Follyamory

“If it’s a problem, you can still scoop the fetus out,” Cadance offered, though more as a mockery than anything else, since she knew Luna wouldn’t have that either. “Or I can if you’re groggy.”

“N-No,” stammered Luna. She still figured she could seclude herself and discreetly get it to an orphanage. At least she had a chance of doing so, and even if Celestia would be ashamed of her, she wouldn’t give her away.

When Shining finally sat up from on his back. Luna toppled back into the drenched dirt, twitching as she sprawled there. Her whole body ached now that she’d started coming down, and her soul felt so empty that she couldn’t bring herself to even move.

“So we can do more of this?” Spear asked.

“Of course,” nodded Luna weakly. “To any of those here, I am yours whenever you desire, assuming I can get away from my duties at the time. You may use me in any way you wish, whatever hole you wish. I am your… 'fuck toy', as it were.”

“Mmm, good,” Cadance said. “But I have one more surprise.”

Luna looked at Cadance and felt a new chill from that sadistic grin. Her horn lit up again, and she pulled the device back down from another tree. She hadn’t teleported it away, she’d just teleported it into another position in the trees. It’d recorded the entire act.

All too late, Luna realized what Cadance had done. Luna would have eventually lived down the first video, even if it would have been a long and difficult path, but now she had another video of her not just tempting stallions, but being gangbanged by them and appearing to beg for the most perverse sadism the whole time.

“Is that why you wanted me to pretend to enjoy myself?” Luna’s face tensed up, but then relaxed, too exhausted to bother. She looked at Shining. “Did you know?”

“Pretend?” Shining blinked.

“Oh, like I said, he didn’t know,” Cadance assured. “But yes, that’s one reason I set it up like this. Now I have a video of this, and your situation is even worse than before.”

“Wait, what’s going on?” Shining grew still, looking at his wife.

“Remember when I said I’d explain why her pussy felt better?” Cadance asked Shining with a giant smirk on her face. “It’s because unwilling pussy always feels better. She never agreed to this. I blackmailed her with a video of her flirting with her guards and she agreed to pretend to like it.”

“I just raped Princess Luna?” Shining blurted out.

“Raped a foal into her,” grinned Cadance with a nod. “I told you I could do it. I didn’t even need the dark magic I’ve been studying so hard, just a little normal magic to control when everyone got off.”

“What?... no!” Shining was rather appalled, to his credit, and looked at Luna. “I… we don’t have to do it again if you don’t want to.”

“Oh no, you do have to,” Cadance peered at Shining. “As your wife, I get to decide who you fuck and why, even if I made it easier on you this time. It can’t be a hours-long marathon like this every time, but any time you and she are in the same city, you’re going to have at least one screw a day.”

Shining gulped and nodded slowly. So she had him in the same kind of trap as Luna. It was no wonder he hadn’t noticed when Chrysalis replaced Cadance, they seemed so much alike now that Luna really knew her.

“I-I’m sorry…” Shining said to Luna, sounding sincere as he looked away.

“Fuck this is hot,” Spear gasped.

“You said it,” nodded Thrust, but overall let the royals talk. “Damn, I’m fucked in the head now too.”

“What do I have to do?” asked Luna. “To prevent that video from going public. And… will it only result in an even worse video?”

“I don’t think I could make you look any sluttier than this one does,” chuckled Cadance. “And from the angle it was at, it wouldn't have gotten the part where you sobbed like an infant, nor picked up the whispers.”

“What should I do?” repeated Luna.

“Shining?” Cadance said. “I think you know.”

“I… Cadance… sweetie,” Shining shook his head, eyes still wide. “This is wrong, I can’t force her to-”

Cadance growled, clasping Shining’s muzzle shut with her magic. She clenched it so hard that he whimpered, and he didn’t dare resist.

“It’s not like you’ll be able to hide that you broke your vow forever,” Cadance looked at Luna, her expression brightening even as she held her husband’s muzzle shut. “So how about following up by consenting to marry the two of us?”

“But I did this to prevent the secret from getting out,” Luna shook her head, starting to cry outright again. “That is the opposite of what I wanted!”

“You have a choice,” Cadance said. “Support my lie that you only fucked my husband and that you’re joining our marriage because you’re with foal by your own choice, or let it be known that you got gangbanged by three males at once like a little bitch, all while begging for it like a masochist.”

