Follyamory

Cadance rolled off the bed on the other side, standing up and walking to the middle of the room.

“Guards!” Cadance called back into the room with an air of authority.

“Princess?!” The door opened and the two bat stallions guarding it came inside.

They looked frantic, as if they might think someone actually attacked the couple during their marital bliss, but instead they found only the couple. Shining was still standing awkwardly next to the bed, as Cadance turned her rear towards them, tail hiked up and showing off her goods, which were now drooling down her thighs all the way to her hooves. She waggled her hips slowly back and forth.

“Are either of you taken?” Cadance smirked back at them. “Because the two of you are going to help me cuck my limp-dicked husband.”

“I am not limp-dicked!” Shining couldn’t believe what he was hearing. “You can’t be serious!”

“Um, your Majesty,” said one guard, a bat with a purple mane, looking nervous as Shining walked around the bed, but didn’t back up, knowing that Cadance outranked him by anyone’s account. “N-not that I mind the idea, but what if ponies find out…”

“I-isn’t it illegal for us to touch a princess like that?” the second blue-maned guard asked in a somewhat squeaking voice. “Uh, but yeah, we’re actually taken… I’m married with two foals, so I couldn’t do that even for a princess.”

“Oh that law only applies to Celestia and Luna’s uptight cunts.” Cadance rolled her eyes. “Else I wouldn’t have gotten married, dumbass. And who cares if ponies find out? Don’t you want to be known as the guard that knocked up a princess in front of her newlywed husband?”

Shining couldn’t believe what he was hearing. Regardless of what good a lay she might be, this had clearly gone too far, and he had to put his hoof down on this out-of-control slut.

“Now wait a-” Shining started, but Cadance’s magic quickly forced his muzzle shut, closing it tightly enough that his teeth hurt.

His own telekinesis couldn’t hold a candle to an alicorn’s strength, so Shining was helpless. He heard Cadance’s closet open behind him, several items pulled free as if they’d been ready just in case. He struggled as his mouth was opened again only to have a ball gag shoved into it, which was then tied around his head. Before he could do anything else, his forelegs were pulled behind him and tied there, another leather restraint tying off his hind legs. He even had a magic restraint placed around his horn.

“Also don’t tell me your names, boys,” added Cadance with a wink. “I’ll just call you Purple and Blue for now for your manes. I want this chump to know that even on our wedding night, I’d rather play pelvis ping-pong between two strangers than let him fuck me.”

Shining struggled a moment longer before realizing that it was pointless and going limp, in every way but his frustratingly hard shaft at least. All he could do now was listen to their conversation as tears welled up in his eyes. What Cadance said before had been stunning, but this outright broke his heart.

“I am so down for this,” panted Purple, apparently far more so than Blue. His veiny shaft had already dropped down in front of his plump balls, and Shining blushed in the realization that it was significantly larger than his.

“Y-you want me to… i-impregnate,” Blue looked wide-eyed between the struggling prince and the ridiculously do-able princess, but shook his head. “I-I can’t I’m sorry, my wife would never…“ He turned to Purple and arched an eyebrow. “But you’re married too… to a stallion no less.”

“So?” shrugged Purple. “You’re knocking her up, which means I get her royal ass. And my husband won’t mind other than being mad he missed it.”

“I’m not impregnating anyone but my wife!” Blue looked like he might actually back out of the room. His reluctance gave him credit, but his body was responding all the same. His shaft slid out more slowly, but seemed somewhat longer than Purple’s, yet with less girth, though still both larger than Shining’s. Shining was above average himself, yet they just had to end up with two guards that were bigger. This was so unfair.

“You do know I’m an expert at love magic, right?” Cadance grinned evilly at Blue. “I can put her in a state where you can fuck anyone you want right in front of her, and she’ll be a-ok with it. Even if you banged your own foals, she’d be into it.”

“W-what?! No!” Blue shook his head, turning as if to go, face beat red but shaft still flopping stiffly beneath him.

“Fine,” shrugged Cadance. “If you want me to do this the easy way instead, then I’ll make sure you tell her exactly what we did. Have fun explaining why you did it without my help though.”

Blue’s whole body went stiff as Cadance’s magic reached him just before he opened the door. He took a deep breath, shaking his head as if to clear it, then looked back at her with literal hearts in his eyes.

“You want to fuck me, and you don’t care if your wife knows, right?” Cadance smirked at him. “She’s a bad lay anyway, and you’ll describe to her how much better my cunt is than hers as soon as you get home.”

“Yeah… she is…” Blue turned and staggered back towards her. “That’s a great idea…”

“Uh, won’t this be raping him?” Purple asked. At first, Shining was going to respect him for not being okay with that, but it turned out... “That’s so bucking hot. I’ll tell my hubby on my own by the way, he’ll want to hear the story.”

