Nightmare Moon’s Indecent Proposal

It was hard to say just how many hours had passed since their victory, but the shining light of the next day roused Twilight from her slumber. Opening her eyes slowly, she saw she was still on this bed, resting within the ruins of this once mighty castle. The other girls were equally waking up, yawning and stretching as they slowly sat up. They were sore, feeling the occasional spasm from their still sensitive pussies and mouths, as well as some cramps on their sides and joints.

“We…we did it!” Twilight commented, panting and huffing as she could see the other mares were waking up. “Thank you…thank you, all of you. I…I couldn’t have done it without you.”

“It’s alright!” Pinkie cheered, smiling as she crawled a little to give Twilight a hug. “It was fun to stop her this way!”

“I…was quite surprised myself that this was how she wanted to be fought.” Rarity commented, trying to fix her mane as she spoke. “But I am happy we were able to succeed.”

“Um…I’m just happy it didn’t get…you know, violent.” Fluttershy added in, blushing a little. “N-not that I’m complaining about how we…I mean…uh well…”

“It’s fine, we did what we were able to.” Applejack nodded, smiling confidently. “And I’m glad to have helped.”

“Same here!” Rainbow said, almost boasting as she smiled a smug expression. “It’s not everyday you get to fuck an alicorn to exhaustion.” As she spoke, she looked down, looking at where Nightmare lay. “Um…does she look different to you?”

Looking down, the six mares saw that Nightmare Moon had changed. She wasn’t nearly as tall, or even voluptuous as she was before. Even her coat was a midnight blue, while her mane was more like a regular mane of lighter blue hair. Her curves were smaller, though still quite impressive for her height, but had seemingly shrunk down to nearly half the size of how they were before. And finally, her cock was much, much smaller; now only as big as possibly a well bred earth stallion.

“What happened to her?” Pinkie asked, giggling a little as she playfully poked at the limp and twitching dick. “She’s all…smaller, and softer.” She then turned her attention to Twilight. “Any idea what’s happened?”

“I-I-I-I have no idea.” Twilight stuttered, shaking her head as she was trying to figure out what was going on. “There’s nothing in any book that could-” An idea sparked in her mind, as if a realization was reached. “Maybe…just maybe, this is Princess Luna.” The other looked confused for a moment, to which she cleared her throat. “You see, it was Princess Luna who, in her envy of Princess Celestia, became corrupted and thus turned into Nightmare Moon. Perhaps we managed to cleanse her…using our bodies.”

“You know, now that you mention it.” Applejack added, looking herself over. “I’m tired, sure. But I don’t look like someone who’s been rolling in the hay all night and day.”

“I didn’t want to say it before, but I was curious too.” Rarity commented, rubbing her mane a little. “I was certain that my hair would be such a mess, given all that has happened. And especially after Nightmare covered us in her…well, mess. But there doesn’t seem to be a drying drop on us.”

“Maybe it was magic!” Pinkie giggled, looking herself over. “I mean, it was either that, or maybe alicorn cum goes away after a while?”

“That’s an interesting guess.” Called a faint chuckling voice from across the room. “But I felt you all at least deserved to wake up fresh and clean.”

Looking over to the source of the voice, the six mares saw, sitting on a fallen piece of broken masonry, was the alicorn they were searching for, Princess Celestia. She was as tall as Nightmare was, maybe even a few inches taller. Her features were even bigger than the defeated alicorn, with an off white gown with gold trimming that seemed to hug around her alluring curves. Her multicolored mane flowed despite a lack of wind, and she was looking at the ponies on the bed with a warm, amused smile.

“Princess Celestia!” Twilight called out, got up and tried to rush over to her mentor, but slipped and collapsed back on the bed. “You’re free! Are you alright? What happened?”

“Now, now, my dear Twilight, there’s no need to rush.” Celestia commented, smiling at her student, as well as the other mares. “Please, remain lying as you are. Your bodies are all still too tired from your ordeal.”

Walking over to the six, Celestia raised a hand whenever the mares tried to move. As she came closer and closer, she seemed to almost radiate a warm glow. Drawing nearer to them, the mares could almost feel as if their bodies were feeling more and more relieved. And while Celestia gave each of them a nodding smile, her focus was becoming more and more on the mare lying exhausted on the bed. It was only when she reached the bed, that she was standing over the mare.

