Twilight's Tough Decisions

It was around five in the morning when Starlight found her way to Rainbow's house using the levitation spell to fly up and the cloud spell to be able to step hoof on it. She headed over to a window and found the two mares she was looking for. Well, one in specific. She made her way through the window and approached the sleeping pegasus. She tapped lightly on her shoulder to try to wake her up. It seemed to move her a little. The unicorn kept tapping until the pegasus turned and opened her eyes in shock. She was caught off guard by Starlight standing over her.

"Whoa, Starlight!?" Rainbow whispered in surprise. "What are you doing here?"

The unicorn tried to talk soft enough to not awake the alicorn but loud enough so Rainbow could still hear. "I need you to come with me to Twilight's castle. We have something extremely important to tell you regarding Twilight."

"Is it something I should be scared of?" Rainbow whispered back, not really knowing what to do.

"Twilight's life is on the line if that answers your question."

Rainbow's eyes went up hearing that. It couldn't be that serious that Twilight's life would be on the line. She had no choice but to go with Starlight. "Alright, let's go."

Rainbow slowly got out of her bed and left Twilight alone. Hopefully, they would be done and she would be able to get back to Twilight before she woke up.

Once they made their way outside, Starlight teleported them to Twilight's room. There were the three ponies plus Rainbow in total. Upon looking in the room, Rainbow spotted Sunset. "Oh, hey, Sunset. I haven't seen you in a while."

"Hello, Rainbow. It's nice to see you again. It has been a while, but we need to focus on Twilight now. The small talk can happen at a different time."

"What's the big issue about?" Rainbow wasn't sure what was going on and needed a little bit of an idea. This question also seemed to start the mood as Sunset levitated over the calendar again.

"I'm going to show you Twilight's calendar. We do not think any other pony wrote the words you are about to see. Please read these words out loud and say what you think these words might mean."

Rainbow looked at the two phrases written down and read. "The start of no more. "The time has come."

Rainbow took some time to process this but wasn't sure if her thoughts were correct. Surely they were wrong. Twilight wouldn't do such things. She took a closer look at where on the calendar these were written. Last Sunday, and this upcoming Sunday. Her face went from scared to horrified. This upcoming Sunday was tomorrow. There was absolutely no way Twilight would be doing it tomorrow.

"Do you get the message?" Starlight nervously asked.

Rainbow was starting to breathe heavily. Tears started forming in her eyes. "Please, no. Twilight wouldn't do that, I know her." Rainbow was almost about to have a meltdown.

Sunset put the calendar back in its place before moving next to Rainbow. She wrapped her hooves around her to try and calm her. "Rainbow, I know this is hard to take in. That's why we're telling you this now. If we didn't tell you this and Twilight does end up doing it, then that would leave everypony feeling defeated. But most importantly, it would leave you devastated."

Rainbow didn't say anything to what Sunset had said. She just took in everything she heard from the mare and continued crying. The three other mares looked at each other with sad expressions. After about a couple of hearing nothing other than Rainbow's heavy crying, Starlight spoke up. "Rainbow, we're planning on helping Twilight. We know you want to help her too. Maybe she forgot about it since your day yesterday. It looked like she was sleeping well when I came to get you. Is she feeling better? Are the tips you received from our friends helping her."

Rainbow took a moment to stop her crying. She needed to try to talk to the ponies that would help her. They needed to help the one mare she would put her life on. Towards the end of her crying, she took a couple of deep breathes. That always seemed to help.

"I think she's okay now. She hasn't been having anymore nightmares recently. Maybe the tips did help. I try my best to be there for her as much as I can. I even gave her the best time of her life yesterday. I just really hope all of this is forgotten and maybe she wouldn't think of doing this."

Sunset continued to hold the sad pony and even laid her head on her shoulder while replying. "Don't worry, Rainbow. We're going to talk to Twilight about it. We want you to come with us."

Rainbow looked up confidently from the floor. "I will be more than happy to try to help the best I can. Twilight mustn't die. She has so much more to live for. I can't let her die."

"Then lets start going over the plan," replied a serious Starlight.

Twilight was peacefully sleeping until she was suddenly in Tartarus again. "Oh no, not again. Please, don't do this to me."

