Caramel and Derpy had been happily dating for five months now, but when a certain ex-husband returns to reclaim his former wife, Caramel contemplates what he should do. Why did Doctor Whooves come back? Will Caramel get to stay with Derpy?

Pinkie Pie bought a unicorn, but who cares? Twilight Sparkle cares. Twilight tries her best to stop Pinkie from doing whatever the hoof she is going to do, but why would Pinkie buy a unicorn?

Big Macintosh is finally going to marry Fluttershy, but he doesn't know how he should propose. To figure out how, he asks his three best friends for advice: Caramel, Mr. Cake, and Braeburn. Hilarity ensues. Will any attempts to propose work?

Fluttershy goes to Rainbow Dash for advice when she falls in love with a certain Apple, but the unexpected happens.