object that could drive a noble man crazy. Your Milk…” He leans down and plays with her nipples, using her tongue before sucking delicaly at them treating himself to some milk, and looking at her with a smile, tasting it properly without the pesky mind control that deprived him of his chance the first time, and enjoying the odd flavour of a blueberry pie with a side of strawberry ice cream flavour. “…pure ambrosia.”

Mark stops playing as he leans beside her, and starts to explore her body with his open palm. “Your fur is as soft as velvet, your lips are incredible to kiss, and your perfume is making me go wild.”

During the storm of praises, Celestia’s face just keep getting hotter and hotter as she pants like crazy, moaning and gasping lightly under his touch as he systematically turns her into pudding, making her feel electricity and begging for him to get more daring, as her panties were completely drenched at this point, and her clit was just winking like there was no tomorrow begging for attention.

Something that Mark seems to have read her mind on, while nibbling at her neck and whispering sweet nothings to her, he slowly turns her around so she was now on top of him, granting him access to her back and specifically her wings as he caresses the base of them, leaving them complete outstretched and rigid, while his other hand ventures south, getting lost in the lower part of her dress, and getting closer to his final prize. Stopping briefly at the touch near her entrance made her hold a gasp of delight.

“You shaved, for me?” He smirks at the blushing princess in front of him as he steals a quick kiss. “You spoil me, my beautiful Princess, I just loooove the sensation of your hair on my fingers.”

He lingers a bit, circling around the area earning long moans and flinching from his touch, increasing her sensitivity even more.

“Pl-please, please Mark, please I’m at my limit here, please sto-p teasing!” She began rubbing herself against him, making him aware of the raging boner he was developing, and somehow ignored during all this time, and how now it was almost painful for him.

Getting the message, he stopped with the foreplay and went for the gold, inserting two fingers in her flower and like a seeking missile, strikes right into her G-Spot.

Everything went white for the Princess at that moment as she stood up and sits up with her wings fully extended and spamming like there was no tomorrow, threatening to lift her up at any moment, and just like a switch being turned on her inhibitions were completely lost, announced by her scream of ecstasy and the very first orgasm of the night, while Mark continued with his vaginal stimulation.

Smirking in victory, he saw her body shine completely, the disguise spell cracking and slowly shattering to make way to her real form as her scream continued.

“And now we can really begin, don’t be a shining sweetie, show me your real face, Queen…LUNA!?” Mark's eyes widened the second the light died down and in front of him riding the afterglow was none other than the Princess of the night, with her tongue hanging out and looking down at him with a hungry smile and heart shaped eyes.

“Trick or Treat dear Mark.” She says between pants, and giggling like crazy. “Looks like you got the trick, but I get the treat!”

“But I…what…when...?”

“It’s Nightmare Night sweetie, best not to think about it and just enjoy your first time with an alicorn.” She winks before using her magic to rip the rest of her clothes and remind him how his fingers were still pressing firmly in her pussy. “Tell me again how much you love my ass.” She almost demanded. Before leaning forward and kissing him hard, fully drunk on lust, as her horn shone again and worked like crazy removing the rest of his costume.

Before he could say anything else, Luna was already busy pressing her butt against his rock hard dick, making it painfully hard to think straight, as her soaking wet pussy was lubbing his tool completely as she took charge and using full range of her magic, captures his hands pressing them firmly on her flanks, as she smooshes and squeezes her own breast in front of the human.

“Just let go, Mark, we both knew this was coming, my sister and I have been curious for so long, wanting to be more intimate with the one responsible, that brought us closer, all those teases, and joking around. Why don’t we forget the foreplay and enjoy the main course…” Standing up she lines her pussy with the tip of his dick. “…once and for all!”

Gulping once, Mark manages to recover his line of thought and start to consider his options, and finally understanding how big this trick was that his whole herd pulled on him.

‘I’m gonna have a talk with those three later, but first…’

He squeezes her ass harder, as he smiles accepting his fate. “Oh Luna, you incredible sexy naughty Princess.” Pulling her closer he started to insert himself inside of her. “You have no idea what you started, it’s too late for me to stop now”

He starts to rub his hands on her flanks enjoying the texture and softness, greatly. Earning a moan from both of them. “Damn, this ass feels incredible.”

“Y-Yeah! Keep going, keep praising my glorious moons, show me exactly how you would be willing to praise a full moon.” Luna yells, absorbed in her lust, moving her hips side to side. “Oh yeah, this sensation is heavenly, your penis simply feels glorious inside of me, it’s almost as if it was built to please royalty.”