While she noticed that she was alone in a room, she took the time to examine her surroundings. There was a table with straps in the middle, no doors, and a rack with a bunch of different objects on it. There were axes, swords, and blades. The others included things like floggers, whips, blindfolds, gags, and collars. She almost felt disgusted looking at these objects. She then remembered the thought about what she heard from the ponies talking. They wanted to break her physically by torturing her and mentally by sexual standards.

She started to breathe heavily. There was no way to escape. These ponies wouldn't have any mercy on her. She had made them mad by not doing what they told her to do. There was only one way this could end, horribly.

There was a sudden noise that caught her attention and made her turn around. She saw the four ponies that were always in her nightmares, always following her. They were all in front of her and staring her down. The alicorn tried to back up, but she was soon backed against a wall with nowhere else to turn. The four ponies approached her at a pretty slow pace, all grinning evilly as they did.

"Please, why am I here again? I thought we moved on. I thought everything would go back to normal," the scared mare nervously spoke.

The devilish ponies were now close enough to be able to touch and grab a hold of her. Two of them went to either side of her and grabbed her roughly. She was dragged with ease over to the table with straps. The alicorn tried to wiggle herself free, but to no avail.

"Please, don't hurt me. I just want to live a happy life. Just let me go. I'm begging you," the alicorn softly spoke as she started to cry. She soon gave up on her efforts to escape. There was no point in trying. Where would she even go after she got out of the two pair of grips?

As she was continued to be dragged, a pony spoke with no concern. "Hear us out, Twilight. You're going to enjoy this moment. You just got to give us a chance."

"What are you going to do to me?" Twilight had a pretty good idea of what was going to happen to her, but she wanted to just make sure so that she could prepare.

"We're going to break you. I also take back what I said earlier about you liking this. The physical part of your breakage comes first. That's the part you might not like. However, I'm sure you'll enjoy the second half of your breakage, the part where we will break you mentally. It's going to be fun for all of us, as you can see from the rack full of different types of equipment."

There was now silence after the pony finished talking. Twilight was placed on the table and strapped down with each hoof spread to each corner. She didn't even try to fight it. She just silently cried to herself as this was all happening.

At one moment after being strapped down, the alicorn opened her eyes and saw a glimmer of hope. She saw one of the devilish ponies have a look of concern when he was looking at her. The look that was on his face almost looked like he felt heartbroken for her. It looked like he didn't want to do anything to her.

"All right, lets get this show on the road," said one of the ponies who strapped her in.

All of the ponies went to the rack to grab an object that would be used to torture the poor mare. All, but one. The look of concern on the one pony's face was now noticeable to everypony in the room if it wasn't before. He was soon snapped out of his thoughts when the lead pony spoke harshly to him. "Hey, you! Go grab something, now!"

The pony took off towards the rack, giving another look of concern to Twilight as he did so. The alicorn mare didn't know what was happening. Was he truly feeling sorry for her? Did he change? Is he regretting hurting her? Did he start to have feelings for her?

She saw the concerned pony grab a sword off the rack. Twilight wanted to shrink into her body. She was really going to have a hard time right now. All of a sudden, Twilight felt like her heart stopped. The moment the lead pony started talking, she knew that it was time.

"Who wants to go first?"

Two other ponies raised their hoof in anticipation. They were both eager to send harm's way to the helpless pony. "All right, you can go first," he said as he pointed to one of them. "You can go next." He pointed to the other pony.

The first pony stepped up first. His choice of weapon was an axe by the looks of it. Twilight shut her eyes as she got ready for the painful blow to her body. She started to whimper quietly. Her whimper soon led to a scream in the worst pain she'd ever felt. "AHHHHH!"

She opened her teary eyes a few seconds later to see that blood was all over the place. Blood was also coming out of her right forehoof. She could see that her hoof was chopped into and detached from her body. Twilight was about to pass out by the look of it.

The lead pony used his magic to slowly heal Twilight's hoof. That didn't do much to help the pain though. She could see her hoof healing, but the pain was still as bad as ever. Twilight didn't get to rest too much before she heard the hoof steps of the second pony coming up. She saw him raise his axe and didn't even get time to close her eyes and prepare before the axe swung down and chopped her entire right shoulder.

"AHHHHHHHH!"

