A Pair Of Silly Strings

It had been 5 months since you arrived in Equestria. You looked back on all that happened, especially when you saved Bon-Bon, shared a kiss with her, then confronted Lyra and shared a kiss with her all in the same day. Over the past 5 months, Bon-Bon’s candy shop got some more attention, both because of her and you. The day you took on the Bugbear, it was too weak to fight back, so capturing it was a breeze, so a lot of people wanted your autograph or just to say hi. And as for Bon-Bon, they praised her for surviving one of Bugbear’s stings. Eventually, during a visit to Canterlot, you finally got to meet Princess Twilight, who praised you for your bravery in going up against Bugbear with no assistance. Her daughter, Moonlight Sparkle, thought you were brave as well, saying that what you did was very cool, and oh boy, she was cute. Twilight’s Husband, Beau, also commemorated you for your bravery and said that if you ever wanted to go out drinking, he was available. You also spent time with Lyra, such as going to some of her favorite spots, watching movies with her, and all sorts of things. Eventually, they both confessed their feelings to you. Bon-Bon confessed her feelings to you while you were both closing up shop, and you kissed under a single light, which made it all the more romantic. Lyra confessed her feelings while the two of you were chatting about the most beautiful ponies in Equestria, then shared a kiss after you said she was the most beautiful out of them all, and after a few months, you were basically dating both mares, and living with them fully.

As of now, you had thought about your relationship with both mares. It had been going on for 3 months, since you started dating them 2 months after saving Bon-Bon, and you wanted to form the herd with them. You saw how they already had rings with each other’s cutie marks on them, so you had to think hard on what else to do. You decided to get Lyra a sapphire ring, and Bon-Bon an amethyst ring, so you set out for the Jewelry store.

A few hours later, you walked out of the jewelry store with two ring boxes: One had Lyra’s cutie mark on it, and the other had Bon-Bon’s on it. Now the only thing left to do was to wait patiently for both of them to come home. There you sat on the couch, thinking of what to do to pass the time, and since you were bored, you decided to drop by Sugar Cube Corner.

You walked into Sugar Cube Corner, and the pink mare known as Pinkie Pie immediately recognized you, “Hi Sacchy! What can I get you today?” she said as she smiled at you

“Root beer float, Pinks, if you could” you said, sighing as you sat down at a table. Soon enough, Pinkie brought over a root beer float to your table, setting it down and taking a seat at the table.

“Why so stressie, bestie?” she asked as you took a sip

“Not exactly stressed, Pinks, I’m just a tad anxious” you said to her

“Is it because you have to propose to two mares who are also your marefriends and you’re not sure exactly how to do it?” she said, surprising you

“How’d you- whatever, yes. I’ve never proposed to two girls at once before, I know I won’t mess it up, but what should I say?” you asked Pinkie as she stroked her chin softly

“Sacchy, let me ask you this? Do Lyra and Bon-Bon love you?” Pinkie asked you, tapping her fingers softly on the table

“Uh, yeah, they do” you responded nervously

“Then just be yourself! As long as you do that, nothing could go wrong!” Pinkie said, smiling as her smile got wider, and it was pretty creepy.

“Okay Pinks, you’re creeping me out…” you said, finishing off your root beer float and putting down 20 bits.

“Sorry! My bad for creeping you out, Sacchy!” she said as she pocketed the bits into her mane as if it was a coin purse, “So, you know what to do, right?”

You stood up and stretched slightly, saying, “Just be myself, yes, I got that”

Pinkie then hugged you tightly, crushing your ribs a little, “Awesome! You got this, Sacchy!”

“Ack! Ribs! RIBS!” you cried out as she let you go. After sighing, you smiled a little, “Thanks for the advice, Pinks, you’re the best”

“That’s sweet of you, Sacchy! Go get em’!” she said as you left Sugar Cube Corner.

The streets were dark and cold as you passed through to home. Of course, once you got to the door, you heard giggling on the other side.

