“Uhm… I uhm” I stammered nervously. Lotus got off from on top of my body and stepped over to her sister.

Aloe looked to her sister. “I’m sorry about what happened with Ron. I never knew it was him that you had feelings for. If I had known I swear I wouldn’t have done what I did” she apologized to Lotus. Her sister nodded then they both looked back to me with somewhat seductive looks on their faces.

Aloe was on the left and gave her flank a little wiggle towards me. “So what should we do? I’m feeling a little… adventurous today sister” Aloe said, making Lotus blush furiously. I gulped deeply.

This was insane, I just came over to apologize to Lotus and tell her how I felt and now they were going to… do whatever it is they wanted to do with me. “Uhm… Lotus, is this okay with you? I mean… with your sister?” I asked hesitantly, not really knowing what they had in plan for me.

“Well you do like it kinky in bed right?” she asked. I wanted to slap myself in the face. How the hell’d they know too, did they get a special order of next year’s calendar as well.

“Okay that Playmare calendar is a load of crap. I never said that and besides, I don’t like it kinky in bed… I like sleeping in bed” I said with a chuckle.

Lotus raised an eyebrow. “You read Playmare magazines and calendars?” she asked and I felt like an idiot. Playmare was for females not guys.

“Not exactly… Twilight had a copy and I found a picture of myself and… yeah anyway, moving on” I said, trying to switch the subject of me reading a female erotica calendar.

“Ohh, so I see someone’s quite antsy” Aloe said with a giggle. I don’t know if I felt more foolish from bringing up the subject of Playmare or by making her think I was antsy.

“I didn’t mean that” I told her and she giggled again. Lotus was somewhat silent and not really engaging into the conversation.

Aloe licked her lips and I saw her back left leg get a little twitchy. “So tell us… what are you going to do to us? Are you going to lavish our bodies? Stuff us with your manhood? Cum deep inside our needy wet pussies?” Aloe said with a heavy sexual tone in her voice.

Her talking like this gave me a raging boner. “I uhm…” I trailed off as I realized I had no idea what I was supposed to do. I mean I know you’re supposed to stick it in one of the holes but… “Jeeze I wish I had watched more porn as a kid” I muttered, speaking my thoughts.

Lotus raised an eyebrow from the comment. “Why?” she asked curiously, obviously not understanding my deep thought of what I was supposed to do.

“Because I… okay don’t laugh but… I’m still a virgin” I said as I winced, figuring she might giggle. Most of the guys that found out usually laughed at me, calling me a softy or a real gentleman.

“Really?” Lotus asked and I opened an eye. That question was rather unexpected. I nodded hesitantly. “Oh well I uhm…” she trailed off and I gulped but then Aloe took over.

“Oh it’s easy you two. Look I’ll show you how you do it” she said and led Lotus over to me. I was still sitting on the bed not really knowing what I was supposed to do. “Okay now Lotus you get on top of him and Ron… take off your clothes already, that black suit looks ridiculous” she told us, well it was more like an order but in a very gentle tone.

I easily slipped off the black suit but I stopped after I tossed it away. “Uhm… do I have to… I mean do we really have to do this?” I asked hesitantly, figuring that this escalated way out of control so fast that maybe we were pushing things. Aloe smiled then quickly lept up onto the bed.

She proceeded to quickly unzip my jeans and slid my pants down. My erection made a tent out of my rather stretchy boxer briefs. Aloe smiled and Lotus blushed from the sight of my hidden manhood.

“I think your body speaks for itself” Aloe said, “Now take off your clothes”. I obliged, though a bit hesitantly. I had been naked in front of people before but that was usually in a change room at the gym and only a few times had I ever been naked around a pony but never once was it around a female so I was a little shy to say the least.

I slipped off my pants, socks and was about to pull of my shirt when suddenly Aloe stopped me. “No wait… stand over there” she ordered me and I got up off the bed and walked over to where she had directed me.

“Take off your shirt like you would if you were in Playmare” Aloe told me as she watched me contently. Lotus was also watching me with rather lustful eyes. Why did they find this attractive exactly? Was it because I was strong and muscular?

“Hey uhm Aloe… why did you want me to do this again?” I asked, speaking my mind.

Lotus answered for her sister. “Because you are you: strong, loving and gorgeous” she answered. Strong, loving and gorgeous? But I was a different species and… you know what, I’ll just go with it.

