The sounds of chirping birds slowly stirred Button up from his slumber, and the shining light of Celesta’s rising sun bore into the window, illuminating the room.

“Mmmmrgh,” Button grumbled as a ray of light hit his eye, prompting him to roll over to avoid it and sleep some more. When he did so, he felt his face land in something very soft, causing him to smile and snuggle into the soft material.

Then, he heard a giggle that he didn’t recognize, causing him to furrow his brow, before a familiar hand gently ran along his shoulder. “Mmmm, good morning, Chrysalis,” he said as he rolled back over onto his back and opened his eyes while looking to his left.

His vision was slightly blurry from sleep, but after rubbing his eyes, it cleared up, and he saw Chrysalis sitting upright next to him, her belly as big as two large watermelons.

“Good morning Button,” She replied as she gently pat her belly. “Sleep well?” She asked him.

“Mmm, yeah, I feel fine,” He answered.

“Oh good,” Chrysalis said happily. “Luna here was a bit worried,” She continued as she looked beyond him.

“Oh, well that’s swe-Luna?!?!?!!!” Button exclaimed, rocketing into an upright position and turning his head to his right like he’d been bitch-slapped.

His eyes then widened and jaw dropped a bit upon seeing Princess Luna sitting on the bed next to him in the nude, her belly as large as two and a quarter beachballs.

“Good morning, Button Mash,” She greeted him with a small smile. “I am glad to hear that the potion from last night has not damaged you in any way,” She continued, giving Chrysalis a small frown as she spoke, while Button furrowed his brow with confusion.

“What potion are you-” Button began, before his eyes widened as his mind woke up a bit more, and the memories of the previous night’s events came back to him. “Holy buck!!” he continued, putting a hand to his mouth in shock as he looked at Princess Luna. “I bucked you!!”

“You most certainly did,” Princess Luna said with a smile, before she looked at her swollen belly and carefully rubbed her hand across it.

“All according to our plan,” Chrysalis added with a grin, causing him to arch an eyebrow and turn to her briefly with a very confused look.

“What plan?” He asked her.

“It’s really Chrysalis’ plan,” Luna said as she stared at her belly. “She confronted me about my feelings for you, and decided to get me involved with last night’s activity,” She continued. “We set up Phasmophilia so that you’d get pulled into it, with us roleplaying as two of the many ghosts in the game.”

“So, wait, that was all real?!?” He questioned with shock. “The house, the old furniture, the words appearing in front of me. It was all real?!”

“Yes, with Discord’s help,” Luna answered, causing his eyes to widen even more and jaw to drop a bit.

“You got Discord involved?!”

“Well of course!! I may be an alicorn, and Chrysalis a changeling queen, but neither of us know of any spells to enter a video game world,” Luna explained. “He was very happy to help, as long as we let him be in charge of your streaming while we were busy with you,” she continued, frowning slightly.

“He was what?!?!!” Button exclaimed, his heart leaping into his throat a bit at the thought of the Lord of Chaos handling his stream.

“He was running your stream,” Chrysalis repeated, putting a hand on his shoulder as she spoke. “And he let everypony watching see you take care of us,” She continued with a grin, causing his face to pale a bit and his jaw to drop even more.

“Cannot believe he did that!!” Luna growled as she drummed her fingers gently on her belly while he stared off into nothingness. “I told him to take it seriously, and he goes and does that. That’s the last time I ask him for a favor,” She continued, her growl growing louder.

“Oh, you should have expected he’d do something like that,” Chrysalis replied with a chuckle. ‘He is the Lord of Chaos after all. And besides, it’s not that big a deal. Button’s watchers will just think that it was another female changeling that looked like Nightmare Moon,” She continued as she looked at Luna.

“He put credits at the end of the video,” Luna said with a somewhat low tone and a huff. “Not to mention that my sister was watching, and she’d know it was me,” She continued. “He will pay for that.”

“I think you’re overreacting,” Chrysalis replied, before shrugging. “But if you want him to really pay, just let Fluttershy know what he did. She’ll reel him in and give him what she deserves,” She said with a grin.

“Hmm, thank you for the information, Chrysalis,” Luna said with a smile, before she looked at Button. “How are you feeling dear Button?” She asked him gently, putting a hand on his shoulder as she did so, which snapped him out of his daze.

