Nightmare Moon’s Indecent Proposal

Nightmare had underestimated this mare. Her grip was strong, and the way she was stroking, it was as if Applejack’s stamina was bottomless. How did she come across such talents? Nightmare tried to ponder this, but as she did, all this did was send more shivers of pleasure throughout her leaking cock. Applejack was looking at her, smirking, and with confident eyes as she was jerking off this massive alicorn cock faster and faster.

“Keep it up, Applejack!” Rainbow commented, getting her shorts off to show off her petite but tight looking ass. “Get her all lubed up!”

“Working on it, sugarcube!” Applejack called back, picking up the pace as her hands were teasing and playing with Nightmare’s cock and balls. The alicorn couldn’t help but groan a little. “Almost there, get ready!”

“Sneaky little mares.” Nightmare commented, only now realizing what was happening. “Clever, very clever-ahh!”

Applejack’s hands were just enough to jerk another small amount of cum to gush out of her cock, a smaller orgasm, but enough to get both the mare’s hands, and the alicorn dick to become much more slick. Panting a little, Nightmare saw as the blue pegasus was getting into position. Flapping her wings, Rainbow took to the air, flying right to the alicorn. Stopping just above the throbbing cock, the pegasus started with a confident smirk at her.

“Think you can handle the tightest ass in Equestria?” Rainbow asked, turning around to not only wiggle her flank a little as a taunt, but even smacked it. “Well time’s up! Applejack, line it up.”

“Got it!” Applejack replied, gripping at the full shaft with both hands. Angling it directly upwards, the slick and soaked cock was able to easily shove itself in Rainbow’s ass. “And it’s in!” Pulling her hands back, she watched as her friend took in inch by inch of Nightmare’s cock.

“Fuck! That’s tight!” Nightmare gasped, feeling as if her massive cock was being crushed by this athletic mare’s incredibly petite tailhole. “Impressive, you were just trying to build into helping the others.” Her eyes glanced over to Twilight and Rarity. “You have Celestia’s students put me in a sense of superiority, only to have the other unicorn get a quick release out of me…” She then looked between Applejack and Rainbow. “Only to then get a few more globs out to get me soaked enough to fit in this pegasus’ ass.”

“And we’re not done yet!” Rainbow grunted, trying to hold back the pleasure growing inside her. Flapping her wings, she dropped herself lower and lower. “Cause I’m gonna make you bust so many loads, you’ll be limp for weeks.”

“That’s quite the claim, little pony.” Nightmare commented, her eyes gleaming with an almost animalistic lust. Reaching out, she grabbed at Rainbow’s hips. “So I guess I don’t need to hold back anymore.” After what these mares have proven so far, there was no way this alicorn was going to be merciful any longer.

Pulling the mare downwards as she thrusted upwards, Nightmare nearly bottomed out in Rainbow’s ass. The mare only howls in the sudden sharp pleasure. It was intense, making her only want to be filled with more of this alicorn’s thick dick. Nightmare only smirked in a satisfied grin, feeling the tightness of the pegasi’s ass squeezing her shaft. Applejack could only move back, as her hands weren’t able to get around the alicorn’s dick between the hard and deep thrusts.

Seeing no other choice, the farm mare could only grope and fondle Nightmare’s huge, cum filled balls. The alicorn didn’t seem to notice as the earth pony was not being as rough with the huge orbs as she was with the cock. Rainbow was already panting as she could feel the thick size not only reaching deeper and deeper in her tight ass. This wasn’t the first time she had taken something big enough to push so deep in her, but it was the first time someone was so rough off the bat.

“My, my, you’re right.” Nightmare chuckled, savoring the feeling of her dick being tightly embraced by Rainbow’s ass. “Tightest ass in Equestria is quite the earned title. I can’t remember the last time I’ve sampled such a tailhole.” She was panting as she was making this pegasus’ ass bounce on her cock.

“I…I told you…” Rainbow panted, gritting her teeth as she was already feeling herself getting closer and closer to an orgasm. “Bet you wanna bust all that thick nut in my ass.” Her tone was mocking Nightmare, egging her on to try and fill her up. “You know how many studs love to fuck my ass? You got the biggest dick I’ve ever had, but you better have the spunk to match.”