Twilight didn't even want to look. She couldn't bare to stand the visual pain of the last one. Magic was healing her arm again after the cut. At the same time, the third pony stepped up, which happened to be the lead pony himself. He calmly talked to the mare, but that would do nothing to calm her down. "Oh my, you poor thing. I almost feel bad for doing this." Twilight's ears perked up. Did he say that he was starting to feel bad for hurting her?

"Blood is getting everywhere. I'm not in the mood to clean all of this up." The mare's ears went back down. Of course he wasn't talking about him feeling sad about hurting her. He was just teasing her.

The devilish pony gave a nightmarish smirk as he lifted up a chef knife. For Twilight, this scared her the most. The tip of the knife was placed on the bottom of her right hind hoof. It suddenly was forced down with all of the pony's might. Twilight let out a scream again. The knife went through her hoof and came out the other side. The devilish pony kept the knife there and began slicing up until he reached her knee. The screaming was happening constantly during the whole session.

The knife was pulled out and put back on the rack, along with the other two axes. The three ponies now looked at the one pony who didn't have his chance yet. He looked terrified at this act. Sure, he was a part of the devilish group, but things started to change on him. He never did get the answer. Why was it always her? Why must harsh things be done to this one poor mare? Sure, he was told that her life was meaningless, but did that really mean she deserved this kind of treatment?

The leader shot him a stern glare right into his eyes and stomped his hoof twice. This alerted the concerned pony and got him to move forward with his sword. He quickly stepped up on the side of Twilight and quickly sliced her hoof. He just wanted to get this over with. He didn't want to see anymore of this pain on the poor mare.

They were all met with another agonizing scream from the helpless pony. The leader healed up her hoof again and put the sword back. Twilight was still on the table, panting heavily. Tears were all over her face. Blood was everywhere around the room. That was only the physical torture, though. Now comes the time for the most fun part, the sexual torture. The torture that would break her mentally, as if the physical torture wasn't enough.

Two ponies came to undo the straps that held Twilight down. They flipped her onto her stomach with ease since the mare didn't fight back. Her hooves were strapped back in place again. The four ponies circled around Twilight with one each being at the sides, behind, and the lead pony in front.

The pony in front of Twilight moved his lips close to Twilight's ear to whisper what was going to happen to her. "Don't you worry your little head one bit. It's going to be the best thing you've ever experienced in your life. It's going to feel so good that you're not going to want to go back. But before we begin the fun, I have something to show you. You might recognize this."

He backed up a little and made something appear using his magic. He levitated it so that it was right in front of Twilight's eyes. She looked down on it and her eyes went wide. It was a version of Twilight's calendar. It looked exactly the same as the one in her room. She saw the two phrases she wrote on two of the Sundays. The flashbacks she had reminded her that she was actually planning on suicide. She had completely forgotten about that ever since a few days after her nightmares were gone and she was having the time of her life with her new marefriend.

"Why are you showing me this?" Twilight softly asked.

"You wrote this down. You wrote the start of no more on the Sunday of this week. You also wrote the time has come on the Sunday of next week."

The calendar disappeared as he leaned on the table with his eyes looking directly into the alicorn's own eyes, just a few inches away. "You are the most responsible mare in Equestria. You will follow through with what you wrote down, right?"

The alicorn just stared, not knowing what to say. Was she actually going to kill herself, to end her life for good? How would her friends feel? More importantly, how would Rainbow Dash feel?

"No matter," the mare was snapped out of her thoughts as the pony continued to speak. "I will show you a good time. We will all show you the best time of your life. You don't need your little Dashie to show you a good time. Don't ask how we know you're with Rainbow Dash. You don't need to know that. You just need to know the amazing feeling of feeling good. You can trust us. We will make you feel safe. We will care for you. Just don't resist and everything will work out just perfectly."

Just as he was finishing up his talk, he used his magic to make four black permanent sharpies. Each of the four ponies took a hold of one and undid the cap. Twilight had no idea what was going on. What were they going to do with sharpies? But it turned out that she didn't need to think long since the pony in front of her started talking again.

