Author's Note

Pairing: Applejack/Butterscotch
Contains anal, blowjobs, sexual potions, bottom half body transformation, doggy style, friends to lovers, brief conflict before sex, sexual references towards other herd members, making out.

Buttering Him Up

Applejack felt himself wake up even before his eyes opened, hearing the door to the room he was in close as he gave a sleepy gasp of surprise before settling back into falling asleep again as he only partially woke up. His body relaxed back into the comfortable mattress as he started to snore and drool a little bit out of his mouth, when he felt something light and feathery tickle his nostrils as his muzzle started to scrunch up.

“Haah, hah,” Applejack’s ears flickered, his eyes squinted hard as he loudly went “ACHOO!” and then opened his eyes to see Butterscotch staring back at him with his bright green eyes and big smile. After all the time with Zecora, it was a bit refreshing for the orange farmpony to see another pony willing to listen to what he had gone through. Or just to physically be there for him. “Oh, h-hey Butterscotch, good morning?”

“It’s afternoon now, but thank you,” Butterscotch grinned wider, briefly showing his two bat pony fangs before continuing. “Hopefully you slept really well? Zecora told me a bit of what happened yesterday, and hopefully you feel a lot more refreshed today.”

“Mah heart still hurts quite a bit,” Applejack shrugged. “Ah’m not gonna lie to you about that, but ah’m really glad ah took off some extra days from teaching for if last night ended up being a disaster like it did. Funny though, the rest of the family beside Grandpa Smith was really accepting and happy for me. It’s just he acted much worse than all of them combined in mah worst case scenarios ah imagined. What a fucking pain.”

“Well I’m really glad your siblings were so accepting,” Butterscotch placed a forehoof on Applejack’s forehoof sticking out from the blankets as he smiled. “And Sugar Beau too without a doubt, would be a bit surprised if he somehow was against a femcolt relationship of all things.”

“Yeah, that’d be ironic huh?” Applejack laughed as he imagined the pink curly-maned unicorn and his dainty feminine figure, briefly, before returning his focus to Butterscotch. “Where is Zecora by the way, working on his cauldron again?”

“No, he went to buy some groceries real quick,” Butterscotch explained. “Different vegetables and then ingredients for the potions, and probably looking for somepony to take over deliveries to Sweet Apple Acres I’d imagine. So maybe not quick, probably will be a while.”

“Oh,” Applejack deflated a little, already missing that masculine smell that bathed over him when Zecora was cuddling him the night before. Butterscotch’s ears flickered as he caught the orange farmpony’s tone, taking a bit of a bold move as the yellow pegasus climbed onto the bed and extended his wing to rest over Applejack’s blonde mane.

“Well, aren’t we part of the same herd?” Butterscotch pointed out, looking down at Applejack with a big smile. “I’m plenty company till he gets back I hope?”

“We’re part of the same herd, but you haven’t taken up mah offer at all,” Applejack rolled his eyes, and Butterscotch’s heart skipped a beat in pure shock as he didn’t expect the orange farmpony to speak so bluntly. “Ah’ve just watched ya fuck mah former rival, and then the stallion ah loved before all this, while ah get railed by Zecora. That doesn’t really count.”

“I-”

“Sorry, ah initially was more than okay with taking it slow,” Applejack shook his head, climbing out of the bed and away from Butterscotch’s touch as he shook his head. “But such a shitty night’s got me feelin’ all kinds of ways. Mah Grandpa can’t stand me, and ah wonder if you feel a similar type of way.”

“Great Artemis, Applejack, it’s not like that at all,” Butterscotch walked towards Applejack while remaining on the bed, his wings open from his sides as he stared down at the farmpony from his higher perch on the mattress. “You’re definitely perceptive enough to know something is up, but it’s not me hating you. To tell you the truth, I figured your family would have a lot more influence on you and that their disapproval would lead you to leaving the herd. We’ve never had anything like that happen before and I don’t know how it would’ve damaged the herd. I didn’t want to know. Because Elusive is becoming increasingly fond of you and you love him the most, I was also worried about you convincing him to leave. I guess this has been an on-and-off worry since you joined the herd and it didn’t become truly stressful up until the day before. Even though it made sense in my head at the time, it was truly selfish of me to let something that wasn’t happening at all take priority, and I’m sorry. I’ll even leave the hut and let you process if that makes you feel better, or you're mad and you think I’m an asshole. I honestly wouldn’t even blame you.”