“Please!” Luna sobbed as she sat up. She crawled up to Cadance, kneeling low and bowing. “Please don’t do this to me! My reputation… everything will be destroyed. My sister is already going to be ashamed of me forever, please don’t do this to me!”

“Oh yes, that’s it,” Cadance purred, sitting up on her haunches, rubbing at her slit with one hoof and her breasts with the other, literally masturbating to Luna’s weepy pleading. “So I should release this video? I know I’d want that in your place; every stallion in Canterlot will want a piece of you.”

“We still get to keep fucking her either way, right?” Spear asked somewhat quietly. “Like… even if you marry her?”

“Of course,” smirked Cadance. “I’m not a monster.”

“You are,” Luna growled under her breath, feeling renewed rage overpowering her emptiness. She’d done all this, even agreed to be a regular sex toy for three disgusting males, and for nothing. Her entire reputation would still be shattered, and she couldn’t trust Cadance to hold anything a secret that she said she would at this point.

“Oh, stop being a drama queen,” Cadance scoffed at her.

“You are a foal,” Luna growled louder. “You wanted everything you could get, but you went too far… you left me with nothing to lose.”

“Oh I can make your reputation much worse,” laughed Cadance. “What if I told people that you secretly ordered your guards to comply and they were the ones that weren’t consenting? Would you like to be known as a rapist?

“I’m done with this!” Luna screamed loudly enough that even Cadance took a step back.

The step wasn’t enough, as Luna charged forward at her, rearing up and slamming her own head into Cadance’s horn. When the love princess stumbled back, Luna shoved her hard enough to send her sprawling onto her back. Cadance could manipulate and blackmail, but in a straight up power match, she couldn’t defend herself against Luna.

“You seemed to like my horn, harlot, but you didn’t enjoy the full length!” In the back of her mind, Luna couldn’t believe what she was doing herself, but she was boiling over in rage. She rammed her horn into Cadance’s snatch again, rearing up as the other princess squealed to leave her sitting atop Luna’s head again. Luna clamped her throat shut in her magic to keep her silent.

It was a strain to keep her up there, but Luna was driven forward by blind anger and adrenaline. She gripped Cadance with her magic as well, and pushed her head upwards. Her horn pierced deeper than before, down the slick path that so many disgusting cocks had followed and through her cervix, invading her womb.

She felt the amniotic fluid from Cadance’s torn open womb flow over her head, but she didn’t care. Cadance didn’t deserve to be a mother, and Luna was doing the fetus a favor by making sure it didn’t grow up with a wicked mother that would probably have it raped as soon as a penis could fit, if not sooner.

Suddenly feeling a touch from behind, Luna thought at first that Shining was protecting his wife and unborn child, but was stunned when he instead lifted Luna’s tail and pushed his muzzle to the slit that he’d raped a foal into minutes ago. She had no idea why he was doing that, but the feel of his eager tongue against her during her indignation felt so good. She found herself rotating her hips back against his muzzle rather than kicking him away.

Maybe Cadance had a point about combining violence and sex, but Luna concentrated on the violence. Cadance flailed when she found herself being impaled, but Luna grasped her legs and wings within her magic. She moved forward to slam Cadance against the tree where the camera had been, bracing her there but continuing to violently horn-fuck her womb.

Her horn was long enough to drill into the sides and back of her womb, blood joining the other fluid flowing out of Cadance’s slit. Unable to scream for help with her throat clenched in Luna’s magic, and unable to concentrate on her own magic while being literally stabbed in the cunt, all Cadance could do was writhe as he face twisted in torment.

After a few moments of stunned silence, the guards turned to run, but Luna grabbed them by the tails with her telekinesis, effortlessly able to multi-task even with her current recreation. They whimpered as they ran in place for a few moments and then went limp.

“You took everything from me, miserable strumpet!” Luna growled. “Now I’ll take everything from you… your disgusting spawn… and your whore life!”

“... and her amazing husband?” Shining’s suggestion came as a surprise even when it was wet and between lewd slurps at her nether regions. She felt her passage start to churn again as he rubbed his nose against her clit, and she shivered and rolled her eyes back as she looked up at the terrified expression on Cadance’s face.