"You may be wondering what we are going to do with these sharpies. We are going to degrade you. We are going to write very degrading things all over your body. You are going to enjoy every second of these sharpies writing on your skin. We are going to turn you into our pet. You will become our plaything. Sadly, this is only temporally, as this is only a nightmare. You could make this last forever. All you have to do when we let you go back, is to kill yourself. That's all you have to do. Do that, then you can stay here with us. The five of us will have the greatest time. We will make you feel so good. How does that sound?"

Twilight was too shocked to say anything. They were going to use her, write on her, and turn her into their pet? That was just not right.

"No answer? I guess we shall just begin. Go ahead boys, start writing."

After some writing started to happen, the leader just couldn't help but want to show the mare the amazing art at the end. "Don't you worry, Twilight Sparkle. When we're done, we'll show you all the new improvements we've made to your body. It will just blow you away. You're body will look so hot that none of us will be able to resist touching you first."

Twilight just let out a whimper. Degrading words were being drawn on her body. She would be below them, as if she wasn't already below them before. Her body would not only be different shades of purple, but a lot of black added to it. She would look like a mess at the end of this. She didn't want to say it, but she would also look like a slut too.

The alicorn just laid there, motionless. She didn't bother moving as it would just irritated them and she didn't want that. She could feel her whole body being written on. They started with her hooves, then moved onto her back, wings, neck, then the lead pony began writing on her face. The sharpie moved to her forehead, cheeks, chin, then around her mouth.

After they were out of room to work with, The unicorns undid the straps and turned her back over so that she was lying on her back. The straps were once again strapped tightly around Twilight's hooves. They continued to now write on the front half of her body.

After they took a few minutes to finish up, they all stood back and admired their work. Twilight noticed that the pony that was concerned before, didn't look that concerned right now. Maybe he just didn't want to hurt her. Maybe he only wanted to give her sexual pleasure, not pure pain.

"This looks so god damn hot. Man, you guys really made art on her," said the enthusiastic leader.

The four ponies all smirked at their piece of art. Twilight still laid there motionless, letting her body get examined by her enemies. She felt hopeless, helpless, and useless. She didn't care about anything at this point. Her body was theirs to enjoy. Twilight finally gave up.

"I feel a little bit bad that we are keep this to ourselves. I want the sweet pony to get a look at the piece of art too."

The lead pony used magic to move over a full size pony mirror that was about six foot tall and three foot wide and placed it beside Twilight. Once that was set in place, he used his magic to lift the table and stand it right in front of the mirror, letting Twilight see all of the degrading words on her body. She started on her hind legs. She saw words like slut, whore, cock lover, cum addict, crazy slut, anal slut, sloppy mare, and stupid cunt. They kept going up until she reached her face. She then saw words like I love cock, grateful slut, and cum lover. She also noticed that the words w, h, r, and e, were written between her lips. She soon found out that her mouth was supposed to resemble the o.

After taking the extra time to look herself over again, she couldn't help but feel a bit aroused by the feeling. She couldn't help herself. It was just too much. She actually started to love the feeling, which Twilight hated and didn't want to admit. Her arousal did not go unnoticed and was now being spoken of.

"Look at that. Our little slut is getting horny by the piece of art. Looks like we're not the only ones."

They all chuckled together. Their precious pet was getting horny by looking at herself with a bunch of words that degraded her.

The table was set back down and the mirror was pushed away. The straps were undone and Twilight got lifted off from the table and set on the floor. All four devilish ponies came up to her after she was set down and surrounded her. They all stood up on their hindlegs which entirely exposed their front bodies. What Twilight saw next completely changed her thoughts about wanting to be here or not. Four massive black horse cocks were near inches away from her face, all fully erect and throbbing. They all looked to be at least two feet long and three inches in diameter. Their balls looked about five inches in diameter. That must mean she was going to be in for a rough one.

She couldn't help but lick her lips a little. Was she actually going to be the slut they wanted her to be? Was she really going to service their cocks right then and now?

Smirking, the lead pony continued. "Alright pet, why don't you show us what you got? If you are able to please all of us, we will reward you with greater pleasure. It will make you want to stay here for eternity and service us. We would be more than glad to keep you as our pet and slave."