“Butterscotch, you’re the Element of Kindness,” Applejack looked up back at Butterscotch, his once contorting expression stopped as he stared at the yellow pegasus with gentle green eyes. “I would never think you’re an asshole.”

“Oh, well thank you,” Butterscotch’s shoulders relaxed at Applejack’s statement.

“And that’s a pretty fair thought process, about mah family anyways,” Applejack admitted. “Looking back on it, ah don’t think ah see a scenario where ah would’ve turned Zecora down. Ah realized very recently that ah was never really happy at the barn before he came along. Ah’ll never stop caring about mah family, but a grown stallion is supposed to leave the ‘nest’ so to speak, and the family obligation that we push on each other running that barn isn’t exactly normal. Ah’m sure when Apple Buck becomes an adult, he’ll feel the same way as me if he doesn’t already and leave for Manehatten or something. And Big Mae and Sugar Beau will likely run the barn with their foals who will go on to either run the barn or leave, and the cycle will continue.”

“And,” Applejack spoke just a second before Butterscotch could interrupt him. “Elusive would never quit zebra dick, not even for me. Let’s be real.”

“Haha!” Butterscotch laughed, his heart blossoming at Applejack’s forward statement as he blushed a little too before looking at the orange farmpony. “I do suppose you’re right. Well, if you weren’t a solid member of the herd before, you certainly are now. That was the one worry I had, and exaggerated quite a bit. Our previous spat didn’t help at all either, even if I had forgiven you.”

“Ah know,” Applejack nodded.

“You know what I’d like to do?” Butterscotch suggested, and Applejack narrowed his eyes expectedly as he tilted his head a little at the pegasus who threw his wings up in exasperation. “Oh come on now, I don’t think about doing it all the time. That’s not even what I was going to suggest right now, I was going to suggest a massage. Even if you don’t buck apples anymore, I’m sure those muscles of yours deserve it. What do you say?”

“That seems like a very comforting activity,” Applejack’s face softened a little as he watched Butterscotch move to the other side of the bed, giving the orange stallion a chance to slowly climb back on as he threw himself on his stomach. Stretching out his forelegs and kicking out his hindlegs as they hung off the bed a little, Applejack groaned and sighed in pleasure from the simple act alone as he felt them unchecked for a very long time. Zecora and Elusive had their own methods of care for the orange stallion, helping him feel validated and desired in their own ways. With that said, neither of them ever suggested something practical like a massage. Something that Applejack didn’t realize he needed so badly till Butterscotch mentioned it.

Then, Applejack blushed at his statement earlier as it came up in his mind again.

“Ah uh, wasn’t pressuring you to fuck me by the way right?” Applejack muttered with embarrassment creeping up in his brain. “Ah’m still plenty okay with taking it slow, ah just wanted to understand the reason. It was mighty frustratin’ putting up with it and not talkin’ about it is all.”

“You weren’t,” Butterscotch assured the farmpony as he gently flew on top of Applejack, the yellow pegasus’ hindlegs resting on the orange stallion’s slightly squishy ass cheeks. As he placed his forehooves on Applejack’s shoulders, Butterscotch snickered with his fangs poking out from his mouth as he narrowed his green eyes at Applejack unbeknownst to the farmpony sub. “It’s not like it's possible for you to pressure me on anything now that you are part of Zecora’s herd. I’m the second one in charge, seeing as how I’m the Switch. Understand me?”

Applejack’s eyes went wide as he felt himself starting to get a little hard against the bed, processing Butterscotch’s statement while at the same time feeling the soothing motions of the pegasus massaging his shoulders and moving his hooves down over the farmpony’s spine. He wasn’t expecting Butterscotch to flip from being apologetic and remorseful to being firm and dominant so fast, especially with the yellow pegasus massaging him during all of this, but Applejack welcomed it as it made him feel at ease from their disagreement. Almost forgetting that he didn’t answer Butterscotch’s question, Applejack gulped as he spoke up.