“Shining Armor,” Luna panted. “Why are you pleasuring the murderer of your foal?”

“Impale that bastard,” Shining responded. He dug deep, so deeply that he managed to push his entire muzzle into her. It felt blissful as his tongue reached deeper, soothing the aches that he himself were responsible for and suckling up bits of his own sperm.

“Bastard?” Luna grunted, then it all made sense. This foal wasn’t even his, it probably belonged to one of the guards behind them. “Have you ever even penetrated your wife?”

Shining shook his head, glaring up at Cadance angrily.

Luna let Cadance drop, slinging her around with her horn and sending her flying into another tree. Cadance hit it so hard that the tree cracked and tilted. As she felt to her bottom at the base, she waved her front hooves frantically at Luna. Her hind legs twitched, her belly mostly deflated from the loss of fluid as more poured out into a bloody mess beneath her.

“Luna, wait!” Cadance begged when Luna released her throat, and it was good to see after what Luna had been through. “You can’t do this! You can’t assassinate another princess! Your sister would literally send you to the Moon for this!”

“But why would they believe a dead princess over her superior?” Luna demanded. “Especially when all other witnesses will confirm any turn of events that I wish them to. This is correct, yes?”

She turned to Thrust and Spear, who both nodded enthusiastically, the two bats literally dripping with fear. Luna could feel it coming out from every pour, like she had felt fear as Nightmare Moon. She’d forgot how good it felt.

“What? No!” Cadance looked at Shining. “You said you still loved me no matter what I did! Shining! The next baby in me is going to be yours, remember?”

“I loved you before I got a taste of this hole,” Shining pulled his muzzle back to say. “I think they gave the Princess of Love title to the wrong alicorn, it’s like I’m suckling a candy fountain over here…”

“The Princess of Love was never supposed to be a sexual title,” said Luna, rotating her hips further back against Shining, using the movements that Cadance had taught her by force. “But thanks to your ‘education’, I think I may come around to the idea.”

“Fuuuck…” Cadance staggered to her hooves, forgetting the camera she’d left laying on the ground. “I took it too far, gotta get out…”

“Even now, you care more for your own life than the dying life inside you,” said Luna. “That’s… kind of hot… isn’t it.”

Luna pulled Cadance back, and though Cadance tried to counter the telekinesis, Luna easily overcame the much younger being. Almost all Luna had to do on the Moon for all those years was move things around, so her telekinesis was unbreakable when fueled by her anger.

“Help me!” Cadance screeched. “Anypony help me! I’m being fucking murdered HELP ME!”

But it was no use. Luna had already cast a sphere of silence over the entire group, enchanting the outside with invisibility so no one could see the occupants inside. Cadance would be getting no help from any creature.

“DId you want to get use from this one’s holes before they grow cold, my love?” Luna said back to Shining.

“Oh I definitely want to fuck her in spite,” Shining said wetly. “But I don’t want her to enjoy it… so let’s wait until after they’re cold… then I’ll do all of them.”

“Y-you can’t!” Cadance’s confidence was gone, tears streaming down her face now. “I-I can’t be killed! I shouldn’t be able to be killed! Your sister said I got to be immortal!” But Luna knew that Cadance knew better, and that Luna was more than able to crush her head. She could have already done so in fact, but now Cadance had foalishly taught Luna the joys of mixing violence and sex, so she wanted to make her suffer.

“You two,” Luna looked at the guards. “Hurt her while I attend to my fiancé, without using your disgusting male anatomy; she would only enjoy that.”

“Uh,” Spear said. “Does this mean we might get to fuck you again? Like, consensually?... maybe you raping us even?”

“Is that really the most important thing?” Thrust grunted.

Luna wanted to say that yes, they could, but couldn’t bring herself to vocalize it. She knew before that she felt an interesting pleasure when raging as Nightmare Moon, but she’d never connected it to sex. But now that she’d tasted sex for real, like a shark tasting blood, it all made sense. Now that her body knew what it was, it was screaming out for cock the more enraged she became.

In fact, that was more the reason she was letting them live than the fact that they would definitely say whatever she wanted them to say as for what happened. She still didn’t want it to be well known, but she was slowly coming around to the idea of having some extra dick on the side so she could occasionally take three at once.