“Oh don’t you worry, I shall.” Nightmare said, only for her eyes to look towards where Applejack was. “Farm mare, you’ll need to do better than that to churn my cum. I barely noticed you were doing anything.”

“Then maybe I can try this.” Applejack responded. Whistling towards Pinkie, she waved the pink mare over to her. “Come on Pinkie, let’s show this mare how it’s done.”

“Okie dokie lokie!” Pinkie cheered as she giggled. Skipping over to the massive pair of balls, she joined Applejack in the playful act. “I’ll take one, and you’ll take one?”

“That’s the plan.” Applejack nodded, shifting to the side to give Pinkie some room. “Rainbow, pick up the pace.”

“Alright…” Rainbow panted and moaned. Flapping her wings, she tried to increase the speed of the thrusts going in and out of her ass. Applejack and Pinkie pressed their own tits against the heavy balls, suckling and licking them to add more pleasurable stimulation to the alicorn. “Come one girls…I can’t keep this up…forever…”

“No, you cannot.” Nightmare commented, a gleaming in her sinister eyes was the only warning the mares got as she tightened her hold on Rainbow’s hips. “I believe I should see how much this pegasus whore can handle.”

Thrusting upwards, Nightmare bounced her hips hard and rough in and out of Rainbow’s ass. The mare’s petite chest bounced as her entire body was moving so quickly as well as the air was filling with the sound of the alicorn’s large, cum filled balls slapping against her body. Applejack and Pinkie couldn’t keep up, causing them to back away as they could only watch. Rainbow’s eyes were rolling back, her tongue dangling from her mouth as she was experiencing numerous small and strong orgasms.

“Here comes you tight toy…” Nightmare grunted, gritting her teeth as she was getting to the point of release. “Here is your reward…tightest ass in Equestria!” Lifting her nearly off her length, she bottomed out her entire girth in Rainbow’s ass.

Nightmare’s orgasm filled out Rainbow’s anal cavity, stuffing her insides with her thick, hot, and potent load. The mare’s eyes went wide as she could feel as her insides were filling with the cum. It wasn’t long until she was full of this alicorn’s seed. Rainbow shivered as she came from the pressure, before going partially limp. Eventually, Nightmare released her plaything, letting the blue pegasus to fall forward, slipping off the cum soaked cock.

Groaning and twitching from her still ongoing orgasms, Rainbow’s ass spewed out excess cum, making a mess on the bed between them. Applejack and Pinkie could only watch on as the last few ropes of Nightmare’s orgasm shot out, splattering on the back of Rainbow’s head, along her back, and ending at her fucked sore ass. Looking at each other, they nodded. Applejack grabbed at her friend, helping her off the bed, while Pinkie remained standing.

“So…you are next?” Nightmare asked, her cock twitching towards Pinkie. “One moment, I believe I should freshen up a little.” With a wave of her hand, her cum soaked cock was brought back to the same glimmer and clean shine it had when this began. As well as this, it was now fully erect and throbbing. “Now then, what are you planning on doing?”

“Well, I noticed something…you know, when you were fucking my friend’s ass.” Pinkie giggled, looking at Nightmare with seductive eyes. “And it got me wondering.” Crawling on the bed, she poked her head closer and closer until it was at Nightmare’s balls. “I was right. You have both!”

“Oh? And what are you planning on do-oh?!” Nightmare tried to speak, but felt an immediate pleasure coursing through her. Pinkie’s tongue was already burying itself in her pussy, while her hands were stroking off the alicorn’s cock. “N-not bad…not bad at all.” She hesitated for a moment, but managed to compose herself.

Pinkie was jerking Nightmare off faster and faster, while her tongue was slipping and playing along the insides of this alicorn’s pussy. There was a sweet, but strong flavor of her wet hole, and it was making the lustful mare all the more eager to try and make this powerful mare moan in pleasure. As well as this, Pinkie’s hands were stroking off Nightmare’s dick with the skills of the most expert of sluts.

“R-remarkable.” Nightmare commented, clearing her throat again to compose herself. “Far more skilled than the white unicorn. You must’ve had your fair share of fun, haven’t you?” Pinkie’s tongue continued to slither and tease along the alicorn’s pussy. “There’s no way you could be this naturally skilled!”