“Yes, Butterscotch, I understand you,” Applejack’s voice teetered on the brink of merely answering Butterscotch as a friend, and succumbing into deep hot arousal with his answer. “I can act however I’d like towards you, and you will gladly assert your authority if need be. Because you are as dominant as you are submissive~”

“That is correct,” Butterscotch nodded as he blushed a little at Applejack’s reciprocation, his wings flickering in arousal as the pegasus was starting to get a little hard himself. He moved backwards, his hindlegs now on the bed as he placed his forehooves right over the orange farmpony’s cutie marks. Maybe if it was two months ago, Applejack would have both the temperament and physical figure to dominate Butterscotch. But the orange farmpony wasn’t truly happy that way, and he happily gave up that facade he was unknowingly playing until recently. Seeing how different the orange earth pony looked in such a short amount of time made Butterscotch’s forehooves feel hot and fiery with arousal that was tickling him in all the right places. Surprised that their initial start to the day led them to getting along so well, faster than Butterscotch had planned in his mental method of seduction, the yellow femcolt started to test the waters a little bolder than he thought he would only an hour ago.

Pulling back his forehoof from Applejack’s cutie mark, Butterscotch rushed it back to his flank and smacked the farmpony’s ass loudly. Those apples on the stallion’s ass rippled with the impact, and Applejack’s eyelashes fluttered a little as he shuddered and whined. He moved his blonde tail to the side, exposing his dark orange ponut and balls as he glanced at Butterscotch over his shoulder with a big smirk and a subtle wiggle of his ass cheeks. Butterscotch’s eyes lit up, his mouth parted a little in delightful surprise at how quickly Applejack welcomed the touch, and he did the same smack on the farmpony’s other ass cheek. Applejack bit his lip, moaning a little louder but holding it back.

“Don’t keep it in,” Butterscotch ordered, and Applejack threw his head back and loudly moaned in a higher pitch than the femcolt switch expected. The massage was quickly shifting into something far more lewd as Butterscotch flew back till his butt and hindlegs were off the bed completely. Butterscotch draped his upper body over Applejack’s ass cheeks, while resting his hindlegs on the floor as he pressed his muzzle against the orange farmpony’s dark orange ponut and giving a large sniff and inhaling that vibrant yet musky apple scent. Applejack’s eyes shot wide open from the motion, his blonde tail flicking in excitement as he couldn’t believe that Butterscotch was taking up his offer. The orange farmpony desperately wanted Butterscotch to fuck his brains out ever since the three-way with him and Rainbow Blitz where they didn’t go all the way. And now? With Applejack truly proving himself and staying with the herd even with a family member disapproving, the earth pony could tell that Butterscotch was comforted to see that his anxious worries never came to pass. The yellow pegasus opened his mouth, rimming Applejack’s ponut as he was swiftly caving to the arousal he was holding back.

“Haah, great fucking Solaris,” Applejack gasped, pressing his forehooves against the bed for dear life as he felt that warm ticklish pleasure that Butterscotch was delivering just from rimming him alone. The orange stallion could only imagine how good Butterscotch’s tongue would be inside his plump apple-y backdoor, lubing him up naturally for the fucking that would rock the farmpony’s world. Fortunately, Applejack didn’t have to wonder for long what that would feel like, as a warm and wet appendage penetrated his backdoor and wriggled back and forth stretching him out to the tiniest degree. Applejack blushed brightly, his facial cheeks like apples, as he let out a deep moan while even his ears were burning with profuse arousal as Butterscotch parted his cheeks further apart to press his muzzle further against the orange farmpony’s ass. Applejack melted into the pleasure that made the minutes bleed away insanely fast, making the orange farmpony lose track of time of that warm euphoria moving back and forth deep in his ass before Butterscotch decided to take it up a notch. Pushing his muzzle inside with a fair bit of effort, Butterscotch closed his eyes as he had penetrated the farmpony’s ass with a fraction of his muzzle. The thick intrusion, almost as thick as Zecora’s dick, caused Applejack’s dick to twitch as his eyes went wide as saucers and he gritted his teeth from the intensity. It wasn’t painful in the least, but Applejack wasn’t expecting it and he felt his hindlegs kicking a little from the sensation. His cock between his body and the mattress became fully hard, and Butterscotch rocked his muzzle back and forth a few times before pulling back till only his tongue was inside again. Giving a few more wriggles of his tongue, Butterscotch then pulled out entirely as he got up and walked out of the room.