I reached my hands down and grabbed the bottom opposite sides of my shirt and began to pull it off, just like Aloe had wanted me to do. I got my shirt off and I let it fall to the ground. I took a deep breath as I saw Aloe slowly slide her hoof down to her exposed nether region and she began to play with herself.

Lotus swallowed deeply as she too let her hoof slide down so she could pleasure herself to the sight of me, albeit more shyly then her sister.

Aloe licked her lips. “Ooh… Ron… do you like what you see?” she asked through a slight whispered moan. I nodded slowly, still a little unsure of what I was supposed to be doing.

“So uhm… what am I supposed to do?” I asked rather curiously. I had to say the sight of the two mares in front of me while they pleasured themselves was quite arousing.

Aloe snickered. “Ron… come over here and take my sister” she told me and both Lotus and I swallowed as we blushed.

I walked over to the bed and stood there. “So uhm… what do I do?” I asked and Aloe giggled.

“You have to take off your underwear first” Aloe snickered. I felt sort of foolish but I wasn’t exactly sure how to do this. I slipped off my boxers and was now completely naked, standing in front of the duo like a fool.

“Uhm… okay so uhm… now what do I do. Do I uhm… just…” I trailed off. Aloe giggled again.

“You have to take that” Aloe said as she pointed to my erection “And put it in my sister” she said and pointed to Lotus’ somewhat moistened lower lips.

I face palmed. I knew that I was supposed to stick in her but I was wondering if there was like a special way to do it. I’ve heard of stuff like doggy style and missionary and all those other good things.

I slowly reached my hands over to Lotus and held her sides. Her cheeks turned a bright pink as she blushed even more. I was so nervous from all this that I stood like that for a few minutes before Aloe grabbed the back of my head and gently pushed my face forwards.

I mean sure I had just made out with Lotus a few minutes ago without a second thought but now we were naked, well she was generally naked all the time but her tail usually concealed that region of her body.

My mind subsided as we both just forgot about what was happening and began to kiss passionately. I felt her open her lips slightly and slip her tongue into my mouth. Our tongues began to wrestle with each other for dominance and I let her take control, figuring she’d know more about this than me.

Her tongue felt pretty good in my mouth as she slithered it around, exploring even the deepest parts of my mouth. Usually when something goes that deep into my mouth I gag but she somehow kept me from gagging.

I felt my manhood constantly twitch in need of attention as we moved around a little every now and then. Finally we broke from the kiss, a string of saliva connecting our parted lips.

“Lotus… I love you” I whispered, a little out of breath. I never knew that it was hard to breathe when making out. I had always just figured you could breathe through your nose.

I looked over to Aloe who was gently caressing her clit with her left hoof. “So uhm… do I just stick it in?” I asked, a little dumbfounded.

“Yes… but slowly” she told me and with that I lined up my tip with her entrance. As I felt my tip touch her folds we both gasped from the shock of sexual contact. As directed, I very slowly began to slide myself into her hole.

Her marehood was already moist from her heavy arousal which made it easier to slide into her. I only had the head of my cock inside of her and it felt absolutely amazing… and hot.

Not hot as in sexy but hot as in it was warm. Not uncomfortably hot but more of an above room temperature feeling, and slick from her wet moisture. Suddenly I felt myself come to a stop as my tip pressed up against what felt like a fleshy wall inside her love tunnel.

I realized that I had barely an inch inside of her. “Okay now I know that ponies are smaller than me but… is that really it?” I asked Aloe, curious to why her sister could only take one inch.

Aloe sighed. “You have to break her” she told me and I raised an eyebrow.

“Break her? What do you mean?” I asked curiously.

“She’s a virgin just like you so you must… pop her cherry, so to speak” she informed me. Pop her cherry? What the hell was popping the cherry?

“Pop her… cherry? Is that some sort of slang?” I asked and Aloe chuckled. Lotus was just about as curious as I was yet had stayed silent for the conversation.

“Her hymen, you have to break it. But try to be gentle. Lotus hold my hoof, this will hurt a little” Aloe said and Lotus held
her sister’s hoof.

“Uhm… okay I’m having second thoughts. I don’t really want to hurt her” I said frantically. Aloe rolled her eyes.

“It generally hurts during a mare’s first time, just push but try to be gentle about it” Aloe told me and I obliged. I began to give a rather gentle push and suddenly I felt the wall break and I slipped past it, Lotus cried out in pain and squeezed her sister’s hoof in a firm grip. I felt my cock get covered in a somewhat thick liquid.

I looked down to see blood seeping from Lotus. “GAH! She’s bleeding!” I exclaimed and Lotus looked down also.