“Oh, ummmm, shocked, scared, confused, happy,” He replied, before a thought occurred to him. “So, what happens now?” He asked, looking from her to Chrysalis questioningly.

“Hmm, well, that all depends on you and Princess Luna, Button,” Chrysalis said to him, making him cock his head a bit with more confusion. “After last night and hearing what Luna said to me yesterday before our activity, I’ve come up with an idea,” She continued, prompting Luna to look at her with an arched eyebrow.

“And, pray tell, what is this idea you have come up with?” Luna asked.

“Given what you told me about how you feel about my stud here, I was hoping that we all start a herd together,” Chrysalis replied, causing their eyes to widen with surprise.

“A what?!” Button exclaimed with shock.

“You wish for us to form a herd?” Luna asked her, with Chrysalis nodding in response. “Why??”

At that, Chrysalis sighed for several seconds. “Because you and I both love Button dearly, yet know so little about being in love with somepony,” She replied. “I figured that, maybe, we could learn about that together,” She said, causing Luna’s eyes to widen and start to tear up.

Luna then sniffed, and rubbed her eyes for several seconds, before she looked back at her with a smile. “I think that is an acceptable idea,” She answered, having thought she’d never have a chance with Button. “What do you think, dear Button?” She asked the stallion, whose eyes were even wider after hearing Luna’s response.

“You…you want to…share me?” Button asked as he slowly turned to look at Chrysalis.

“Yes,” Chrysalis replied simply with a nod, causing his eyes to twitch a bit, before he slowly turned to Luna.

“And you really love me? Not puppy love, but love love?” He asked her.

“I love you more than the moon and its precious light!” Luna replied with a bit of a blush as she looked at him. “I want to be your marefriend Button Mash,” She continued as she took one of his hands with her free one. “If you will have me.”

Button’s eyes twitched some more upon hearing that, with his pupils dilating slightly, before he slowly turned his head so he was facing the TV. He then breathed in and out slowly and deeply for about a minute, before he sighed.

“Yes, I’ll have you Princess Luna,” he replied as he looked at her, a smile growing on his face as he did so. “I’ll be your coltfriend.”

Upon hearing that, Princess Luna let out a high-pitched “EEEE!” of excitement, tears forming in her eyes with happiness, before she slammed her lips into his. His eyes widened as he felt her lips press hard into his own, while she grabbed him with her other arm and pulled him closer to her.

Chrysalis chuckled as she watched Luna kiss Button passionately, before she broke out into a giggle upon hearing Luna let out a happy hum as Button started to kiss her back. “I think this is the start of something wonderful,” She said happily as Button wrapped his arms around Luna and deepened the kiss.

Then a couple seconds later, the sounds of a doorknob turning got the attention of all three individuals in the room, and the door opened up to reveal Button’s mom with a basket of food in her arms. Everyone stopped what they were doing and turned to the door.

“Button, I figured that you were hungry so I thought that I would surprise you with-” she stopped mid sentence when she noticed Chrysalis, Luna, and her son Button Mash were all naked in the room, and both mares had their bellies heavily bloated with his semen. The smell of sex permeated the air and she let out a sigh.

“You couldn’t have put a sock on the doorknob to let me know that you had someone over for the night?” she added with a dull stare. “I could’ve made breakfast for everyone here right now. Did I interrupt something btw?”

“Do you mind?” Chrysalis groaned in annoyance.

“I’ll just wait in the kitchen,” she said with a sigh and closed the door behind her, before her eyes widened as she realized something. “Wait, was that Princess Luna?!” She questioned, before she cracked the door open and looked back inside.

Upon seeing the alicorn still staring at the door, her eyes widened to the size of dinner plates, and she shut the door quickly, before putting a hand to her mouth as she gasped. ‘Holy mother of Celestia!!’ She thought as she stared at the doorway, before she slowly turned and started to walk away. ‘My son got lucky with Princess Luna!!’ She continued as she walked away. ‘That-I never-not even in my wildest dreams!! I can’t believe it!’

Meanwhile, Chrysalis smiled as she looked from the door back to Button and Luna. “Well then, now that she’s gone, make some room,” She said to the two of them as she started to move. “Mama wants in on that action,” She continued with a grin as she slowly crawled over Button’s legs and then headed towards their faces.