“Don’t worry, this is far from over~!” Butterscotch assured the gasping farmpony as he trotted down the hallway, Applejack taking deep breaths as the calming massage had quickly escalated to the femcolt switch shoving part of his muzzle into the farmpony’s backdoor. Though, Applejack wasn’t complaining. Not about the escalation, anyways. If there was anything for him to complain about, it was that Butterscotch’s carnal domination on him took so damn long. Applejack’s ears perked up, briefly pulled from his sinful thoughts, as he heard Butterscotch gulping down something in the main living room where the cauldron was. Less than two minutes after Applejack heard that noise, he watched as the yellow femcolt walked in with the bottom half of his body looking absurdly different. Instead of those fat submissive cheeks that Applejack knew Zecora loved, Butterscotch had toned cheeks and hindlegs that were far more fitting for a pegasus. On top of that, Butterscotch’s slightly less than average length was completely hard and while not as thick as Zecora’s dick, was a more-than-respectable ten inches of slightly thinner pegasus cock that made Applejack’s mouth water when he looked at the yellow femcolt over his shoulder. Applejack was still laying on his stomach with his hindlegs splayed out and his blonde tail to the side, presenting himself to the other stallion as he grinned.

“Do ah, um, look fitting for you?” Applejack batted his eyes as he stared at Butterscotch’s narrowed dominant gaze. Butterscotch grinned as he flew up on top of Applejack again, this time with far more ease as he didn’t have the weight of his fat bubbly ass weighing him down. His wings were open, though they reminded Applejack of the slightly folded wings of a bird-of-prey with the narrowed gaze and sharp fangs poking out of the yellow pegasus’ mouth as he pressed one forehoof between the farmpony’s shoulder blades. Applejack gasped as if the air was knocked out of him, blushing heavily as he felt one of Butterscotch’s wings fold around his blonde tail and lift his ass up further until the switch’s dick tip was pressed against the orange stallion’s ponut.

“Are you ready for me to take up your offer, so you can see if I’m all that like you’ve been thinking about?” Butterscotch’s ears flickered. “Bet the only thing better than getting constantly railed by zebra dick is getting dominated by both a zebra and a pegasus that is putting you in your place. Doesn’t that sound hot?”

“Yes! Fuck me!” Applejack demanded, blurting out the order first before shortly realizing what he had done. Butterscotch dropped Applejack’s tail, letting his ass drop as the orange farmpony whine hungrily. “Ah’m sorry! Ah won’t order you around. Could you please fuck me, and forgive me, Butterscotch?”

“Better~” Butterscotch grinned again as Applejack adjusted his hindlegs so that his ass was raised high in the air with his fat ponut against the pegasus’ magically grown dick. Butterscotch savored the feeling of his cock snug between those plump apple-decorated cheeks, the magic energy flowing and vibrating within his now bigger dick. He could swear that the potion not only made substantial physical changes, but a psychological change as well as the dominant part of himself was alight with hunger, of taking this pony that had so eagerly taken to submission. Butterscotch snorted with sharp arousal as he pushed for a moment, feeling that cock penetrate that hole that clamped down on his cock like a vice as soon as he entered. Applejack threw his head back and brayed in arousal, louder than the moans he made before. Butterscotch snorted, flapping his wings like a vulture swooping in, and pushed further as he had three inches inside of Applejack’s ass now. Applejack’s eyes fluttered to the back of his head as he delighted in the fact that not a full day after he gave up the farm life he was raised upon, that Butterscotch had finally decided to officially make him one of his valued subs. Where he was completely certain of his decision before, Applejack now thrived and reveled in his confidence of being one of the herd. The Elements of Harmony were quickly taking sinful shape as the striped subs of Zecora, and Applejack was certain he’d be made official soon enough. He had hesitance before leaving the farm for good, and now that the most important obstacle was no more, Applejack was ready to take to the striping like a fish to water.

