Nightmare Moon’s Indecent Proposal

The sky was dark, the night had covered the sky for hours now, and it wasn’t going to even allow the light of the sun to break its blackened horizon. Even the twinkling stars seemed to glow with a much brighter, victorious attitude as they shone in the night sky like evil diamonds. The moon was full with a golden ring burning around it, the last bastion of the sun’s radiance, light, and hope bleeding around the edges of this cold, silver sphere. Though it was night, the mix of moon and stars seemed to give an eeriness to their normally dim light.

Rushing through the dense, dark, and untamed forest known as the Everfree Forest were six ponies. There were two unicorns, Twilight Sparkle and Rarity, two pegasi, Rainbow Dash and Fluttershy, and two earth mares, Applejack and Pinkie Pie. Twilight had foreseen this darkness to come, she ran faster than the others. Applejack and Rainbow Dash were keeping up with her, while Rarity, Fluttershy, and Pinkie Pie were keeping up in the rear.

“How could this happen?” Was all Twilight could say to herself, as she was running through the last stretches of the Everfree. “I gotta hurry!”

Her mind was rushing with a mix of fear and anger. Nightmare Moon, the mare in the moon, has returned. Her first act, banishing Princess Celestia away, has begun to usher in a new and terrible reign. Twilight cursed herself for not being able to convince her guide and mentor to let her help in preventing this from happening. Not that she was blaming Celestia for all this, she would never consider such a thing.

Along the way through the Everfree, the six of them had faced trials and obstacles. From the darkness of a manticore, to a sea serpent, a haunted, possessed forest, the temptation of betrayal, and even a breaking cliffside, but each challenge was met and beat by these six mares. Twilight had quickly learned to trust these mares, who she was forming a friendship with as they went to confront Nightmare Moon.

“There it is!” Twilight called out, seeing the long abandoned Castle of the Two Sisters coming into view. Looking back she was assured that the others were following her, even though she was previously annoyed that they would come to help her. “Whatever happens, we have to stay together!” The other five girls nodded as they followed the unicorn into the castle.

It was bleak, dark, dusty, and an ever present sense of fear and uncertainty that radiated the air like a foul miasma. Swallowing hard, the six mares continued forward, despite the chills running down their spines. Eventually, they made it to the main audience chamber, or what remained of it. Crumbling walls, broken sections of ceilings and glass, as well as the fractured and chipped remnants of the Elements of Harmony remained in their stone orbs. But yet, there was no Nightmare Moon to be seen.

“Nightmare Moon!” Twilight shouted, calling out in all directions. Her horn ignited as she was ready to battle this evil alicorn. Small bits of magic crackled between her fingers as she continued. “Where are you? Show yourself!”

“Ooo how scary.” Nightmare Moon called back, but remained hidden. Looking around, none of the girls could determine the source of the voice. It was as if every dark corner and shadow of the room was speaking at once. “Look who has come to challenge me…an over eager fool…a proud farm peasant…an angry cloud sleeper…a would be noblemare…a timid weakling…and you, my dear sister’s favorite pet.”

“Enough of your words! Show yourself!” Twilight continued to shout back into the shadowy dark. Her new allies trembled a little, but did not fall nor run. “We’ve beaten every dark temptation you’ve thrown at us, we’ve bested all your terrible fears, we will defeat you!”

“Defeat me? I highly doubt that.” Nightmare Moon responded, her tone shifting to a somewhat dismissive attitude. “Yes, you six have succeeded in some shows of will and unity. I must say, it is a little impressive. But you are not strong enough to defeat me.” The shadows began to manifest, forming a dark blue mist as it spread from every dark corner of the room. “But now that you are all here, the greatest potential threats to my new rule, I believe I know exactly how to deal with you six.”

“Whatever you have planned, it won’t work!” Twilight declared, her horn radiating with confident light. “We will prevail!” She looked over to her friends. “We’ve faced your trials, we’ve overcome your obstacles, and together, we shall put an end to your evil reign!”

“Brave words, such confidence, such determination…” Nightmare Moon said, still taunting the mare as she spoke. The mist slowly began to manifest further, taking shape as the alicorn’s form came into view. Standing a head taller than the others, even from this distance, she stared down the six mares. “But I have a different plan for you all.” Taking a deep breath, she let her starlight gleaming eyes stare the mares over. “I would like to parley.”

“I’m sorry…what?” Twilight asked, her face turning from focused to confused. Blinking for a few moments, she shook her head before resolving herself. “You can’t fool us!”

“Oh, by no means is this a deception. I am being legitimate in my suggestion.” Nightmare Moon explained, maintaining her posture. “If you would allow me a moment to explain, I believe you six will wish to hear me out.” As she spoke, there was something about her face, her eyes, and even as her voice seemed to ripple with a strange sweetness to it.

“I…I…” Twilight wasn’t certain what to think. This mare had harmed her precious mentor, threatened the ponies of Equestria, and was a clear threat. But the fact she was willing to parley, maybe there was something. Turning her head to the others, she whispered. “What do you all think?”

“I say we kick her ass!” Rainbow Dash commented, pounding her fists together. “She attacked us, and tried to make us betray each other.” Clearly she was still upset about what had happened. “We shouldn’t give her a chance to keep talking!”

“I agree, she’s too dishonest.” Applejack added, nodding with her friend. “There’s no telling what sort’ve trick she has planned.” Looking back over to Nightmare, she only glared angrily. “She’s planning something, and none of it can be good.”

“But if she had anything planned, wouldn’t she have already done it?” Rarity asked, looking between Applejack and Twilight. “She’s clearly strong enough that she could do anything she wanted. So maybe she’s being honest?”

“I think we should hear her out.” Pinkie added, smiling a little as her mane seemed to shiver a bit. “I got a feeling we should hear this.”