Twilight submitted and dove into the first cock that was right in front of her face. She knew she was a lesbian and had Rainbow Dash as a marefriend, but she didn't care anymore. Upon inserting the first few inches into her mouth, she could already taste the precum coming off of it. It tasted so pleasant, so lovely, and definitely addicting. What Twilight didn't know however, was that each of their cum acted like an aphrodisiac. This would keep the party going for as long as they wanted and Twilight would be able to do nothing but keep drinking it.

The mare started bobbing her head up and down the shaft, taking in a little bit more when coming on the way down. After about a minute of constant sucking, her throat expanded to the point where she got about half of it down her throat. She hoped to be able to take it all in her throat at some point. She wanted to go as far down as she could before moving onto the next cock. She shoved the piece of meat down her throat until it was about a little over half way down. Just as she was doing this, she heard heavy breathing from above her. The pony was clearly enjoying this lovely moment of what Twilight was doing to his addicting cock.

Twilight kept gagging until she couldn't hold it anymore and came up for air. There was so much spit around her mouth and on the cock. She put her right hoof up to grab a hold of it and started stroking it all the way down and back up, making sure to rub the spit everywhere on her tasty love stick.

Twilight moved onto another cock to her left. She used some of the remaining spit in her mouth and spat all over the nice fleshy meat. After it was coated in what Twilight thought was enough, she took it straight down. She didn't feel like working her way slowly.

As she was getting into it, her tongue tasted the familiar liquid. It was the precum of the second pony she was servicing. It tasted a little bit different, almost like it was sweeter. Twilight came to enjoy the taste as she tried to suck up even more of her treat. She sucked so hard at one point that the pony above her gave a loud moan. The pleasure he was receiving was definitely and intense one. He stroked the pet's mane as she continued to bob her head.

Twilight decided that now would be a good time to move onto the next one in line. She didn't want to keep them waiting for too long. They each needed to have a chance at getting the wonderful feeling of their slave's mouth.

She shoved her head all the way down until she reached the point she had gotten to on the previous cock. She was determined to go even further. With an extra effort to try and accomplish that, she did just that. It was about three inches extra, but to her and the stallion, that was a lot. She was distracted by the huge horse cock shoved down her throat, that she didn't even notice the two stallions above her whispering to each other.

She lifted herself back up and just as she was about to move on again, she was stopped. She was lifted up by the two stallions she had sucked off. They both grabbed her by the forehooves and moved her over to the table. They put her back on it but didn't do the straps. The two ponies used their magic to decrease the size of the table until her hind legs and head were hanging off from both sides of the table. They also removed the four straps from each corner of the table.

After the table was set in place for good use, they used their magic again to make a huge link of chain come up from the ground. Twilight saw this and was impressed that they could just bring anything from anywhere.

Attached to the chain was a cuff that would be big enough for secure Twilight's hoof in it. Her right hind hoof was moved in front of her head and a little over to the right. It was strongly secured in the thick piece of the metal. The same shortly happened to her left hind hoof as it was strongly secured by the second piece of metal. Both of Twilight's hind hooves were now above her head and over each side. This still left her head hanging over the table but now because of her new addition, both of her other holes were now completely exposed.

One of the ponies who didn't yet get his cock sucked, moved to face in front of Twilight. He lifted himself on his hindlegs and placed his cock right on her face. Twilight breathed in the strong musky scent through her mouth and nose. Her own body started to take over as her mind was getting filled with the addictive scent. The mare stuck her tongue out to try to taste it. The stallion wanted a little more than for her to just taste it. He shoved as much as he could into her mouth without going down her throat. He wanted to make sure his cock was nice and wet before giving her throat the pounding of its life.

As the two ponies were minding their business, the two other magic-using ponies created even more chains. They made just two cuffs alone that attached to both sides of the table. Twilight's right forehoof was moved down onto the table and was locked firmly in place, just like her hind hooves. The same was soon done for her left. All of the mare's hooves were now locked in place. Her hind legs being where they were prevented them from being in the way and closing her other two holes, giving the stallions complete access to her sex holes. Her forehooves being where they were prevented her from doing anything with them and left them useless.

"Okay, you can go ahead and start having fun with her holes. I'm going to go to the rack and find some things to enhance our slave," one of the magic using ponies said to the other. The pony left the other to start pounding away while he went in search for items to use. Along the rack were blindfolds, collars, gags, more chains, and a full bottle of liquid with pure aphrodisiac. He didn't need to think twice to know which ones to pick. He picked up the blindfold, collar, and the bottle, before going back to the group.

