Follyamory

Shining looked half-conscious, Luna’s thick love slime matting his belly fur with splotches of pink, her stolen chastity now just cherry pudding drooling down their thighs. The explosion drenched most of his body from thighs to muzzle. She tried to pause to give herself time to adjust to the agony between her legs, but the others weren’t having it.

Cadance must have noticed how Luna pried her front hole open, because she used her magic to do the same to Luna’s rear entry. Spear pulled her legs behind her harder, pressing his tip against it, but even with the magic assisting, his muscles tensed with the effort to get inside. As soon as he popped inside, Cadance released it to allow it to clench. The pain jolting up through Luna was even more intense, building upon the first. She wanted to cast a spell on herself for pain relief, but Cadance would no doubt consider that cheating.

Luna gave in and tried to scream outright, but before she got it out, Thrust rammed himself into her throat. He paid no heed to her comfort, grasping her head and shoving it downward, shivering at how her unwilling throat convulsed around him.

“Time to learn your place as a pin cushion, Slutmare,” groaned Thrust. “You’re not worth being called ‘princess’ anymore. You’re just a collection of holes to clench my dick.”

“That’s it, as hard as you can!” Cadance moaned, and Luna could hear the sloppy sound of her masturbating with both hooves even over the lewd squelch of her own triple virginity loss. “No mercy, give this cock tease a first time to remember. You’ve got to make up for all the stallions and mares that this bitch refused to put out for.”

The pain might have lessened at least had they just given her time to adjust, but there was no such dignity afforded her. Shining yanked Luna’s body upwards before slamming it back down again, bouncing her agonized body on his shaft. It was likely the only pussies he’d ever had were sluts like Cadance and Chrysalis, so it didn’t even occur to him that this might be hurting Luna.

The other two stallions knew full well they were hurting her, but only pounded her even harder. Spear didn’t even have the courtesy to take turns with penetration, ramming in at the same time as Shining, Luna’s sleek belly bulging at the girth of the twin shafts as her juice and blood dribbled down his and Shining’s ball sacks each time they collided beneath her.

She tried to shriek, but only send a flurry of vibrations over Thrust. His girth made it impossible to breathe when he pressed in, and she strained to catch tiny bits of air as he drew out. He felt his hooves over her neck, the shape of his shaft visible there. She looked down into her eyes with a sadistic grin; no doubt the power trip of abusing the Princess of the Night overshadowed anything she felt earlier in the night.

“Harder,” Cadance commanded them as she licked at Luna’s cheek. “She doesn’t deserve a moment to cope. She leaned over Luna’s shoulder, opposite to where Spear was gnawing her ear, to look at Shining, “So how does the Moon’s pie feel? As good as mine?”

“Ha, ha,” Shining grumbled as if Cadance had said something sarcastic.

“Oh you can say it,” assured Cadance. “You wanted to cuck me, right? So cuck away.”

“It’s heavenly,” admitted Shining, looking almost vindictive at Cadance. “I never thought I’d say this, but it’s so much better than yours. Maybe it’s from breaking in a thousand year old virgin pussy, or just from how lewd this whole thing is.” He smirked. “I’ll need to try a few more times to know for sure, but you’ve lost your chance to ever satisfy me now that I’ve had the royal Moon pie.”

Cadance ground against Luna’s bouncing flank as Shining ranked her below Luna. They definitely had an interesting relationship if she got off on that, and a contradictory one since she was obviously the dominant party in their marriage. Either way, the compliments to Luna were the opposite of encouraging, only pushing her down further.

“It’s because it’s rape,” Cadance whispered quietly into Luna’s ear. “It always feels better to dominate a fully unwilling partner, even if you don’t know they’re unwilling. You should try it sometime.”

So that was what this whole ruse with Shining was about? To show him how good it felt to violate a mare before she revealed to him that he was actually violating one? Every time Luna thought this whore couldn’t sink lower, she did, and she’d never despised her more. Besides that, regardless of Luna’s lack of consent, she’d at least like to think that she felt better to him for more reasons than that. Cadance was clearly delusional in her own warped beliefs.

“Here, let me help,” Cadance purred more loudly in Luna’s ear, before she grasped her hips in her magic. She seemed determined to make Luna into a proper slut, moving her hips to roll smoothly against the two males sandwiching her rather than bounce wildly. It felt like it just ended up stretching her passage in new ways to pain her more.

