Flutterbox

Fluttershy and Big Mac discussed their relationship as they walked back to her cottage

"I'm guessing you weren't really having difficulties with your sandwich," Big Mac said, confidently.

"How could you tell?" Fluttershy asked, feigning naivety.

"You don't have to try and act sexy to please me," Big Mac said, "I think you're sexy just the way you are. You have nothing to be embarrassed about, so don't hide anything."

Fluttershy gulped and draped her tail over her salami shack. She wanted to tell Big Mac the truth, but she was afraid. Fluttershy knew she couldn't keep Cootershy a secret forever.

When they reached her cottage, Big Mac and Fluttershy stood outside her door for a moment. Moths flickered around Fluttershy's lantern as the two ponies stared into each other's eyes. Big Mac leaned in and kissed his marefriend on the lips. Fluttershy blushed and felt prompted to back away, but she suppressed these urge and returned the kiss.

Fluttershy had been kissed before, but never like this. Not for this long and nowhere near this level of passion. When their lips finally parted, Fluttershy's eyes were sparkling with stars as she stared up at the powerful stallion standing over her.

"You're so nice," Fluttershy said.

Big Mac pushed Fluttershy's door open with his hoof.

"After you," he said, inviting her inside.

Fluttershy looked around her cottage. She looked at her bed, then at Big Mac, then back to her bed. She knew what she needed to do.

"I need to use the little filly's room," Fluttershy said, blushing, "I'll be right back."

Fluttershy ran into her bathroom and started to open the window. Her plan was to escape to the Everfree Forest and never return.

"Where do you think you're going?" Cootershy said, sternly. Fluttershy lowered her head in defeat and crawled back in through the window.

"I can't do this," Fluttershy said, "What if I do something wrong? What if he doesn't like it? He may never want to see me again."

"Is that all you're worried about?" Cootershy said, relieved, "You'll do fine. Ponies have sex every day! There's nothing to it! Now get out there and boink his brains out!"

"It's not just my performance I'm worried about," Fluttershy said, "I can't keep you a secret forever. Before I take my relationship with Big Mac to the next level, he's going to have to meet you."

Cootershy was silent as she thought deeply on what Fluttershy was saying.

"I don't want any secrets," Fluttershy said, adamantly.

"Okay," Cootershy said, "Go ahead and tell him about me."

Fluttershy stood at the bathroom door. She was finding it difficult to take that final step towards Big Mac. She was about to move forward, when Cootershy stopped her.

"Wait! I have a confession," Cootershy said, "I've always been jealous of you."

"You're jealous of me?" Fluttershy said, surprised, "I thought you hated me because of how sexually repressed I was."

"I don't hate you," Cootershy said, "The more time I've spent talking with you and Rarity, the more I've realized that life isn't just about making yourself feel good. It's more important to make others feel good. You taught me that." Fluttershy felt herself tear up.

"I don't hate you either and am sorry for how I've treated you," Fluttershy said, "All my life I've ignored my sexuality, until you showed me how to fully explore my Element of Harmony. Now, I can take the steps to make up for lost time; but first I have to tell Big Mac everything."

Psyching herself up, Fluttershy walked out of the bathroom and over to her bed, where Big Mac was already sitting; waiting for her. She sat next to him and nuzzled his neck affectionately. Big Mac responded by showering her neck with tiny kisses.

"Stop," Fluttershy said, tensing up, "Before we go any further, there's something you need to know about me." Big Mac became very still and listened intently.

"My marehood isn't... normal," Fluttershy said. Big Mac's heart started pounding and his mind started racing.

"What's wrong?" Big Mac thought, "Does she have a disease, or something?"

Fluttershy turned around and hiked her tail up, allowing Big Mac to see her pussy. Her yellow cock squeezer looked perfectly healthy. Big Mac didn't know what the issue was.

"My vagina can talk," Fluttershy said bluntly as she hid her face behind her mane.

Out of respect for his marefriend, Big Mac didn't burst out laughing. Instead, he opted to play along.

"Alright, vagina," Big Mac said, leaning in close, "Tell me what you want."

"Please," Cootershy said, "Call me Cootershy. Vagina sounds so clinical."

