Author's Note

SPOILERS (This is what I would normally put at the BOTTOM of the chapter in the author notes:
I think this is probably the weakest of the three NSFW chapters. I was consciously aware of the fact that I was consistently failing to cover all five senses, but for some reason whenever I tried to come up with something for that sense I either couldn't imagine it to try and write about it, or I couldn't find the right words to describe it.

As a result some parts of this chapter feel more like a summary of a sexual encounter rather than a first person POV of an intense session of lewdness. I'm happy enough with the chapter though.

This is once again definitely skippable. With how soon it is after the last NSFW chapter I can see a decent chunk of readers skipping this one and maybe coming back to it at some point. Thanks for reading!

Kinks Included: Femdom, Hickeys, Very light biting and choking, Master/toy play, face sitting, Cowgirl, M/F, Creampie, An overuse of onomatopoeia's, Ahegao, Temporary Mind Break, and Magically induced forced orgasm

(NSFW) Main Quest - An Overdue Lay

We’re still sitting together in the canoe when I feel a sudden warmth around my ear. It’s gone as quickly as it arrived and I let out a gasp when she gently bites my neck. At the same time her right hand slides up the inside of my shirt, lightly dragging her nails as she travels up my chest.

I find myself panting for breath as the suction increases on the left side of my neck. “Hah…You’re really just going for it, huh?”

Suddenly all I feel is cold air on the left side of my neck as she responds. “Oh as soon as you got pissed at that mare and intimidated her into silence I found my thighs involuntarily rubbing against each other. That dominance really got me riled up and made me feel something I haven’t felt in quite a while..”

“Oh no you’re a sub too? How did we end up with a herd of four creatures and three of them as subs?”

“No…” She pauses and kisses my neck again. “That’s not quite the feeling that stirred in my chest.” Another pause is followed by another light bite on the neck. Then I feel her other hand grab the inside of my left thigh, slowly moving upwards. “I didn’t want to be on the receiving end of that dominance. It made me want to conquer that dominance.”

As she puts emphasis on the word, conquer, her hand goes from the inside of my left thigh to my groin. The constant assault on my neck, chest, thigh, and now groin start to overwhelm me as an embarrassing moan tries to force its way out of my mouth. I keep my lips sealed shut though so instead the only sound heard is a quiet, “Mmmph.”

“Music to my ears, little human. Look at you already putty in my grasp as I’ve got you completely ensnared. Your jewels are literally in the palm of my hand.” She gives me the lightest of squeezes with the aforementioned hand currently resting on my groin. “Honestly I thought you’d put up a bit more of a fight.”

With an impossible quickness her left hand leaves my groin and slides down, under my dress pants. She wraps that hand around my member as she suddenly bites my neck again with a bit more force. I can feel those fangs threatening to pierce me as she sucks in, hard, trying her damndest to give me a bruise.

Getting hit with both at the same time, completely out of nowhere, makes me arch my back. I push the back of my head against her breasts and press myself harder against her mouth. “Oh yes. It should be no problem to make you mine. What do you think about retiring and just living out your role as my toy? Would you like that?”

“Ahhn, N…no. I’d never….hah…demean myself to something so low as a toy.”

“Oh? The mighty knight still has some fight left in him? If that’s the case then why aren’t you stopping me? You know right now you’re already my toy, yes? C’mon just imagine it. Luna and Celestia can rule the kingdom and you can just lose yourself in me entirely. No worries, no fears, no thoughts.” She punctuates each pause with another brief kiss to my neck. “So why don’t you stop lying to me and to yourself and just accept that you are mine.”

My pants are now alarmingly tight as she pumps her left hand at a slow but consistent pace. “N-n-n…no. Never.”

Suddenly all of the sensory overload stops and I no longer feel her entangling me. Until I’m suddenly spun around and pushed backwards into the canoe. As I land on my back, laying down, I feel a weight come to rest on my waist. As I look into the woman's predatory gaze she pounces. Both of her hands come down onto my own, our fingers interlocking. Her face mere inches from mine as I feel her breath against my face.

Nightmare starts to ever so slightly grind herself into my groin as she licks her lips. “You are going to worship me.”

Without allowing me a chance to refuse she closes in and locks her lips with mine. The force of her grinding increases as her tongue dominates and explores my mouth. After a few seconds her tongue withdraws and she bites my lower lip with a slight tug. When she releases me and pulls away I find myself a bit dazed and breathing heavily. Her purple hair is like a curtain as I feel it on the sides of my face, cool to the touch.