Luna clenched her teeth though as she also realized that as she moved, the hint of pleasure was building up beneath the stinging pain. It was such a contradictory feeling, pain almost like she was being fucked by knives, but her body reaching out to the physical gratification at the same time. She tensed up, trying to push it back down, but it kept welling up whether she wanted it to or not.

“Please,” Luna managed to push Thrust back for a moment to speak, tears rolling down her face. She looked at Cadance with a pleading expression, lowering to a whisper so Shining wouldn’t hear. “It hurts so bad.”

“What’s that?” Cadance purred, licking the new tears from her face along with the Spear. “Make it hurt so good? My goodness, I thought we should go easy on you, but just look at you. You’re actually tearing up from joy.”

Desperate as the sharp pains slowly dwindled, Luna tried to use her own magic to jab herself within, but the attempt drove her further and she immediately stopped. In another attempt, she tried to scrunch up her vaginal passage with her telekinesis, enough that Shining’s tip impacted her cervix directly, causing her whole body to convulse with each impact against her womb’s door. No, but it wasn’t enough, she still felt it welling up.

By contrast, her anus passage became drier with each thrust when it couldn’t replace the meager slime given by Cadance’s spit. Soon the only thing lubricating her there was the blood from her torn hole, and that made for surprisingly poor lubrication. But even that was being absorbed by the lust her brain was dumping into her system.

“Who said you could stop sucking to beg for more, slut?” laughed Thrust. “I’ll give you harder, but don’t you dare bite your master, dog.”

He yanked her muzzle open, prying it past the point of comfort and beyond. Luna cried out at the strain, in her panic giving him far more pleasure than she intended, but she couldn’t control her gagging through and lashing tongue, head dizzy from the lack of much needed air. He growled in frustration when he couldn’t get it to open wider.

“Mmm, just break her jaw,” Cadance suggested, making Luna’s already panicked eyes widen further. “No worries, alicorns have a healing factor. I’ve had my neck snapped during sex, and this powerful slut can take more damage than I can.”

“Yeah, remember what Slutmare said before the prince got here?” Spear grinned, playing along with a lie. “She said her lusts wouldn’t be satisfied if we didn’t break a few bones.”

“Yeah,” grinned Thrust. “I wouldn’t want this rabid tart to go home unsated on her first time.”

“Fuck this is amazing,” squeaked Shining. “I had no idea she would be this eager! I can’t wait to go for a matched set with her big sister. Being the first one to impregnate the two most forbidden mares in Equestria… this seems so impossible. And the slut actually wants us to break her? I thought it was just my wife being a snuff whore, but I guess all alicorns are kinky, and I like Luna’s kink so much more than Candy’s.”

“Oh you still have no idea how hot this is,” purred Cadance. “But you will.”

Luna tried to scream in rage and frustration only to gag violently again, just before something hard impacted the side of her face. She realized to her horror that Cadance and Shining had both picked up large rocks from the pond, and brought them together on her head so as to smash each jaw joint.

Combined with Thrust forcing it open, Luna’s jaw eventually gave in with a sickening crack as both joints fragmented. Blood streamed down her neck, rolling through her dark sweaty fur as he bent her jaw back all the way. He faced her upwards, opening it as wide as a snake swallowing prey and further tearing the flesh as her eyes rolled back.

Her face had been dizzying and uncomfortable, but now it stung even more than the other two holes had. She would have welcomed the added discomfort if it did anything to quench the growing flame in her loins, but it was like trying to put out a forest fire with a spray bottle. Thrust rammed directly in her throat with brutal strokes, belly smacking the roof of her muzzle as his balls bounced against her loosely hanging lower jaw.

Shining dropped his rock when he saw it had worked, but Cadance cracked her over the horn several times before dropping hers. The horn trauma seemed to intensify everything, both the torment and pleasure, swirling around and leaving her unable to do much more than twitch violently.

“Holy fucking horse apples,” groaned Cadance. “To see you bleed and convulse like this… Snuffing you and your sister out would be the hottest thing in Equestria, so you’re lucky I’m not wanting to take over… yet.”

“The rougher we are, the more she clenches,” Shining moaned. “It’s like a bliss blender down here, I had no idea she was this much of a masochist! This is so much more fun when I’m the one doing it!”