There was still another stallion left who didn't have a chance to get his cock sucked. He quickly stepped to the side of the mare's face to await his turn after the stallion currently using her. He would get prepared in the meantime. He slid his cock under the stallion's who was currently plowing her mouth. He collected as much spit as he could running down her face so he could get ready to start his turn of using her mouth. He also shoved his musky scent right into their slave's nose. The mare noticed immediately and started getting even more aroused. She started to squirm on the table until the stallion pulled out of her.

Twilight needed more cock and quickly spoke up as soon at the warm meat left her mouth. "Please, fuck my throat. I can't wait any longer. I need your cock to go down my throat. I want to train to be able to take the entirety of all of your cocks. Please make me your toy, your sex object. I don't want to go back anymore. I want to stay here with you four so I can get roughly pounded by your huge horse cocks."

The stallion coming back with the two items put on a smirk upon hearing those words. He got up to the mare and put the blindfold around her eyes, making her lose her sight completely. Twilight not being able to see made her even more horny. She didn't need her eyes after all. The only three things she needed to provide to the stallions were her three warm holes that were perfectly fit for cock.

The collar was the next thing to be attached. It fitted the mare perfectly with the words ",Tartarus Slut," written on it. Twilight seemed to like the collar around her neck since there was a smile that appeared on her face.

After the blindfold and collar were set in place, the pony started to talk again to prepare Twilight for the fun. "I can see that you're a needy little mare. You're such a bad girl. We'll give you what you want because we know that what you have right now isn't enough. I have a bottle of liquid levitated over your face right now. I'm not going to tell you what's in the liquid because that would just ruin the surprise. I want you to drink all of it. If you can do that, then this is going to be a lot more fun for you and for us. Do you understand?"

Twilight didn't need to be told twice before replying back, "yes master."

This took all four ponies by surprise. They each smirked right after. They have completely got what they wanted. "I see you're a quick learner. That's what good girls do. Anyways, I'm going to pour the bottle in your mouth right now. Open up, slut."

Twilight opened her mouth all the way to prepare drinking whatever they gave her. The bottle was tilted to start the flow of liquid. The alicorn drank all of it up, not wasting a single drop. She kept drinking until every drop of liquid went right into her stomach. Once it was all gone, she felt her mane being stroked. She also received a sweet kiss on the cheek after that.

"Okay, let's wait a little while to let the substance take effect. This slut is going to be screaming for us in about two minutes."

Twilight didn't really feel the effect of the liquid after she drank it, but when around two or three minutes had passed, she started squirming. Her pussy was getting hot. She was starting to sweat. Her tongue was craving for cock. She felt like she was too horny and started to beg as the ponies watched her in amusement.

"Oh my goodness. What was that? I-I need you guys. Please, help me. My body is getting hot. I need cum to cool off. Please feed me your cum. I need to be pounded senselessly. I need a cock shoved down my throat. I need all three of my holes filled at the same time. There needs to be a huge amount of cum inside each of my holes. Please fuck me so hard that I won't be able to move by the end of this. Please use all of my holes for your own pleasure. I want to serve you now. I'll do whatever you want me to do in order to stay your sex slut. Please keep me as your slave. I'll do anything at anytime you want. Please, just use my body that should only be used to service you four masters."

Smirking, all four ponies started again. The real fun could now begin. One pony went to take her pussy while the other three moved to her face. The pony who didn't yet have a turn, started to throat fuck the slutty mare. They all took turns until her entire face was covered in a mix of precum and spit. While the ponies were waiting for their turn, they kept slapping the mare's slutty face with their wet cock. She had to admit, it was a great feeling. She couldn't get enough of the musky flavor. It flooded her entire mind and now the only thing she could think of was cock and cum.

Twilight just relaxed and enjoyed the feeling of letting her masters use her body. The pony abusing her pussy pulled out and moved over to her face and exchanged positions with a different pony. However, this pony chose to pound her ass. He wanted to see how well the tightest hole would work around his two feet cock.