“Yes, Butterscotch, please give me more of that dick~” Applejack whined, intentionally raising his normally deep voice by an octave. It wasn’t naturally as high-pitched as Rainbow Blitz’ voice was, but Butterscotch was turned on all the same as he rushed forward, hitting Applejack’s p-spot and shoving all ten inches of his dick inside of the orange farmpony. Applejack yelped in pleasure, his entire body shuddering as he nearly came from the sudden movement inside his ass. Butterscotch kept his erect cock there, remaining still and taking joy in Applejack trying to rock his ass back into the pegasus. Butterscotch relented, pulling out slowly inch by inch leaving Applejack’s ass even though the orange stallion’s backdoor desperately clamped down and tried to keep him there. He didn’t know if Applejack was expertly clenching his walls down, or if it was just the orange stallion’s instinct to have dick in his ass, but Butterscotch was more than happy to partake in his need. Rushing forward, his wings flapping harder as he was succumbing to the dominant predatory part of his brain with his bright white bat pony fangs glinting, Butterscotch slammed his entire length inside of Applejack’s ass as the orange farmpony wailed and bucked his untouched dick into the mattress. He was just at the cusp of having an insane orgasm that eluded him and moved out of his reach, and he was fired up to get that release, even if it was before Butterscotch came. Butterscotch slowly pulled out and thrusted in even faster, and Applejack’s hindlegs stretched out as he brayed, his tongue lolling out of his muzzle as he came into the blankets and sheets. Something that Zecora was more than used to, to be throwing them in washing and drying spells in the cauldron after. Applejack bucked and humped the warmth of the blankets as he got them sticky with his cum, his eyes becoming unfocused as his braying stopped altogether save for the occasional moan and grunt while he continued blushing hard.

“This is so fucking hot,” Butterscotch snarled as he started pistoning Applejack’s fat orange ponut in earnest, getting off even harder than the two sissies he was used to fucking like fleshlights. They were physically made to be subs, lithe and feminine in every conceivable way. But Applejack spent years carefully building a masculine body with a powerful earth pony build to match, only to give it up and let it go into something submissive and soft over the past two months. He was surrendering that life to being plapped by a striped pegasus switch and their mutual Zebra Master, who would always have been stronger than Applejack even at his best. And that was insanely hot to Butterscotch, who was creating thunderous plapping that filled the room in its sinful sound as Applejack’s voice grew louder again. His dark yellow balls plapped against Applejack’s inferior subby balls as the orange farmpony gritted his teeth at times from the sheer arousal flooding his body and making him completely hard again. Butterscotch rushed forward, sinking his bat pony fangs and pony teeth into Applejack’s blonde mane while jackhammering his dick into the vice-like grip of the orange stallion’s asshole.

“Yah, that’s right, get that ass of mine, get it~!” Applejack begged, parting his hind legs even more to give Butterscotch room to rearrange his insides as he panted and felt dirty in the best way possible. Butterscotch grunted and snorted into Applejack’s mane, and the orange stallion moaned and felt his vision blurring into the dizzying pleasure of the pegasus dominating him. Applejack leaned into feeling like a slut, finding the feeling making him more turned on and hotter rather than ashamed. Butterscotch snorted, moaned a little, as he hilted himself inside of Applejack’s ass and came ropes of his white seed deep into the orange stallion’s backdoor. Butterscotch held himself in place, his wings no longer flapping as they were slowly folding back against his back by the time he was finished cumming inside of his newest submissive. Using his wings to adjust Applejack, and the big earth pony moving the way Butterscotch wanted, the pegasus was able to get the earth pony back onto his back with his hindlegs splayed into the air. All the while, Butterscotch’s cock was still lodged inside of Applejack’s ass as he stood over him, the switch’s yellow floofy chest hovering over the farmpony’s firmer orange chest.

Butterscotch lunged forward, pressing his muzzle against Applejack’s muzzle as he laid on top of Applejack while they were making out. Applejack’s eyes rolled to the back of his head from feeling Butterscotch’s temporarily lithe figure pressed against his hard cock, and the yellow pegasus stuck his tongue inside and wriggled it against Applejack’s tongue. Applejack was still deprived of his second orgasm, and wrapped his earth pony forelegs around the pegasus as he gently bucked his hips up against Butterscotch. Butterscotch’s tongue was like that of a viper, wriggling fast against Applejack’s thicker tongue as the orange pony submitted. When Applejack’s tongue did move the slightest bit, the orange earth pony shuddered as his tongue briefly felt those sharp fangs that Butterscotch got from his two occasions of being a bat pony. Even if Butterscotch didn’t really do anything with those, it still turned Applejack on as even fate determined him to be a true switch. Butterscotch then pulled his muzzle away, his green eyes narrowed as a strand of saliva connected his fangs to Applejack’s mouth as he continued.