As she reached them and leaned forward while puckering her lips, Button thought, ‘My life is awesome!’

One month passed since that night, and Button found his life becoming rather busy during said month. First off, when Twilight returned a week later, having taken care of the emergency in Saddle Arabia with Princess Celestia, she had requested that Chrysalis talk with her in private.

That had, of course, put Chrysalis on edge, and Button, wanting to be supportive, suggested he come with her. She agreed, and a few days after Twilight had returned, she and Button went to talk with her. In said talk, Twilight revealed that she had overheard Chrysalis’ breakdown about her fears due to a monitoring spell she’d put on the castle after the whole ’changeling kidnapping’, which she’d put on it so she’d know if Chrysalis was in the castle at any point. That revelation had made Chrysalis freak out a bit and run out of the room, prompting Button to go after her.

It took him several attempts before he was able to convince her to begrudgingly talk with Twilight six hours later, with her nervously trembling when they went back to her.

When they talked for the second time, Twilight said emphatically that she was not going to do anything to Chrysalis. She wasn’t going to perform horrible experiments on her, nor were any of her friends going to do anything bad to her. Chrysalis, of course, voiced how she heavily doubted that, pointing out that she’d been absolutely horrible to Twilight at their first encounter, and pretty bad with their second, so of course Twilight would want to torture her.

Twilight responded emphatically in the negative upon hearing that, and she even performed the famous “Pinkie Swear” that Chrysalis had seen her friends perform before. That did not really ease Chrysalis’ fears, which she revealed, before she turned and left the room, leaving Button and Twilight alone. The two then discussed how scared Chrysalis was of everypony except him, how sad it was that she felt that way, and then Button asked what they could do to help. Twilight told him to just be with her for now, while she lets her friends know what’s going on.

That night, he’d comforted Chrysalis in her bed, rubbing her back and wings while they laid there. When the next day came, Twilight brought Button to the throne room while Chrysalis took a nap with the eggs, another batch of eggs growing in her belly from her intense love-making session with Button and Luna/Nightmare Moon. There, he spoke with Twilight’s friends, who expressed their horror at what Chrysalis feared they might do to her, with Fluttershy being the most horrified, followed by Applejack. Twilight also revealed that Celestia was very sad to hear how Chrysalis was feeling, and Cadance had been horrified more than she’d ever been in her life upon hearing Chrysalis’ fears.

When he asked them what they could do to help Chrysalis, they revealed that they had come up with a plan that should help Chrysalis out with her extreme fear and paranoia. It was a long-term plan, but it was a rather simple one.

They agreed that about three times a week, Button and Chrysalis would help out one of Twilight’s friends, with the goal being to ultimately get Chrysalis to lose her fear of the ponies. But they decided to wait for her eggs to hatch before they started the plan.

While that was happening, Button had to also deal with the fact that he was now dating Princess Luna!!

At first, only his mother knew about him being with Luna, as they’d revealed the relationship during breakfast, which had caused her to faint with the biggest smile on her face.

But Luna’s frequent visits to Ponyville had not gone unnoticed, and soon a photo of him having a picnic with her appeared in the papers and on the Internet. He was immediately called to Canterlot by Princess Celestia, who told him to be the best coltfriend her sister ever had, before she hugged him and Luna happily, a cry of happiness coming from her mouth as she did so. Tears also had streamed down her cheeks, and she revealed that she was so happy for her sister, and that she hoped for the best.

Before he’d returned to Ponyville, Luna showed him around Canterlot, showing him some of her favorite places, as well as introducing him to her personal guards and her pet possum Tiberius.

When he returned to Ponyville, he was accosted by paparazzi for a couple days, with Chrysalis and Twilight having to get him away from the reporters and photographers.

He asked Twilight for help, and she suggested that he let Luna know what’s going on, which he then did, with her teleporting the message to her. Luna almost immediately responded in person, with Celestia coming with her as well, and the two revealed that they were going to be making an announcement later that day about the reporters accosting him and his family.

After the announcement had been made, with Celestia revealing in said announcement that if they were harassed or bothered in any way, they’d have to answer to her. They were only bothered by a couple stupid reporters after that for about a week, before those reporters were brought to talk with Celestia.