“Now see, you I like,” Cadance chuckled. “You can fuck my cunt too when your friend is done if you want, or if you don’t want, I don’t care how gay you are.”

“A hole’s a hole, I guess,” shrugged Purple, either okay with it or not wanting to risk getting mind-bucked by this crazy tart.

“Aw, too bad,” Cadance giggled as if she’d actually been looking for an excuse to rape both the guards instead of just one.

Cadance hopped back onto the bed, and dragged Shining a bit over, propping him up so that he could get a good view of the action. She licked her lips at him with a wink, then shook her bottom at the two guards once more.

“This is what you get for being a bitch, Shining,” Cadance said. “You mind better… and maybe I’ll let you put the next one in me.”

“Don’t worry, pantywaist,” Purple laughed, much less timid in what he said with Shining restrained. “We’ll fill this cock sock’s holes better than you ever could either. I guess you’re out of luck for getting any hole unless Chrysalis shows back up.” He glanced at Shining’s shaft. “Unless your wife let’s me…”

“No,” Cadance chuckled. “His pathetic cock gets nothing.”

Blue was quieter under the spell, rushing onto the bed with Cadance and pushing his lips to hers. Cadance purred against him, slurping her tongue together with his as she turned her body about. She sat up on her haunches, front-to-front with the guard.

Shining felt sorry for Blue now. The poor guy tried to do the right thing and would get his marriage ruined in exchange. No one would believe him over a princess if he claimed she used mind control; she could even claim he raped her and no one would question it.

No one would believe Shining over her for that matter. If he said he hadn’t wanted this, ponies would think it was a plot to get the marriage annulled so he could get some princess money out of her. They’d think he’d planned it all along. His reputation would take way more of a beating than that of a beloved princess, and it was unlikely she minded being known as a slut that cucked her husband. If anything it’d just get her laid more.

“That’s right,” Cadance growled playfully as she nipped at Blue’s chin, but kept her eyes on Shining as she grinned. “Hold my leg up so that he can see you impregnate the precious princess pussy he thought he was putting one in tonight. I have a fertility spell on me right now so the next dick inside my cooch will knock this unfaithful womb up.”

Purple moved up behind her, front-to-back, and both him and Blue together pulled her leg up on this side so Shining could see. Angry as he was, Shining didn’t want to take his eyes off those beautiful holes, but did when the other stallions’ shafts probed close to them.

“Oh no you don’t,” Cadance pulled his head back to face them with her magic, then squeezed his balls hard enough for him to cry out through the gag. “I see you take your eyes off the action, and you’ll never be able to get action again. In fact…”

Her horn glowed again, and Shining felt his own mind addled. It felt a little like when Chrysalis had a hold of him, from what he vaguely remembered, but after a moment he realized it wasn’t mind-control. Instead, his shaft pulsed harder, hormones surging.

Shining didn’t dare take his eyes off it now, because with all that she’d done tonight, he wouldn’t bet on her not being willing to castrate him. But he was so horny now that watching it physically hurt, more so with every second. He took deep breaths to try to control himself, but nothing worked. Damn it, he wanted this conniving mare more than he ever had now, but he couldn’t so much as touch his dick for relief.

“Good, no foreplay boys, I’m ready to bang,” Cadance purred at the guards, then rolled back her eyes. “Oh Shining, love, I feel how heart-broken you are. Even now you’re too smitten with me to ever leave me, fuck that’s hot.”

Both bats were ready to give Shining’s wife a good time. Shining clenched his teeth around the gag as tears ran down his face, watching Blue continue kissing her as if she were his one true love, sliding his hooves up and down her lithe body. The bat’s pulsating cock aligned itself eagerly with Cadance’s entrance, her fluid drooling down the length from the moment it touched her nether lips. Slipping inside was as easy as it was loud and wet, and Shining watched the hole that she teased him with so cruelly as it stretched wide, lips gliding over every curve and vein of his shaft.

Purple took things less romantic than the captivated Blue. He grasped her behind unceremoniously, pushing his tip to her pucker as he yanked her leg up further. and tensing as he rammed forward with all his might. He looked surprised at how easily he penetrated, then rolled his eyes back and lay his muzzle on her shoulder, drooling and grinning like a fool. Her asshole, despite being much less lubricated, pushed down around his equipment easily enough. Shining could see it clench once he was inside, making up for the slut’s looseness with her hold control.

Soon, the two were bouncing her hips back and forth in perfect time as she moved with practiced motions. She let herself be swatted back and forth, but clearly had control of the situation, her sweaty muscles tensing as her movements tantalized her lovers. Cadance groaned louder than she needed, sticking her tongue out at Shining again as she did so.

