Follyamory

The wait for Cadance to return with Shining couldn’t have been more awkward. It shouldn’t have taken very long since it was a teleport, but Cadance probably took longer to give Luna time to fume. The whole time, her guards looked her up and down, shivering. They’d gone from afraid to have a boner in front of her to outright stroking it as they looked at her in anticipation.

“Um, Princess?” Thrust almost whispered. “You know… despite what Princess Cadance said, you really are a lot hotter than Celestia.”

“Obviously,” Luna growled in return, and he shrank back slightly. “But thank you I suppose.”

“No need to flirt with her dumbass,” Spear said to Thrust. “She’s ours whether she wants it or not already. Probably more fun if she doesn't want it, so don't try to make her comfortable.”

Luna gritted her teeth.

“I can’t believe what she was going to do,” Spear added a few minutes later as if Luna wasn’t there. “... can’t wait for what we’re gonna do.”

“Seriously, what a bitch,” nodded Thrust, his earlier anger having melted a bit into dreamy anticipation. “But damn, I’m so glad she tried now. Gonna fuck her weekly at the very least from now on.”

“Maybe we can get some ranks out of this,” Spear grinned. “But holy fuck, I’ve dreamed of raping this tease for so long, I can’t believe this is happening!”

“I know, right?” chuckled Thrust. “I don’t even care that my bitch wife left me anymore!”

Luna looked away so they wouldn’t see her tears, trying once again to dry them off. She had to make it look real when Cadance and Shining got back, or else.

Cadance appeared with Shining in a flash, and at least the guards stopped their locker room talk. Luna took a deep breath, then turned to Shining.

“So um,” Shining asked Luna, eyes wide. “Did you really agree to…”

“You are here? Very well,” Luna said, swallowing hard and not dignifying his question with a direct response. “We shall commence with the activity. I am ordering you three stallions to sate my desires during my season. Thus, you have no need to feel disgrace in regards to your families. Furthermore, I exempt those present from the legal consequences that, in normal circumstances, would result from performing such actions upon my orifices.” She took another deep breath and turned to the two guards. “Since Prince Shining has ‘called’ my vagina, which of you desires your princess’s anal cavity, and which her muzzle?”

“Y-you seriously are,” Shining looked truly stunned, and Luna realized too late that her trying to get it over with gave the impression that she wanted it even more. “I’m finally gonna lose my consenting virginity… to Princes Luna!”

“Virginity?” Luna stared at him. “You’re married to the biggest sperm-guzzler in Equestria. Your virginity is long dead.”

“Uh, I mean…” stammered Shining. “Right… I meant um… feel a virgin hole for the first time… yeah… cause clearly I’m not a loser whose wife won’t even fuck him.”

The guards were rubbing their hooves together and licking their lips like foals waiting for fresh apple pie. She hoped at least that their disgraceful hormone-addled brains wouldn’t forget that she was under duress.

Their silence gave Luna time to think, more than she wanted. Was she actually going to do this? Was she going to break her vow made so long ago? She tightened her face, holding in the tears of her humiliation.

“Well she said I get first choice, so anal cavity for me!” Spear finally stammered, predictably given that he was married to another male.

“Muzzle is... fine!” stammered Thrust right after. “Even if Prince Shining gets her pussy now though, I definitely want a go at it later. I can have it later, right?”

“O-of course,” Luna stammered as he leered at her, knowing how she was forced to answer around Shining. “You may make use of my vaginal passage for your pleasure as often as you wish, so long as it is in private and you tell no one.”

“I’m definitely fine with getting the Moon pie first,” joked Shining, near hyper-ventilating. He was shivering almost too hard to stand up, as if even more excited than the guards were.

Luna took another deep breath, resolving herself. She supposed this was her own fault. Getting off on the misery of her subjects was unjust and tyrannical, so perhaps this nightmare was what she deserved. Then again, she supposed if it wasn't for her desire to prove herself to her sister, she'd be far more tyrannical; she was starting to think maybe that had been the way to go.