Fluttershy's bedsprings squeaked as Big Mac scrambled away to the far side of the bed. He acted as though he'd just seen a ghost.

"Fluttershy!" Big Mac said alarmed, "Your pussy can talk!"

"That's what I was trying to tell you," Fluttershy said.

"Don't worry, big guy. I don't bite," Cootershy said, flirtatiously, "Not unless you want me to."

Big Mac couldn't tell if Fluttershy's vagina was serious about biting, or not. For all he knew, that was an alien that had burrowed inside her snatch which fed on stallion dicks. Needless to say, Big Mac had serious reservations about sticking his penis inside.

"How long have you had a talking vagina?" Big Mac asked.

"It started this morning," Fluttershy said, "Ever since then, it's been telling me to have sex."

"We could have a three-way," Cootershy said, "Big Mac, Fluttershy and me."

"So this wasn't your idea?" Big Mac said, feeling more uncomfortable by the second, "The only reason you want to sleep with me is to satisfy your pushy pussy?"

Big Mac looked as though he wanted to call the whole thing off. He turned away from Fluttershy and was about to head for the door.

"No wait!" Fluttershy said, "I'm not doing this just for Cootershy. I'm also doing it for you!" Big Mac turned his head to look at Fluttershy, she was crying.

"Please don't hate me," Fluttershy said, "I love you!" Big Mac crawled next to her and cradled her in his arms. She rested her head against his chest as he stroked her pink mane.

"I love you, too," Big Mac said, "I would just hate to have sex if you weren't ready first. Don't let me or your talking vagina pressure you to do something you don't want."

"But I do want this," Fluttershy said, "I've never been able to give sexual kindness before, because I was afraid. I'm ready now; and when I do it for the first time, I want it to be with you." With a small amount of trepidation, Big Mac agreed to have sex.

"I guess we can try," Big Mac said, "as long as we're all in agreement."

"Are you ready, Cootershy?" Fluttershy asked.

"I was born ready!" Cootershy said eagerly, before stopping to consider the implications of that statement, "...That's actually a pretty sick concept, now that I think about it."

Big Mac helped Fluttershy get into position. He stared at the thin slit in front of him.

"I've never touched a talking vagina before," Big Mac said. He glanced over at Fluttershy, who turned around to look at him with a stern expression on her face.

"Uh, what I meant to say was, I've never touched any vagina before," Big Mac said nervously. His eyes darted back and forth suspiciously as he made the Apple family's trademark 'bad poker face.' If Fluttershy was angry about Big Mac's previous relationships, she didn't show it. She knew that all that was in the past. Now that she could commit herself fully to her lover, things would be different.

"Enough words," Cootershy said, passionately, "Now shut up and kiss me!"

Big Mac leaned forward and held Fluttershy's flanks in between his hooves. With her hindquarters sticking up in the air, Big Mac buried his nose in Fluttershy's crotch.

"Oh... my," Fluttershy said, as she grabbed a pillow and held it over her head. Fluttershy had never felt such a strong, burning sensation in her loins before. Cootershy moaned as Big Mac relentlessly licked Fluttershy's clit spit slit.

"More," Cootershy groaned, as Big Mac pulled his face away from Fluttershy's moist mound, "It's so good, you're making me drool! I need you inside me. Stick your penile python inside my serpent socket!"

"Wait!" Fluttershy said, removing the pillow, "First, let me prepare his instrument of love." Big Mac snickered at her use of over-flowery language.

"You've been hanging around Rarity haven't you?" Big Mac said, "She's the only pony I've ever known who calls a cock an 'instument of love.'"

"And just how would you know that?" Fluttershy asked, suspiciously. Big Mac gulped and started to sweat.

"Well, I don't know from experience," Big Mac said, awkwardly, "But one does hear rumors..."

"Sure, rumors," Fluttershy said, dubiously.

Big Mac lay on his back, allowing Fluttershy to crawl on top of his stomach. They faced their lover's genitals, approaching them with a quiet reverence. Fluttershy remembered Rarity's lessons and began to touch Big Mac's tool. Trying not to think of the hygienic implications of what he used his penis for, Fluttershy touched her tongue to the side of his cock and began to lick timidly.