They start to move slowly, but gradually start to gain momentum as Mark matches each of his thrusts with her own, getting a rhythm going, and filling the room with their combined moans, until he could feel her walls contracting, signaling the arrival of her second orgasm.

“Glad it’s to your liking, your walls feel incredible in how they massage my rod too.” Getting more control, he turned them around so he was on top again. “And I’m sorry, but I can’t resist your charms anymore, I must conquer you like only I know how.” Grabbing one of her legs, and lifting it up slightly, he positions himself in such a way his thrusts pierce her deeper.

Soon his thrust resumed and Luna didn’t waste time in voicing her approval, with her eyes rolling back. “Yes! Oh yes, yes, yes! I’m a good Princess!”

“You are an incredible Princess!”

“I’m the best Princess of the night!”

“Oh yes you are!”

“I’m a veeeery naughty Princess.” She suddenly says with hearts in her eyes, Mark too drunk in lust to notice her tone of voice starts to become a bit deeper, and stops momentarily to turn around to show her beautiful ass to him as he resumes.

“By the stars, you are such a slutty naughty Princess.”

“Yes, I’m the sluttiest! I’m a very bad princess! I've been very bad, I almost brought eternal night to the world! I’m such a horrible princess, I need to be taught a lesson, teach me, oh great human, discipline me with your incredible rod, and your heavenly hands.”

Snapping out of his stupor, Mark stops and looks at her in shock by the sudden shift in personality.

Pulling out of her, making her flinch and lay down in bed to recover her breathing, as the two pant and start to sweat.

He starts to get scared once he notices how her fur got lighter and her mane and tail adopted a silver white color matching her eyelashes, as she slowly turns to look at him.

“My dear, beautiful knight, please do not stop now.” She looks forward and raises her hip up. “This unfit ruler is yet to receive her punishment.”

“Luna, your fur, your mane, what is happening?”

Giggling lightly the mare looks at him over her shoulders, keeping her hips raised up. “Does it really matter? Come on my knight, let us not dwell on the small things, I can feel it in your heart, you can’t stop. You want to do it, just as much as I want to have it. So don’t hold back, growl for me, punish me, make me remember.”

With his mind going foggy, and gulping again, Mark slowly stood up again, growling once his expression became neutral as he got closer, and without saying a word brought his open palm down, hard on her. Unlike the other times he did it. This one seemed stronger, fully intended to produce pain and smirks in satisfaction as his response was a loud moan of a mixture of pain and pleasure.

“Yes!”

He repeats the action.

“Yesh!”

Grabbing hold of her tail, he lines up his dick back with her entrance.

“Yes, yes! My holes, use both, don’t hold…”

“SILENCE!” Mark orders his eyes going wide as in front of him Luna was smirking in victory licking her lips. “You will talk only when I give you permission, criminal.”

Nodding eagerly she holds a gasp when he slowly inserts into her, getting more aggressive and pulling at her body in an almost possessive manner, as he leans closer to her ear. “Go ahead and scream, let this be your reward for obedience.”

Doing so, Luna only spends the rest of the night screaming in pleasure as Mark grabs hold of her body and does with her whatever he pleases, ramming her against a wall, taking her doggy style, ordering her to suck his dick, cleaning her up in the bathroom, and circling back and forth all over the house, as he keeps pinching hard on her nipples, and playing with her anus with one finger while ramming her over and over again. The Princess never complained once, in fact her smile only indicated how close to heaven she was feeling at the moment, with some drool coming from her mouth, at the moment Mark wasn’t busy playing with it with possessive kisses.

After hours of that intense session, the two somehow circle back to bed, and end their night with one last shared orgasm before falling down next to one another, Mark bringing her against his chest in a possessive hug, as she rubs herself against his leg lovingly, before passing out from exhaustion, her horn sparking like crazy unable to do anything and having discharged more than once. Until she finally fell asleep.

Neither human, or Princess were aware of what happened, what force, deep in Luna they just awoke and caused this session to turn so violent, and until the next day arrived, how her magic going out of control caused all creatures mature enough sleeping at the time wake up with wide eyes, messy sheets and vivid memories of intense wet dreams.

Happy Halloween everyone! Hope you liked this as well as the mini stories before this.
For those confused, allow me to introduce Lusuna. Basically Molestia’s sister. Hehe, think the Princess of the day was scary when horny? Imagine one that can turn your most normal dreams into something porno rated.

And no, nobody saw those two fucking like rabbits, her magic only opened up their deepest most desire and charged them to eleven. They simply had a very vivid dream of what they are most lustful about.

Hehe all this and more will be explored later down the line, until then have a great evening! And don’t forget to brush after eating your candy!