Follyamory

The long and exciting wedding exhausted Shining. Being possessed and used as a conduit for weaponized love had left him without an ounce of energy. Could he last for a night of marital bliss with his seemingly insatiable wife? He hated to delay their first time past their wedding night, but he was ready to drop.

Cadance didn't seem to notice his exhaustion as she was much the opposite. It was as if powering the shield had gotten her high instead of tiring her. She pranced in front as they walked, bouncing and flagging her tail upward. Her passion drooled down her thighs. Of course, he expected that of a pony whose special talent may as well have been sex. There were all sorts of rumors about her being easy due to that, but Shining had never believed them.

The prancing did less to speed him up than Cadance likely intended. Watching her pleasantly plump pink princess plot waggle almost hypnotized him again. So after a while she pushed him ahead of her, prodding him along. He squeaked in a less-than-macho manner as she jabbed him with her horn, but it sped his movements.

“Sorry, sweetie,” Shining said, “I’m still out of it.”

“Then I’ll get you into me instead,” Cadance said, a playful gleam in her eyes. "If you play your cards right at least."

Of that Shining had no doubt.

As Shining opened the door to their suite, Cadance ran her tongue up the back of his sack. Her talented tongue tugged and slurped each loudly. Shining jumped and blushed, the guards outside the room exchanging glances. Cadance only smirked at them as she shoved Shining into the room.

“Now boys,” Cadance winked at the soldiers, bat ponies since the couple was staying in Luna’s wing of the castle while here. “Just because it’s our wedding night doesn’t mean you don’t check on loud noises. We wouldn’t want an enemy taking advantage of the moment, would we?”

Cadance loved the idea of being watched. She’d even suggested they consummate their vows in front of family and subjects alike at the wedding, but he was pretty sure she’d been joking about that. She followed Shining, unbuckling the front of her dress, walking out of her clothing and leaving it lying in the doorway. He doubted they understood that she did that because she wanted them to watch.

When Cadance didn't pick it up, the guards folded it neatly and placed it inside the room. Cadance gave them another seductive glance, wagging her tail up to flash them as well, but they only blushed and closed the door, glancing nervously at Shining as if they thought he might pound them for being flirted with. He wouldn't, because she surely wasn't seriously trying to tempt them at her, but he wished she wouldn't do that, as it didn't help the rumors about her.

“We need kinkier guards,” Cadance smirked. She pulled Shining’s vest open with her magic and yanked it off with a single movement.

“Sure,” chuckled Shining. He moved his legs so she wouldn’t rip his vest in her eagerness to remove it. “We can place an ad ‘Wanted: Guards that like to watch’”

“Who said I only want them to watch,” Cadance teased, “I have more than one hole and so do you. I could have my own knight in Shining Armor.”

“Just us,” chuckled Shining. He didn’t mind her silliness, though it made him blush up a storm. “I really wish you wouldn’t joke like that though… you know that contributes to ponies thinking that you’re easier than you are.”

“Oh my goodness,” laughed Cadance as if what he said was far funnier than her joke.

Shining was one of the few stallions that would be fine with her antics, but despite all the rumors, he trusted her completely. He’d asked her to wait to lose her virginity with him, and he was sure she did, though he might regret keeping her that pent up with as tired as he was now.

Yet something else was bothering him, and his inability to look her in the eyes made it obvious.

“Is something wrong, love?” Cadance asked, looking at him like a child would a toy that didn’t function quite like they wanted.

The princess climbed onto the bed, not bothering to pull the blanket over her as she sprawled onto her back. She splayed her legs to give Shining a good view. He barely kept himself from zoning out on her perfect body.

"Nothing important," Shining replied, "I'm just glad to be here with you and... not someone else."

"I'm sure you are," Cadance smiled, "Don’t make me drag the truth out of you, dear. I have ways of making you talk." She winked.

"It's probably not the best time to bring it up." Shining hesitated, but there was no resisting her eyes as she waited for an answer. "Well it's just... you were in that cave for weeks right? And me out here the whole time mind-bucked by Chrysalis… which means while you can offer me your first time, I can’t offer you mine."

Cadance stifled a laugh for some reason and motioned for Shining to come hither with one fore hoof. She gently took his hoof but yanked him onto the bed. When he tried to lay next to her, she grasped his chest and tugged him atop her instead.