“I-if we could end this…without any violence…” Fluttershy stuttered, her voice speaking even quieter than the rest. “T-that would be nice.”

“Alright. But the second she tries anything, we attack.” Twilight said, getting the other five to nod in agreement. Taking a breath, she turned to face Nightmare Moon, who was still standing there patiently. “Alright, Nightmare Moon. We’ll parley. But if you try anything, I swear by Celestia, we will stop you!”

“Fair enough.” Nightmare Moon stated, clearly unphased by Twilight’s threats. “I will admit, at first I believed you six were just some annoying pests. But to see you all here, having overcome all I have thrown at you. That is not a simple coincidence.” Gesturing her arms towards the stone orbs, she continued. “I believe you six have some connection to the Elements of Harmony. But the Elements draw their powers by tapping into Primal Magics. You may defeat me in such a battle, but the resulting conflict will only lead to the ruin of the region.” She then looked more at the other five behind Twilight. “Especially that backwater town your friends are from.”

“So what, you expect us to just let you rule all of Equestria instead?” Twilight asked, getting back in an aggressive stance. “What could you possibly offer as an alternative?”

“Simple. We settle this in a much more comfortable, and enjoyable fashion.” Nightmare Moon explained further. “All I ask is that you give me a moment to properly explain. Will you grant me that?”

The way she spoke seemed to be sincere enough, and when Twilight looked to the others, she contemplated her next move. She could just attack the alicorn, but there was no guarantee that she could take her on alone. And though she did get a good look at the other fives’ abilities, there was still a lingering doubt in what they were capable of together. Twilight swallowed hard, she hated this, but she had no choice.

“Very well, but only once.” Twilight said, her eyes remaining on the alicorn at all times. “But no funny business or surprises!” Her horn lit up as she was preparing herself for anything. “I see a spell I don’t like, we’re taking you down!”

“I assure you, you may enjoy this surprise.” Nightmare Moon commented, raising a hand carefully. “Let me show you.” Snapping her fingers, a ring of magic swirled around her hand. The girls flinched, taking a step back. “Fear not, this is merely to make something a little more comfortable for us.”

The piles of rubble seemed to crumble further into dust, only to then clear away for what appeared to be a massive form being conjured into existence. Taking a few moments before it settled, what was only a foot to the side of the alicorn was a royal bed, large enough to fit maybe seven or so ponies on it. With a content smile on her face, Nightmare Moon strutted herself over to the bed. Crawling a little on it, she adjusted until she lounged on the soft cushioning.

“There, something a little more comfortable.” Nightmare Moon commented, gesturing a little as she posed towards the six. Raising a hand, she snapped her fingers. Her silver and black armor melted away into a fine mist, revealing her bare and nude body to the mares. “Now then, shall we negotiate?”

Twilight, as well as the others, stared at the alicorn lying on the bed. Nightmare Moon had a very impressive body. She was slender in all the right places, filled out in the best places, and the coldness of her eyes only seemed to add to the allure about her. Her hips looked so soft and wide, narrowing into her slender waist, and topped off with a sizable pair of endowments. Swallowing hard, Twilight's nervousness was obvious.

As she continued to stare, the mare’s eyes noticed something. Though it was previously, somewhat blending with the same shade as her body, there was no denying it. Nightmare Moon had a cock, a very, very impressive looking cock. Twilight’s face went into a red blush as she looked on, as did the remaining mares. Fluttershy and Rarity nervously tried to look away from it, while Rainbow Dash, Pinkie, and Applejack stared at it with a little more interest.

“It seems some of you have seen what could be on offer.” Nightmare Moon commented with a laugh. This laugh only caused her chest to heave and bounce a little. “Now then, shall I continue to explain what I have in mind?”

This cock was terrifying. Massive and throbbing, as well as leaking precum as if it were drooling hungrily. The girls couldn’t help but tremble at the sight and size of this dick. Nightmare Moon was smug in how she looked at the mares. She could tell they were being intimidated by her length, and it was only filling her with more and more ego and pride. She was savoring this feeling, but was slowly losing some patience in Twilight’s responses.

“I-I-I don’t…I don’t understand.” Twilight exclaimed, trying not to look directly at it, but it was hard not to. The thing between Nightmare Moon’s legs was bigger than anything she’s seen, even when she accidentally walked in on her brother with Princess Cadance back when she was foalsat by her. “What is your game? What are you planning?”

“Such an innocent mare…this will be fun.” Nightmare Moon laughed again, only to look at the six mares over again. “You see, us alicorns have incredible libidos, and can handle many partners…often at the same time. Any such partners who have managed to satisfy our lusts have been granted great rewards.”

“Get to the point!” Twilight snapped, losing her patience as she could feel her face getting hotter from the growing red blush. “What’s your point?” As she spoke, she tried to avert her gaze from Nightmare’s cock, which was still making her body slowly feel hotter and hotter.

“Well, being banished to the moon for a thousand years has certainly built up a major desire in my loins.” Nightmare Moon explained, her words seemingly giving her a sense of arousal as her cock was starting to twitch. “And if you six were to aid me in this regard, I might be willing to delay my conquest of Equestria.”

“You…can’t be serious.” Twilight commented, shaking her head for a moment. “There’s no way you could be-”

“Oh but I am.” Nightmare Moon interjected, her hand slowly running from her lips, down to her breasts, and ending at the base of her cock. “If the peace of your home is not enough, then perhaps I shall offer more.” Her eyes glanced across each mare, her gaze making the six tremble a little bit. “Any who can properly please me, I shall grant a great boon. But, if you fail to please me, or fall to exhaustion, then not only will I continue my campaign, but I shall claim all of you as the first members of my new harem of broodmares.”