“You still need to cum a second time, seeing as you’re hard as a brick underneath me~” Butterscotch laughed, watching as Applejack pressed his forelegs up against his own chest while averting his eyes with a heavy blush. Still, despite Applejack’s unexpected shyness, the big earth pony nodded as Butterscotch moved down till his head was hovering over Applejack’s thick length. While not as long as Butterscotch’s temporary ten inches, Applejack’s dick was still thicker due to his earth pony body. Dark orange and stiff as a brick as Butterscotch said, Applejack’s apple tree pointed up towards the yellow pegasus and his muzzle as he was licking his fangs. His ears flickered with eagerness staring as such a fine specimen, and Applejack gulped as he knew that Butterscotch would be relentless. Opening his mouth, Butterscotch showed his tongue and fangs briefly to Applejack as he stared in awe for a few moments before the yellow pegasus lunged. Moving down and engulfing all eight inches of Applejack’s dick in one go, Butterscotch aimed his mouth carefully so as to not stab his sub’s dick with his bat pony fangs. His muzzle pressed against the orange fur of Applejack as he hilted himself, mouth and throat, with apple pony dick. Thanks to the potion he had taken earlier, Butterscotch’s throat felt no pain from such a thick intrusion inside of it. Instead, deep pleasure vibrated in his throat as if it was his p-spot being fucked. Butterscotch moaned, his eyes fluttering to the back of his head as he batted his eyelashes, as he moved his flexible tongue around Applejack’s cock in circles.

Applejack panted, his eyes back on Butterscotch now even though the pegasus’ eyes were closed in concentration at that moment. Butterscotch was, despite being the one sucking dick, blushing very lightly in comparison to the big farmpony who was still red in the face from the whole experience. His eyes were closed very gently, as if the blowjob was a relaxing walk in the park. Butterscotch even hummed happily against Applejack’s dick, starting to bob his mouth up and down half of the farmpony’s dick. Applejack refrained from bucking his hips in pleasure and daring to ruin Butterscotch’s rhythm. Instead, he endured the true test of fiery pleasure as Butterscotch worked his dick like a champ. Sucking intensely on some moments and licking like a wet tornado on others, Butterscotch’s blowjob felt much less like a blowjob and more like the predatory bat pony-turned-pegasus sucking the soul out of Applejack’s body. Applejack could only last against such a powerful blowjob for so long, before his submissive body was ready to give Butterscotch what he wanted.

“Fuck, Butterscotch, yer gonna make me ahn!” Applejack moaned loudly as that time he did buck his hips into the inevitable. Butterscotch hilted himself at the same time so that Applejack’s tip was closer to the back of his throat, the yellow pegasus’ eyes rolling to the back of his head as he felt that magical pleasure of fat cock in his throat while Applejack came his rich apple seed right into the femcolt switch’s stomach. Butterscotch was a true freak, both eager to rail Applejack into carnal oblivion and then have the earth pony’s fat dick inside his throat. And both orgasms were equally satisfying to the pegasus’ soul, all the more happy to put his hesitation and long-gone gripes in the past and properly bring Applejack in as one of his and Zecora’s submissives.

“Gaah, hnnng,” Applejack sputtered as Butterscotch gulped the last couple ropes of his apple seed before pulling away, the bat pony licking his muzzle and fangs as he did so. Applejack felt a post-nut haze of happiness hit him hard, and a sense of deep comfort blossoming in his heart as now all of his best friends within the herd were now sexually bonded to him. The herd no longer had the disconnect of him and Butterscotch not being intimate with one another, and Applejack exhaled a huge sigh of relief before grinning at the yellow pegasus. “T-Thank you, Butterscotch. Ah knew you had in within yerself to fuck mah brains out, but ah can tell you got hard from sucking me off. Lemme return the favor~”

“Are you sure?” Butterscotch snickered.

“Ah want it so bad, please Butterscotch,” Applejack whined. “Ah wanna know how yer dick tastes, ah want those ten inches down my throat.”

“You must stare at Zecora’s dick a lot if you know my length down to the inch~” Butterscotch grinned in delight at how far Applejack had fallen from his once dominant facade. Applejack chuckled and nodded, waiting for Butterscotch to move to the side so that the earth pony could roll off the bed. Butterscotch replaced his spot, laying on his back on the bed and stretching out his wings to rest against the sheets as he wolfishly grinned at Applejack. Just like Applejack predicted, the bat pony pegasus’ length was completely hard and nearly as intimidating as Zecora’s cock. Butterscotch slipped a forehoof underneath the pillow as he pushed out a bright red vial towards Applejack who was still off the bed when he took it in his forehoof and stared down at it without a word.