“It has been many years since I have seen you in that form, sister.” Celestia commented, staring down at her sister. “How do you feel?”

“S-sister?” Luna’s voice rang out weakly, almost trembling as she stared up at her sister. “I’m sorry…I’m sorry…I’m so, so sorry…”

“I know, and it’s okay.” Celestia nodded, leaning down to hold her sister closer to her. “You’re safe now…I missed you.” Looking over to the rest of the mares, she smiled. “Thank you, all of you. You have returned to me something I have thought I lost so many centuries ago.”

“But…what do we do now?” Twilight asked, looking from her friends to her mentor. “We…we were able to defeat Nightmare Moon, right?”

“Oh, Nightmare Moon has been defeated.” Celestia explained, gesturing to her sister, that was still being almost cradled in her arms. “You have purged my sister of the evil that had corrupted her so long ago.” She smiled at them. “My sister has always been particularly insatiable, and becoming Nightmare Moon has amplified it. You have my gratitude for overcoming such a heroic challenge.”

“I…I’m sorry.” Luna weakly commented, looking at the mares with remorseful eyes. “I caused…so much pain and I just…I jus-”

“Shh, shh, it’s over now. There’s nothing to fear anymore, dear sister.” Celestia commented, but then as she glanced over the mare again, she raised a curious eyebrow. “That being said, if it is alright with all of you, I would like to cast a spell to check you all over.”

“What do you mean?” Twilight asked, looking a little nervous as she looked back and forth between the mares and Celestia. “Is there something wrong?”

“Oh, no, no, there isn’t anything wrong.” Celestia commented, igniting her horn. The room was partially illuminated with a rainbow colored light. It was warm as it washed over the six mares. As it did, the mares all felt as if there was a tingling running down their spines, ending with their bellies giving off a small, blinking light. “Oh…well then…”

“What, what is it?!” Twilight asked, looking back and forth from Celestia to the other girls. “Are we going to be okay?”

“Oh, yes, yes, you’re all not in any danger.” Celestia replied, waiving a hand back and forth. “You all just have some minor dehydration, as well as some strained muscles. Pushing yourself all night like you did, would have some consequences.” Waving her hand in a semicircle, several pitchers of water were conjured into existence. “Here, drink up, but do it slowly. There’s no rush.”

Taking the pitchers, the mares drank down the water. It was cool, sweet tasting, and seemed to fill their bellies and ease their dry throats. As well as this, the magic that was still emanating from Celestia’s horn was enveloping the mares. It was subtle, gentle, and yet so warm. Like their bodies were being massaged and eased up. It was soothing, mixing with the sensation of the cool water pouring down their throats.

Twilight looked over to the others. These five mares have done more for her than anypony she had ever known in Canterlot. While she had some ponies back home she associated with, she never felt she had close friends. But ever since coming to Ponyville, she felt as though these five were some of the honest, loyal, generous, kindest, and happiest ponies she’s ever met. Maybe this was what she was missing all along? Maybe what she needed was friendship?

“Princess Celestia…thank you.” Twilight commented, looking back to her mentor. The alicorn was almost beaming with pride in her pupil. “If it wasn’t for you, I wouldn’t have come here, and met these amazing ponies.”

“I’m glad you feel that way.” Celestia replied, smiling warmly at her student. “I was certain you would find what you were missing here. And, if you would like, I could arrange to have you move to Ponyville.” She then chuckled a little. “It would seem you’ve learned a great lesson, and I know you will always learn more; with your new friends.”

Twilight’s eyes were filled with stars and joy. Praise from her mentor meant the world to her. All she wanted was to please her mentor, her Princess. And though she had been complimented, this was the first time Twilight felt an echo of love in the alicorn’s voice. As she spoke her words, she gently hugged her sister closer. Luna only watched on, still timid, her eyes filled with sorrow and remorse. It was going to take a long time before she could come to terms with what she’s done. But Twilight was confident she’d work through them with time.

“Now, how are you all feeling?” Celestia asked, watching as the mares had finished drinking their water. The mares nodded in agreement, getting ready to leave. She raised her hand forward to catch their attention. “I…I would remain seated if you would please.”

“Why? Is something wrong?” Twilight asked, coming down from the euphoria of being praised to notice the troubled look that was growing on Celestia’s face. “Was there something else?”