“Hurt her,” Luna re-ordered instead, pinning Cadance against the tree again. Cadance struggled as her back pressed firmly against it, all six limbs wrapping back until they were near snapping point. “No, my new fiancé, make love to me properly for your ex-wife’s viewing enjoyment. I want that perfect shaft to enjoy the pleasure only a true goddess can bring.”

Luna floated herself and Shining to Cadance, standing next to her and pulling Shining’s head up from her slit. His giant grin was even larger than when he’d had Luna sitting on him before, because now he was getting rid of the bad as well as getting the new. He licked up her back as he moved, then slid his tip back to her opening.

In contrast to the first time, it felt amazing. From the first touch against her, her fluid was drooling all the way to his balls. Now that she had regenerated, her hymen had healed as well, and her entrance was once again impossibly tight. She smiled gently, prying herself open for him, then shivering as he pushed inside. Her tight nethers felt every detail, a pleasure that she never wanted to stop.

Celestia had been a foal when she suggested their vow; their bodies were made for this. What was more royal than having every creature in their kingdom want to lay with them? In fact, had Cadance stopped while she was ahead, Luna might have eventually been thankful, even if she’d have never thanked her. But now, she wanted her tormentor dead and didn’t care about the consequences.

“When our wedding is announced,” Luna purred, wanting to dig it into Cadance in any way she could. “You’ll be the envy of stallions and mares all over the world, far more than you were when you were wed to this defect.”

“The fuck he will,” Cadance grumbled, then looked at Thrust and Spear fearfully as they approached, knowing exactly how far they’d be willing to go with her. Any games she’d played in the bedroom likely hadn’t been as intense as what she’d put Luna through, and that wouldn’t stand up to this.

“You are the Princess of Love,” smirked Luna. “But I am the Princess of Dreams. In dreams, sex can be true perfection, and not even in reality is love required for it, as you’ve so expertly taught us.”

“Your cunt is perfection,” groaned Shining, speeding up his thrusting. His shaft was so hard that she could feel his pulse through it inside her. The spastic motions showed that he’d get off soon, but she didn’t hold him back as his cruel wife would have, rolling her hips back and squeezing herself in waves around his shaft, driving him rapidly towards orgasm.

As Cadance was pressed with her back against the tree, Thrust and Spear grabbed her from opposite sides. Their shafts were rock hard, though they’d been instructed not to use them on the cock fiend, and instead they twisted her upper legs the same way Luna’s had been, pulling them back against the tree and around it, then bending the knees backwards. They found it easier than it should have been, Luna’s telekinesis aiding them as they splintered the bones apart.

“Yes, dismember her fully!” Luna ordered them. “I will be creating a toy out of her torso for my beloved husband to cuddle up to at night, and to violate as often as he pleases to make up for her denials.”

After what she put Luna through, Cadance’s shrieks were the most beautiful things she had ever heard, the terror on her face as tears streamed was truly delightful to behold. She felt herself churn within, and even had Shining not been plowing her, she might have gone off.

As it was, they exploded against each other, Shining filling her womb with another load of more consensual stallion slime. It didn’t feel grotesque anymore to have him inside of her, but incredible as her hole exploded over him in return, juice spraying out as they came together.

“Take it, Slutmare Moon,” Shining shivered, commandeering the word Cadance had used to demean her. “I don’t care how tired I am, every hole of yours is mine today!”

“Yes, invade my every orifice!” Luna responded. “Your body and soul are a tool for my pleasure, as it should be.”

Shining ripped his shaft from her pussy, juice flying all over Cadance and her tormentors, and immediately rammed it into her anal cavity. Luna backed her rear up again, colliding with him as his balls impacted her pregnant pussy with each strike. Committing such blatant infidelity with a mare’s husband in front of her was a thrill of its own. It was a thrill she’d like to repeat, but Shining seemed like he wouldn’t stop Luna from indulging in others.

The guards made steady work of the screaming Cadance's limbs, but it wasn’t quick. They first tore off her upper legs at the knee, then moved on to her shoulders, twisting them around in the same fashion to splinter and tear her bone and muscles. When they finished there, they moved on to her wings, shattering every bone, wadding them up so she felt every snap, and only then working them free at the joints. Blood splattered down the tree, and though the bleeding slowed from her regeneration, Cadance wouldn’t be able to grow back anything significant while under Luna’s power.