“Do your worst.” I barely manage to quietly utter the phrase in between breaths and I give her a lazy smirk.

Nightmare flashes her fangs as a wicked smile breaks out on her blushing face from my challenge. “I shall introduce you to one of your primary duties as my toy, then.” The canoe rocks left and right a bit as Nightmare stands up and takes two steps forward. I’m treated to a view straight up her dress as I eye the lacy black panties being worn underneath. Down her thigh there’s already a small trail of fluid.

She reaches down and pulls her panties to the side before descending onto my face. “A Goddess such as myself deserves only the best to serve as my throne.”

I feel her grab a handful of my short black hair before she tugs upward, as a result my lips meet her lower lips. Using both hands I grab her hips tightly and pull down as I open my mouth and my tongue darts forward. She lets out a gasp as my tongue brushes between her outer folds before flicking across her clit. I’m instantly treated to the taste of blackberries in my mouth as I repeatedly and forcefully drag my tongue across her sensitive nub.

Every gasp and breathy moan motivates me to continue. An overwhelming sense of satisfaction washing over me, knowing that it’s my efforts causing her to make this symphony.

My hands start to wander up the sides of her body in a slow and methodical motion. She looks down and we make eye contact as I rub my hands all over her. From her bosom down to her thighs pressing tightly against the sides of my head. When they travel up her body once more I grab the strapless dress and pull down, my eyes drink in the sight of her breasts spilling out as the dress is pulled down and away from them.

Nightmare lets out a heavy gasp as I grab both of the double D sized perky melons with a decent amount of force. Greatly enjoying the softness of her tits as I squeeze them. With my left hand I let go and lightly pinch her nipple, causing her to release a sharp gasp that turns into a moan.

She starts grinding herself against me as I continue to assault her chest. In between moans she decides to taunt me again. “I didn’t even tell you to do this, you know? I simply instructed you to act as my throne, and you began servicing and worshiping me like this all on your own. Your actions and your body continue to expose your lies every step of the way. It’s your baser instinct, you just know you’re meant to serve me.”

The pressure around my head from her thighs spikes out of nowhere and she starts to tremble. The hand grabbing my hair pulls me up with even more force. “Something’s happening! Something’s coming!” She seems almost confused about the overwhelming pressure and heat she's feeling that signals her approaching her peak. It’s then that I’m reminded of the fact that this is her first time.

Her grinding becomes more erratic as her moans become higher pitched. I decide to send her over the edge by speaking directly into her mind.

“You’re right. I am completely yours, mistress. Please cum for your unworthy throne, and allow me the satisfaction of fulfilling my new purpose in life, to give you pleasure.”

The effect is instant and I start to fear for my life as she threatens to crush my skull with her thighs. Her back arches as she releases an ear piercing scream. My mouth is filled with her essence and it starts to run out the sides of my mouth as I try to greedily drink it all.

All at once the pressure is relieved and I start gasping for breath as my head is freed from between her legs. When the woman glances down at me while breathing heavily it seems like she’s lost in a haze. Her eyes are unfocused. Her horn ignites and I suddenly feel the cold night air against my entire body. The magic leaves both of us completely bare and exposed.

Nightmare shuffles backwards until I feel an intense warmth resting against the middle of my cock as it lays flat against my groin and stomach. She slowly moves back and forth and my eyes start to roll up as her folds move along my shaft. If she already feels this good I can’t imagine what it’ll feel like when she actually puts it in.

Momentary lucidity overcomes me and I realize an important question. “Are you sure you want your first time to be in that form? This is all for you so if you’d rather be in your alicorn form then I wouldn’t mind in the slightest.”

Her gaze looks a bit annoyed as I break character. “Don’t question me. If I wanted to be in a different form I’d have done it regardless of your preference.” That annoyed scowl turns into a playful smirk. “Besides, I plan on doing it with both forms tonight.”

She lifts herself off of me and uses telekinesis to line up my member with her entrance. “Who do you belong to?”

“You, Nightmare Moon.”

“What is your purpose?”

“To serve and pleasure you, mistress.”

“Where is your place?”

“Beneath you, mis-Mmm….ahn.”

When I answer her final question I feel myself completely enveloped with an unprecedented level of tightness as she slams herself down on me. Another embarrassing moan slips out at the unexpected timing. I can feel myself twitching in her as she flexes herself around me.