“By Celestia’s crusty dry cooch,” Cadance swore. “To be invaded by such perfect shafts, either one of these could give me a better time than your pitiful little toy. Isn’t that right Shining?”

Shining felt his balls gripped in her magic again, and sighed as he reluctantly nodded his head. He wanted to make his own shaft deflate so it wouldn’t seem like he was enjoying it, but it wouldn’t have worked even without the arousal spell she’d cast on him. His wife’s hip movements during the blatant act of infidelity was mesmerizing. The wet slop as she moved one way to push Blue’s shaft into her fertile pussy, then the drier suction of Purple inside her ass, it was all too perfect. Shining had never been so simultaneously horny and completely enraged as he was now.

“Fuck this bitch can clench!” Purple shivered, keeping his eyes on Shining as much as Cadance did, clearly delighted to be cuckolding royalty. “My own husband will be jealous when I tell him about this.”

“How about your wife?” Cadance asked between passionate kisses with Blue. “She’s going to have a lot of trouble satisfying you after you’ve had this royal pussy, isn’t she.”

“Impossible… she could never…” drooled Blue. “Her cunt would be like sticking my cock in a blender after having you.”

“Oh, creative cuckolding, I like it,” Cadance giggled as shivers ran up through her. “Make sure to… tell her… exactly… that…”

Cadance squealed, voice rocketing up several octaves. Her whole body convulsed, and Shining watched as her belly and thighs especially shivered. Pussy juice splattered out from around the penetration so violently that it splattered all over Shining’s face. He strained to keep his eyes open unless he get another ball squeeze, but it stung as much as his over-hard shaft without any way of cleaning them.

“See how hard I’m cumming over two strangers’ cock, sweetheart?” Cadance groaned. “You’ll never set me off like this!”

“Take my… “ Blue started to try more dirty talk but was quickly driven to incoherence by the pleasure furnace exploding around him. His whole body clenched as he exploded inside her so hard that Shining could see his cock pulse with thick ropes of seed shooting through it. Cadance’s pussy clenched visibly as if to keep any from escaping, sucking up every last drop like the cum vacuum she was.

“Fuck I’ve never enjoyed someone without a cock this much!” Purple was soon to follow, extending his legs slightly to raise up and pound her slutty asshole as hard as he could. He wrapped his forelegs around Cadance’s neck, pulling them tight and choking her as he did so. This only made her eyes roll back further until they were almost completely white, the alicorn’s pussy exploding a second time in a flood of her impure arousal.

“That’s right,” panted Cadance as she continued to move her hips slower as they released inside of her from either end. “See, Shining? My cock holes are so incredible that even a faggot like Blue adores them. I can clench hard enough that even your tiny cock would feel it, but it never will unless you shape your cuck ass up.”

“Still gonna sleep with his loser?” Purple chuckled as he started to come down.

“I’ll sleep with you!” Blue offered, and he might need a place to sleep after he gets home to talk to his wife.

“I’ll sleep with my hubby, of course,” Cadance smirked. “I want him to fall asleep every night smelling the pussy he isn’t getting right next to him, or the cum drooling from it. I want him to watch as my belly grows with somepony else’s foal.”

“My foal!” Blue blurted out triumphantly. “And it’ll be half you too… I want to fuck it as soon as its old enough.”

“Adorable,” Cadance gave Blue one last kiss. “Now, run home now, I want you to get there with my pussy juice still shiny on your dick. Then tell your wife everything we did and how much better I am than her. Tell her how you want to make love to our foal too while you’re at it. After that, the spell will be broken, but I guarantee you won’t ever forget this night.”

Shining grunted out, actually pleading on Blue’s behalf. That was possibly more cruel than what she’d done to Shining. How did her and his love manage to repel the changelings earlier? Was her tainted lust even more powerful than normal love?

“You on the other hoof,” Cadance said to Purple as Blue excitedly exited the room to begin his new life as a single stallion. “I want you to help me with a little performance. You’re going to play Shining, and I’ll play Chrysalis, and we’ll enact their most recent night together.”

“Sounds good!” Purple nodded. “Though… I’m gonna have to fuck your pussy too, huh. Maybe instead I could play Chrysalis and Shining could play Shining? I’ve been told my ass is better than most pussies.”

“Oh you are just a delightful both-ways anal slut,” Cadance chuckled. “But he doesn’t get to use his cock tonight, so you’ll be fucking me, including my pussy, you hot piece of faggot you.”

“Eh, fine,” Purple agreed somewhat reluctantly, probably afraid to disagree after what happened to Blue.