“Oh, yes, yes I have!” Pinkie cheered, almost as if she was bragging to the alicorn. “I’ve fucked a lot of ponies. Oh! Oh! And there was this one time that-”

“You can just get back in there.” Nightmare commented, using her hoof to push Pinkie’s face back in her pussy. “There, just like that. Keep this up, and I’ll reward you as I have done to the pegasus.”

Pinkie picked up the pace, stroking the alicorn’s cock with a greater fervor, as well as delving her tongue deeper within this pussy. She was set to get Nightmare to cum again, and soon. Though she couldn’t see her, she knew Fluttershy was going to be next and wanted to get this mare as close to release as possible. As well as this, Pinkie had never been with a mare like this that had both cock and pussy before.

Continuing to eat out with alicorn pussy, as well as jerking off this dick as if she was going to drain her balls of every drop of cum. But after another few short minutes, it was becoming apparent that Pinkie, despite making this mare feel good, wasn't getting any closer to cumming. Though she couldn’t see it, the others could see a smug smirk across Nightmare’s face. She was clearly taken by surprise by how skilled these mares were and was going to put up more of a fight.

“Come on, get cumming!” Pinkie teased and giggled, working more and more to get Nightmare off. Lifting her face from the sweet tasting pussy, she started licking and suckling the balls. “Doesn’t this feel good?”

“Oh, it does. But I was going easy on you all.” Nightmare commented, almost chuckling in her amusement. “You’ll have to do a lot more than just this to get me o-oah?!” Suddenly, her body tensed up as she felt her wings being gently touched. Looking over, she noticed Fluttershy had somehow managed to slip over to the bed and was now rubbing her wings. “W-what are you-oh…oh…”

“Well, you seemed to tense up.” Fluttershy explained, still gently massaging along Nightmare’s wings and letting her fingers rub along the alicorn’s feathers. “And I figured this would also be a good way to ease up and relax.”

“I-it will do…” Nightmare said, struggling to maintain her composure. Her words and face were not matching as she was feeling a growing sensation of relaxation and pleasure. “I never would’ve guessed you could give a massage.”

“Well, I know after flying all day, my friend likes a wing massage.” Fluttershy explained, speaking calmly and softly. “So just relax, you don’t need to be just all evil and sexual. Just let me get into these stiff muscles.”

Fluttershy continued to massage along Nightmare’s wings, while Pinkie continued to tease and lick along the alicorn’s balls. Slowly but surely, the pink mare’s mouth was working between the balls, pussy, and base of the cock shaft. Fluttershy’s fingers were so skilled, gentle and yet could reach and apply the right amount of pressure on the alicorn’s most tender regions. The combination of passion and compassion was building within Nightmare in a way she never considered.

“Fuck…you two…this is…” Nightmare panted, moaning a little as she was getting closer and closer to orgasm. Shivering, she felt as if she was ready at any moment. “P-pink slutmare…get that mouth over my cock…I’m gonna cum…”

“Okie dokie lokie!” Pinkie cheered with a giggle. Getting herself into position, she suckled along the blunt and hard cockhead. “Let her have it, Fluttershy!”

Fluttershy nervously nodded, making her fingers work deeper and more directly over Nightmare’s wings. Pinkie started bobbing her head over the thick, alicorn cock, working her tongue along the shaft to get this dick nice and wet as she was easily deepthroating this mare. Between the pegasus’ hands and this earth mare’s mouth, Nightmare wasn’t able to hold herself back anymore.

Groaning out in pleasure, Nightmare released herself, cumming her next orgasm in Pinkie’s mouth. Her wings spread out and stiffened as she was twitching on climax. The mare swallowed as much as she could, while Fluttershy was moving along to massage the alicorn’s shoulders as she continued to let out spurt after spurt of cum. It was barely another minute before Nightmare settled down again.

“Well…” Nightmare panted, shivering as she felt the sensation of the afterglow. Looking down, she saw Pinkie as still drinking down the large amounts of cum she was pumping into her belly. Turning her gaze upwards, she saw Twilight, staring at her in disbelief and worry. The alicorn only smirked in confidence. “Now then…who…is…next?”