Fluttershy knew a stallion's cock would be warm, but she didn't realize how that warmth which seemed to emanate from his shaft filled her with a fiery passion the more she licked it.

Growing excited as she heard Big Mac moan from her ministrations, Fluttershy began running her tongue up and down in long strokes.

"You like this?" Fluttershy asked.

"Eeyup," he replied.

Big Mac, who up to this point had just been enjoying his dick's tongue bath, decided to return the favor by lapping at Fluttershy's vagina. Cootershy was in front of Big Mac's face and just as eager for him to begin.

"Kiss me!" Cootershy said. Big Mac wasn't sure if this should count as cunnilingus or a french kiss. The whole concept of a talking vagina was too weird for him to comprehend, so he decided to ignore the voice and focus simply on pleasuring Fluttershy.

"More tongue!" Cootershy said, passionately, "Stick it in deep!"

Fluttershy tensed up as Big Mac's tongue entered her pussy. She stopped servicing her stallion's tool as she felt the first tinglings of pleasure course through her body. Her head slumped down against his crotch as she pressed his cock against her face with her fore-hoof.

"Oh yes! I can feel your tongue inside me," Fluttershy said, "Thank you. That feels nice."

"Mmmm," Cootershy moaned, as Big Mac ate Fluttershy out. Fluttershy didn't know what was happening to her, but Cootershy could instinctively sense an orgasm brewing.

"You're gonna make me drool!" Cootershy said, "I'm cumming!" Fluttershy squeaked as she was treated to her first waking orgasm. It was much more visceral than the most erotic wet dream she'd ever had. Her fluids leaked out of Cootershy and onto Big Mac's face.

Once the euphoric high of her orgasm had worn off, Fluttershy returned to her senses and blushed furiously. The bliss she had felt was replaced by feelings of shame.

"Fluttershy, you're so selfish," she thought to herself, "The moment you feel a little pleasure, you forget to share that kindness."

Fluttershy's vagina was still horny even after her first orgasm and was excited for the next phase to begin.

"Oh yes!" Cootershy said, "I want more! Hump my mouth hole!"

Receiving sexual instructions from a talking twat was a little off-putting. Wanting to defend his marefriend, Big Mac confronted Cootershy.

"You can't tell us what to do," Big Mac said, "What are you anyways? Some kind of evil spirit haunting Fluttershy's vagina? A demon?"

"I'm only a demon in the sack," Cootershy said, coyly, "Now stick your cock down her throat! I wanna feel you hump her face!"

"Why would you care about Fluttershy's mouth?" Big Mac said, "You're just a cunt! It's not like you can feel pleasure from Fluttershy giving a blowjob."

This comment had a profound impact on Cootershy. It started to sob. Surprised by the crying cunt, Big Mac leaned close and tried to apologize. Fluttershy looked at Cootershy, concerned.

"I didn't mean anything by it," Big Mac said, "I just didn't think a vagina would have any thoughts beyond its physical desire."

"What's wrong?" Fluttershy said, "I could try teasing you with my hoof. That might make you feel better."

"No," Cootershy said, "It's just that for once I'd like to know what it feels like to be a mare. I want to pretend that I'm more than a cunt. I want a special somepony who cares about me and loves me."

"I had no idea you felt this way," Fluttershy said. The tenderhearted pegasus wanted to be kind, not only her special somepony, but her vagina as well.

"Please, Big Mac," Fluttershy said, "Just for tonight, pretend that my vagina is me. We'll do a role reversal. She's your marefriend, and I'm just her cunt."

"You'd do that for me?" Cootershy said, gratefully.

"If Big Mac's willing to do it," Fluttershy said, "What do you say?"

"Eeyup," Big Mac replied.

Fluttershy determined that this was the best way to make it up to Big Mac for neglecting him during the build up to her first orgasm. She wanted to make sure he came as well and was willing to let him use her body however he wanted.

"Alright, Big Mac," Fluttershy said, "Now get off the bed."

