Taking the Queen

Chrysalis was very much regretting her choice to let Starlight walk away. While it took a lot of convincing just to bring Fluttershy in here in the first place, it took even more to bring her to agree to help with Chrysalis' rehabilitation. Even then, she'd only agreed on the grounds that nopony watched them. Chrysalis had thought that this was solely due to performance anxiety. This was no less true than she'd thought, but there was something else lurking just below the surface.

Starlight had hung an enchanted blackout curtain over the cell door. Not only did it remove all light from flowing in and block any spectators, but its enchantment provided a lot of sound protection, as well, meaning that nopony outside could hear what was going on in there, nor could they hear or see outside. For all intents and purposes, they were completely alone.

It started off as expected. Fluttershy had been uncomfortable with her expectant stare, and had requested that she put on a blindfold. Then, concerned about Chrysalis removing her blindfold, she bound her hooves behind her back. At the time, Chrysalis had commented on Applejack's methods, asking if she was going to lick her hooves, but that had resulted in Fluttershy slapping her. It didn't hurt much, but that had been very unexpected.

It was very much a surprise how brutal Fluttershy could be, whispering things into her ear such as "You're going to tell everypony that you enjoyed it, or I'm going to have to come back," and "If you don't meet my standards, I'll tell Twilight you were mean to me." It was all very threatening.

That's why Chrysalis was very eager to please her. It would take no effort on Fluttershy's part to make good on her threats. If word began to spread that she had harmed Fluttershy, all of the goodwill she'd earned would immediately be forfeit.

Once she was tied up, Fluttershy pushed Chrysalis to the ground and sat on her face. Chrysalis immediately shot her tongue out of her mouth and into Fluttershy's snatch. It was dry, meaning there was no excitement to be found inside. Even the simple act of tying her up had excited Applejack a little bit, enough to notice the smell. With Fluttershy, Chrysalis had to use her own spit as lubrication just to be able to slip inside.

Her treatment didn't improve after that, either. Fluttershy's grip on her breasts was very tight and uncomfortable. She tugged and yanked on her nipples as though she was trying to pull them clean off, and Chrysalis just had to lie there and take it, pretending to enjoy the touch as she dug her tongue up inside of Fluttershy, doing everything she could think of to make the mare enjoy herself, but it seemed to be all for naught.

Thinking it might help her cause, Chrysalis pulled her tongue back into her mouth, then suddenly wiggled it up Fluttershy's arse, instead. Clearly, her first attempt wasn't doing anything for her, and she needed to rethink how she was going about satisfying her guest.

Fluttershy clamped down on Chrysalis' tongue and whimpered, which was the first feedback she'd given as to how Chrysalis was doing. For a moment, Fluttershy's hooves let up, giving some much-appreciated relief to her breasts. A single droplet of fluid dribbled from Fluttershy's labia and down Chrysalis' chin as she began to grind against her face. Finally, she was doing something right.

That thought was immediately dashed as Fluttershy leaned down and bit her thigh. Chrysalis really didn't want to make a scene, especially with nopony around to have seen her treatment, and she especially didn't want to infringe on Fluttershy's enjoyment, but she was absolutely hating this, with no control of her own. She just had to weather the abuse.

As Chrysalis took a deep breath in an attempt to calm herself down, however, she smelled something foul. It was expected that Fluttershy was disappointed with the services rendered, but mixed in with that emotion were several others. Foremost was fear, and if she concentrated, she could feel her guest trembling. There was also uncertainty and trepidation, along with a heaping dollop of anxiety. Most telling of all was that there was no comfort to be found in her at all.

Chrysalis sucked her tongue back into her mouth. "It's clear to me that you're not enjoying this. If you like, we can change positions."

Fluttershy slapped Chrysalis' tit. "Let me remind you which one of us is in ch-charge..."

Even the slap seemed forced, like Fluttershy was trying to put on an air of toughness. She was very timid in her normal behaviour, and it suited her very well. "If you still want to hit me, you can, but if it's not making you feel better, we ca--"

"I can't go through with this!" whimpered Fluttershy suddenly. She immediately climbed off and ran into the corner. Chrysalis didn't need her nose to find out that she was crying. She was clearly upset by this.

With her hooves still bound behind her back, Chrysalis rolled onto her stomach and crawled until her face hit the wall. With it supporting her, she lifted herself up onto her knees and waddled over to where the sobbing was. She sat down next to Fluttershy and contorted her body in a very uncomfortable position for the sole purpose of placing a wing on the weeping pegasus' shoulder.

"I don't want to do this," she sobbed. "I don't want to hurt you. I don't want to hurt anypony."

Chrysalis rubbed her shoulder. "Then why did you?"

Fluttershy sniffled. "I thought that's what I was supposed to do; take out my frustrations on you in a sexual manner."

"Are you really so frustrated that you needed to do all of this?"

There was a pause. With the tip of her wing, Chrysalis could Feel Fluttershy's head moving, but could not feel how. As soon as Fluttershy looked up, she realized that Chrysalis was still blindfolded. "No," she answered finally. "I didn't mean any of it, really. I just thought it was what I was supposed to do."

"Who told you that?"

Fluttershy shrugged. "I guess I just thought that way. Something in me wants to think you're still bad, and it wants your behaviour to prove it. I don't know what to think anymore..."

"Well, what do you really want?" asked Chrysalis. "What's supposed to happen is that I need to make sure you enjoy yourself. I need to show you a good time. Will you let me show you a good time?"

Fluttershy moved her head nebulously again. "I still don't want you looking at me. Can you leave the blindfold on?"