He slowly started to thrust in to get the feeling going. He was about five inches in before the slut was sick of not getting fucked roughly at the moment and spat out the cock she was currently sucking to give him some words of encouragement, as she likes to think of it.

"Hurry up! What are you waiting for!? Pound my little slutty asshole! All of my holes are from a slut's body! She can take whatever pounding you can give! Nothing is too much for this whore!"

This seemed to work up the pony using her asshole. He got rid of everything he thought of before and started going haywire on the slut's asshole. Even the pony who's cock got spat out was getting affected by those words and started to shove his cock deeper into throat.

Twilight was enjoying every second of her pounding. Her moaning was so loud that it covered up the heavy breathing of the stallions combined. If this is what it felt like to serve her masters, then she didn't want to go back to Equestria. She wanted to stay here with them, to be used, to be nothing more than a slut and a whore, a worthless sex object that have no other meaning other than to please her masters in whatever way they desired.

The words Twilight said were now giving the lead pony an idea in mind. She just said that she could take whatever they can give her and that nothing is too much for her. It's time to test if what she just said is true. If that's the case, she's literally the best slut that ever existed.

"Alright fellas, this whore says she can take anything. Why don't we test and see if that theory is true or not?"

The three other ponies got excited at that. However, Twilight seemed to be the most excited out of all of them. Maybe this was the time she was really going to feel it. She was going to get abused by four cocks and she was going to love it.

The leader spawned in an ordinary bed with his magic. He undid the blindfold and all of chains holding Twilight and lifted her over onto the bed. He then whispered his plan to his crew and they gave a smirk. Twilight watched them start to come towards her and thought it would be fun to give them a little tease.

The alicorn spread her legs and showed them her wet pussy, giving them all a seductive look during the whole teasing session. She rubbed a hoof over her pussy and started to thrust inside. She softly moaned and bit her bottom lip as she hoofed herself at the feeling. It then came time that they were all around her with their cocks still hard and wet.

Twilight was then grabbed by a pony and lifted up as he laid down. Twilight was then set with her back on top of the pony's front. The stallion holding Twilight positioned is cock to line up with her asshole. Once he was able to align it, he thrusted in deep and hard. After hearing her screams of joy, he started to pound her ass.

Another pony came on top of her and positioned his cock with her pussy. He pounded away at her pussy the same time as the other stallion pounded at her ass. Twilight was in a state of heaven with being double penetrated by two fat horse cocks.

Her head was hanging over the bed as the remaining two stallions came up to her. As soon as she opened her mouth to try to suck a cock, they were both forced into her wet mouth. Her breathing was becoming more difficult, but that didn't matter in the slut's mind. Her four masters had priority first before her. She was just a stupid slutty whore after all who's only use was to be used for their own pleasure.

Constant precum was coming out from all four horse cocks. All three of her holes started to fill with more aphrodisiac. This made Twilight's mind go numb. Her entire body felt limp as she let her own body go.

Each pony was still thrusting away at the helpless mare. They were each coming closer and closer to the edge. That was when one of the ponies face fucking the mare leaned over and whispered to the other stallion's ear. The response he got was both of his ears perking up and a devilish smirk. He also purposely said out loud his response. "I guarantee this slut would more than love that idea."

This made the other two stallions and Twilight look up at the pony who said it. They didn't know what was going to happen. The ponies just stared at each other while still pounding away.

It was almost about time for each stallion to release their huge loads. The two ponies face fucking the mare nodded at each and both combined their magic to spawn in a bathtub that could easily fit about two ponies inside.

The two ponies stopped pounding away at the sight of the bathtub and grinned widely. They both had a feeling that they knew what was going on. He and the pony that was pounding the mare's ass got up and set hoof back on the ground. All four ponies then started to walk towards the bathtub with the leader picking up their slut and carrying her on his back.

Twilight loved the feeling of being carried by such a dominant pony on his back. She wrapped her hooves around his front while leaning her head close to his ear and whispering, "is it time for my reward? Have I been a good girl for you?"

Still looking forward, the strong stallion whispered back. "You have been a lovely girl for us. We will put you in this bathtub and fill it up with your reward. Consider it the best gift of your life."