He slipped his hooves around her and they lay facing one another. His sheath sat comfortably against her slit as if molded perfectly for one another, and his shaft responded to the warmth and moisture, expanding from its home and thickening against her. Even as tired as he was, his body reacted more to her than it ever had for Chrysalis.

"Around six weeks, in fact," said Cadance after some thought. Her tone sounded like she was enjoying the conversation, but he was sure she was just trying to cheer him up.

“Well exactly... it's just,” Shining panted, having trouble forming words while this close to her, “I did a lot of things with ‘you’ during that time, and I was worried you might be upset that… we couldn’t share our first times together.”

"I see," Cadance caressed his face and wrapped her hind legs around him. Her hips twitched as she enjoyed his growing shaft against her. "Do you think it would upset me that you boned Chrysalis, on accident no less? I wouldn't have minded if you boned her on purpose; too bad she invaded instead of just asking for a threesome."

"Well I don’t mean angry AT me," Shining said, "Just uncomfortable about it… come on sweetie, this is no time for jokes like that."

“I'm more curious than uncomfortable.” Cadance wore a wicked grin. She slid a hoof around his neck as another slipped between them to stroke his throbbing love. “And I’m not joking.” She chuckled. “So naïve, you honestly think all of that was rumors and I’m still a virgin, don’t you?”

"Curious?" Shining shivered with every touch, then blinked. “Wait, what?”

“Shining, sweetie, it’s time for you to clue in,” chuckled Cadance, pulling her legs more tightly around him as if she thought he might try to escape now, continuing to grind her hips. “I did tell you the rumors about me weren’t true, and they aren’t, but only because most of my trysts keep their muzzles shut. I’m way more of a slut than the rumors say.”
“What?...” Shining was too stunned to even be angry; he just sort of felt empty inside. His body didn’t care as much, instinctively pushing his hips downward to press his tip against her sopping wet entrance. She pulled back before he could get into position. Instead, she teasingly rubbed her soft pink princess pussy against his pulsating shaft. Even on the bottom she was in control.

“Let’s see,” Cadance’s smile went from playful to sadistic. “I bucked pretty much all your friends, all the jocks I saw bullying you in high school, the two marefriends you had before me and didn’t put out for... “ She chuckled. “For that matter, I’ve been bucking your dad since before I started foalsitting Twilight.”

“But… you were 14 when you started foalsitting...” Shining couldn’t believe what he was hearing.

“Yeah I was,” smirked Cadance. “And I first did your dad two years before, lost my virginity four years before that. On the plus side, I have a lot of experience.”

“Please tell me this is a bad joke…” Shining sighed.

"No joke, but we’re getting off subject," Cadance said, playfulness entering her voice again, “Tell me what you did with her. I love kinky stories.”

Shining sighed. Even if she had always been as easy as she said, it caught him off guard that she’d want to hear about her husband being raped, physically and mentally. She really wanted to hear about it?

"Uh, Sweetie," Shining quivered from her attention, "No offense, but this wasn’t some kinky thing. It was traumatic, so I’d rather not talk about it. Besides, are you sure you’d want to hear about it?”

“Mmm, but your trauma is so hot,” Cadance purred, narrowing her eyes seductively. “Besides, I’m not asking you, I’m telling you. Don’t forget who wears the figurative pants in this relationship.”

She showed no concern for his feelings, as usual when they were in private, but he’d always assumed it was sarcasm or jesting. Was he really that much of a fool for assuming it wasn’t serious? Had he really just been a toy for her this whole time? It wasn’t like he could just walk out though, not after marrying into royalty in an extremely public manner. Now that she had him, he pretty much could never leave her without having his reputation ruined, since a royal like her could tell the news how to report it.

But he still wasn’t sure if he wanted to end it even after that, not with that feeling of her warmth against his shaft. He wasn’t about to give up a chance in the hole he’d fantasized about since he started masturbating. He flustered, feeling very uncomfortable with the conversation, but Cadance only narrowed her eyes in warning when he paused.

“Can we please go the night without me having to remember being raped?” sighed Shining. “I’m starting to think I prefer having my love fed on if you’re just going to make me suffer.”

“If you get inside me, you won’t prefer any other,” Cadance’s tone reached ‘scolding mother’ levels of annoyed. “And no, we can’t. Now tell me about your most recent night with her, because the longer you resist, the more I’m tempted to invite the guards in. Then you won’t be putting it in any of my holes, and certainly won’t be the one fueling my foal factory tonight.”