“This can’t happen!” Cadance squealed, sobbing as the second wing came free. “I can’t be killed! I was told I couldn’t die! Why am I dying?!” She had been so enamored with her immortality that her imminent death was hitting her hard. Instead of a forever of indulgence, she would die young even for a mortal, as she so richly deserved.

Luna realized it was hypocritical to think that Cadance deserved it when she was now considering similar things, but at least Luna would be more upfront. If Celestia was raped, it would be forceful and direct, though blackmail might still be useful. It had been nothing for her to temporarily seal Celestia away when she first returned as Nightmare, and Chrysalis had bested her too, so Luna had no doubt she wouldn’t need pathetic mind magic.

Even if it might be fun to use occasionally anyway.

As Shining pounded her asshole and the other guards worked on Cadance’s hind legs one segment at a time, Luna took hold of the harlot’s horn. Cadance shook her head violently, but only gagged painfully when she tried to speak again. Luna bent it one way and then the other with her telekinesis, weakening it with a beam of energy from her own horn as she did so.

When it began to crack, Cadance’s scream was more piercing than ever before, but Luna didn’t stop. Rather than just breaking it off to a stub, she twisted and uprooted the entire thing in fragments, leaving a huge gaping hole in Cadance’s head. It left a gaping hole right through her skull, showing her slick brain flesh beneath.

“Mmmph!” Luna moaned, knowing this was more painful for Cadance than anything so far, to the point that she might not even be able to feel the last part of her legs being torn off her body. “Fill my posterior with seed, my beloved. I believe I have found a way for you to make love to your wife while she lives that she will not enjoy.”

Shining obliged her, his moans turning to whimpers as he exhausted himself. Luna channeled more energy into him, but kept him low for the pleasure of pushing his limits. After he expelled another load into her ass, he collapsed on the ground behind her.

“Now,” Luna smiled down at him. “The final fun begins.”

Luna twisted Cadance’s head, and her last scream was cut off. Her face turned blue as her lungs were separated, spine breaking apart like a rotting tree under an avalanche. Cadance’s limbless and headless body fell limp on the ground, twitching slowly to a stop, as Luna took time to cast a preservation spell upon it. She then looked Cadance in the eyes and smiled gently before hoofing her over to Shining.

“Take her,” Luna told him. “It’s only fair that you handle the ‘divorce’. I will keep her head energized enough to stay conscious, so do what you want with it. When you are finished, ram your organ into the hole I provided atop her head, and destroy her brain. When she dies it should release quite a bit of energy for your enjoyment.”

“Yes, oh yes!” Shining weakly picked up the head in his magic and looked her in her fearful eyes as well. “I can’t believe it, I’m really getting to murder this bitch! You really are the Princess of Dreams, Luna.”

“Then fulfill your dream and end her existence,” Luna encouraged. “We will keep her head and torso for your future pleasure any time you desire. This cuck will be in no shape to tease you.”

Luna walked over to the guards, who both looked like they wanted to run, but stood at attention fearfully as they didn’t dare. She grabbed Spear by the throat, slinging him onto the ground as he squealed like a filly, then began to climb atop to straddle him.

“Aw, not pussy again,” Spear complained. “Oh Luna, it feels like over-heated pudding in there!”

“Deal with it,” Luna grinned down at him. “You are both my toys now, rather than me being yours as you conspired. And I will make sure you have interesting dreams to make up for any pleasure you might feel from this.” She looked at Thrust. “You, inside my posterior!”

“Now that’s the kind of dominant mare I like,” Shining purred, then turned Cadance’s head around. He pushed his shaft into her neck and all the way through, letting it emerge against her tongue, which was convulsing inside her muzzle, the only thing left she really could convulse. He trotted over to Luna, and sat on his haunches in front of her, offering a kiss from Cadance.

“Amazing!” Luna purred. “Even at my worst, I never snuffed out a pony’s life. It’s incredible!”

She shivered as she slid her slick pussy down over Spear’s unwilling shaft, and she thought somehow it really did feel better with him being more reluctant. She squeezed it firmly, her rear entry sucking in Thrust, who nibbled at her wing a bit more appreciatively at the firm warmth of her tailhole gripping his shaft.

