Nightmare Moon’s Indecent Proposal

Twilight stood there, nervous as she had to consider her options. On the one hand, she could try to battle with Nightmare Moon, but there was no guarantee things would work out if she did. She could tell her friends were nervous, but if there was a chance they could defeat her without any bloodshed, violence, or pain, was it worth the shame of being her sex relief? Twilight swallowed hard, she knew what she had to do.

“We…accept…” Twilight said, though there was some hesitation in her voice. Looking back to the others, she tried to sound reassuring. “We can do this! We just need to get her off and it will be enough!”

“Such confidence.” Nightmare Moon commented, almost laughing a little as she looked the ponies over. “Well, perhaps you shall be the one to go first.” Her eyes continued to look around the other five girls. “Then I believe I would like the other unicorn, followed by that farming peasant, the blue pegasus, that busty pink one, and…oh yes, I’ll save that timid yellow one for the end.”

“Not if I can get you off first.” Twilight protested, stepping forward as she tried to take the attention off her new friends. “We haven’t even started yet.”

“You’re correct.” Nightmare Moon said, changing her position to sit at the edge of this bed. Her cock was swelling in size as her mind was filled with all manner of thoughts and fantasies. “By all means…show me what you can do.”

Twilight swallowed hard, having never handled such a thing before. But she had to save these girls, save Princess Celestia, and of course, save Equestria. Boldly taking her steps forward, she approached the dark alicorn, who kept a smug expression on her face. Her eyes were already judging her before the unicorn even began, but this didn’t deter Twilight. Lowering herself to her knees, she was now face to cock with this throbbing girth. It felt almost overwhelming as she could see just how big it was.

‘Are they supposed to be this big?’ Twilight thought to herself, only to shake herself from her worries. ‘I can’t back down now. Not after coming this far!’

“Come now my dear.” Nightmare Moon teased, almost laughing as she stared down this mare. “Surely this can’t be the first you’ve ever…oh? It is, isn’t it?” She let out a hearty laugh. “My, my, this is adorable. My dear sister’s student, a timid little virgin?”

“D-don’t get too full of yourself.” Twilight snapped back, but her voice waned a little. Swallowing nervously, she reached out with her hand to touch it. “It’s not that complicated. I just need to get you to cum.”

“But can you?” Nightmare Moon asked in a mocking tone. “I will not be pleased by some pathetic display. So you had better show me the best you have.”

Taking the cock in hand, Twilight started nervously stroking the length of Nightmare’s girth. The alicorn only stared down at the unicorn, a cocky sneer ran across her face. Despite her clear lack of experience, there was a pleasure in watching her sister’s student struggling to satisfy her needs. But it was growing more and more apparent that Nightmare was growing bored. Her cock, though throbbing, wasn't nearly as hard as she could’ve been. Tilting her head to the side, she stared down at Twilight.

“Come now, is this honestly how you think this is done?” Nightmare asked, laughing in a mocking tone. “If you can’t get me to cum…” Her eyes then drifted over to the other mares. “I’ll have to move on to your friends.”

Twilight paused for a moment. She was hesitating, it was obvious. She was nervous about this, but she didn’t want these girls to have to suffer if she could save them all on her own. Swallowing hard, she licked her lips. Her mouth quivered a little as she knew what she had to do. Opening her mouth, she leaned a little more over Nightmare’s cock, taking the hard cockhead past her lips and into her muzzle.

“This is taking too long.” Nightmare groaned in impatient annoyance and placed her hand on Twilight’s head. “Hurry up already.” The unicorn, resolving herself, continued until she managed to take in nearly half the length of the alicorn’s cock. “There we go. Much better. Now get to it, or I will make it worse.” Moving her hand, she let Twilight continue.

Holding herself in place for a moment, Twilight lifted herself back up, only to come back down over Nightmare’s cock. The unicorn began to develop a steady and deep pace. She could taste the intensity and potency of this cock. Though she couldn’t see it, she could almost feel Nightmare’s judging stare looking down over her as she was struggling to properly suck this monster The more she heard the teasing chuckles of this alicorn, the more Twilight was trying to pick up her speed.

“There we go, much better.” Nightmare commented, watching with some glee as Twilight was getting into a better pace and pattern of sucking her off. “This is the proper way to worship at my loins.” Her eyes went back towards the other mares. “Don’t stand there too long. Your friend will not be able to sate me for long.”

Moving her mouth faster and faster, Twilight was now fully deepthroating Nightmare’s full size. She was gagging, almost choking on it as if she could feel the cockhead poking at her stomach. Her throat was almost visibly throbbing from the cock that was filling her mouth. Whether she noticed it or not, the unicorn was picking up her speed as she was sucking faster and faster. Nightmare continued to enjoy the sight and sensation of this mare handling her cock.