Luna tried not to be a bliss blender, but her pride wasn’t enough to stop the convulsions that was making her holes clench. Her pussy twisted and squeezed Shining’s stallionhood as his tip slammed into her cervix. Even when he finally broke through, ripping through directly into her womb, it just felt better, and she finally released all futile attempts to keep herself dignified in her lower portions. Her whole body seizured, and if Cadance hadn’t slammed on her horn with a rock already, she might have burst fireworks out of her horn.

Still under the impression that Luna was in a masochistic mood, Shining punched her in the stomach with both hooves, knocking what little air she had out. He continued to slam one hoof then the other, boxing her breasts and watching them bounce from the impacts as her unwilling body undulated atop him.

Emboldened by the other violence, Spear twisted her front legs back more, still drilling her tailhole as it tightened further with each new torment. Luna felt Cadance’s magic grasp her joints to assist him, and finally her knees gave out with a crack and wave of nausea through her body, more foul torment in the rising ocean of contradictory feeling.

Her body was wracked with jolts as they kept bending, bone splinters jutting through matted fur and bleeding flesh. In the corner of her eye, Luna watched in horror as they bent them all the way back at the knees, folding them fully in the other direction to shatter the joints.

He held her plot steady as he rammed into it the entire time. Luna’s keen hearing could make out each element, the squelch of pulsing flesh in each hole, the smack of the stallions’ balls together, the plunging of her throat and the trickle of blood down her front.

“Fucking tight,” Spear panted. “Sheesh, she’s having a seizure around my dick, how much of a masochist is she to get off on this shit? Was she stabbing herself in private to get off?”

“Well now she can stab herself in private while we fuck her lights out,” Thrust panted. “I can’t wait to tell my idiot wife I no longer want her back. Even this slut’s throat is better than her pussy, so I can’t wait to indulge more holes.”

“Such a pain slut,” Cadance purred. “Now Auntie, make sure to diminish your regeneration if you want to feel more pain.” Of course Luna didn’t want to, but had no choice but to do as she was told now. She let it slow her bleeding so she wouldn’t pass out, but her jaws and joints slowed their other mending.

Cadance got into it too, moving away from Luna’s flank. Instead she pushed Luna forward and down a bit, straddling her head as she stood up on her hind legs. As if her humiliation hadn’t been enough, Cadance pushed Luna’s horn into her own pussy, tensing and arching her back as her lips slid down the edges. As she did, she yanked Luna’s mane, though she couldn’t push all the way down without risking the little one inside her..

Luna couldn’t believe this was happening, raped by four ponies, three of which had a duty to guard her purity with their lives. As anger welled up inside her and Cadance’s pregnant vagina clenched at her horn, she felt her self-control slipping. Perhaps a little of her Nightmare half surged up, because she got visions of herself slamming her horn up into her tormentor’s vagina and stabbing out her and Shining’s first foal.

The only reason she didn’t was that Shining wasn’t as much at fault other than having chosen a very poor mate. And being dumb enough to think Luna was having a good time.

She did give Cadance a jolt of magical energy with her horn, but the other alicorn only moaned. Cadance responded by releasing her bladder, and Luna felt the warm stench of urine pouring down her head, matting her mane and stinging at her wounds. With her jaw shattered, she couldn’t avoid the disgusting fluid flowing down over her flaccid tongue.

Unfortunately, Luna lost self-control completely in another way, as her own bladder released shortly after, spewing the royal urine all over Shining’s belly and making him moan more as both mares tinkled down on him. Luna burned with shame, realizing that it would give him the impression that Luna did it on purpose because she liked what Cadance was doing. Would there be any fetish that they didn’t think she had at the end of this?

“That’s right,” Cadance purred. “This is all you are to me, Slutmare. Just a toilet.” She stroked a hoof over Luna’s wet face. “Control slipping, Auntie?”

Luna felt an odd tickle in the back of her mind. It seemed an insane thing to do, but she felt like Cadance was pushing her ever so slightly towards the edge on purpose. While the princess couldn’t take control of Luna outright, she could definitely edge her in a direction if she was already slipping, but why would she want her to lose her cool? Maybe she thought she would only lose it enough to nullify the deal, then she’d have gotten to use Luna and also still tell on her freely. Luna strained to keep her will strong.

“Fucking Luna damn it,” Spear swore appropriately. “Every time I think you can’t get sluttier, you somehow do.”