Gee, I can only wonder what’s on the other side, you thought to yourself, but to really make yourself known to your marefriends, you said, “Oh no~ I can only wonder what’s on the other side of this door~” you said, giggling to yourself

Not wanting to keep them waiting, you walked in, rings in your jacket pocket, and as you got to the soft carpet, you suddenly felt some arms wrap around you and gently pull you backwards and onto the carpet. Before you could find out what you were laying on, or rather who you were laying on, you felt another pair of arms wrap around you as something got on top of you. Eventually, a horn lit up and a lamp turned on, and you found yourself sandwiched between your marefriends Lyra and Bon-Bon. Bon-Bon was underneath you, and Lyra was on top of you.

“Well well well, Bonnie, look who we caught~” Lyra said as she rubbed her covered breasts against your chest, making you blush a little.

“I know right, surprising how our plan worked~” Bon-Bon said, brushing her tail against your legs and hips, which also made you blush

“Um girls, what’s going on?” you asked, clearly confused by their behavior, but soon enough, you found your face smooshed into Lyra’s breasts

“Saccharo, we’re just giving you some “Special attention”~, don’t you want that?~” Lyra asked seductively, and you didn’t really understand it

“We just want to give you a fun time, sweetheart~” Bon-Bon said, having given your neck a hickey

“I… I… do want that… c-could you girls give me some air for a second?” you said as they both sighed, but obliged regardless, allowing you to get up

“Do you promise to come back, Saccharo?” Bon-Bon asked

“Yes, I just… need a sec” you said as you raced to your room

Suddenly, this whole thing became harder, and it wasn’t just you, it was your pants too. You had never seen Lyra or Bon-Bon this… horny before. It reminded you of something, and it took you a while to understand, but eventually you knew why: They were in heat! It did make you think how they dealt with heat before you came into their lives, but that was something for another time. Staring at the door that led to the living room, you gulped, but instead of having to leave the room, you heard a knock at your door.

“Saccharo? Is everything alright?” Bon-Bon asked, somewhat worried

“You’ve been in there for a while, is something wrong, are we scaring you?” Lyra asked as she sniffled a little.

“Girls, please come in” you said as the door opened and they walked in, sitting next to you side by side.

“Are we bothering you, Saccharo?”
Bon-Bon asked you quietly

“No no, not at all, Bonnie, but I do have something to say to you both. 5 months ago, Lyra talked about forming a herd between the three of us. At the time, it was too soon, but I did like the idea. Now it’s five months later, and I want us all to be a family. So girls, if you’d stand up with me” you said as you stood up and they stood up with you

Lyra’s tail wagged excitedly, “Saccharo… is this what I think it is?!”

You got down on one knee, pulling out the two ring boxes and presenting them as both mares gasped, blushing a little. Giggling, you said, “Well, what’re you waiting for, open them~”

Lyra and Bon-Bon opened the boxes, finding their rings. Lyra squealed as she carefully picked up her Sapphire ring, and Bon-Bon blushed brightly as she carefully took her Amethyst ring. Both mares looked to you with a soft smile as you said, “Lyra and Bon-Bon, will you add me to your marriage and start a herd with me?”

They looked at each other, then at you, then at each other, then at you again. After doing this for a while, Bon-Bon decided to speak, “Saccharo, of course we would. We love you, don’t we Lyra?”

“That’s right” she said as she kissed your cheek softly, “You brought a lot to our lives, Saccharo. To be fair, before you came along, Bon-Bon was a bit uneasy around humans cause they looked like… well… a hairless ape. Eventually, she did adjust to humans, but didn’t interact with them too much, so when you came along, I was surprised to see Bonnie so open and comfortable around a human”

“You also changed Lyra’s life, too. When a human first showed up, she was so excited to find out they were real, and once she found out that your kind could cross breed with ours, she’d just daydream about having a foal with your kind, but never got the chance to due to how many were coming in, then getting into relationships with somepony else” Bon-Bon explained