“There we go, much better.” Nightmare commented, chuckling as she pointed to the mares. “She’s not going to last long. So you better get prepared.”

“We can’t just let her do this alone.” Applejack commented, getting ready to take a step forward. “We gotta help her.”

“Oh yeah, we gotta take this bitch down.” Rainbow added, pounding her fists in determination. “I say we take her at once.”

“That’ll make her cum buckets!” Pinkie commented, giggling as she was thinking of all the way she could get Nightmare off. “I say on three…” Swallowing hard, Fluttershy hesitated, still trembling. The three mares were getting ready to switch places with Twilight, when Rarity raised a hand in front of them. “Rarity? What are you-”

“Girls, if we go at her at once, she’ll defeat us at once.” Rarity commented, giving the four of them an intense stare. “We need to be more tactful. Besides, she already said what order she wants.” Looking over to Nightmare, she resolved herself. “I’ll go next.” Before the others could say anything else in protest, she took a step forward.

Walking over towards Nightmare, Rarity's horn ignited. Her clothes were wrapped in a magical aura, causing the fabric to vanish. Her bare and alluring body caught the alicorn’s attention. This caused her cock to swell further in Twilight’s mouth. Seeing her fellow unicorn was struggling, Rarity kneeled beside her friend. Groping at her chest, she lifted her soft mounds up to gently lick along the center to help get her tits a little more slick and wet.

“Twilight, darling. You don’t have to do this alone.” Rarity commented, helping to lift up Twilight’s head until she was fully off Nightmare’s cock. Gripping at the long, hard, saliva soaked shaft, they started stroking her off. “Let me help you.”

Not letting Twilight have a moment to protest, Rarity took her tits and pressed them against Nightmare’s cock, enveloping them in her large, soft endowment. Lifting and dropping, the unicorn started to give the alicorn a soft and firm titfuck. Twilight could only watch as her new friend was working over Nightmare’s dick with a skill, confidence, and determination that couldn’t be helped by an inexperienced mare.

“Oh, fuck…that feels pretty good.” Nightmare commented, shivering a little as the tingles of Rarity’s breasts were sending through her body. “Feels like you’ve done this before.”

“A lady never kisses and tells.” Rarity commented, giving Nightmare’s cockhead a tender kiss. “Just lay back and enjoy this.” She didn’t give the alicorn a moment to give a response as she began to suckle along the hard cockhead.

Taking her time, Rarity was working over Nightmare’s cock in a way Twilight couldn’t. There was no hesitation, or pausing. Only focus, and a skilled use of tongue and tits nopony would’ve ever expected a classy mare like Rarity to possess. Licking along the tip, she tasted at the alicorn’s precum. It was strong, sending a raw, almost primal shiver down the mare’s spine. She shuddered as she was savoring the taste before placing her lips back on the cockhead.

As she suckled along Nightmare’s dick, Rarity’s own soft breasts pressed and squeezed along the shaft. The alicorn only seemed to hum with a growing pleasure. This unicorn was far more skilled than Twilight, but despite this, the unicorn pupil watched on, waiting to assist Rarity at any moment. The seamstress mare appeared to be fully in control of the situation. Almost giggling, or moaning a little as she began to take in more and more of this savage cock.

“Such a good and devoted mare.” Nightmare commented, reaching out to rub along Rarity’s mane. The unicorn only growled a little as she swatted the alicorn’s hand away. “Oh? And feisty too? Such an interesting combination.”

“Do not touch the mane, my dear.” Rarity commented, lifting her lips enough to speak while still rolling her tongue along the cockhead. “I am a classy lady, not some cheap harlot.”

“Could’ve fooled me, with how skilled you are at working my cock.” Nightmare chuckled, speaking to the mare in a teasing tone. “But by all means, please…continue.”

Picking up where she left off, Rarity’s mouth took in a little more of Nightmare’s dick, but never ventured too far onto it. She was focusing more and more of her chest taking in the length of this alicorn. Squeezing as she could, the mare was lifting and dropping her breasts, giving Nightmare’s cock a tight and yet soft embrace. Feeling the dick twitching, she could tell an orgasm was coming.

Picking up her pace, Rarity pressed her boobs faster and faster, rubbing along the slick shaft in her bosom. Nightmare only continued to smirk confidently, but was getting closer and closer to her release. Unlike Twilight, Rarity was willing to push things as far as she could. Pressing harder and harder, she was bobbing her head over the cock, taking a little further down until she was just about nearing the halfway point.