Shining pinched himself as if to ensure that this wasn't just Luna non-literally fucking with him in his dreams. He walked up to Luna, close enough that she could feel his breath on her muzzle and hear his heart thumping. It beat every bit as hard as her own, if for lust instead of abject horror. She got the impression that he wanted a kiss, but Luna was still too stiff and nervous to lean into one.

“I believe it to be customary to perform ‘dirty talk’ during such acts.,” Luna remained official. If she would be forced into this, even having to pretend to like it, she would at least remain as regal as she could. “Thus, I also give all here leave to speak to me in as degrading a manner as you desire during the act.”

“And future acts?” asked Spear. They were really digging it in.

“I-indeed,” said Luna. “I hereby agree to be a… play thing for your sinful desires. I… will assign you as my bedroom guards to ensure you have easy access.” Otherwise it’d be too suspicious for them to come to her room repeatedly, as she knew they would. What had she gotten herself into? What had she gotten into herself?

Her voice was quivering every bit as much as her guards’ were previously. She hoped Cadance would count this as complying, because regardless of her situation she wasn’t going to moan and beg for it as Cadance would. Meanwhile, Spear and Thrust were hopping in excitement, and drooling like rabid hounds.

“To reiterate...” Luna turned to face each guard in turn. “Once we depart this location, around others, none here will speak of these events to anypony else. If any of you break this promise, Tartarus will be envious of the torments that I shall unleash upon you... in your dreams of course. I am no tyrant... yet, though I'm increasingly tempted to be.”

They looked a little nervous at the implication that she could still get vengeance in their dreams, though Cadance smirked. Perhaps she didn’t think Luna had the guts with what Cadance had on her, or perhaps she just didn’t care. It wasn’t like the guards could stop any more than Luna could.

“Cadance,” Luna turned to the whore she was forced to call niece because of Celestia’s misguided adoption of her. “You have long endured as Equestria’s foremost expert on such lascivious acts. What is the best way to position a mare so that three stallions may simultaneously penetrate her?”

Cadance looked at her as if she was getting the same kind of power trip that Luna had earlier, ready to lord her own experience over her. The attempt at an underhooved verbal jab seemed to only turn her on more.

“Did my dear auntie call me a slut?” Cadance smirked. “The easiest way is for Shining to lay on his back, Luna to sit her hot puss on his dick facing him, then Spear can move up behind while Thrust stands in front. You know, if you’re interested, they make bondage furniture to hold you in that position so that a group of males can form three lines and take turns.”

“I am not interested in that,” Luna growled, then backtracked slightly when Cadance peered. “I mean to say, even though I am disregarding my vow, I have carefully chosen those I wish to lay with. It is not an open invitation to every penis in Equestria.”

“Us three, really?” Shining looked at Luna and then back at the two guards. He obviously didn’t think they looked like shining examples of stallion-hood, and it was odd he included himself in his surprise at her choice. He shrugged though. “Hey, as long as I get my dick inside a veritable goddess, what do I care?”

Now that there was no turning back, Luna was determined to get this over with. They weren’t likely to be gentle with her, so she wasn’t gentle either as she shoved Shining to the ground. Being married to an insufferable bitch like Cadance, he was probably used to it.

“Position yourself upon your back and yield your reproductive organ at once,” Luna ordered.

“Fuck yes,” Shining said. “See, this ‘sweetheart’. I don’t need your whore cunt when I got the Princess of the Moon wanting to leap on my hot cock.”

“That’s right,” purred Cadance, sneaking one hoof down to her own slit. “Cuck away, Shining dear, and give her everything she ‘wants’ from you.”

“Indeed,” Luna responded. “Cease delaying our copulation to tease your poorly-chosen wife. I wish to have the phallus she doesn’t deserve inside my vaginal passage promptly.”

“She’s cucking you too, so hot,” panted Shining. They really had an interesting relationship.

Luna felt her stomach churn in disgust at the words coming out of her muzzle, though not as much as when Shining lay on his back with a giant grin plastered on his face, fully believing that she was doing this from a burning desire to have him inside her. His hind legs splayed and front legs held his respectable stallionhood straight up as if he expected her to immediately leap upon it.