“To be honest, Saccharo, had you not come into our lives, we would’ve just adopted a foal, but now that we have you, it’ll be beautiful when me and Bonnie have children, cause they’ll have a handsome father!” Lyra said as she smiled

“Well, they’ll also have two beautiful mothers~ though I have to ask, if you two are saying what I think you’re saying, does that mean you both want to be mothers? No condoms, nothing?” you asked, as the last thing you wanted was an unwanted pregnancy

“We wouldn’t want you as bad as we do if we had condoms. Now, what say you we give you some attention~?” Bon-Bon asked as she removed her top, revealing her pink padded bra

“Your little friend down there looks lonely~” Lyra added, discarding her top as her golden-colored bra shined a little in the room light as she gently rubbed your crotch. It was clear to you that your marefriends/fiances wanted to show you just how much they love you, so you nodded hesitantly, getting a giggle out of the both of them

“Alright, let’s get it started~” Bon-Bon said as her and Lyra got your pants and underwear off, revealing your rather impressive length, “Whoa, look at the size of it~”

“Looks juicy too~” Lyra said as she gently gripped your member and gave it a slow, long lick, making you shiver a little and blush as well

“Now now Lyra, let’s go easy on his little friend, as this may be his first time~ And that reminds me, Sacchy~ Which of us do you want to be your first? It won’t change anything, just who do you want to lose your virginity to when the main event happens?~” Bon-Bon asked you, now taking off her bra, with Lyra doing the same.

“To be fair with you, Bonnie, I want to lose it to you, you sweet drop~” you giggled a little, as you used her real name as both a pun and a way of flirting.

“You’re such a flirt~ Now lie back, and let us do the work~” Bon-Bon said as you laid back, your shaft having hardened from Lyra’s lick and soft grasp. After looking at your shaft for a few seconds, Lyra and Bon-Bon laid on their stomachs and mashed their breasts together, encasing your shaft. Your marefriends began giving you simultaneous boobjobs, causing you to moan softly and twitch a little. Every now and again, Lyra and Bon-Bon would give your member a couple sucks, until you felt pressure build up in your member.

“G-Girls! I f-feel it! I-I’m gonna-!” you said as you felt yourself cumming and someone’s lips go over your member, and they belonged to Bon-Bon. As you came, you saw Bon-Bon’s cheeks inflate, which made her blush red as she swallowed your cum, though some of it leaked out as she had taken so much. After pulling away, her lips were coated with your cum. Lyra cleaned up after her by licking your shaft dry and then licking Bonnie’s face like a puppy, which you thought was cute.

“Salty at first, but with a sweet aftertaste~” Bon-Bon said as she leaned down and kissed you, and during the kiss, you tasted your own cum, but you didn’t care. After a few minutes, she pulled away and looked down at you, “So, shall we move onto the live event?~”

“Bonnie! Before you get to the main event, let me have some fun!” Lyra said, pouting cutely

“Hehe, sorry Lyra…” Bon-Bon said, having forgot that this wasn’t just her in all this

“I forgive you, now…” without any warning, she mounted you and was sitting on your upper waist, “Time to give this joystick a ride~”

You just gulped and Bon-Bon giggled as Lyra began bouncing on your shaft inside her ass. With every bounce and clap of her flankcheeks, she moaned and moaned. You reached up and touched her horn, stroking it softly as you got a rather cute yelp out of Lyra. You stopped, then stroked her horn again, causing her to twitch and yelp cutely again.

“What’s wrong Lyra?” you asked with a hint of concern

“I-It’s just, m-my horn, it’s s-s-sensitive…” she said, still blushing from the whole thing

“Really? That true, Bonnie?” you asked Bon-Bon, turning to her

“All Unicorns and Alicorns have sensitive horns, it’s basically an instant trigger of the nervous system, but to most mares, it’s a sign of pleasure, just don’t over do it, Sacchy~” Bon-Bon said seductively, running a finger across your 4-pack.

