A Brief Window of Opportunity

Wrong. I'd hardly gotten through naming her, and the rope's already out. With a little help from Twilight and Rarity, my arms and legs were bound before I can even ask what's going on.

"Is that really necessary?" I asked, perplexed.

"Sure is, Darlin'. We didn't used to do this, but a human tried running off once, cuz he'd rather stay in Equestria than go home. Things got messy. Lyra still won't shut up about it."

"Oh... well... I wouldn't try anything like that. I'm not stupid."

"Nothin' personal, just can't take any chances."

"It was almost impossible to get Celestia off my back about it," Twilight grumbled, "If it happened again she'd probably banish me from Equestria."

"But I mean... I can't really do anything with my hands..."

Twilight smiled. "Aww, how thoughtful. Don't even worry about that. You won't need to. Just lay back and we'll take care of the rest."

This could be really bad or really great... I can't say I've ever done any bondage before. As I was giving the ropes a tug, to see what kind of mobility I had to play around with, Applejack popped up at the foot of the bed, staring down my semi-hardened dick like it was a snake in the grass. She brought her hooves up to it—

Oh god, a hoof-job? No, no, I didn't agree to this! That sounds very... Oh... Well... Maybe it's not so... Oh. Her hooves were surprisingly soft and warm, despite decades of farm work. With a skill and dexterity that seemed nearly impossible without hands, she worked up and down the shaft. It easily felt as good as hands, maybe even better. When I was finally fully hardened, she took a break from handling— hoof-ling? — my member and slowly climbed on top of me, looking into my eyes. She sat down on my abdomen, her strong, muscular flank pressing gently into my belly, and her soft, silky tail hair just brushing against my penis.

She bent down low over me, and pressed her lips against mine, in what was a very sensual, but closed-mouth, kiss, as she slowly slid her flank along my body, grinding her genitals against me and slowly working her way down to my crotch. I felt her press against the tip of my penis and slowly engulf it; somehow she had managed to get it perfectly aligned with her vagina without any manual assistance. Aside from the ropes, this was definitely some pretty straightforward stuff, like I thought it'd be with her. Though, she's maybe a little better at it than I expected.

She pulled back. What a tease. She adjusted herself so that her marehood would rest on top of my penis and rubbed herself forward and back, sliding her clitoris against the tip of my dick. Part of me wanted to rush to the good part, but this was thoroughly enjoyable, I might have been contented to do this all day. But she wouldn't have, apparently. She moved forward, lined herself up with my cock again, and pushed herself down a little further than the first time, taking in the whole head.

The intense tightness caught me by surprise. "Gah—"

Applejack laughed. "Y'all make the funniest faces when you do this, I swear."

Once again, she rescinded the penetration, drawing away from my crotch, and began bumping and grinding against it once more. That was the part that was most pleasurable to her, I imagine, though she's certainly not a greedy lover. The sensation was quite nice for me as well. The very fine, soft fur on her body added to the experience, I imagine if a human woman had tried to pull off the same motions, my hips would be chafing by now.

Without warning, she suddenly adjusted herself and drove her weight down on my member, taking in the whole length in a tiny fraction of a second. With very rapid, accurate motions, she used her hindlegs to move herself up and down. She brought her muzzle down close to me, changing the angle of penetration slightly. I felt her warm breath on my neck, slowly quickening as she continued to use me for her pleasure. Her eyes were closed , but she was very in-tune with my body, and she was somehow able to take me just to the moment of orgasm without actually getting me to come. As I was just about to feel the sweet release of orgasm, she suddenly stopped her motion altogether. While she waited for me to cool down, she sat back up straight on top of me and took her own hoof to her vagina, pleasuring herself with great skill.

Very, very, slowly, she lifted up off of me, squeezing tightly around my member as she did so. I gasped as her lips passed along the head, but I still wasn't able to come. She went back to the grinding motion she had started with, and I could tell she was starting to get off. She moaned softly as she continued the rubbing.