“Oh…oh fuck!” Nightmare gasped as she couldn’t hold herself back. Seeing Rarity was too focused on keeping her head down, the alicorn reached over and grabbed at the side of the mare’s head. “Fucking take it you harlot!” The alicorn’s voice was almost burning with an intense aggression and frustration.

She could feel her cock getting hot, swelling with her erupting lust. Nightmare’s balls swelled and tightened, the vast amounts of hot cum that were sloshing and boiling in her were rushing through her shaft. The alicorn’s breath became hot as she felt as she was releasing herself in Rarity’s mouth. Her tongue hung to the side of her mouth in a vulgar manner as she moaned out in the raw pleasure.

Rarity’s eyes widened as the vast amount of cum was being pumped into her. Swallowing gulp after gulp, the mare was taking in as much as she could. Nightmare was certainly more virile and thicker than any other stallion she’d bedded, but she continued to take in as much as possible. Eventually though, this alicorn’s amount was too much to handle. Thankfully, Nightmare released her to which Rarity pulled her face off the alicorn’s cock, to which a spurt of cum splattered across her face.

“I must say, I am much more impressed.” Nightmare commented, nodding her head as she looked to Rarity, still swallowing what amounts of cum was still in her mouth. Twilight was quick to catch her friend as the mare stumbled back, shivering as the cum seemed to cause her pussy to get soaking wet. “Now then…let’s see…” Looking at the others, she gestured towards Applejack. “I believe you’ll last a little longer.”

“Oh don’t you worry.” Applejack commented, striding herself over to the alicorn. Throwing aside the last bits of her clothes, she approached Nightmare. “Let’s see if you can handle this farm mare.” Her confidence seemed to radiate off her body, emphasizing her commitment and dedication to her friends. A noble quality that the evil alicorn could admire, but she had other things to admire on this mare.

Nightmare took a moment to look the earth mare over. Applejack certainly had a decent pair of tits, a slender yet muscular frame, and a remarkably round ass that seemed to have been honed from years bucking apples. Nodding in a curious satisfaction, Nightmare gestured for Applejack to come closer, a smirk still on her lips. Twilight was so far a slight disappointment, but Rarity’s recent skills were giving this alicorn some expectations.

“You certainly have some strong assets.” Nightmare commented, raising an eyebrow as she was growing more and more eager. “I wonder how you will try to make me cu-” She received her answer before finishing as Applejack grabbed at her cock in a somewhat tight grip. “What are you doing?”

“Showing off the basics.” Applejack commented, starting to jerk off Nightmare’s cock. “Us Apples like to keep things basic, and there ain’t nothing wrong with that.” Her technique was old fashioned, but seemed to be quite effective. Nightmare was panting a little as the pleasure continued to grow. Not that it mattered, the alicorn was more than confident she would overwhelm this mare next without any issue.

“That remains to be seen.” Nightmare commented, glaring a little at the mare. “But you have moxy, so I’ll show you some courtesy. So by all means…wow me.”

Smirking, a fire seemed to light in Applejack’s eyes as she started picking up her pace. Nightmare was still skeptical of this mare’s skills, but the confidence she held was impressive. This earth mare’s grip was equally remarkable, holding the alicorn’s cock in a fashion that showed either familiarity. And yet, despite the firmness of her hold, Applejack was somewhat gentle in her strokes.

“I must say, I am becoming more and more impressed.” Nightmare commented, looking as Applejack was keeping pace with her heavy panting and her stroking. But her smirk was turning to a sneer. “Impressed you pitiful ponies believe such petty actions are enough to please me.”

“But we got you to cum.” Twilight protested, getting Rarity back to the others. “Clearly, we can do it.” Looking at Rarity, she could tell the unicorn would be out of commission for a while. “Are you going to break your promise?”

“I never break my promises.” Nightmare protested, huffing in frustration as she glared at Twilight. “You merely have not held up your end to mine.”

“What do you mean?” Twilight asked, starting to get more and more worried. After what Nightmare had her do, she didn’t think she could face her if magic was to be used. “You said if you came, you’d stop.”

“I said if I was pleased. This was only one small spurt, but that isn’t going to be enough for me.” Nightmare commented, almost laughing at the mare. “But it will take more than that to stop me-ah?!”

Nightmare’s eyes looked back to Applejack. The farm mare was now using both hands. The first stroked up and down the alicorn’s cock length, while the other hand was fondling along the heavy balls. Staring up at her with a stubborn determination, Applejack was working up and down the girth size, stopping every so often to tease at the cum dripping cockhead while lifting and lowering the balls.

“You see Nightmare Moon, we’re not finished yet!” Twilight commented, seeing a sign of hope amongst her friends. “We can still defeat you!”