“Ah, I see. Well, continue bouncing, Lyra” you said, reaching up and caressing her cheek. She smiled and blushed in response, then continued bouncing. She was so horny that she stuck her tongue out, moaning like she was possessed. Eventually, you felt yet another climax coming as you felt your shaft bubble up, sweating a little, “L-Lyra, I’m gonna! Ah-” you came and filled her anal cavity to the brim and some of your cum leaked out of her. She moaned in ecstasy when you came, and just kissed you out of exhaustion. Eventually, she lifted herself off of your shaft, laying down next to you and staring at you with those lovely eyes.

“Your shaft was so big inside of me, you’re the best~” Lyra said as she licked your cheek and wagged her tail excitedly

“Thank you Lyra, you sweet girl yo-” You were cut off as you felt Bon-Bon straddling you, her marehood dripping right over your still erect shaft. You gave Bon-Bon a heartfelt smile, “Is it that time, Bonnie?”

“Y-Yeah, but I’m scared…” Bon-Bon said nervously

“Is this your first time, Bonnie?” you asked her, getting a soft nod from her

“Since me and Lyra never had actual sex, we never lost our virginities, so we’re still virgins. Of course, now that we have you, that won’t be the case, but I’ve heard how painful it is when a mare loses her virginity. Promise to comfort me afterwards?” Bon-Bon asked, gently lowering her marehood onto the tip of your shaft, but not quite going all the way down.

You gently placed your hands on her hips, looking her right in the eyes, “I got you, Bonnie, you’ll be okay” you said as she nodded and slowly inserted your shaft into her, right where her hymen was. She looked to you again, and you gave a soft nod, helping her lower down completely and puncturing her hymen, causing her to gasp and yelp in pain as fresh blood poured down your shaft, but you knew that Lyra would go through the same thing as well. Being the loving boyfriend that you are, you kissed Bon-Bon’s cheek and stroked her mane as she whined a little and shedded some tears. Her tail carefully wagged and brushed against your hips as she sighed happily.

“Saccharo… you’re the best boyfriend ever…~ I’m glad you were my first~” she said as you thrust into her slowly, pinning her down softly as wet slaps could be heard. You thrusted and thrusted into Bon-Bon again and again, causing her to grip the sheets as hard as she could. Her tail was wagging like crazy and she was moaning like an angel. While you were thrusting into her, Bon-Bon and Lyra shared a kiss, which you thought was beautiful, but you kept going. Bon-Bon’s moans were just beautiful, and soon enough, you felt that all too familiar feeling: Your climax. You twitched with your thrusts, moaning a little.

“B-Bonnie, I- I’m gonna!-” you said as you felt it start to release. This caught her attention as she held you close, making sure you were there to stay.

“Go ahead Sacchy! Make me a mother! I wanna have your foal!~” she screamed as you both climaxed. Your seed filled her womb, and her juices sprayed your crotch. After that was all done, Bon-Bon just stared at you with those eyes of hers and kissed you wrapping her arms around your neck and her tail brushed against your hips, “Sacchy, you’re the best, I love you so much~”

“Same to you, Bonnie, I love you~” you said as you gave her a kiss and a love bite, looking at Lyra, “Now Lyra, sweetheart, your turn~”

She blushed when you called out to her, and carefully lowered herself onto your shaft, not even hesitating as she went all the way down and pierced her hymen, causing her blood to flow out of her marehood as she tried to keep a straight face, but soon enough, she just couldn’t control herself and hugged you tightly, crying into your shoulder. To comfort her, you gently patted her flank, rubbing it softly as her cries turned into soft whimpers as she looked up at you and kissed you, feeling all the pain slip away. After the two of you parted lips, you did the same with Lyra as you did with Bon-Bon: pinning Lyra down softly and thrusting into her slowly. You did exactly that, seeing her tail wag just like an excited puppy getting the pets they so desperately wanted, and it was so cute to see. Lyra brought her lips close to Bon-Bon’s breast nipple, drinking milk from her breast. Bon-Bon moaned softly, and you just kept thrusting into Lyra. This time, you felt your climax come faster than usual, which was probably due to how much you’ve climaxed, but it felt like a hefty load regardless as you twitched and moaned.