Thrust angled himself to better cut off her breathing and pressed a hoof against her throat. He clenched her throat hard until breathing was out of the question for her, but it allowed her to feel every detail of his throbbing member.

Luna had never felt so ashamed or dead inside. Her body convulsed all three holes milking their invaders whether she wanted to or not, but she was a void inside. Her eyes stung with Cadance’s piss, her mane and fur matted. These ponies were so eager to defile her, delighting in her suffering.

Luna felt her composure drained. While it wasn’t as visible to Shining with Cadance sitting on her head, she began to sob bitterly around Thrust’s shaft. She couldn’t stop herself even as Cadance leaned down, doubling over to get a look at her face, grinning widely as she watched her breakdown.

“Beautiful,” Cadance said loudly. “You always looked down on me, but who is looking down on who now, my broken little toy?” She added in a whisper. “Now dry up before Shining notices you sobbing like an infant, or this deal is off and you’ve given up your crusty consecrated cunt for nothing.”

Luna couldn’t have regained composure, her willpower was shattering. Lucky for her, the piss drooling from her face hid that she was crying, and soon she was dry of tears anyway. She just let them knock her back and forth between them as her rage died down into supreme humiliation.

She kept thinking they’d get off at any moment and it’d be done, but they didn’t for what seemed like forever. It seemed obvious Cadance had used magic to make sure they wouldn’t get off very easily in order to drag out Luna’s trauma, because they all lasted well over an hour. Cadance had no such limitation though, creaming on Luna’s horn only minutes after sitting on it and three more times while the stallions were hammering away, adding her disgusting orgasms to the combination of fluid dripping down Luna’s body.

Luna’s body had no such limit either, and she lost track of how many times her pussy betrayed her by exploding over Shining’s shaft. Cadance must have indeed have been working more magic as Luna’s defenses waned, because she felt the pain dry out into pleasure as well, and soon her body was lost in an ocean of it until her body seemed to actively crave more punishment, even intentionally twitching her injured limbs to jar them against her anal rapist.

Shining's royal shaft pulsated within the divine love tunnel, somehow even more wet than when they started. But despite being incredible for him, the waves of physical passion were tormenting her, yet she couldn’t turn it off. He twisted her heat-swollen breasts so that her milk mixed with all the other female juices that had drenched him on the bottom, continuing to twist further until they were red from the strain. No matter what any of them did though, it just felt better though.

Thrust didn’t tire at all either, and Luna had to wonder if Cadance hadn’t cast another spell to keep them going. He delighted in Luna’s anguish, repeatedly rubbing urine into her eyes. From time to time, he yanked at her free-hanging jaw, slowly prying it off, then finally ripped it off completely and tossed it aside. Blood poured down the front of her body, leaving her matted with red before her healing slowly sealed the bleeding. By then, she was probably unidentifiable if anyone had walked up to the scene. She had to wonder how Shining wasn’t completely grossed out by the gory mess he was plowing, but maybe he was desensitized by Cadance.

On top of that, Thrust did everything he could to keep her from breathing, leaning down and spitting fluid into her nostrils before clamping them shut, and Cadance helped by clenching her neck further with her magic. Luna kept fading and then popping back awake, repeatedly dying from oxygen deprivation and then having her cursed immortality kick in to bring her back. Even as her lungs and muscles burned from this, it didn’t dull the pleasure that frightened her more than any pain.

Spear didn’t let up either. He continued twisting her legs about until they came off at the knee, then began twisting her wings instead. With weaker bones and her defenses draining as she dutifully blocked her own regeneration, they gave more easily, but still took time to snap into pieces. Before he finished, they were more or less wadded up against her back, a mess of bloody feathers and shattered bone, as if he’d painstakingly wanted to break every single bone in them.

“If stallions knew how good this felt, they’d be tearing down your door,” Shining sounded strangely sincere. “Fuck I can’t believe I’m going to put a foal in you… I know my bitch wife is dragging this out, but damn I am going to cum so bucking hard when she stops… if she stops… please stop....”

Luna let her body go limp, submitting completely, letting her body act on its own. Shining arched his back as he felt her cunny milk him, wanting nothing more than to unleash a river of seed into her, yet still he didn’t go off. It had to be going on two hours by this point; how long would Cadance drag this out?

