We went deeper into the forest than I had anticipated. When I first came here, Pinkie and I had only gone in the forest a few dozen yards. This time, however, we went so far into the forest the trees completely blocked out the sunlight, with the exception of a few rays here and there. Unnatural fog settled in and I was really hoping we wouldn’t get lost. Fluttershy seemed to know where she was going and what she was doing, so I trusted her. She delicately picked up ingredients for her dinner. I tried to make small talk.

“So…uh, you normally come out here?”

“Not usually. I…I just wanted to try out a new recipe is all…Roasted Mushroom soup!” she stated, unevenly.

“Ah. That sounds delicious.” I said. “Say, do you guys ever eat…meat?” I asked, noting how I haven’t seen anypony eat any version of meat. In fact, the only things I had eaten were a few dozen cupcakes and various salads. Fluttershy stopped in her tracks, and looked back to me.

“Meat?”

“Yeah! You know…it comes from animals?”

She began to withdraw a little bit and began to look disgusted. “You mean…like milk?”

“What? How do you not know what meat is? It comes from animals! You know, like you get beef from cows?” She looked even more disgusted and frightened.

“Y-You…wouldn't have to kill animals…to get ‘meat’…would you?” she quietly asked.

“Well…I mean yeah.”

She leapt ten feet into the air and came crashing down. “Ahhh! What kind of pony eats that kind of stuff?! Why would you… kill…an animal, only to eat them…?! It doesn't seem very…nice…”

I thought about it. On Earth, did the animals actually care? Of course they had feelings, emotions…but what did they feel? We always viewed them as a food source…but what did they view us as? We never even began to think about what they thought…and the ways we slaughtered them, beefed them up just so we could be more pleased…

I snapped out of my thought and said “It isn't. It truly isn't nice.” She smiled softly at me. We continued on with our journey…

Sometime Later...

It was becoming dusk, and fast. I remembered that I hadn't eaten anything before Applejack and Rarity had kidnapped me, and I was regretting it. Fluttershy’s stomach rumbled as well. “Ah…Fluttershy. Would you happen to know the way back?” She glanced back at me and smiled. “Of course.” I figured we were done with picking ingredients, because her bag was filled to the brim. “We just need to stop at Zecora’s to grab the last thing.”

Before I could ask who the hay that was, we arrived at a small hut. “Huh, this looks just like Yoda’s hut.” I thought out loud. Luckily Fluttershy didn't hear me, because I didn’t feel like explaining the entirety of Star Wars to her. She knocked gently on the door and a Zebra stepped out. The Zebra saw me, and exchanged words with Fluttershy. The Zebra went inside and came back out with a vial of red fluid. Fluttershy thanked it, and we continued on our way.

“Who was that?”

“Oh, that? That was Zecora. She’s nice…once you get to know her.”

“What did she give you? Some sort of…spice?”

“Uh…yes…that’s what it was. A spice.”

I took Fluttershy’s odd behavior into account but said nothing. I didn’t have the energy to ask her. Zecora was also nice enough to hand us a lantern so we could light our path. As we trotted along, the lantern suddenly became extinguished. “Oh…don’t worry. Just give me a second to fix it.” She said coolly.

I didn’t understand how she wasn’t quaking out of her hooves. I was scared to shit. “Y-you sound calm. How can you do that? If I were you, I’d be screaming. It’s so dark…”

There was a silence, before she finally said “Pinkie Pie taught us a song once…it was to laugh at your fears. She said the only way you could be afraid of things was to be afraid of them.”

“H-huh. I wish I was there.” I said, staring at the foreboding trees. They seemed to be looming closer to me. I began to trot faster. One looked like it was reaching for me. I began to canter. I looked behind me and saw a dreadful creature, reaching towards me, it's claws an inch away from me, and it was about to-

I ran into Fluttershy, knocking her over. “Ah! Oh, Earth, are you alright?” she asked, completely ignoring any injuries she had.

“Yeah…sorry I thought I saw something.” I suddenly smelled something spicy.

I think Fluttershy smelled it too because her eyes widened, and she said “Oh, no.” I closed my eyes and lowered my head. The vial of red spice had cracked and leaked all over the forest floor. “Fluttershy…I’m…I’m sorry. I really am. I didn’t mean to…”

Great. Perhaps the nicest pony in all of Ponyville that has never caused me harm, and I ruin her dinner.

“…I can go back to Zecora’s to get some more, so that way you can make your dinner.” I offered. Fluttershy simply shook her head.

“Ah…if you want to. That would be nice… but…” her voice trailed off. I suddenly began to feel extremely light headed. Fluttershy collapsed, her tongue hanging out of her mouth. Her irises grew to an incredible size. “Ohhhh noooo….the vial…” she said, her voice coming out incredibly slurred.

“Fluttershy…what whas in dat vial?” I said, hearing my own voice become slurred.

“Wasn’t spice…it was…a love potion…. Ever since Rainbow Dash…made fun of me for being virgin…I…I..I kinda really wanted to try it a lot.”

Either my hearing was going or she was pulling her trademark soft voice. What I had gotten out of that sentence was that Fluttershy was still a virgin. I stared at Fluttershy, and she stared back. I felt myself smiling and saw Fluttershy smile in return, her face now a deep velvet red.

Oh man. NOW what will Pinkie think?!

I tried to stop myself, but couldn’t. It was almost as if I was on auto-pilot. I stood over her, and Fluttershy threw her hooves around me. When I entered her, she let out a soft moan “Oh…my…”

“Y-You’re so big…ouch…ouch…something hurts…”

I would have told her that her hymen was most likely “popping”, but I found myself not able to do anything. All I could do was watch, almost as if I was along for the ride. I couldn’t even move harder or slower. I was stuck at a very menial “average” speed. At least I could still feel everything that was happening. Her walls closed in around my erection, and I leaned in for a kiss when I unexpectedly pulled out.

Wh-What the hell?

“Oh, right…I forgot” I said, with a strong monotone. She turned around on her belly and spread her ass. Again, I automatically moved forward.

WHAT?!!? I didn’t even like anal in the human world!!! OH GOD!

While her ass was significantly tighter than her vagina, it still felt dirty. I hunched down over her and began to lick her neck, and I saw her eyes tearing up, her face now a scarlet color. With one, final thrust I filled her ass with my seed.

I then lost my lightheaded feeling and toppled down right on top of her, still inside her. While I didn't like not being in control of my body, I still enjoyed the experience. I flipped her over and kissed her. She accepted it and looked at me with longing eyes. “You can do it again…If you want to.”

And so, I dove back into Fluttershy.

Author's Note

Originally, Fluttershy and Earth were to have made it out of the forest well, and Fluttershy was to have used the vial on Earth. However, seeing as her Element Of Harmony would most likely disallow that, I instead changed it to this, with the text being being a homage to the game.