As I stared at my bedroom ceiling that night, the only thing I was sure of was that I was glad Cadance would be leaving tomorrow morning. Just a quick visit, just stopping by. I sure couldn’t take much more of this! And maybe there would be no more opportunities for her to—

The door to my room opened. Oh crap...

“Um... Twilight?” I asked, hopefully.

Cadance’s blue magic glowed from her horn, the only light in the room. “Guess again.”

My hands started shaking. What the heck was I supposed to do? Should I tell Shining Armor about Cadance’s cheating? Should I tell Cadance about Shining Armor’s cheating? Did they already know? But they sure didn’t act like it...

“Don’t worry,” she said, “I’m only here to get my panties back. They are our special anniversary panties, after all.”

“Oh, um, sure!” Hurriedly, I hopped up and fished them out from where I’d hidden them in the bottom of my underwear drawer. Which was fitting, right, because they were underwear...

Best not to mention how I’d used them to jerk off with after dinner, though. My first taste of pussy had gotten me pretty worked, up alright?

“Oh, and one more thing.”

With a trepid gulp, I held out my hand. The panties were snatched away. A slip of paper replaced them. It was much too dark in here to read, and I wasn’t about to turn my lights on – lights have a way of traveling in this crystalline castle – but there was very little doubt just what I now had in my hand.

“It says, ‘One Free All-Out Rutting, Like You’ve Never Had Before’.”

I winced. Yeah, I remembered writing that one. I’d been particularly worked up after writing up all the others, and my mind had been brimming with fantasies of Rarity redeeming it. Now, though ... now it felt like I wasn’t ready at all.

I glanced back at my bed, even though it was too dark to see. “Can we ... really do that? What if you get pregnant or something?”

She placed another coupon in my hand.

“W-what does this one say?”

“’One Free Cream Pie’. Though, I was hoping I might get a two-for-one special on that one. Seeing as you have two dicks and all...”

I gasped. “You know?”

“It’s not my first dragon rodeo.”

Her hands firmly took hold of my shoulders. She steered me to the bed and pushed me over onto it. The coupons fell from my grip, somewhere on the floor. “Ready?” she whispered from somewhere above me.

“N-no....”

“Well then I’ll just have to get you ready.”

I squirmed as Cadance pulled my pajama pants down, but it was no use. They went down to my ankles, binding my legs together and holding me in place. My underwear followed only a moment later. And then I felt Cadance’s mouth against one of my cocks.

Yes, they were already coming out. I wasn’t a stupid dragon ... nor a particularly chaste one. Not by choice, anyway. My reaction to the Princess of Love alone with me in my bedroom was only natural.

What happened next changed my entire world. I couldn’t see what was happening in the dark, but I could feel it. Warm, soft lips closed over one of my cocks and quickly enveloped it to the very base. A gentle hand stroked the other.

I’d like to say I gasped or groaned or something masculine like that. But honestly, I squeaked. This was a heaven like I’d never felt or imagined before! And not just because Cadance’s mouth was luscious and inviting – because she was skilled with it. Her tongue swirled over my most sensitive spots with the same rhythm as her hand on my other cock. Pulses of gentle suction pressed her cheeks against the sides of my shaft as she bobbed her head. And, as my cocks grew and she swallowed my tip, squeezed me with her throat as well. My back arched involuntarily, and I made instinctive humping motions toward her, which she expertly and uncomplainingly accommodated.

I could have busted like that in mere moments ... but she stopped before I did. At first I yearned for her to resume, I would have given anything! But a moment later, I felt the bed move, felt Cadance’s body above my own, and felt a new warmth against the same cock that had just been in her mouth.

“C-Cadance!” I said, my voice barely more than a croak.

“Mm-hm?”

“But I’m ... I’m a virgin!”

She lowered herself. “Not anymore.”

One of my cocks was pressed awkwardly to the side by the big softness of Cadance’s leg, but I didn’t care. Because my other cock was inside her. Really, actually, inside a mare! Something I’d been starting to think would never happen, and yet here it was! And not just any mare, one of the most gorgeous mares in all of Equestria! Surrounded in her tight wet warmth!

