Nightmare Moon’s Indecent Proposal

It was hard to say how much time had passed since what Nightmare would call the foreplay had ended. All the mares were now on the bed, with the alicorn hunched over Twilight’s body, fucking in and out of the mare’s pussy with a greater speed and pace. At the sides, Pinkie, Fluttershy, Rainbow, and Rarity have been fucked into cum filled, sloppy messes. Applejack was ready to switch with Twilight at any moment, but the unicorn was doing everything she could to endure this.

“You’ve done well to last this long, Twilight Sparkle.” Nightmare commented, mocking the unicorn as she was stuffing her cock in and out of this tight pussy with incredible pleasure and ease. “But one by one, I’ve stuffed all these mares with my cum. And soon, you’ll join them!”

“Don’t be so sure yet.” Twilight said, gasping between small moans as her body was cumming over and over again by the raw pleasure this alicorn dick was giving her. “We’re not…not…finished…yet…”

“Oh? What are you planning?” Nightmare asked, raising a curious eyebrow, but still continued to pound her cock in and out of Twilight’s pussy without mercy. “Cause from the looks of it, you’re on your last legs.” She laughed at the mare. “Poor little unicorn, all alone.”

Twilight tried to speak, but all that could escape her lips were more and more moans. It was becoming harder and harder to form thoughts. The alicorn’s cock was pressing and rubbing along her most sweet and sensitive spots, which was only sending ripples of pleasure throughout her body. Though she hated this feeling, Twilight couldn’t deny it was sending tremors of electric pleasure more so than any rousing of estrus has ever brought her.

“See…feels to me like you’re ready to give up.” Nightmare mocked, grabbing at Twilight’s arms. Pulling them to cause the mare to gasp as the thick cock was hammering deeper and faster in her tight pussy. “Just give up, and I’ll give you this passion everyday.” Her lips were curling into a wick smirk. “Renounce my sister, and all of this can be yours.”

“I…I…I…” Twilight cooed, feeling as she was slipping deeper and deeper into the primal pleasure that was consuming her. Her body was almost fully at Nightmare’s mercy, making her getting closer and closer into falling. “I…I…”

“Come on, you unicorn slut. Say it!” Nightmare said, almost demanding it as she was fucking faster and faster in Twilight’s body. Her attention was focused solely on the mare. “Just say the word, and I will give you pleasure greater than anything my sister would have offered.”

“I…I…” Twilight was still feeling as her mind was slowly slipping, but while Nightmare was still fucking, she failed to notice the mares she had came in were coming to their senses. She could see her friends were getting the resolve to get back up. Swallowing, she looked at the alicorn. “I…do…not!”

Igniting her horn, Twilight let out a burst of magic. This washed over not only herself, but her friends, giving them an extra boast of strength to help them move from their fucked tired states. Even with this, they struggled to drag themselves up from where they lay. Nightmare was far too distracted by Twilight’s magical release to even notice. Applejack, who still had more strength than the others, helped her friends upwards, preparing to strike at the alicorn.

“You’re wrong, Nightmare Moon.” Twilight declared, her voice almost booming as she spoke to the alicorn. “It is because of these ponies I have met, I am not alone.” The magic of her horn glowed brighter and brighter, wrapping the other ponies in a colorful aura that further revitalized them. “It was thanks to them, I learned what friendship was, the power it can give, and win or lose, we will do what we can to stop you.”

“Stop me?” Nightmare asked, laughing at the mare while her cock was still throbbing inside her. “And what could you possibly do to-ahh?!” Her words were cut off as she felt the hands of the mares grabbing at her body. “What are you?!”

Nightmare’s words soon became moans and she felt these mares’ hands and fingers were rubbing and fingering along her body. From the edges and tips of her wings, along her large breasts and tender nipples, down to her balls and hidden pussy, she was being stimulated by the other five mares. Fluttershy took the wings, Rarity groped the tits, Rainbow cupped the balls, Pinkie fingered the pussy, and Applejack held her arms to keep her from taking charge.

“So…the mares still have some fight back in them?” Nightmare commented, laughing some more, though moans escaped her lips with every other breath. “Go on then. Show what this Friendship can accomplish!”

“Is this it? Is this the full extent of your Friendship?” Nightmare asked, mocking the ponies as they were now laying around her as they had before. Her cock was delving in and out of Applejack, while the other five were now twitching, and both leaking cum and covered in it. “All that remains is you, some earth mare peasant.”

“Don’t…think this is…enough to…stop me…” Applejack groaned and grunted, shifting her body as best as she could to keep Nightmare’s cock to keep rubbing within her. “Us…Apple mares…are tough…”

“Let’s see if that’s true.” Nightmare chuckled, grabbing at Applejack’s hips, thrusting upwards as the mare was riding on her cock. The alicorn was getting closer and closer to an orgasm. Gritting her teeth, she could feel it. This mare’s tight hole was milking her for everything she had left. “Don’t think…this’ll be…the end…of me…”

“Then give it to me!” Applejack shouted, grabbing at Nightmare’s shoulders to better angle herself. “Come on your alicorn bitch, fucking cum in this pussy! Let’s see if you can really mess me up!”

Riding faster and faster, Applejack was moving her hips at the pace to let Nightmare bottom out inside her. The alicorn could feel as this pussy was hugging and embracing her in a way that was making it harder and harder to hold back. Though she had come numerous times already, Nightmare could feel as if she was starting to run out of cum. Her balls were tightening on her body, making her cock swell as she was going to cum soon.

“Come on, you’re almost there.” Applejack grunted, bouncing her ass on Nightmare’s cock harder and harder. The sound of her soft ass clapping and smacking on the alicorn’s legs echoed out as she was working to milk everything from her partner. “Give it to me. Fuck that pussy. Fuck it full of that alicorn…fucking…cum!”