“Don’t worry, it’s supposed to bleed. Hence the term: Pop the cherry” Aloe told us, somewhat easing our sudden shock from the sight of blood. I really wished I had watched more porn as a kid so that this sort of thing wouldn’t have scared me so much.

Lotus winced in pain as I continued to slide into her and I stopped from the sight of her large amount of discomfort. “Do you want me to stop?” I asked. I was only about three inches inside of her.

“Just keep going” Aloe ordered me then leaned over and began to make out with her sister. WAIT A MINUTE! She was making out with her own sister! Wasn’t that wrong? Maybe not considering that she’s having sex with a different species.

I continued to slid, stretching Lotus’ inner walls which clamped around my cock very tightly as I forced myself inside of her. She finally took my entire length and I sort of wished that I could go deeper inside of her but there was just no more to put in her.

We just stayed like that for a few minutes, letting Lotus’ pain subside. It felt incredible to be inside of her but I kind of felt bad for causing her this pain even if it is what happens during the first time.

Aloe broke away from their little kiss. “Okay lover boy, start sliding back and forth inside of her. Give in to the pleasure you both so desire” she told me and I began to slide back ever so slowly. I could feel her inner walls close back up as I left her until only my head was left inside of her.

I began to push back inside of her, feeling her love tunnel stretch around my cock and squeeze it rather tightly, though it was a pleasant feeling. Actually it was almost too pleasant. I felt a small tingly feeling start to build up in my groin. It was different from when I masturbated due to the fact that it was something much softer and wet than my bare hand.

I gave a small groan of pleasure and Aloe looked to me. “Don’t go off yet. You have to satisfy my sister first. Remember that gentlecolts err gentlemen always finish last” she told me. I held back the pleasure that was starting to build in my groin area as I began to slowly and gently thrust inside Lotus’ tight pussy.

Lotus was now experiencing pleasure rather than pain. Well I think she was because she was starting to moan. I continued my slow thrusts, slowing down every so often to make sure I didn’t cum before she did. Aloe smiled as she rubbed her hoof around her clit.

“There, you see? You’re a natural” she told me, or maybe it was Lotus she was speaking to. Lotus’ moans soon became a little bit louder and she began to talk. It hadn’t been that long since I last heard her talk but her voice while she was in pleasure just made me feel warm all over.

“Oh Ron… oh yes… oh buck me… I love you so much” Lotus whispered through several moans. Her vagina had become considerably wetter, partially due to the blood, from when we first started, which lubricated my cock and made it easier for me to thrust.

Lotus began to slide her hips in unison motions with my thrusts, sliding towards me as I thrusted into her and sliding away as I pulled back. Each time I thrusted into her she would take my full length without problem. Christ it felt so good I could barely hold it back.

Soon Lotus’ moans got louder than without warning she simply went haywire. She began to thrust at me without a steady pace and the feeling was just so incredible that I tried to hold back but felt it coming without any barriers whatsoever.

Lotus wrapped her hindlegs around my lower back. She began to scream and suddenly I felt a large amount a wetness leak from her folds as her inner walls clamped around my shaft. I let out a groan and gave one last thrust before letting go, stuffing my entire length into her.

It was like a cataclysmic tidal wave of pleasure that washed over me as I came inside of her, spurting my warm sticky seed into her deepest depths. We both began to cry out in pleasure. I could feel myself twitching inside of her, each twitch would spurt another load of cum inside of her pussy which milked me for every drop, not letting a single bit drip away.

Finally we both came down from our orgasmic high and I gave a few last thrusts, which made squelching sounds, before pulling out of her. Cum dripped from her hole and stained the rather nice bed sheets. Her hole tensed and un-tensed continuously, probably craving the feel of having something inside.

My cock was stained with the mixture of her fem cum, my cum, and a bit of her blood. I gave her a rather sloppy kiss and flopped down beside her but then from out of nowhere Aloe crawled up on top of me.

“Ah-ah-ah, you still have to satisfy me. You owe me one for my tutelage” she told me and I looked over to Lotus.

“Uhm… is it… you know, okay with you?” I asked and she gave me a shrug. I think that meant go for it but I wasn’t sure. I wasn’t exactly horny but I was still hard. Lotus crawled over to our side.

“What can I do?” she asked and Aloe looked to her with a devious smile.

“I know a way where we can all have fun, just follow my lead” she told us. I think I was going to be the meat in this sandwich.

Author's Note

Just a little bit of a spoiler for all you readers, gonna call the second chapter 'The second cumming'.