Twilight just smiled and snuggled against his neck while she was carried to the bathtub and was slowly levitated off the back of the pony and put inside. The alicorn pony laid as comfortably as she could and proceeded to spread her hind legs. Her whole body was now completely exposed as she rubbed her clit while giving a seductive look.

The stallions all surrounded the tub and stroked their cocks until they reached orgasm. They each aimed their cock so that their load would land inside the bathtub and give the alicorn a literal cum bath. The extra words of encouragement from the mare seemed to help accomplish that. "Please fill the bathtub all the way. I'm filthy and need to be cleaned."

That was then the moment that all four stallions unleashed their loads into the bathtub and seemed to fill it rather quickly. Twilight tried to catch whatever she could with her mouth before swallowing it all and opening it back up to repeat the process.

Cum was sprayed all over the slutty alicorn and the bathtub was almost filled all the way to the top. The orgasms of the stallions were starting to die down after about thirty seconds of constant cumming. The bathtub was now filled all the way to the top and looked like it was about two inches from overflowing. Their pet was submerged all the way in except for her head sticking out that was covered in cum.

The leader had an idea as he lifted the mare out with his magic and held the pony above the cum bath with a smirk. "Let's see how far this mare can go," he said before taking four bondage straps and strapping the mare's hindlegs together with one. He took another and strapped her forehooves together behind her back. The third one was to connect her forehooves and her hind hooves together. The last one was to wrap around her neck and overlap the other straps, locking them together. Twilight was now hogtied and felt it harder to breathe because of the strap constricting her throat.

"Think you can take on breath play with your head submerged in the cum bath?"

"I'm a true slut. I will keep my head down in the cum bath until you let me up for air. I am the best slut ever."

The four stallions smirked at how far they have taken their pet. She was completely broken and had a feeling that she would stay with them to service them more.

The purple alicorn's entire body was now submerged into the bathtub for about a minute before she was pulled back up for air. After the stallion let the mare take a few breaths, he shoved her back down. It repeated for a total of five times, each time getting a little longer.

After she managed to handle the cum bath challenge, she was unstrapped and fed a lot of cum from the bath. She later got horny and got fucked senseless again and sprayed.

This lasted for about a few hours until they had enough and Twilight was a broken mess that laid on the ground, not being able to move. "I hope you enjoyed that, you filthy cumslut," one of the ponies said.

It was about time to let Twilight go back into her real world and out of this nightmare, or maybe the best dream she's ever had. The lead pony looked over to his crew before giving Twilight a decision.

"All right slut, you have two choices to choose from when we let you go. You can either stay in Equestria with your friends and we will stop all of your nightmares. But if you choose that, then you won't have the amazing experience like we just had, ever again."

Twilight was horrified. She didn't want to leave these ponies. She wanted to stay with them.

"Or, you can choose to stay with us. Of course, we can't make you stay with us in your dreams forever, but you can choose to stay with us. When we let you go, all you have to do is find a way to kill yourself. I know it sounds harsh and ridiculous, but if you can do that, then you can stay here for eternity. We will treat you like a princess down here, and you will love every second of it. Those are your two choices you need to make. If you want to take the first choice, then don't kill yourself. If you kill yourself by tomorrow night, then you have chosen the second choice. Tomorrow night is the deadline for a decision. If you don't have your mind made up by then, then we will assume you have chosen the first choice and not bother you ever again. Is all of that clear?"

The mare looked up and nodded slowly before giving out a sigh.

She wanted to take the second choice since it was great pleasure down here, but could she really leave her friends? Would she be selfish?

The unicorns then lit their magic which awoke Twilight from the dream. She saw that she was alone in the bed and that it was already three in the afternoon. She really did spend a lot of time in her dream. She would also have to use this remaining time to think about what choice to make. She got up to find something to eat and to think more.

A few hours had passed and she still hadn't seen Rainbow Dash yet. Why isn't Rainbow back yet? Did she leave me? Does she not want to be with me anymore?

Twilight couldn't make her choice. She wanted to stay in Equestria with her friends. Her friend's showed her that she was worth something. Rainbow was the main one in particular. Twilight also wanted to be the four stallion's slut. It was the hardest choice she would ever have. She gave up thinking about it today as she was tired. She could always make it tomorrow.

The alicorn drifted back to sleep again, which was another quiet and peaceful sleep.