That was, in fact, what she intended to do, if not for the reason he thought. She’d get them all off as fast as she could so that she could depart here, go back to her own room, and sob herself to sleep. Cadance had other plans though, coming up behind Luna and sliding hooves around her to tug her back.

“Auntie Luna,” Cadance giggled, the term of endearment becoming a way to lord her power over her superior. “You’re so eager to be promoted to slut, but you’re still just an ignorant little virgin. Don’t just hop on his dick, especially as tight as you probably are. Give us some build up, make-out, grind a little.” She added in a whisper, her lips to Luna’s ear so only she heard. “And don’t rush, I want to get off hard on your slow and helpless humiliation, my little rape toy.”

Cadance looped her tail between Luna’s hind legs, getting drooled on in the process, and pushed Shining’s shaft back against his belly. Shining didn’t argue with his owner wife, though looked a little worried like he thought she wouldn’t let him have Luna after all. He splayed his front legs and panted as Cadance ground her hips against Luna’s generous behind and pushed her downward. Luna's slippery, untouched slit slid forward and back against the front of Shining’s shaft drooling all over him while Cadance left a wet spot above Luna’s tail.

Having a male organ against her like this made Luna shiver in revulsion. Even if she had been one to degrade herself with peasant activity, she wouldn’t have chosen a male partner, and now she had three. There was no part of this that didn’t make her violently ill.

“With respect, dear niece, I require immediate satisfaction,” Luna said, still trying to get it over with, but wording it in a way that wouldn’t break their vile agreement. She quivered like a leaf in the wind, rage still coursing through her, but it must have looked to Shining to be lust. “I desire to feel your husband’s organ inside my pleasure canal forthwith.”

“Wow,” Shining chuckled, then added. “Sorry, but your attempts at dirty talk need work, Princess.”

“Well... you’re fucking my stallion." Cadance licked Luna’s cheek. “So I will dictate a few things, including when your purple princess pussy gets pounded. Don't you think that's fair, dear Auntie?”

Shining hmphed from beneath them. Luna doubted he got the same honor when his wife was laying other ponies.

“I apologize,” Luna panted, her attempts to contain her rage making her voice inadvertently seductive. “I did not intend to make use of your property without your full consent.”

“You two have a little more in common than I thought you did,” Shining commented somewhat less enthusiastically.

Being talked about like property caused Shining to arch an eyebrow, but it was exactly what he was. He hugged his legs about Luna’s hips even as he looked her body over from face to chest and down to her breasts, licking his lips.

“Now come on, boys,” Cadance said to the other guards, who seemed unsure about when to approach the threesome of royalty. “Give your princess here some smooching to warm her up.”

Kissing her guards heaped on the humiliation for Luna, since it involved looking into their eyes, her teary vacant gaze taking in their lustful stares. It felt like they were drilling her shame deeper into her very soul. She could tell they’d gone from looking at her with awed respect to looking at her like meat, but she had to do this, because if that video got out everyone would look at her that way.

Luna hesitated before pressing her lips against Spear’s. The stallion batted her tongue with his own and licked the back of her throat. She gagged, not realizing that kisses were so complicated, but tried to return his motions, suckling his tongue. Thrust was in her face immediately after, exchanging spit in the same manner. Luna moved back and forth, kissing one then the other.

She momentarily lost control enough for tears to roll down her face, but they were quickly taken care of as each guard ran their tongue up either side. She closed her eyes tightly as they slurped at either eye as if savoring the tears of the mare that had been planning to do such horrible things to them. Their hooves explored her body, and she felt their eager shafts brushing against her.

Luna had never wanted to break down into sobs more, yet she knew she had to keep it together. If she failed at any point, all she’d put herself through to avoid having the video released would be for nothing.

“Oh Luna,” Shining groaned, licking her chest as his shaft throbbed against her. He breathed deep as his fore hooves slid over her flanks before massaging her milky breasts. “You smell amazing; Cadance would be lucky to smell half this good. Such a perfect sleek body, and I can already feel how tight you are tensing against me, not like my gaping whore of a wife.”