Unbelievingly, I raised my hands toward her. And to my surprise, I didn’t feel any clothing at all, only Cadance’s own supple body. Was she ... naked? She couldn’t be! When did she take her clothes off, before she even came in my room? All the way through the castle’s halls?

I slid my hands up her toned belly, all the way up to two new heavenly softnesses.

“You like them?” Cadance said as she started moving, grinding up and down on the cock inside her.

With both hands, I explored and squeezed Cadance’s huge, springy-soft tits, quickly finding her big nipples and rubbing those as well. They had a way of folding back into the softness of her breasts that just made me go wild for some reason...

She giggled. “You do like them. And unlike Rarity’s, these are completely real.”

I froze for a moment with her huge tits still in my hands, though Cadance herself didn’t stop moving on my lap. “Rarity’s are real.”

Cadance outright laughed now – and still didn’t stop moving. “If you say so, dragon boy. But I bet I’ve gotten a much closer look at them than you ever have.”

“You ... you and Rarity...?”

She pressed a finger against my lips. “Shh. The Princess of Love doesn’t kiss and tell!”

“Buh ... buh...” I couldn’t make my mouth work. Cadance had been with Rarity and I hadn’t? And now I was with Cadance instead? What kind of world would let that happen? And should I even be mad about it? It was hard to feel mad at Cadance with her inner walls steadily massaging one of my shafts.

“Ready for more?” Cadance unexpectedly lifted herself up.

“More?”

The way she turned sideways took her titties out of my reach, but what happened after that made it all worthwhile. My other cock touched against the familiar wet warmth of her pussy ... and the one that had just been inside her touched something else entirely.

With a slight, very unladylike, groan, Cadance forced herself down on me again. This time both cocks went inside her, aided by the juices she’d already smeared on me. One so slick and warm, the other so tight and hot!

“Cadance! It’s ... it’s in your...”

“Of course it is,” she said, beginning to move again. “I told you I wanted a two-for-one special on that cream pie.”

My whole world was imploding. Only in my wildest fantasies had I ever been inside a mare with both cocks at the same time! Usually that was two mares ... if only because I never thought I’d find a mare willing to do this! Certainly not Rarity, who was the usual focus of my fantasies. My head was spinning with the insane pleasure of both cocks being so intimately stroked at once. I felt like I was on the verge of passing out!

After a short time of that, though, Cadance reached one hand down and stroked my chest through the pajama shirt I still had on. “This is nice... But I’d hardly call it an ‘all-out rutting, like I’ve never had before’.” Her nails dug into my chest through the shirt. “Is that all you’ve got?”

I snorted out a little bit of flame, briefly lighting the room and revealing Cadance’s nude beauty to me. She wanted more? I’d give her more!

With all the strength I had, I lifted myself up and – still inside of her – twisted around, laying her on her side on my own bed and at the same time sliding off the edge of the bed next to it.

I’d unavoidably pulled slightly out of her during all that maneuvering, and now, not holding back in the slightest, I slammed back into her, filling both her pussy and her ass at the same time.

That earned me a shocked – but not displeased – gasp from Cadance. And encouraged by the sound, I did it again. And again. And again. I hammered into her with everything I had, all the strength I could muster. Soon I was gasping for breath as if I’d been running a marathon, but I didn’t care. All I wanted was to feel more of her fantastic inner walls – both pussy and ass – gliding against my cocks, to hear more of her gasps and outright screams, to win this, once and for all! With one hand, I grabbed her bouncing tits and squeezed each of them as hard as I dared. With my other, I grabbed her ass cheek, feeling it ripple as my ribbed cocks plunged in and out of both her holes.

Even so, that didn’t seem to be enough for Cadance. As I began to falter and slow, her horn lit up, dimly lighting the decadent scene in front of me. Her magic grabbed me by the base of my tail, and with the stunning brute power of an alicorn’s magic, she pushed and pulled, forcing my hips to move even faster.

She climaxed – loudly and messily. Screaming my name at the top of her lungs and dousing my bed with her orgasmic juices. Her magic faltered as she lost concentration, leaving me to keep going as best as I could.