Obeying her command, Big Mac got off the bed and allowed Fluttershy to get herself into position. She lay on her back, with her head hanging over the bed. Big Mac watched as her long, pink mane hung over the bed and onto the floor. The sight of Fluttershy presenting her face to him got the stallion harder than a cockatrice egg.

Big Mac approached the side of Fluttershy's bed and brought his cock to her face. His dick left sticky precum as he pressed the tip against her chin and cheeks.

Eventually, he found his mark, and Big Mac slid his sizable tool into her eager mouth. Fluttershy was grateful that Rarity had made her swallow the extra large dildo. Nothing less than that would've adequately prepared the pegasus to handle Big Mac's girth.

Once Fluttershy was suckling his stallionhood, Big Mac began pumping into Fluttershy, twerking her face.

Fluttershy's cute little nose was under assault, as Big Mac's big weighty balls repeatedly slapped against her snout with each thrust.

The sound of Big Mac's cock pistoning Fluttershy's mouth made sickening, squelching noises. It sounded like getting a hoof stuck in mud and then trying to pull it out. The wet, sucking sound repeated as Big Mac hammered away at Fluttershy's face hole.

While this was going on, Fluttershy was practicing the nose-breathing exercises Rarity had taught her.

"So, is this what being a cunt feels like?" Fluttershy thought, "It's so warm and wet."

After ten or so thrusts, Big Mac pulled out completely. Fluttershy took this moment to gasp for breath. When she opened her mouth wide to inhale as much oxygen as she could, her mouth drooled a mix of saliva and precum onto her cheeks and nose.

Big Mac's cock was also covered in Fluttershy's drool, which gave it a pristine sheen. After giving Fluttershy a second to breathe, Big Mac reinserted his cock; only this time he went balls-deep down her throat in a single thrust. He didn't hump her face this time; he just held it there and listened to the sound of Fluttershy fighting her gag reflex as she choked on his shaft.

"Oh, it's so tight!" Big Mac said, as he groaned with pleasure, "I love you, Cootershy!"

"I love you, too!" Cootershy said, "Now kiss me!"

Big Mac leaned forward and place his lips on Cootershy. He didn't perform cunnilingus. He simply kissed her like he would kiss a mare. There was no licking. There was no teasing the clit. He just planted his lips on Cootershy and gave a deep, passionate kiss.

Fluttershy gagged and drooled as the stallion's sizable schlong monopolized her mouth.

"Uh!" Big Mac said, breaking the kiss, "I'm cumming!"

"Cum inside!" Cootershy said, "I wanna feel you cum inside me!"

Fluttershy's eyes went wide. Rarity hadn't gone into the specific details of ejaculation. All she told Fluttershy was that, 'a lady always swallows.'

Big Mac pulled partially out so that the tip of his cock rested on the back of Fluttershy's tongue. As he felt his semen shoot from his shaft, Big Mac instinctively thrust forward. This sent Fluttershy's head knocking against the baseboard of her bed. The force of the wooden bed, coupled with the force of Big Mac's wood, caused Fluttershy to snort in surprise.

When she did, cum shot out of her nose and mouth. Once Big Mac had finished cumming down her throat, he pulled out of Fluttershy. She choked and gagged as semen dripped out of her mouth and nose.

Big Mac felt horrible for using her in such a degrading way. Fluttershy sat up in bed and turned to look at Big Mac. She dabbed at the cum on her cheek and rubbed the jizz leaking out of her nose as though it was nothing more than an unsightly booger.

"Fluttershy, are you hurt?" Big Mac asked concerned as Fluttershy rubbed the back of her head.

"I'll be okay," Fluttershy said, "So, was I a good little cunt?" Big Mac smiled and was relieved that Fluttershy was still her gentle, accommodating self.

"You were amazing," Big Mac said, as his spent penis grew more flaccid. He leaned in and hugged Fluttershy as she sniffed her nose, sucking some of the dripping semen back inside.

"Thank you for letting me pretend, Fluttershy," Cootershy said, "Of all the mares I could've been attached to, I'm glad it was you. I love you."

"I love you, too." Fluttershy said, "You gave me courage when I needed it most and helped me."

It seemed like a decent spot to end things, but Cootershy wouldn't be satisfied until Fluttershy lost her cherry.