And another big thing that had happened during the month was that all 69 eggs that Chrysalis had laid beforehand had hatched into very healthy grubs. Their looks had slightly thrown him off, but he’d quickly moved past that when he’d held one of his daughters in his arms, and she’d snuggled against his chest before looking up at him with her big, dark purple eyes. He loved each and every one of his children, and found that they were a bit of a handful, as they were rather curious of their surroundings. His mother and Chrysalis were happy to help him out with learning how to be a parent, with Mr. Cake giving him advice on how to be a good dad, which he greatly appreciated. His mother was also so proud of him giving her so many grandchildren to spoil, which she was doing a very good job of, giving them as much love as she could and taking lots of photos of them in cute outfits.

About two weeks after the eggs had hatched, Chrysalis laid all 50 eggs she had gotten from their late night session with Luna, and then a week later jumped him in the shower for another session, which ended up with her getting knocked up again, much to her and his mother’s pleasure and his shock.

Now, Button was sitting in the nursery on a very comfy pillow, reading a story to all his kids. Some were watching him intently, and others were sleeping, digesting the large amount of love they’d been given earlier. “...and that is how the zebras got their stripes,” he said as he shut the book and looked at his kids with a large smile. ‘I can’t believe Chrysalis insists on me reading these books to the kids,’ he thought as he set the book to the side, before he reached down and picked up one of his kids. ‘I mean, they’re two weeks old and the books she’s having me read are for two-year-olds! They’re not going to understand any of it!!’ he continued as he looked at the male grub in his hands, before he pulled him close and kissed him on the snout, eliciting a small happy hiss from the grub.

“I love you too, Omma,” He said to the grub, before he set him back down and picked up another grub, a female one this time. “And you too, Zyga,” He continued as he pressed his muzzle against her tinier one, causing her to giggle and wrap her forelegs against his nose.

As he started to set his daughter down and pick up another grub, Chrysalis walked into the room, her belly as big as a yoga ball. “Button dear, Luna’s here,” She said, catching his attention. “She wants to talk with both of us upstairs in the guest bedroom you stay in,” She continued as some of their grubs crawled over to her hooves and looked up at her with wide eyes, hissing and giggling as they did so.

“Oh, about what?”

“Not sure honestly,” Chrysalis replied, holding back a grin, as she knew exactly why the lunar princess was there. “It seems to be about something quite important,” She continued as she lifted up some of the children with her magic, and put them in her arms. “You should go on ahead. I’ll tuck the children in for their nap.”

“Okay Chrysalis,” Button said with a nod as she lifted up the rest of the children with her magic and levitated them over to their small beds, which were built onto the walls with little barriers of slime preventing them from rolling out. “I’ll see you up there,” He continued, standing up and walking out of the nursery, but not before giving her a kiss on the lips.

As she listened to him walk away, she smiled, and then chuckled a bit. “Heheh! I wonder how he’s going to take the news?” She asked, before she walked over to the beds and started to hum a soft tune.

“I wonder what Luna wants to talk to us about?” Button questioned as he headed towards the guest bedroom, a curious look on his face. “Did something bad happen? Does she want to go on another date?” he asked, remembering how fun the last date had been. Said date had consisted of him and Luna playing laser tag and eating pizza, and had been very fun for the two of them. Then, they’d gone back to the castle, and had a passionate night, with him having a large hickey on his neck that was still somewhat present, as the date had only been four days ago.

As he pondered over what Luna could want to talk to him and Chrysalis about, he soon reached the guest bedroom and entered it, where he saw that Luna was pacing across the room, a small dark blue bag sitting on the bed.

“Luna, what’s wrong?” He asked the princess, seeing that she had a nervous look on her face.

His voice caused her to jump a bit, and stop pacing, turning her head to look at him as well.

“Ah, my dear Button, you got here quickly,” Luna said with slight surprise.

“Well, yeah, Chrysalis said you had something important to tell us,” Button replied as he walked up to her, and took one of her hands. “So, what’s up?” He asked her. “What’s got you pacing across my room?” He continued.

At that, Luna began to sputter. “Well, um, I uh…I learned that-I fo-Oh, how do I say it??” She questioned, before Chrysalis walked into the room, having successfully tucked the grubs in for their nap.

