While a group of teenagers escape from the Lakeshore Winery, the remaining Special Control Attack Team (SCAT) officers notice a strange phenomenon a number of blocks over. It is unknown where this phenomenon leads to, but the officers have overridden what presence of security cameras there are anyway.

Ashley, Cindy, Megan, Kelly, Lisa and Danny have all escaped Lakeshore Winery and are riding back home until they see something strange in an ally. When they all get out, Danny is the first to investigate, who subsequently gets pulled closer to this strange something. The girls try to get him back but they are pulled closer as well. And when they all are inside, they find themselves falling into a new world with new bodies.

In Ponyville, there seems to be a lot more cameras than usual. What do they do? Did Princess Celestia place them overnight?

Watching a perfect playthrough of Night Trap is advised.