Shining wanted to think it was an empty threat, but wasn’t sure anymore, so figured he’d get it over with.

"Well we had sex and..." Shining started, but Cadance cut him off with a kiss. She licked the roof of his muzzle before pulling back.

"I want details, Shiny," Cadance slurped his chin, "Give me some dirty talk."

"I fucked her changeling cunt." Shining gulped, but spoke more with her insistence. "She lay me on my back and she rode me cowgirl style until I painted her insides white."

"That’s better," Cadance encouraged, "And you mean she raped you cowgirl style. Let’s not sugar coat it; get me wet with your trauma."

Shining attempted to hit the mark again, but she moved so he couldn’t penetrate still. He felt her vulva, so hot and drenched, tormenting him. She loved to stoke his flame even while torturing his emotions, but this had to be a new low for the torture. Somehow though, the divergence made it feel hotter.

"I rolled her over face-down and mounted," panted Shining, voice and body shaking, "Even though she was the one desecrating me, I choked her and rammed balls deep into her tail hole. I drowned that hole as well." He groaned, "Sweetie, if you keep teasing, I'll blow before I get inside."

"You better not ooze a single drop without your wife’s permission," Cadance chuckled again, "Mmm... but Chrysalis has a choking fetish? I'm not surprised. We’ll try all her fetishes so you don’t miss your bug waifu. Now tell me how she defiled your unwilling body next."

"She cleaned me with her tongue," Shining stammered. "Her tongue was so long that it could wrap around my cock several times, but I was too far gone to realize how weird that was. We lay on our sides to sixty-nine; I sucked my cum from her fuck holes and came a third time into her muzzle. She drenched my face with cunt honey. Then we made out while snowballing my sperm between our muzzles."

Cadance wasn’t holding her own climax in, adding to her poor stallion’s suffering as she blew. Her soft lips twitched with inner convulsions as warm honey sprayed his painfully erect shaft. He was so hard that it was a wonder that he didn’t pass out from blood loss.

“Then she told me how much she cared for me,” Shining added, starting to realize how the succubus had treated him better than Cadance, even with ulterior motives. “How special I was.”

“Tsk, you definitely should have known it wasn’t me then,” Cadance smirked, either not getting or not caring about the point he made. She was always shallow with him in private, and it hurt more now that he knew she wasn’t joking. “The only reason I love you is because you realize how not special you are and will take my abuse, you’re a favored toy at most... who knew that kind of love could defeat an army, right?” She let him simmer with her juices splattered all over his shaft and belly, still refusing to sate him. “Now, how many times did she cream for you?"

"Around half a dozen times I guess," groaned Shining, "That was it... we fell asleep together. She was surprisingly passionate given she didn’t actually love me. I’m starting to wonder if you love me."

“I show my love differently,” Cadance winked. Her line of questioning became more wicked, “And how do you know she didn’t love you? Anyway, you talked about Chrysalis’s tongue, do you think I’ll be able to compete?”

“I didn’t say that,” Shining stammered. Did she want to know or if it was a loaded question?

“Hesitating, hm?” Cadance sensed his turmoil, then grumbled. “So you definitely think I won’t be able to then. Was it so heavenly that I may as well be gnawing on your cock? Careful or I just might.”

“Oh come on,” Shining admitted. “I just told you how long her tongue was, it’s not like you can even be expected to compete with that.”

“Oh, getting brave now,” Cadance chuckled.

“It’s true,” Shining said between clenched teeth. He tried to push inside again but her hips moved to foil his plans, but it’d reached the point where he was feeling spiteful at her insensitivity. “I’ll never be able to get a blow job from you without thinking about how much better Chryssie’s was.”

“Mmm, now I feel cheated that she never ate me out when I was imprisoned,” Cadance giggled, but then suddenly shoved him off of her. His shaft throbbed in complaint when denied her warmth, and he landed on the floor beside the bed.

“Ow!” Shining grunted, sitting up. “Well you can’t expect me to not be mad!”

“Oh, I actually don’t mind you cucking me a little bit,” Cadance smirked. “I’m more disappointed that you’re already forgetting whose property you are, so it’s time to remind you who the dominant party in this marriage is.”