“How do you say what, Moona?” Chrysalis asked in a teasing tone as she walked over to them, causing Luna to blush a bit at the nickname.

“Well, I-I, um, i went to, you know, um,” Luna stammered, much to Chrysalis’ amusement and Button’s confusion. “I-I-I discovered that, well, I um, a-”

“Oh, what’s this?” Chrysalis said upon spotting the bag on the bed, levitating it over with her magic. “A present? Oh, you shouldn’t have!!” SHe continued as she reached into the bag and grabbed what was inside, before she pulled it out.

“Don’t!!” Luna exclaimed, leaping at her with an outstretched arm. “Put it back!!” She continued as Chrysalis held the bag’s contents out of reach with a grin.

“But it’s a present, and presents should be shown to those who get them,” Chrysalis replied, before she grabbed LUna’s horn firmly at the base to prevent the use of magic. “Take a look Button, she got us something special,” She continued as she moved her hand over to him and opened it, revealing the bag’s contents to him, which made Luna’s eyes widen even more.

At first, Button saw that it was a pregnancy test. One of the more expensive ones, from what he’d been shown in health class. ‘Why’d she get us this? Chrysalis always knows when she’s pregnant,’ He thought with confusion as he picked up the purple and white rectangular object to look at it closer, which caused Luna to freeze in place.

And when he did, his eyes caught sight of something that made his heart leap into his throat. There, in the exact middle of the test, was a large green checkmark.

He stared at the checkmark with wide eyes for what felt like forever, before he finally spoke, his mouth feeling very dry for some reason. “Are you…are you pregnant Luna?” he asked her, slowly looking at her face as he spoke.

Luna was silent for a few tense seconds, before she slowly nodded, tears forming in her eyes as she said, “Yes, dear Button.”

Button’s mind reeled like he’d been hit with a sucker punch, and he dropped the test, the plastic hitting the carpet with a light “Thump!” as he stared at her.

“You’re pregnant?” He repeated, not quite sure he’d heard her correctly.

“Yes, Button, I am pregnant with your child!!” Luna exclaimed. “And I do not know how, as I’ve always cast the birth-control spell whenever we’ve mated!!” She continued. “I shouldn’t be pregnant!!”

“Oh, that’d be my doing,” Chrysalis answered simply, causing their eyes to widen even more, before they slowly turned their heads towards him.

“What?” Luna said simply.

“I cast a spell that nullified the anti-baby spell when we both roleplayed as ghosts,” Chrysalis replied. “And that potion I gave him should have upped his sperm count a bit, so you should be pregnant with at least twins,” She continued.

“WHAT?!” Luna shouted in the Royal Canterlot Voice, causing the castle wall and floor to crack a bit. “You made me get pregnant?!” She continued, before she swung her hand at Chrysalis’ face and slapped her hard, while Button’s mom, who was in the kitchen, heard her voice and dropped the pan in her hand with shock.

“Yes,” Chrysalis replied as she rubbed her very red cheek with a hand. “I figured you wouldn’t mind, since you’re so attracted to my stud,” She continued. “I’m sure you’ve dreamed about having kids with him.”

“Yes, but not so soon into the relationship!” Luna snapped. “I wanted to wait until we were married to have kids!!”

“Well you don’t have to worry about it any more,” Chrysalis replied with a smile. “And hey, I’ll help you with the foal, as will Pretty Princess Mi Amore Cadenza,” She continued with a slight frown.

That made Luna’s ire go down a bit, before she crossed her arms. “She will want to do that once word gets out,” She replied with a sigh. “And Tia will want to be involved too.”

“Yes, I’m sure she will be very eager,” Chrysalis said, before a very large grin appeared on her face. “In fact, maybe she’ll want to have one with Button as well,” She suggested, wiggling her eyebrows at him as she spoke.

That sentence was the knock-out blow for Button’s brain, and he felt himself start to fall back, while Luna let out an exclamation of shock. As his brain started to shut down and eyes started to close, one final thought ran through his head.

‘If my kids don’t kill me, then either one of the princesses or Chrysalis will kill me.’

Author's Note

I should mention that Chrysalis only teased this just to mess with him, but yeah, this is the end of the story, and I don't plan to add Celestia to his harem. Anyways, my friend and I finally finished this and hopefully I can get to my older works.