"Takin' your sweet-flank time, huh, AJ?" Rainbow asked. I hadn't noticed that the others were still in the room, but they were, each of them watching the show with great enthusiasm. I'm not sure if that made it more or less sexually exciting.

"Ah, fiddlesticks, is my time almost up?"

"Don't listen to Rainbow, you've still got plenty of time." Twilight added, examining a clock and scribbling down some notes. Were they timing this? Timing me? Okay, now things are a little different. I've got to prove myself, right? I mean, if I don't last long enough, they migh—

"Ah-ah-ah-ah—" AJ pressed herself down upon me again, taking my cock into herself, and squeezing even tighter than she had previously. I couldn't speak or think as she brought me to completion. She started to laugh when she saw my face contort in ecstasy, but for her own sake, she looked away and kept rubbing herself. Even though I was done, she kept going. And going. And going. Thirty seconds in, and the pleasure was incredible. Sixty seconds, it was starting to hurt. Ninety seconds, I was groaning in painfully intense euphoria, struggling to hold myself together. Finally, she came, moaning loudly and abruptly stopping her perfectly-timed motions to collapse on top of me. The two of us laid there in each-other's embrace, panting heavily.

"That was amazing..." I said, quickly wishing I'd thought of something better. This isn't just my first impression, after all, it's my only impression.

"You weren't too bad yourself, sugarcube." She said, rolling off of me. Her hair was thoroughly disheveled by the whole experience, and she looked quite pleased. I guess I just helped her work off quite a lot of stress.

"So, who next?" Twilight asked, writing down a couple more notes and twirling the quill in the air, waiting for an answer.

"Next?" I thought carefully, remembering my reasons for picking AJ in the first place. I immediately regretted having used the process of elimination to select her, because now I was having a hard time coming to any conclusion other than 'AJ again.' I still didn't feel ready for Pinkie, Rainbow Dash was still a little too up in the air for my taste, and Fluttershy? I may have clopped to her before, but actually having sex with her? She's just so sweet. I don't want to turn her down if she wants it, but I'll need more time to prepare mentally. Rarity it is, then.

"Rarity?"

"Are you asking me, or telling me, darling?"

"Telling you?"

She sighed and shot me a sideways glance. Okay. I know what I did. Fine.

"I'm telling you."

"Oh, really? Well that hardly seems like a way to ask a lady for her affections..."

Oh, wait, are we doing that? "Uh... would you like to join me in... uh..."

I really should have thought this through before I started talking.

"M'lady, woud'st though join me in my chambers and lay with me?"

...Yeah, that was completely wrong. I'm a fucking idiot. Rarity gave me an incredibly sarcastic look, but she seemed to have decided that was the best she was going to get from me, a human, and charitably settled for it. I was not representing my species all that well today.

"I'd love to," she replied, climbing up onto the bed.

"Wait, right now?"

"Well, of course. You just asked me to come to bed with you."

"No, I— I mean, I need a break. I don't even think I can get it up again for another fifteen minutes."

"There's no time for that," Twilight replied, manipulating the clock. "You go back in an hour and thirty minutes, and you've still got five of us to go."

"I'm sorry, but I can't do that! It just won't work."

"Look, the spell to get you here is very hard, it takes months of preparation, and it only gives us a brief window of opportunity. Do you want to have sex with us or not?"

"Well, yeah, but—"

"No buts! Put up or shut up!" My penis felt a bit tingly and odd as her magical aura was cast over it, bathing it in a purple glow. In seconds, it was standing at attention on its own, ready to be inserted. I'd honestly never seen it do anything like that before. My balls itched a bit too; I wasn't sure why, but I could guess. I had just been 'reloaded' for another round. The only downside was that I still felt sore. No relief on that front, and AJ had just gotten done pushing me well past my limits.

"Be gentle..." I asked Rarity as she straddled me.

"A proper lady is always gentle. It's the gentleman's job to ravish her."

To be continued...