Which I of course did. I was starting to get really close myself, and I wasn’t about to stop, especially not with both of her love tunnels pulsing and squeezing around my cocks as if begging me for it. I did slow down, though, starting a more leisurely, more sensual pace that allowed me to catch my breath ... and maybe hold back my own orgasm for just a little bit, to experience this just a little longer...

No good! It was too much! I could already feel the burning sensation welling up inside of me. I quickly pulled outward—

Only to be shoved back in by Cadance’s renewed magic. “You still owe me that cream pie.” The magic around my tail squeezed. An extra tendril of it toyed at the entrance of my own asshole. “Now cum for your princess, little dragon!”

There was no holding back. With a fevered mental apology to Shining Armor, I willingly thrust all the way back inside Cadance again, and both of my cocks throbbed inside her, pulsing in tandem.

That triggered another orgasm from her; both her pussy and her ass squeezed back against me, milking more of my cum into her. “Yes!” she cried out. “Knock me up! Fill me until I lay dragon eggs!”

Hearing that in her voice made my knees go weak. I almost collapsed. I might have, if not for my unshakable grip on her body. Anything to keep my twin cocks where they belonged, pumping stream after stream into the steamy confines of her ass and pussy. Jetting her as full of dragon cum as I could possibly make her.

When I finally ran out of steam and pulled my now-limp cocks out of her, it was too dark to see her pussy and ass both gaping, but I could hear the cum splattering out of each.

“Mmm! Goddess I love dragon cum!” Cadance scooped some up with her fingers and slurped them clean. “So steaming-hot! Nothing else like it.”

I stood there, legs trembling, not believing what I was seeing, what I was hearing, what I had just done.

Meanwhile, though, Cadance got up off the bed quite casually and grabbed her special anniversary panties. Using her magic – which lit it up enough for me to see – she pulled them back up her legs and squished them into place, instantly soaking them with my still-leaking cum.

“Was that....” I gasped for breath. “Was that like you’ve never had before?”

“Hmm... Close enough. Better than Shining, at least! His cock is bigger than yours, but he’s only got one!”

I couldn’t hold it any longer. My legs gave way. I collapsed face-first onto my own bed.

Cadance slapped my ass playfully. “And don’t worry, Rarity gave me lots of coupons – I still have plenty left!”

“Hgrnng?” It was the closest I could manage to coherent speech at the time.

“And I truly will be giving most of them to mares in need.” She came closer, whispering in my ear, “But I’m saving the best ones for myself.”

An involuntary shudder ran through my body. Of anticipation, fear, who knows.

She kissed my cheek. “See you soon, hotcakes!”

🎟️ 🎟️ 🎟️

I thought my troubles were over – at least for a while – once Cadance and Shining Armor left to continue their goodwill tour of Equestria. I closed the castle doors with a deep sigh of relief.

Only to feel my heart plunge when I saw Twilight standing just inside. Holding a coupon.

Oh no. Please no! Not her! Twilight was an attractive mare, sure, especially since becoming an alicorn and filling out a bit more. But no! I’d always thought of her like a sister or even a mother. It would be super-weird to have sex with her just like I’d done with Cadance! And, if anything, having just done it with her sister-in-law last night made things even weirder!

Trembling and dying a little on the inside, I took the coupon when she held it out toward me. I barely dared to read it.

‘One Free Luxury Romantic Breakfast In Bed’

Gasping with relief, I collapsed with my back against the door. Oh thank goodness!

She must have misinterpreted my reaction entirely. “I’m sorry!” she said plaintively. “If it’s too much, I’ll take the coupon back! I just thought, you know, since I’ve been so busy and stressed with Cadance and Shining Armor’s visit, I should treat myself tomorrow morning and take a little relaxation break. But I never wanted to make you overwork your—”

Breathlessly, I leapt up and gave Twilight a huge hug. “I don’t mind at all,” I assured her. “I was just worried it would be ... something else.”

“Something else? Like what?”

Author's Note

This story was chosen by my SubscribeStar supporters! Every month, I take suggestions from my supporters and they vote to decide which story idea I'll write next.

If you want to help tell me which stories to write, go to my SubscribeStar page and pledge $5 or more. Then you'll get to vote on which story from my ideas list gets written next and add your own ideas directly to that list!