Though she didn’t disagree with Shining’s insult to Cadance, Luna tensed and glanced at her. Regardless of what level of sex fiend Cadance was, Luna expected her to be miffed that Shining thought Luna was hotter and for a moment Luna feared the might release the video in spite due to it. The only response Cadance gave was to lean in to steal a kiss from Luna as well, every bit as eagerly as the stallions, looking into her eyes with proud dominance.

“She is gorgeous,” agreed Cadance. “It’s honestly a crime that this bitch spent so long ignoring what her body is for, you’re a walking cock tease with a body like this. For a while I thought you were as ugly on the inside as you are beautiful on the outside, but it seems like you were hiding an inner slut, Auntie.”

As things continued, the guards handled her more roughly. Spear pulled her front legs behind her back, bending them back as hard as he could. Were she a normal mare, it might have been hard enough to break them, and he seemed to delight in twisting her knees back the wrong way at the joint. Meanwhile, Thrust bit her ear and yanked on it with his teeth, sliding his hooves around her neck.

“I’m not being too rough, am I?” asked Spear, though she wasn’t sure if he was being thoughtful or knew she had to say he wasn’t.

“Don’t worry,” Cadance said. “Right, Auntie?”

“Yes,” said Luna, “Cease your respectful tone and demeanor. I desire objectification.” It wasn’t entirely insincere; if they were going to rape her, she preferred they not pretend it was anything but a violation of her dignity.

“Looking forward to choking on my dick, Nightmare Thot?” Thrust groaned, then whispered quietly in her ear so only she could hear. “I’ll enjoy violating the muzzle that would have ordered my castration, evil wench.”

“Of course,” Luna said, her voice hollow as the despair welled up within her.

“Mmm, I prefer Slutmare Moon,” Cadance said before pausing to kiss her again. “You don’t seem very eager, Auntie.”

“I am merely overcome with my pent-up lusts,” Luna claimed.

Cadance then turned to Spear as Luna gritted her teeth in rage, “You’ll need some lubrication for that lunar expedition you’re about to go on.”

“She doesn’t deserve lubrication,” panted Spear. “But I’ll probably never get inside her uptight ass without it.”

It’d be easier to use magic than to slobber all over his dick, but this was Cadance; a rabid cock fiend like her wouldn’t pass up an excuse for a slurp. She’d take any chance she got to degrade what should have remained a virgin body.

Cadance slid her head down and breathed over his palpitating shaft. She slurped his tip, working it with her lips. She lapped the underside as she pushed further and swallowed in one go. She showed no hint of shame or a gag reflex as her neck swelled with his girth. The more she visibly enjoyed herself, the angrier Luna felt that she was getting away with this.

She seemed to know that, because she looked at Luna as she slurped as loudly as she could. He looked as if her throat felt better than most holes he’d had, shivering each time she swallowed hard. Yet she was an expert at not letting him get off yet, even if it meant dragging her teeth for a bit of spice.

“And oh,” Cadance added between slurps, “Even if you’re quiet about fucking Slutmare Moon, you can tell anyone about anything you do with me. I’ve become quite fond of my rumor-mill reputation lately, and I’d like to uphold that.”

Cadance made them ‘warm up’ for another fifteen minutes. By the end, everypony was shaking violently. Luna whimpered, the touch of her rapists and the scent of their bodies as frightening to her as her scent was intoxicating to them.

Luna kept herself from crying more at least, if only because she felt raw and empty inside. Cadance knew exactly what she was doing, dragging out this torment to give Luna plenty of time to despair at her situation before her purity was violated into nothing, making sure the experience was as traumatizing as possible. The males were just as happy about the foreplay, their organs pulsing against Luna like they might explode.

“I’ve tortured you enough; it's time to play.” Cadance finally pulled back, licking her lips one last time. She slid a hoof between Luna’s thighs to sample the heat honey there and licked it from her hoof. “Mmmm, she tastes better than me too, Shiny. Anyway, we’ll push her onto my lovely husband’s shaft and then let the others get inside her before bouncing away.”

