Caramel and Derpy had been happily dating for five months now, but when a certain ex-husband returns to reclaim his former wife, Caramel contemplates what he should do. During their confrontation, Caramel may have to give up the one thing in life he loves the most, Derpy. Why did Doctor Whooves come back? What are his motives? Will Caramel get to stay with Derpy?