Luna leaned down and kissed Cadance’s face, staring into her eyes, still wide with shock and horror. She played her tongue with Cadance’s, slurping over Shining’s protruding shaft in the process, lapping blood and bits of flesh from Cadance’s brutal injuries. The taste of a pony’s flesh was… better than it should have been.

“Fuck, Luna, you’re worrying me a bit, but it’s still so hot,” Shining moaned as she mouthed over his shaft. “How are you this good this fast? You’re giving that bug whore a run for her money on quality sex.”

“So uh, what are we gonna say happened?” Spear asked.

“We’ll make public exactly what Cadance did prior,” panted Luna. “That she let another stallion impregnate her and tormented him with that knowledge.”

“And had me raped,” Shining added helpfully. “Also Thrust was mind-controlled by her when he impregnated her.”

“I’d really appreciate that part being public,” Thrust panted. “So I can leave that bitch anyway for not believing me.”

“That’s quite handy information,” Luna smiled up at Shining around his dick, speaking between slurps and still pressed against Cadance’s lips. “Thrust confided with me in his despair, and I confronted Cadance with Shining present. So drawn in by his plight, I lost control and made love to him, consensually. Cadance, in an act of hypocrisy, became enraged and attacked me, clearly attempting to murder me, then fled when her assassination attempt failed.”

They could discuss the details of the attack later before they gave their story, but she no longer minded the stigma that would come from breaking her vow. The feel of throbbing cum fountains inside her was worth it.

Shining went off inside her muzzle first, and she guzzled it down with renewed vigor. She moved up to kiss Shining, exchanging the remnants of his sperm that had gone through Cadance’s head muzzle-to-muzzle. She looked down at Cadance’s head, the agony and horror in her eyes.

“Just kill me,” Cadance mouthed the words, in too much torment now to worry about her loss of immortality.

“Do it, my love,” Luna lapped at Shining’s nose.

Shining nodded, shaking with excitement and renewed energy at the idea of ending his terrible wife. He turned her head around, facing her upwards so that they could both look down into her eyes, grinning at her.

It was difficult to get inside, even if Luna wrapped a protective shield around the bone edges of the skull hole to keep them from cutting him. He jammed it against the still-living brain inside, and continued shoving as it worked its way slowly into the gray matter. Cadance’s eyes crossed as the pressure in her head increased, muzzle gaping open again as her tongue lashed about randomly.

Shining forced it deeper, pushing her brain lobes apart, then thrusting at full power, moving to different angles to literally stir her cranium. Cadance’s eyes darted about before bulging with the pressure, one and then the other popping out of the socket to hang from the raw nerve as more gray matter oozed out from the sockets.

“Consider this a divorce!” Shining called out as he arches his back, and it was probably the last thing Cadance heard before she passed. The energy of her immortality snapping surged up through Shining, sending his body into convulsions and causing him to cum harder than ever. More of her brains blasted out through Cadance’s eyes, now mixed with gory spunk as well.

The other guards were either too tired or too freaked out to be giving her more juice, so she sent a shock into them as well, sending them both over the edge as Shining was still unloading in Cadance’s now very dead severed head. They squealed in discomfort more than moaned, but it sill gave Luna another dose of seed in two of her holes as she desired, her own vagina adding to the bliss as she went over the edge again. After going so long without, she felt like she could do this for days.

But alas, it had to stop somewhere. After this, she’d destroy Cadance’s limbs, clear up the blood, and teleport her torso and head back to her bedroom for further processing before presenting them to her new fiancé as a gift. There’d be a nation-wide mare-hunt for Cadance when it was claimed she escaped after attempting to murder Luna, but they’d never find her. With some clever perception-blocking magic on Cadance’s corpse, nopony aside from who Luna wanted would ever even see it there on her and Shining’s bed.

Though Luna also peered over at Spear. She had some extra business with him later on, if what she was detecting was correct, but had other things she wanted to do first.

“Shining dear,” Luna stroked him. “I’ll clean this up, then we’re report her terrible assassination attempt and fleeing to the guards. Afterward… join me in my room. I might have your gift ready, and perhaps a surprise atop that.”