“You’re gonna want this, considering that your throat is gonna hurt like Tartarus otherwise,” Butterscotch explained. Applejack nodded, moving forward and yanking the corkscrew off the vial with his teeth before bringing it to his mouth and swiftly gulping it down. He was relieved that Zecora and Butterscotch often made an effort to have one of those mini potions underneath the pillows in case either one of them wanted to facefuck their subs. Having gulped it many times before, Applejack felt that familiar pleasure dancing on the walls of his throat before seeing Butterscotch smirk and beckon the farmpony forward with a wave of his forehoof. Applejack jumped onto the bed, faced with ten inches of pegasus cock as he brought his nose towards the appendage and gave a deep sniff. It wasn’t half as musky as Zecora’s length, though Applejack suspected that. Surprisingly, possibly due to the potion changing it a lot, Butterscotch’s temporarily bigger cock had a strong floral scent with a hint of musk. Applejack hummed in appreciation of something new, while Butterscotch’s cock still carried a lot of the traits he loved about dicks.

Bringing his muzzle then to Butterscotch’s balls, Applejack took turns sucking on each ball before moving to the next and then back again. He savored the light gasps and grunts that came from his new secondary dom, and Applejack’s blonde tail flicked at the various images he had of them fucking far more often. Applejack even thought of returning to Butterscotch’s cottage and getting railed in every part of that place too, while dolling up as a “mare” and helping Butterscotch take care of his animals whenever they weren’t fucking. Applejack couldn’t resist anymore, and pulled away from sucking on Butterscotch’s balls to move his thick tongue up from the base of the pegasus’ cock all the way up to the tip of the switch’s length. Then, Applejack opened his mouth as he moved down on Butterscotch’s cock. Inch after inch of that thinner cock slipped past Applejack’s lips and eventually down his throat as he danced his tongue around Butterscotch’s length while never taking his eyes off the pegasus. Butterscotch was blushing a little harder now, biting his lip at the show and seeing more of his cock disappear into Applejack’s mouth.

“Great Artemis,” Butterscotch groaned in pleasure. “You really know how to tease, don’t you? Can’t pretend it isn’t hot though.”

Butterscotch smirked as Applejack moved the tiniest bit faster till his mouth was against Butterscotch’s balls as he had successfully had all ten inches in his mouth and down his throat. It was more effortless considering Butterscotch’s thinner cock was a walk in the park in comparison to the titanic bitchbreaker that was Zecora’s superior Zebrican length, but Applejack knew that the lack of pressure would make it his time to shine. To truly show how well Applejack had become at sucking dick.

Applejack bobbed his mouth up and down, sucking hard and swirling his tongue around Butterscotch’s length for several minutes before the yellow pegasus quickly came. Applejack was proud of himself, a fluttering warmth of achievement blossoming in his heart as he saw Butterscotch’s wings convulse while feeling hot ropes of pegasus seed go directly in his stomach. Slowly pulling up till only the tip was in Applejack’s mouth, the orange farmpony wanted to find out if his pegasus dom’s cum was as good as his smell. Tasting the warm cum on his tongue and moaning in delight, Applejack wasn’t disappointed as it tasted like a slightly salty flower. Bobbing his head up and down a few more times, Applejack ensured that he was very thorough in getting all the cum Butterscotch’s body had.

“Fuck yeah,” Butterscotch grunted as Applejack finally pulled his mouth away and grinned at the pegasus with a little bit of saliva at the corners of his muzzle. “Why don’t you come with me to the cottage for a bit? We can leave a note for Zecora, and check if the animals need anything. Since you don’t work for the farm anymore, perhaps I can put those subby farm hooves to good use and have us take turns visiting the cottage?”

Applejack didn’t even think of it that way, though he was relieved that Butterscotch read his mind about visiting the cottage, and possibly getting it on more and making up for lost time. With no hesitation, Applejack galloped out of the room.

“Heck, we can even shower there too!” Applejack agreed. “Write that letter and let’s get goin!”