Then I watch as the woman stares down at me with a familiar predatory gaze as she places both of her hands on my chest. Without a word she pushes herself up and drops back down. Picking up speed as she gets into a rhythm and starts to bounce on me in earnest.

After a couple of minutes I grab her hips and start to synchronize my own thrusts upwards with her descent. It feels like I’m melting inside her as I’m constantly being milked. Then she suddenly leans down and locks lips with me while continuing to bounce up and down. My eyes roll up as she dominates the inside of my mouth. Then I feel a hand wrap around my throat and when she applies some pressure my back arches and my toes curl as I moan into her mouth.

Her other hand flexes and her nails start to dig into my chest as she slams into me harder and harder. My own hands start to deathgrip her hips as I curl my fingers and my own nails start to dig into her ass.

Nightmare breaks the kiss and looks like she can barely hold herself up as her head hands right next to mine and I feel her breathing in my ear. The soles of my feet start to cramp from how long my entire body has been tensed. “Nightmare, I can’t hold on any longer!”

“Not yet. You won’t finish until I allow you to do so! Just a little more…. Ahn… Fuck fuck fuckfuckfuck, LUCAS!”

When she screams my name I feel her start to spasm around me, and she slams down to the hilt one last time. With my own low growl that turns into a roar I thrust up and pull her down as hard as I can, trying to get even a centimeter deeper. I feel my tip push against something as stars start to fill my vision and my entire body locks up.

After the first two throbs Nightmare releases a whorish moan, this one coming from her core as she trembles. “Maker above! Yesyesyes fill me up!”

The woman apparently cums again in an instant just from the feeling of her first creampie. The fifth throb hits and I can’t stop myself from grunting. It’s her turn for her eyes to roll up as her tongue lolls out of her mouth and I feel her gush around me.

Then it’s over. My entire body goes limp as all of the tension leaves me and Nightmare collapses forward laying down on me. After several seconds of heavy breathing between the two of us, Nightmare is the one to finally break the silence. “That is…dangerous. I might seriously get addicted to that. It’s like my entire body is washed over with a blinding pleasure as I feel that sudden warmth in my core. Like I accomplished my life's mission.”

“That’s your brain dumping dopamine because of your biological need to breed. It thinks I just put a baby or two in you so it fires off those fulfillment chemicals now that you’ve passed on your genetics.”

“Too many science words. Can’t think.” I just pat the woman on the head.

“So uh, for your other form…are we also doing that in the boat? Cause I’ll be honest I think that won’t go as smoothly.” Pretty sure we’d fucking capsize.

“Ah no. We’ll be going back to the castle. I never intended for this little boat to be where we had our moment, but I just didn’t want to wait anymore.” With that she ignites her horn and we find ourselves in Luna’s bedroom. Looks like no one else is in here at the moment.

As soon as I look back at the bed I see Nightmare already back in her alicorn form, laying on her belly on the bed with her hind legs hanging off the side of the bed. Her tail laying flat across her spine instead of hanging where it normally does. I revert back to my original form instead of my human form.

I walk up and take my place behind her, and squat down until I’m eye level with her winking sex. Interestingly the products from our first round are still present and running out and down the inside of her hind legs. With no warning I dive back in and lick her nub as it flicks out momentarily.

I’m treated to a delightfully cute noise from the alicorn as she yelps in surprise but it transforms into a moan halfway through. I only get to enjoy the taste of blackberries for a few seconds before she calls out my name and tells me to stop. “I’m worked up enough from our first go around, just fucking rut me.”

“Rude. Maybe I wanted some seconds before getting to the dessert, hm?”

“Feel free, but feeling you leak out of me set me ablaze as soon as I stood up and gravity took effect. I am raring to go.” Now that I’m looking closer her outer folds are already swollen and damp. Damn, she really got worked up this much in that short period of time? That’s kinda hot.

Standing back up to my full height I line myself up before leaning down and nibbling on the alicorn's ear. After a couple of seconds I release it and whisper to her. “Just so you know, this is going to be a different beast entirely if you’re letting me take the wheel.”

“I doubt it could be tha- AHHN” I interrupt her by grabbing her dock and slamming myself down to the base in one go. When she was riding on top she’d only push herself up around halfway before coming back down, so I elect to go a bit slower than normal but in exchange for the slower speed I pull out all the way to the tip before slamming back in just as hard as the first time. It’s a steady rhythm of long, deep, and hard thrusts.