More desperate than ever to get it over with, Luna didn’t even care that her eagerness was easily mistakable for rabid lust. When given the green light, her hole was all over Shining’s cock like a hobo on a ham sandwich. Unfortunately, it was a hobo with a very small mouth, and that dragged things out longer.

She forced herself downward, but her tight hole resisted. After so long of not being used, a single griffon claw would have been a firm fit, and she was pushing in something much bigger. Despite how large her body was compared to him and how wet she was in her heat, it must have felt like he was trying to penetrate a blank flank, and the guards still slurping at her face didn’t help.

“Oh, Auntie,” Cadance purred. “You’re so riled up, I bet you can just go full blast without even needing to adjust. Any second now...” The implication of ‘you better hurry up’ was understood, and became more than a hint when Cadance began whispering a countdown from 10 into Luna’s ear.

Desperate to sate her devilish abuser, Luna finally used her own magic to push into her hole, prying it open. She squeaked at the sting of forcing her flesh apart, pressing down again, then shrieked as her lips popped over the tip.

Once she realized how much it would hurt, Luna tried to back off, but Cadance pushed her rump down with all her weight. Her labia squeezed Shining’s shaft, able to feel every detail in the clenched grip as it sank deep. Luna felt like she’d literally been stabbed, every instinct telling her to stop as her virgin blood poured down his shaft. Both her cherry and her vow were shattered.

She’d gone from pure goddess to trash in an instant, and couldn’t have been less prepared for how much it stung both emotionally and physically. Luna had taken horn beams to the gut that hurt significantly less, and wondered how other mares dealt with having such painful and disgusting organs rammed inside them.

In horror, she realized that she wasn’t but half way yet. Shining grasped her hips, yanking her down harder as Cadance pushed her further. Her lips glided down his shaft so tightly that she could have memorized his exact shape as she finally came belly to belly with him, drooling a puddle of her red-tinged fluid into a puddle on his belly.

“She tight?” purred Cadance.

“Holy fuck, I thought at her body size she’d be easier to get into,” Shining groaned. “But I swear it feels like I’m plugging a filly guide instead of a giant alicorn.”

“Maybe we’ll try that later,” giggled Cadance. “But the best part is, since she lost her virginity after becoming an alicorn, it will always return due to her healing factor. Every dive into that sweet pussy will be a cherry pop.”

Cadance had swore to Luna and Celestia that she was a virgin before becoming an alicorn, but they should have known she was lying. They shouldn’t have respected her dignity enough to not confirm it as they had with Twilight.

“Seriously?” Shining gasped. “I think we should sleep in Luna’s room when we visit from now on! S-should I go easy though?”

“A-as hard as you can!” Luna choked through a sob, but it probably sounded like excitement to the naïve stallion. “I desire no mercy for any part of my body!”

“Good,” Cadance purred louder, taking Luna’s head in her forehooves and looking into her eyes. “That look of ultimate humiliation as you give up the thing you held most dear to feel my husband’s dick inside you. I still can’t believe you did it for my limp-dicked husband, but it’s so delicious.”

“Cadance, you only think I’m small because your cunt is too stretched to feel anything,” Shining groaned back.

Even if she felt like she’d been gutted, Luna’s body was more than happy after being deprived of the lowly act for hundreds of heats. No sooner had Luna’s sopping wet belly smacked Shining’s than her tunnel erupted into a flurry of convulsions. Her hot slot climaxed in joy at feeling cock flesh clenched within it, even as her mind and stomach rebelled against the idea.

Luna could barely take it, gagging in disgust. The only reason she didn’t vomit is because Cadance held her muzzle shut, making her swallow it back down. When she released it, Luna arched her back and moaned regardless of if she wanted to, her body shaking as it forced the climax on her.

It was a dry enjoyment for her, not proper pleasure, overshadowed by the pain of losing herself. But honestly, she didn’t want to enjoy such a revolting act, straining not to relax eve as much as she could. She’d rather it continue to hurt so she could honestly tell Cadance that she hated every second.

If not for what remained of her pride, Luna would have wailed like an infant, but this was no time to feel sorry for herself. She realized she was paying the price for her own mistakes, and the more she considered it, the more she realized that she deserved it. Her punishment had only just begun.