The longer they took, the more likely others might pass by and see. They were fucking in the grass beside a lake after all. No longer able to speak, Luna looked up at her with pleading eyes.

“Oh, ready are you?” Cadance laughed, looking down at Luna and licking her lips. “You ready, my masochist Auntie? You sure you’re okay with all of this… with a married stallion fueling that forbidden foal factory?”

Luna didn’t even think about it before nodding her head in affirmation, too tired and empty to even hesitate. She didn’t care if they thought she was a slut for answering so quickly, she just wanted this hell to end.

“See, Auntie, I told you this was amazing,” Cadance purred, continuing to lick her face even as it burned bluer from suffocation again. “You should loosen up like this more often. You know most stallions would love to be inside you, you could literally pick a stud at random and demand sex. I know you think it’d be scandalous, and it would at first, but your subjects would get used to it. My subjects in the Crystal Empire definitely don’t seem to mind their Princess randomly demanding sex in the streets.”

“Yeah, she really does that,” panted Shining, though didn’t sound enthused about it.

“Shut up and keep going, dear,” smirked Cadance.

Luna was certain that she’d never randomly offer her plot to a stallion in public. All the same, she wondered if there was even a point in trying to become celibate again. Virginity wasn’t just something she could get back. She was used meat and always would be. Worse, she knew more and more it was her fault that it happened.

“One more time, Auntie,” Cadance purred. “Is it knock up time? Or should we go for three hours?”

Luna looked up at Cadance, too broken to even bother glaring hatefully. She just nodded between bucks of Thrust's hips against her open throat.

As her body churned between them, another climax snuck up on Luna, and it felt so much more intense than the others that it terrified her. When it finally came shortly after the nod, it hit her like a train into a filly-guide cart. She felt barely even sapient, but began to nod more furiously. Her insides convulsed more than ever, begging for their sperm. She could never call it a good feeling, but it was definitely intense.

When Cadance released the stifling spell, all three males went off at once as well, packing her with fertile spunk from all directions. She felt Shining blast his load into her womb, her pussy milking him dry and sucking in his rich fertility. He hosed down the back wall of her womb as he packed it in, drenching her own fertile ovaries in his juice and sealing her shameful fate. Not only had she broken her vow, but was now impregnated by a married stallion.

Spear stabbed her asshole too, expelling a load deep into her bowels. She had never been sure of what made some ponies desire entry into their exit hole, but it felt tingly and warm inside, even when she felt the fluid burning at the friction sores inside her.

Thrust expelled his load as well, pushing flush to her face as he unloaded into her stomach. She nearly vomited at the mere thought of consuming such a perverse thing, but all she did was retch on his dick as he repeatedly pumped the vomit back into her tummy until it finally stayed down.

Luna placed a weak hoof against Thrust, though he gave her several heavier thrusts to pack his seed deeper before pulling out with a lewd slurp. She took a deep breath as he unplugged her muzzle, panting as she stared at the shaft in front of her, glistening with her saliva and his cum. She tried to instinctively close her muzzle only to remember half of it was missing.

Spear pulled out as well, causing her to shiver at the suction as he pulled his thick meat from her still tight ass. Shining did the opposite, grasping her hips and holding her down against him as if he wanted to bathe in her sacred warmth for as long as possible.

“Good filly,” Cadance laughed, finally pulling Luna’s horn from her nasty snatch and sliding down her back. “Patch your whore plot up.”

Luna let her healing kick in, Luna used her magic to retrieve her missing parts to expedite the process. Her jaw pulled back flush with her face, her shattered wings unfolding into a more dignified, if still bloody, state. The bones slowly sealed back together in her wings and her reattached legs, but they would be achy for days.

As she healed, Thrust and Spear moved back to either side. They stood on their haunches, grasping hold of one another above her and both releasing their urine as Cadance had. Luna didn’t question it, simply opening her muzzle like a good toy, turning up her head and guzzling their thick, bitter piss to wash down Thrust’s sperm.

She let it flow over her body, her forelegs moving to rub it into her fur, though she didn’t realize they did so until after they were going for it. Luna briefly tried to resist the lewdness, before giving in once again.

“You really...” Luna said when they finished. “In my condition, it is certain that I'm pregnant with your husband’s foal from this.”

“I know, isn’t it hot?” Cadance smirked at her.

“Y-yes,” Luna sighed. “As this is what I wanted… it’s... hot.”