“Well, yes…it’s just…” Celestia sighed, composing herself as she was gathering her thoughts. “I’m sorry, there is no gentle way to put this.” She took another deep breath. “You’re pregnant. All of you are pregnant.”

There was a silence, a thick, long and awkward silence as Celestia looked at the mares. Fluttershy immediately fainted, being caught by Rainbow Dash, who was more worried about her friend. Applejack’s face went from confused, to a look of dread as she could only imagine what Granny Smith would say when she’s told her granddaughter is having foals before marriage. Twilight and Rarity shared similar expressions, their eyes going narrow as they came to terms immediately what this all meant. Only Pinkie seemed to have handled the news in a much lighter mood, her small giggles broke the silence.

“That’s hilarious!” Pinkie laughed, nearly falling over in her amusement. The other girls looked at her in confusion. “What? I mean we were playing with that dick all night, there’s no way at least one of us isn’t gonna carry a bun in the oven. But all six? That’s funny!”

“Well, you are mostly correct.” Celestia nodded, aware that this wasn’t an easy conversation to have, and she expected the mares to react like this; though Pinkie’s did catch her off guard for a moment. “You see, unlike the average, or even the most virile stallions, alicorn’s have a special magic in our being. This causes our seed to be far more potent, where only the strongest contraceptive spells can give even the slightest chance to avoid pregnancy. So while you have saved Equestria, and brought back my darling sister, you have all been impregnated by her as well.”

There was still a silence, even Pinkie didn’t snicker and giggle after hearing it. Fluttershy was still unconscious, being held up by Rainbow Dash. The athletic pegasus, hearing this, she only now was coming to terms that her dreams to join the Wonderbolts have been shattered. At best, maybe delayed by several more years. A heaviness came over her chest as she felt this worry. Applejack’s fears only amplified. Granny Smith was a patient and understanding mare, but when it came to family traditions, she was as stern and stubborn as an old oak, and she wasn’t gonna let her hear the end of it.

Pinkie still took it the best out of the six. She loved kids, and it wasn’t like she was against having kids eventually, so getting them a little early wasn’t a problem. If anything, she recalled Mrs. Cake, the mare she lived with, was coming along with her own pregnancy, so that would mean her kids could grow up and be friends with Pinkie’s kids. Rarity was also taking this a little better than before. Ever the clever mare, she was already thinking about all the fashion inspirations having a child could yield. Her mind was teeming with various clothes, costumes, accessories, and other things she could market. And she did believe that any mare can have beauty and grace, pregnant or not.

Twilight only sat there. She was pregnant. She had been impregnated by Nightmare Moon. No! She had been impregnated by Princess Luna. What would her parents think? Sure, it wasn’t like they were against relations with the royal family. Her older brother, Shining Armor, has been dating Celestia’s niece, Princess Cadance since high school. But to carry Princess Luna’s babies. This wasn’t something she expected to happen, even in her wildest dreams.

Twilight was far too exhausted to really process all of this. Right now, she was doing her best to handle everything, but she could feel the panic slowly growing inside her. Even if she could push it down, she knew she was going to spiral into a major breakdown in maybe a week or so. Her heartbeat was quickening as she was getting closer and closer to feeling as if she could collapse at any moment. Maybe Fluttershy had the right idea to just faint when she heard the news?

“How about we return to my boutique?” Rarity asked, finally breaking this new silence as she looked around. “Clearly, this is a lot to take in. And I believe it would be much better to handle all of this serious and intense news back in a home…and a bowl of ice cream.” She looked back to the others. “Or several.”

“Y-yes…please…” Luna finally spoke up again, looking at the mares. “I-I-I promise you, all of you, that I will provide everything you will need. I-i-if you’ll have me, I swear, I will use all the power I have at my disposal, to care and tend for both you, and the foals growing inside you all.” She paused, looking up to Celestia, who gave a knowing and kind smile. “I-I-I’m truly sorry, and I will be your devoted servant. I will make amends and ensure you are all provided for in every way possible.”

“Well, we can further discuss everything, once we return to your home.” Celestia commented, looking at Rarity. “Now then, are you all ready?” The mares, at least the ones still awake, nodded. Still maintaining her composure, Celestia ignited her horn again, and all of them vanished from the ruins of this ancient castle.