Nightmare was unable to hold back, feeling as she was releasing herself in the mare’s pussy. Applejack gasped as she could feel the hot cum flooding her pussy, soaking her womb in the potent seed as the alicorn pumped what she could. Anything extra only leaked out as it ran down the still hard and throbbing cock. But unlike before, Nightmare could feel as if her strength was beginning to wane as she was unable to keep her hands up.

“Fuck…feels like…you finally gave out.” Applejack panted, huffing as she felt her own strength leaving her as she collapsed backwards. As soon as she fell back on the bed, she could see that Nightmare’s dick was now going limp. “We…we did it…”

“We did it?!” Twilight exclaimed, almost as if she couldn’t believe the six of them were able to defeat Nightmare Moon. “Yes! We did it! We’ve defeated you, Nightmare Moon.” Though she was weak, she dragged herself somewhat up to point down at the winded alicorn. “Now keep your promise!”

“Over? Over! Who said it was over?” Nightmare shouted, his horn and eyes ignited with a dark, azure flame as she burst with a powerful warmth and light. Her cock slowly grew back to not only full arousal, but seemed to have grown a little as well. “You are all nothing to me. Nothing! Just mortal ponies, weak and frail, with bodies fit only to be at my pleasure!”

The six mares looked on as Nightmare continued to give her speech. They could feel the overwhelming power of the alicorn. Even with the boost Twilight was able to give them, it wasn’t enough. Nightmare was just too powerful, and yet they knew they couldn’t give up, not yet. Try as they might, their bodies could only twitch and shiver, too weak to even attempt to roll to one side, let alone move themselves.

“Look at you, weak and fatigued.” Nightmare continued to gloat, lifting herself, she was now on her knees while her cock throbbed between breaths. “You have all done well to endure as you have, but that is not enough, not even close to enough to stop-” Her words were cut off as she felt a warm, wetness run between her legs, from her pussy to her balls. “What?” Looking down, she saw Twilight, having somehow found a way to pull herself under the alicorn and was now lifting herself to eat out the alicorn’s pussy. “What are you doing? It’s over. You’ve lost!”

Twilight said nothing, only continuing to let her tongue delve in and out of Nightmare’s pussy. Despite her fatigue and near exhaustion, she continued to force herself to lick and tease the snatch. Because the alicorn was paying attention only to Twilight, she once again failed to notice as the other five, weak and sore as they were, hadn’t given up just yet. Moving closer and closer, the mares approached the alicorn, even as their eyes were fluttering from a coming exhaustion.

“What are you?” Nightmare commented, only now noticing as the mares were crawling themselves onto her body. Though she had given herself a boast of strength and stamina, as well as a renewed arousal, she wasn’t able to hold onto the weight of the five mares for long. “So this is your final push? You plan to defeat me?”

Nightmare flexed and threw about her arms, but the mares were holding onto her too tightly. Though they were very much exhausted, Twilight and the others were doing the best they could to bring Nightmare down onto her back. The alicorn’s eyes were still glowing with the azure flames, but even they were slowly losing their luster. She was getting weaker as well. The previous orgasms had trained much of Nightmare’s strength and these six mares were taking advantage of it.

“You can’t…can’t…defeat…me…” Nightmare panted, feeling as her body was getting heavier from all the growing pleasure. She had overexerted herself and she was only now realizing it. “I will…I…will…”

“It’s over…Nightmare Moon.” Twilight panted, still working her tongue in Nightmare’s pussy. “We’re gonna make you cum…until you surrender!” The alicorn could only wince, frustrated as she could feel the other five mares were starting to lick and kiss along her slender and alluring body.

It was like an eternity as Nightmare was laying on the bed. Her body was being held down by these six mares, who were giving her entire body oral worship. Not only were her breasts suckled and licked by Rarity and Rainbow Dash, but her neck was being tenderly kissed by Fluttershy, which only sent shivers down her spine, making her wings stiffen and tremble a little. Twilight, Applejack, and Pinkie Pie were taking turns sucking and playing with the alicorn’s cock, balls, and pussy. Applejack licked and fondled at the huge, cum filled balls. Pinkie was almost muzzle deep in the soaking wet pussy. And Twilight was bobbing her head a little up and down around the upper half of the thick cock.

Nightmare could only moan out in pleasure, unable to move as she was being held down. She trembled, occasionally twitching as she was feeling the next orgasm was coming upon her. Whimpering a little, she felt her cock and balls tingle with the next climax. As if sensing this, the six mares picked up their paces, licking, kissing, and sucking along Nightmare’s body. Each one pushed themselves further and further, even as they were so tired, they could barely see straight.

“This…this…fuck!” Nightmare moaned out, feeling as her cock throbbed hard, releasing her last major orgasm in Twilight’s mouth. The mare swallowed down the load as best as she could, but couldn’t hold it all in. Moving her mouth off the cockhead, the alicorn’s dick sprayed out her release. “Fuck!”

Nightmare’s cum shot upwards, only to splatter not only herself, but the six mares as she shivered from the hot spunk that was coating their bodies. Her eyes were almost rolling back as she could feel her consciousness fading from her. Twilight could only look over from the defeated alicorn, to the other mares. They smiled and nodded, but couldn’t hold themselves up any longer.

Fluttershy and Rarity were the first to pass out, collapsing on Nightmares’s body. Rainbow and Applejack were the next ones, with the former laying on the alicorn’s tits, while the latter rested between the thighs. Pinkie was after that, smiling confidently at Twilight, as if to confirm to her friend that they won. Feeling her own fatigue overpower her, the unicorn felt her chest swelling with pride over this victory. With that, she joined the others as they drifted into unconsciousness.