“L-Lyra… y-you ready, sweetheart…?” you asked her as she looked up at you, giving a wide smile.

“Of course I am! Give it to me, Sacchy! Make me a mother just like you did with Bonnie! Let’s be a family!” She shouted as you nodded and blew your huge load in her, and as you expected, she climaxed as well, spraying her love juices all over your crotch as you filled her womb with your sweet seed. After that, she slowly pulled herself off of your shaft, finally giving it a break. You loved Lyra and Bon-Bon, no doubt about that, but after all that your shaft has been through, it deserved a break. It was still erect, and you were too lazy to put anything on, but you did need to clean up your shaft, so you entered the shower with Lyra and Bon-Bon, who eagerly followed you in.

Sighing, the three of you were out of the shower and in Bon-Bon’s bedroom, since yours smelt like it had just been through a gangbang. During the shower, you had a bit of trouble cleaning up, as half of the time you were cleaning yourself, the girls begged you to clean them at times, scrubbing their privates, their bodies, practically everything. It wasn’t until they were clean that you yourself actually got clean completely.

Finally, the three of you were covered up in Bon-Bon’s bed. You had Bon-Bon on your right, and Lyra on your left. Both mares were wearing the rings you gave them as they had their heads rested against your chest.

“Heh, that was fun, wasn’t it Lyra?” Bon-Bon asked her, reaching behind you and stroking Lyra’s mane. Lyra blushed and nuzzled her hand

“Yeah, especially since we’re gonna be mothers to our hubby’s children in a couple months or so, who knows? However long it takes, I’m willing to wait, it makes me so excited!” Lyra said as her tail wagged excitedly.

“Though, I’ll say this, it was kinda funny seeing my johnson covered in blood, cause it looked like someone slathered marinara or spilt it down there” you said, getting a giggle out of both girls as they kissed both your cheeks, then each other.

“Well, enough talk about that, Saccharo. On more important topics, we’re a family now, and Lyra, our dream of having children of our own will finally come true. We finally did it!” Bon-Bon cheered, squealing a little.

Lyra was actually crying a little, but failed at hiding it. You and Bon-Bon looked at her, and you spoke up, “Um, Lyra, are you okay babe?”

She sniffled a little, looking at you and Bon-Bon, “I’m fine… I just didn’t think I’d end up with two things at once… having sex with a human… and starting a family with Bonnie… Saccharo, I’m so glad you came into our lives, both literally and figuratively…” she giggled at that last bit, but you got the message, kissing her forehead.

“Lyra, Bon-Bon, I’m honestly glad to have met the both of you. When I heard the two of you were married, I just figured I’d be okay with keeping it as friends, but when Lyra talked about starting a herd in the future, I felt something I never thought I’d feel: Love. Back on Earth, no girls ever really fell for me, cause I had poor grades due to my endless love for sweets. Even when I worked as a bartender, most girls at the bar would only have sex with me if I gave them a free drink or something, but having two girls is better than just having one~” you said, earning kisses from both mares, giggling a lot, “I love you Lyra and Bon-Bon, my silly, sweet fiances~”

“We love you too Sacchy~ We’re so lucky to have you in our lives~” Bon-Bon said, kissing you and snuggling up to you, closing her eyes and sighing happily

“Love you Sacchy~ You’re the best boyfriend we could ask for~” Lyra said, giving you a kiss and snuggling up to you, closing her eyes as well.

So there you sat up, having two cute mares snuggled up to you. Lyra and Bon-Bon also had their heads close to each other, so it was like you were a pillow to them. Before falling asleep yourself, you kissed both mares on the forehead and closed your eyes, laying your head down on a pillow and falling asleep. Having two of the cutest mares sleeping with you and married to you sounded like one hell of a life goal completed. You could only wonder how your parents would feel knowing you were married to two mares and had children on the way, but it didn’t concern you all that much as you finally let your mind, and your johnson, rest.