“How can- oh fuck- it feel-mmmf- so different?! Maker above don’t stop.”

Deciding I want to pick up the pace I let go of her tail and slap her cutie mark before sinking my hands into her flanks in a death grip. Using both hands combined with a slightly wider stance lets me keep the same length and depth for my thrusts but at a faster speed.

Within seconds her cunt turns into a vice grip as my groin is splashed with marecum. I don’t relent at all though, I think she’s trying to ask me to slow down because of how sensitive she is right now. But, she can’t really string together anything coherent right now.

“Not soOOommf- fasht- hnng ahn PLEASCH- hah ahn nnnnf- I’m gunna break.” The mare goes limp and her head falls down onto the bed and I worry I might’ve actually fucked her silly, so I slow down and stop thrusting so hard.

In response she weakly lifts her head while breathing heavily. “Please let up for a few seconds when I go over the edge. Please Gods above. I thought I was about to lose my mind, I could see stars all over and my entire body was tensed up from the radiating pleasure. I really thought I might die.”

“Got it. So are you ready to go now?”

She floats over a couple of pillows and puts one under the middle of her barrel and the other one under her chin. “Yes.”

As soon as I hear the word yes I grab a fistful of her mane in my left hand and the base of her right wing with my right hand. I tug backwards and she bites into the pillow before throwing her head back and letting her eyes roll up.

The next time I feel her walls constrict around me and hear a muffled scream into the pillow I decide to let her experience the same thing I did to Luna our first time. In the middle of her climax I cast Command. “Cum for me.”

The instant she registers the one word command the pillow falls out of her mouth and she releases a primal whinny at an ear shattering volume. Sparks fly out of her horn as the whinny turns into gutteral moans and grunts. Her greedy cunt is constricting so hard it’s literally pulling me when I try to pull out so I can keep thrusting.

That sensation combined with the unreal level of tightness is enough to finally push me over the edge. I give her mane one final yank as I collide with her so hard the entire bed slides a few inches across the floor. Everything goes fuzzy as I let out a silent scream and unload into the alicorn's womb for the second time tonight.

Nightmare goes limp and collapses on the bed with her tongue lolled out of her mouth and I watch her eyes twitch and hear her breath hitch with every throb.

Once I’m finished I collapse on top of the pony and it takes all of my willpower to not just pass out on the spot.

“So I take it the date went well?” I don’t even have the energy to be startled or embarrassed as my eyes lazily glance in the direction of Luna's voice.

“Aren’t you supposed to be at Court right now?”

“I had to call for a recess when everypony in the throne room heard a scream followed by a rather lewd whinny sound. I assured them that everything was fine and that we had some drafts caused by damages from Discord, and the wind sometimes made a noise like that. What did you do to her for her to have that kind of reaction?”

“I did that trick where I used the Command spell to order her to cum while she was already in the middle of an orgasm. She went cross eyed, made that noise, sparks flew from her horn, and she hasn’t said a word since. I think I might’ve actually broken her.”

“No, she just needs a few minutes to realize she isn’t dead. I remember that feeling, it was so intense I couldn’t see anything, couldn’t move, and couldn’t even breathe. I really thought I’d died on the spot. Totally worth it, though.”

Sure enough after a few more seconds I hear the alicorn under me start to mutter. “Please no, not the mahogany desk. I can’t wait in that line again. Oh. I’m alive?”

“Yep. Alive and kicking.” I roll off of her and lay down next to the alicorn before wrapping my arms around her and pulling her close. “I gotta figure out how to get us both some water and a couple of towels. We need the hydration and the wipe down.”

“I’ll have a maid bring some in for you.” Luna responds with a smirk on her face as she stares at us on the bed.

“I don’t quite like the idea of a maid walking in here and smelling….this. Plus you can see everything from the doorway. It’s embarrassing.”

“Hm, very well then. I’ll have them leave at the door and knock three times to let you know it's arrived. Then you can bring them in yourself.”

“Thanks Lulu.” The alicorn just shakes her head with a small smile on her face before teleporting out.

Nightmare flips over and faces me as we both lay on our sides. I lean forward and give her a kiss before slightly pulling away and sharing my breath with her. “Love you, Moonie.”

“I love you too, Ignis.” It only takes a few seconds of breath sharing for the calming feeling to wash over me.

Unfortunately neither of us stayed conscious long enough after that to hear the maid knock on the door with the water and towels.

Followers: 3,900.