"We're not done yet!" Cootershy said, "I still need to give my stallion a blowjob!"

Big Mac stared at Fluttershy.

"Are you ready?" Big Mac asked. Fluttershy nodded without saying a word.

Fluttershy lay on her back with her legs spread. Big Mac towered over her. He stared at Fluttershy's cum-stained face and felt himself growing hard again.

Big Mac pressed himself against Cootershy, before sticking his cock inside. The feeling was like nothing Fluttershy had ever experienced. It hurt a little at first, but once she grew accustomed to the new sensation, she started to enjoy it. Sex felt much better than giving a blowjob.

"I can see why Rarity wanted me to wait for you!" Fluttershy said, "This feels too good!"

Cootershy tried to speak, but her voice was muffled by a snatchful of stallion meat.

"Remember what Rarity said," Fluttershy told her cunt, "It's impolite to talk with your mouth full."

Unable to speak, Cootershy decided to enjoy the ride as Big Mac deflowered Fluttershy.

The springs on Fluttershy's bed were working harder than they'd ever had to before. As the couple copulated, the bed bounced and bucked. Her labia leaked, soaking the sheets while Big Mac's pole pounded her hole. Orgasmic sighs and passionate cries rang out as he claimed the prize between her thighs. Big Mac plundered her buried treasure, while Fluttershy lost herself to pleasure. Her sopping slit; content to grip, the cock that spread her lower lips. The bed's frame was shaken to its core as Fluttershy cried out for more.

"I can feel it happening again, Big Mac!" Fluttershy said, "I'm can't take it any more! Cum with me!"

"Eeyup!" Big Mac said, as he thrust harder. The two lovers screamed as they came together. Big Mac blew his load inside Cootershy, filling Fluttershy's cum dumpster to the point of overflowing. Her climax caused clit spit to soak his dick as his pony paste invaded her space.

Big Mac pulled out of her soaking sausage wallet and lay flat on his back, thoroughly drained. His semen leaked out of Fluttershy's well-screwed love tunnel as she rested her head on his chest.

Fluttershy lowered her hoof and stroked at her clit. She didn't do it for pleasure, but in the same way one might pat a dog's head as a sign of a job well done.

"Thank you, Cootershy," Fluttershy said, "You were amazing."

Fluttershy waited for an answer that never came.

"Cootershy?" Fluttershy asked, nervously, "Why don't you say something?"

Cum and her love juices flowed from her marehood, but no sound came out. The deathly silence caused Fluttershy to tear up. Big Mac started to look worried.

"Oh, Celestia!" he thought, "I screwed her so hard, I killed her pussy!"

"Is Cootershy...?" Big Mac said, trailing off. Fluttershy took a minute to compose herself. She then laughed bittersweetly and smiled.

"Cootershy isn't dead," Fluttershy said, "I can still sense Cootershy's presence inside me."

"Then why isn't your vagina talking?" Big Mac asked.

"Because Cootershy doesn't need to talk anymore," Fluttershy said, "Now that I know how to take care of my sexual desires, Cootershy's mission is complete and my marehood can be normal again."

"And that's a good thing," Big Mac said, "Right?" Fluttershy gave a sigh.

"I would've liked to have told Cootershy goodbye," Fluttershy said, wistfully, "I wanted to thank my pussy for helping me."

"I think Cootershy knows how you felt," Big Mac said, "Besides, you'll always have me to talk to."

"Yeah," Fluttershy said happily as she drifted off into a post-coital sleep.

Big Mac lay awake as he listened to the sounds of Fluttershy breathing on his chest. He was just about to fall asleep himself, when he heard a voice talking to him. At first, Big Mac thought it might be Cootershy, but then he realized that it was a different-sounding voice, emanating from a different location. This voice wasn't coming from Fluttershy's vagina, it was coming from Big Mac's... sphincter.

"I know you like screwing mares," Big Mac's ass said, "but would it kill you to let a stallion stuff his schlong inside me every once in a while? I have needs too, you know!"

Big Mac's eyes went wide and he gulped. He knew his week was about to get a whole lot more interesting.